Forums

Karen Maddi Madison (forgot to vote for her lol)

I’ve been hearing different things but is the top 5 Disney night tomorrow (may 6th) or next Sunday?

If Fritz was predicted to win but then misses the finale, Triston might too. All I want is for Jack to make it honestly.

Round 1: 1. Abi Carter - This was honestly her second best performance of the season and the second best of the night! She ate that song up! Her belts are so powerful on the song. Lots of emotions and power in her voice as well. That was incredible! What can't she sing? She can sang the phonebook and I will instantly love it easily. She is my personal favorite as well.   2. Jack Blocker - This was one of Jack's best performances of the night! He sounded fantastic on the song. I wasn't a fan of the song for him but he ate that. I would have liked a little bit more emotions from him, but I loved that he was having fun.   3. Julia Gagnon - This was fantastic from Julia! I loved her song choice for her. She ate that up and crushed it! One of my top 2 favorite performances from her so far. I had chills all over! I loved that! She showed a lot of dynamics and emotions on this song.   4. McKenna Faith Breinholt - This was pretty great honestly! Not as good as majority of her performances though. I wouldn't have chosen this song for her either. I'd much prefer her at the piano. She has a wonderful raspy and scratchy voice that I love. She reminds me of Joni and Stevie.   5. Emmy Russell - This was really pretty! Not as good as her first song as this was not the song to slow down. Don't expect her to dance around the stage. Maybe just standing still with a guitar would have worked best for this song. She still did a great job with it.   6. Will Moseley - This was pretty solid! Great song choice for him and he did a great job. I would like him to do something very emotional at some point. I want to hear that heartbreak in his voice.   7. Triston Harper - Bad song choice for Triston. This was not good at all. This felt too karaoke for me. Even Bryce did this song better, but that's not saying much as both versions are still bad.   Round 2: 1. Abi Carter - Best performance of the season and her best performance of the season! I had chills all over! Perfect song choice for her and she slayed that. She always sings with so much emotions and power every single week. She is so flawless and perfect every time which is what I really love from her. She's the most consistent out of everyone.   2. Julia Gagnon - Perfect song choice for Julia! Way to go out on a high note! That was a fantastic performance from her and her best performance of the season! I loved that. She showed a lot of dynamics, power, and emotions into the song.    3. McKenna Faith Breinholt - This was a fantastic performance from McKenna! What a way to go out on a high note. Perfect song choice for her and it sounds like a record. I had chills all over. Much better than her first performance. This was her best performance of the season!   4. Jack Blocker - This wasn't as good as his first performance, but he still did a really great job with it. I liked this song choice for Jack better than his first song choice.    5. Emmy Russell - This was a beautiful performance from Emmy. Very pretty. I do prefer her being at the piano than standing up but she did a great job regardless.    6. Will Moseley - This was a great performance from Will! Though he did have my second least favorite performance of the night. I think the key could have been a bit higher for him. Regardless he still did a great job with it and chose the right song.   7. Triston Harper - This was a very bad song choice for him honestly. He just doesn't have the vocals/range for the song. This song is vocally demanding and requires lots of big notes and runs. This was a big trainwreck from Triston. I would have sent him home over McKenna based on performance wise in both rounds.

Mine would look like this. 1. Emmy 2. Abi 3. Jack 4. Will  5. Triston   I don't hate any of these people. I think Triston needs the most work out of any of the 5 and I would have gladly replaced him with a several of the people we lost recently. But I'm just not going to get riled up about the eliminations even when it's one of my favorites.