Who's going to win season 19?

[CandiceFan12]

Take your pick.

[kenboy123]

I'm pretty sure I heard Ryan said only 1 will be returning...

[wgm]

i have no idea right now

[Carrie_On]

I wanna say Willie but he’s the early front runner and they rarely win, but he could be like Scotty who pretty much ran away with the competition from the start. Chayce and Grace are my other two guesses. Arthur has a good shot too but I’m not sure if America will vote for a returning contestant over the new contestants. 

[Weedy_Speedy]

Chayce, probably. He's great and a WGWG.

[Shasta357]

1 hour ago, Weedy_Speedy said:

Chayce, probably. He's great and a WGWG.

This. Although who knows anymore.. I remember last season never being more shocked than when Just Sam won, so.. 

[mytake1]

1 hour ago, Weedy_Speedy said:

Chayce, probably. He's great and a WGWG.

He's won Idol several times under different names.  He won't bring anything new.

[kenboy123]

My early pick is Casey, she's young and can appeal to people her age, but since she's rock, she can appeal to a older voters who like that style and looking to bring it back to the mainstream...Chayce does seem like the typical American Idol winner, but it's a competitive season and the last few winners have varied in types...

 

I don't think Willie or Grace will win though, there is something quite dry about their personalities, especially Willie, at least that's IMO...but who knows??

 

If Maddie Poppe can win, maybe Ava August can possibly win...

Edited April 13, 2021 by kenboy123

[CarmenSandiego]

I chose Ava but I could see Willie or Casey winning.

[BamBam]

Unfortunately probably Willie.

 

Otherwise its Chayce, Grace or Arthur.

 

Anyone else wins and I'll be absolutely floored

[kenboy123]

the answer is Arthur Gunn....yuck...

[MargoK]

Anyone but Arthur Gunn!!!!

 

I voted for Willie but Casey or Grace could win.

[Yvette5151]

Casey Bishop 

[Sept390]

Willie, Chayce, Casey, Grace and Arthur Gunn (very likely) are clearly the contenders

 

I can see Ava and Hunter being a dark horse but it's quite unlikely at this point

[Bonga]

Ether Hunter or Caleb

[iloveadam]

COVID-19.

[KelseyW]

8 hours ago, kenboy123 said:

the answer is Arthur Gunn....yuck...

Nice. 

2 hours ago, MargoK said:

Anyone but Arthur Gunn!!!!

 

I voted for Willie but Casey or Grace could win.

 

I don't really know who will win, but I hope it's Casey! We've never had a rocker girl win and I think it's way overdue on this show...  

 

ETA: I will not be voting for Arthur even though he was my main fave last season. I personally think he shouldn't be allowed to compete because runner up is one spot below the winner and just doesn't seem right to me. I am glad he gets to perform on the Idol stage though. My vote will be for Makayla most likely.  

Edited April 14, 2021 by KelseyW

[kenboy123]

For me, Team NEWBIE!!!...ANYONE BUT THE RETURNEE!!!...

[sydneysam]

Makayla Phillips

 

 

 

 

[sydneysam]

Just now, anonymouskid_35 said:

Makayla Phillips

 

 

 

 

 

just kidding LMAO, with the right song choices, I think Casey will win it all (and I would WANT and LOVE that)

 

But if not, Chayce's the one

[Stacey.]

Casey is good but... I really can't imagine her winning at all.

 

Chayce probably... and if not, then Willie.

[hazuki]

I think it'll be a Grace/Willie final 2.  

[Angeles]

Makayla 

[Bk1234]

Just now, Angeles said:

Makayla 

Yes, she will. 

[thenghreport]

If I'm looking at the folks in the Top 12 who have a shot at this thing, it's:

 

Willie

Grace

Casey

Chayce

Ava

 

If Arthur Gunn is the returnee, I'd add him as well.

 

I'd rank the odds of those folks winning at around this:

 

1. Willie

2. Chayce

3. Arthur

4. Casey

5. Grace

6. Ava