I'll begin with the eliminated contestants:
1. Peyton: If she wasn't so young, she could've gone to Hollywood.
2. Julia: She made me cringe, sad to say.
3. Jacob. Uh -- no. He was montaged, so he goes here.
Now it's time for the ones who made it to Hollywood:
1. Elleigh -- I thought she wouldn't be great but she surprised me.
2. Quintavious -- best of the guys by a mile.
3. Deida -- definitely has a lot of potential.
4. Alyssa -- I would have ranked her higher had she not muscled into her friend's audition.
5. Amari -- first song definitely was creative, but her second song was better.
6. Michael -- he was fine, but that was the wrong song choice. Never sing a Kelly Clarkson song on American Idol!
7. Lillian -- she was good enough from what I saw of her.
8. Conall -- he was pleasant enough.
9. D.J. -- I only got to hear him in montage, but he was the best of those montaged.
10. Reagan -- he began well but had problems in the middle. Second song was a mess for me.
11. Dave -- he used too many growls for me.
12. Athena -- first song was fine. Second song was horrific.
13. Anna Grace -- I only got to hear her in montage, so she goes here among those who got less than three yes votes.