xfactor22

Good analysis but I think his facial expressions enhanced his stage presence. Also I do wonder why you’re using only IDF rating for analysis of performances why someone lost. IDF isnt exactly the most reliable in terms of performance ranking

I won’t debate about iam being one of the most predictable winners ever, as I don’t think that’s the case but I can understand why people might think , but Literally everyone on IDF predicted out of the top 3 that Jack or Will would win prior to finale night.

It means idolforums is probably going to continue to be bad at predicting who will win (they assumed Triston would win this season and assumed Colin or Warren would win last season)

Same. That theory doesn’t exactly work since the voting closed before the results were announced. Besides, I voted for Nathan and my second choice pick was probably Karen (based on finale even though I didn’t care much for her prior to her finale performances), not Asher. I have varied taste. Just cause an R&B singer was my favorite of the top 5, it doesn’t mean I can’t have a different genre as my second choice

glad for Asher. I wish Nathan got farther but oh well. I don’t understand how people sudden started disliking Josh tonight, when they were mostly cool with him all season until then . I thought he was good.

I mean it’s not too much knee for a big company if they actually cared about their fan base

im glad a woman won this season, but idol, still needs to fix other issues in their show. Such as going back to single eliminations. They also should go back to having in top 20/24s a male performance night and female performance night. Also the audience itself still needs to work on its diversity voting department. Like Roman and Nya were robbed and shouldn’t have left nearly as soon as they did.

To be fair, if Josh wins it won’t be a meltdown. Josh is actually pretty good. Not as good as Nathan or Asher, but still good. People over on the voice forums here have been much more critical of Bryan than Josh tbh (I do enjoy Bryan personally)

Good point but to be fair, 19 years is a long time away

Josh is good, but Nathan is better tbh

Maddie Poppe isn’t nothing. Nobody is nothing . However I am going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you didn’t mean this in a cruel way, and assume that you meant that it will be hard for Abi to have a Kelly/vardie/etc level career cause nowadays American idol doesn’t support their new winners much sadly, but you hope Abi can be succcesful without idol . I think she can easily be successful, even if it’s not on a grand level. She deserves to be successful

Again, great job Abi. Now everyone make sure to vote for Nathan on the voice finale tomorrow

Congrats to Abi. I was rooting for Jack since Emmy got out but Abi proved she deserved to win. And she had a great run too.

OMG

wrong thread