Jump to content


  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by mytake1

  1. This is the Unpopular Opinions thread - not a Fan Page.
  2. That has to do more with ABC Idol. When Idol was on FOX they still had alums appear even when the show had celebrity judges.
  3. I don't think either are Unpopular Opinions.
  4. And he always handled it really well. Kris won in life too - with his family. He has the most kids of all the Idol winners. There's a dark side to being in the spotlight. Adam has struggled with depression and went through a very dark period. He said he was lonely and felt detached. He was tired of chasing the career and his mental health suffered. Like Kris, he is also now an indie artist.
  5. It was on a Reddit AMA she did a few mos back. Maddie said unfortunately she couldn't talk about what happened with her album and the lack of support from Idol - because she was told there will be consequences if she did.
  6. It was what happened to her post Idol. She was not allowed to perform any new music on the show, even with her album dropping. She has since said she can't talk about Idol or her album or she will be sued.
  7. But look how badly the winners have been treated. Maddie and Laine have never been allowed to perform their own music on the show. Sam has been snubbed altogether. Even if Willie and Grace don't win, they can still get a record deal. Move on and not be locked to the Idol contract.
  8. Like Maddie, Laine, Sam. Look what happened to them. I thought Laine was treated poorly tonight.
  9. Yeah, especially this late in the competition. There's no proof whatever so ever that Chayce has picked up all these votes from Caleb, Arthur, Hunter. And next week from Casey?
  10. It's a myth that Chayce picked up the votes of the eliminated contestants. Some stopped watching, voting. I can also see fans voting against him - since they see him taking the spot of their favorite.
  11. She did at one point. And if she still does, she would not be eligible to compete on Idol. Conflict of interest.
  12. Very few. MJsBlog made the point that ABC Idol has always allowed anyone who didn't make the Top 10 to audition again. But she said very few do. And those who do rarely make it further. Regarding Jeana, she's done with Idol. She didn't even want to appear on the Series Finale at FOX. And if Sonika still has a contract with Disney, she would not be eligible.
  13. There's no real correlation with Itunes (which is small market). If that was the case, Arthur Gunn would be in the Top 2 with voters.
  14. There should be an Option - None of these. The most popular winning songs of all time are: Home The Time of My Life A Moment Like This I don't think any of the Top 4 songs even come close.
  15. I highly doubt most of Kelly's fans even watch Idol. It's just not that an inspiring of a song choice. But if Grace has the fan base, they will carry her.
  16. I actually think Arthur and Hunter have the better songs.
  17. Idol did the right thing. They really had no choice, but to cut him. It would have been a PR nightmare otherwise. I am not buying the 12 yr old kid defense. We've seen people at that age commit some horrible crimes. Also, when he found out the video was leaked, he scrambled and blocked people. That came off like he was trying to save himself.
  18. YES! At the finale in 2 weeks, along with Arthur, rest of Top 10.
  19. Arthur has his fans, just like Hunter. I doubt they will bring anyone back, but if they do, the fairest approach would be the next highest voter getter. I
  20. As I said, I don't think it was your intention, but I would not have started off by saying "nobody wants Arthur back". That's a trigger.
  21. Idol not only needs to can him, but they need tell the truth of what happened. Not some b.s. that he is gone for personal reasons. Unfortunately, there are people making excuses for him, that he is just a kid, it was a joke. I am not surprised since there are lots of super conservatives among Idol viewers.
  22. If they do bring someone back (which I doubt they will), the fairest way would be the person who had the next highest vote. I don't think you meant it, but It's not smart to dog a contestant who is person of color, especially under the circumstances of why this conversation is happening. He could be the next highest vote.
  • Create New...