m1key

Season 11 is my favorite of the old Idol be because of the diverse artists, memorable contestants, good song choices, and great singers that kept me craving more week after week. Of the new Idol, none of the seasons have been amazing in my opinion. I agree that Season 18 had the most potential and couldve been one of the best Idol seasons had Miss Rona not arrived. The Top 20 was super diverse with great vocalists and artists, but the competitions format didnt allow for stellar performances or growth from contestants.

I havent commented on this thread yet, but I've been lurking around all along and keeping up with these rankings LOL. I just want to say that even though I am a HUGE Jessica stan, you phrased your write-up on her perfectly. Keep up the great work, I really enjoy reading these!

If only the Top 11 in CSAB couldve been the real one :///

I would love to see Jeremiahs vote stats.

These guys seriously went as far to find his REPORT CARDS

That is so disgusting. The fact that people made racist attacks and remarks toward an innocent and talented young girl who is very talented is sad. This is even worse then what happened after Alejandro got 2nd.

Ratings are up! The reprises made up the Top 5 performances of the night and Jonny tops the whole thing with a 74

If you hate it all so much then leave! The door is that way. Nobody wants to hear about how you hate everything.

A cultural reset.

1. Julia Gargano- New York State Of Mind 2. Francisco Martin- River 3. Just Sam- Rise Up 4. Dillon James- The Times Are A Changing 5. Jonny West- Makin Love

What are some of the best performances we saw this season?

Last time I cried tears of happiness from someone winning was Darci Lynne on AGT LOL

SAMMM OMGGGG BITCH SHE JUST DID THATTTT

Are they not even gonna reveal the placements of the other 3????????

Hot Take: This season wasnt as bad as people are making it out to be. Sure...it was different. But I think there were some consistent and good performances that we got.