Jump to content

S21 TOP 10: Rank the performances.


S21 TOP 10: Rank the performances.  

83 members have voted

  1. 1. Choose:

    • Holly Forbes - Last Dance
    • Wendy Moten - Jolene
    • Jeremy Rosado- Freedom was a Highway
    • Jershika Maple - Ain´t it Fun
    • Lana Scott - The One that Got Away
    • Joshua Vacanti - If I Ain´t Got You
    • Jim and Sasha Allen - Stay
    • Paris Winningham - Amazed
    • Hailey Mia - Peter Pan
    • Girl Named Tom - Viva la Vida

Recommended Posts

Overall not as good as the last live show imo.

1. Joshua - I was so ready to hate the song, but I'm glad I didn't. It stood out enough from the other versions I've heard.

2. Wendy - She flubbed one lyric, but it was still a beautiful performance.

3. Jershika - Out of the box song choice for sure, and I love every second of it. It was so fun.


4. Paris - I don't like cheesy songs, but he just sang the hell out of it. So no further complaints.

5. Lana - I prefer the studio version. There were some melody changes she did that sounded a bit forced, but still pretty solid performance.

6. J&S - Still don't think their voices harmonize that well, but it's probably their best performance yet. 

7. Hailey - Eh, it was fine, but she seemed shakier than normal.

8. GNT - What's up with two thirds of them messing up the lyrics tonight...? They didn't blend as well as I hoped they would. 

9. Jeremy - He did okay, but the band was overpowering. Overall, not super memorable.  

10. Holly - Yikes, she sounded winded the whole way through, and I was missing the signature big note at the end.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Maneskin -  Even the band was much more interesting than all of these US ones this season when they competed on the X-Factor Italy. 





2. GNT

3. Joshua

4. Paris

5. Hailey

6. Jershika

7. Wendy

8. Jim & Sasha

9. Jeremy

10. Lana

11. Holly

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Girl Named Tom - I don´t care what anybody says. That was a concert!

2. Paris - As consistent as ever. Loved the bit of rasp and how he got in it emotionally.

3. Joshua - Bringing the drama and his own flair to an overdone song. Loved it.

4. Wendy - Finally singing country! Loved her storytelling and props for going on stage after the fall. She´s a pro.

5. Lana - The most I´ve liked her all season, props for the creativity.

6. Hailey - Bandzilla´d at times, but good vocals. That being said, a step down from last week.

7. Jershika - Song didn´t benefit her, but she did what she could, and there were some fantastic moments there. Still, her weakest.

8. Jeremy - Better than last week, actually. He did better than expected although the song didn´t do him any favors and it was just a weak choice.

9. Jim and Sasha - Not as good as last week´s Monday, but better than Tuesday and their PO/T13. Still, their time is done.

10. Holly- Gorgeous intro, and then it fell HARD.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10. Holly Forbes - holly, you might be reading this lmao and i don't want to offend you so i'll just say the opening was okay

9. J&S Allen - some parts were gorgeous, still the harmonies are off and dynamics are barely existent and those few that are ..yikes

8. Jeremy Rosado - karaoke

7. Hailey Mia - the high notes were there and she's a great singer but yeah, bandzilla and a mediocre song choice stood in the way of a memorable performance 


6. Paris Winningham - some off moments towards the end but i like that he showed a more vulnerable side this week

5. Jershika Maple - second half was shaky but props for surviving that song choice, elevating herself from the karaoke lane with it and still giving some impressive vocals 

4. Lana Scott - I think she oversang, keeping it soft would've been a moment, those parts were gorgeous, i appreciate the arrangement 


3. Wendy Moten - she sounded beautiful, not too exciting but beautiful, then again she didn't look one bit invested in that performance



2. GNT - I agree some parts could've been vocally executed better but it was a performance, very inventive

1. Joshua Vacanti - I agree that in some parts, the drama and intensity could've been dialed back but still it was an interesting arrangement, he killed that, also great presence 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Paris Winningham (9) - Damn he really went there, didn’t he?

2. Jershika Maple (8.5) - It WAS fun! I was definitely stressed when I saw the song choice for her but the studio gave me hope. I think this is her least perfect performance so far, but it’s Paramore. It’s permitted. Hayley would stan.

3. Lana Scott (8.5) - A couple iffy spots here and there, but wow. Such a lovely rendition of the song! I was skeptical of her being a worthy country female after several seasons without one, but she continuously proves herself as worthy.

4. Jim & Sasha Allen (8.5) - Wow this was a surprising step up! Honestly I’d loooove to see them make it through for snowflake and meltdown reasons.

5. Wendy Moten (8.5) - This is my favorite live performance of hers I think. I definitely preferred the live performance to the studio.

6. Joshua Vacanti (8) - I’d categorize this as mostly oversung, but it was a solid version. 

7. Girl Named Tom (7.5) - My faves always have an off week, and this was theirs.  It was too inconsistent throughout. The drums were a nice touch, though!

8. Jeremy Rosado (7.5) - Personally I don’t think this was bad, it did feel pretty awkward though. Definitely out of his element and the song itself isn’t that good, but I do hope to see him for another week.

9. Hailey Mia (7) - Not very good tonight, Stale song choice, notable mistakes throughout. 

10. Holly Forbes (6) - Oh Holly… goodness I’m sorry. This didn’t work out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Create New...