Jump to content

Rank the Blinds: Season 19; Episode 3


Choose your favorite!  

46 members have voted

  1. 1. Favorite Performance from Night 3 of blinds?

    • Rio Souma
      1
    • Ryan Berg
      1
    • JusJon
      1
    • Ben Allen
      3
    • Kelsie Watts
      23
    • Carter Rubin
      8
    • Casme
      1
    • DeSz
      27


Recommended Posts

  1. Desz & Kelsie (both of them slayed, if the sound mix had been better on Desz' audition it would've been a clearer cut #1)
  2. Ben (he wasn't bad, just not my taste - I see the appeal to Minivan but I don't know if he's gonna outsell the other country guys we've already met)
  3. Everyone else
Link to post
Share on other sites

1. DeSz (9/10) - Excellent! The sound mix was not kind to her at all, however.

2. Kelsie Watts (9/10) - A pleasant surprise! That note at the end was killer!

3. Rio Souma (8.5/10) - A favorite song of mine and I thought he did very well! Zaxai's version is hard to match but Rio gave it his best.

4. Casme (8/10) - Still somewhat fuming about the 34%. She deserved a much higher score. Very solid performance!

5. Carter Rubin (7.5/10) - Good voice but it didn't sound right for the song and I wasn't too impressed.

6. Ryan Berg (7.5/10) - Not bad, not very interesting either though.

7. Ben Allen (7/10) - Granted, I'm not a country fan - this was just flat out boring the whole time though.

8. JusJon (7/10) - Fine for what it was, but a bit of a waste it seems.

 

Love how my rankings went K/K/J/J/G/G/B/B btw.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

Decent if plain

8. Ryan Berg
7. JusJon
6. Casme

5. Rio Souma

 

They definitely surprised me

4. Carter Rubin
3. Ben Allen

 

As good as I expected
2. DeSz

 

I didn't expect to like this so much, NGL

1. Kelsie Watts

 

I like this episode better than the premiere LOL.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Great

1. DeSz - The first 40 seconds alone make this #1 for me. Even if I expected more, her tone is beautiful and the song is a jam.

2. Kelsie - Great song + arrangement and impressive high notes.

 

Ok/Mediocre/Meh

3-8. Everyone else

 

I don’t think any of the chair turners were bad, but they were really boring or nothing special (mostly due to dull song choices)

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

My list has been changed after watching all of the performances, So here is the current version:

 

1- Carter Rubin 

2- Ben Allen

3- Kelsie Watts

4- DeSz

5- Rio Souma

6- Ryan Berg

7- Casme

8- Jus Jon

Link to post
Share on other sites

This episode felt a little "meh" overall. A lot of these people seem like fodder.

 

1. Kelsie Watts - Well that was unexpectedly good. Her range is outstanding, and her control is impeccable for the most part-she did have one or two slightly flat notes, but overall it was an outstanding performance.

 

2. Desz - Like with Kelsie, Desz had amazing range and control but also had a slightly off high note. It didn't help that she was drowned out by the band, either. Also, she reminds me SO MUCH of Toneisha, especially in her higher register.

 

3. Carter Rubin - Let me just say, the amount of control he has at 14 really is outstanding, but he's not my type of singer.

 

(gap)

 

4. Rio Souma - He was ok. Not as good as Zaxai's version as everyone has been saying, but decent.

 

5. Casme - Her stage presence and tone are interesting, but the phrasing was a little off and I couldn't help but compare it too to Katie's amazing audition. Hell, I think even Mia Boostrom's version is better than Casme's.

 

6. Ben Allen - He's a good vocalist, but I absolutely hated that song choice. The twang is also.... not appreciated on my end.

 

7. Ryan Berg - Not bad. That's everything I got from this performance.

 

8. JusJon - See Ryan Berg.

Link to post
Share on other sites
17 hours ago, Someone648 said:

1. DeSz (9/10) - Excellent! The sound mix was not kind to her at all, however.

2. Kelsie Watts (9/10) - A pleasant surprise! That note at the end was killer!

3. Rio Souma (8.5/10) - A favorite song of mine and I thought he did very well! Zaxai's version is hard to match but Rio gave it his best.

4. Casme (8/10) - Still somewhat fuming about the 34%. She deserved a much higher score. Very solid performance!

5. Carter Rubin (7.5/10) - Good voice but it didn't sound right for the song and I wasn't too impressed.

6. Ryan Berg (7.5/10) - Not bad, not very interesting either though.

7. Ben Allen (7/10) - Granted, I'm not a country fan - this was just flat out boring the whole time though.

8. JusJon (7/10) - Fine for what it was, but a bit of a waste it seems.

 

Love how my rankings went K/K/J/J/G/G/B/B btw.

my list is very similar:

kelsie

desz

rio

casme

ben

carter

jusjon

ryan b

 

i am also very mad about casme, she was really good!

Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Desz - I can't believe it took 19 seasons for someone to slay this song as hard as she did

2. Kelsie - her range is insane, and that whistle note is hella impressive

3. Casme - the beginning was rough, but she really picked it up halfway through, it's still a little messy but she's so much fun to watch 

4. Carter - I was pleasantly surprised, he's got really good vocal control, though obviously he's got no believability on this song 

5. Rio - he was alright, middle of the pack for me, a little forgettable tbh

6. Ryan - he's got a James Morrison vibe, but I feel like the performance went on for much longer than 90 seconds, it's just not very exciting, maybe it's the song's fault? idk

7. Ben - I don't hate country at all but he's way too twangy for my taste, also not all of that twang sounds natural either

8. Jus Jon - another performance that seemed to drag on for much longer than it actually was, no offence to him but it was just so monotonous the whole way through that I don't think he deserved a chair 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

It's interesting to contrast and compare and IDF poll to a general public poll like TVLine.  Pretty different outcomes.

 

IDF-B3.thumb.JPG.44636c4cefc5ad833f2f97fce705de46.JPGTVL-b3.JPG.f195bb7887d6fe6036e6a77400f34c74.JPG

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 minutes ago, Spurrious said:

It's interesting to contrast and compare and IDF poll to a general public poll like TVLine.  Pretty different outcomes.

 

IDF-B3.thumb.JPG.44636c4cefc5ad833f2f97fce705de46.JPGTVL-b3.JPG.f195bb7887d6fe6036e6a77400f34c74.JPG

Perhaps it also has something to do with the scores Charlie gives. He gave Desz a B- 

Link to post
Share on other sites
51 minutes ago, FloorWax said:

Perhaps it also has something to do with the scores Charlie gives. He gave Desz a B- 

Naw...that only works if you have selective vision cause he gave Casme an A- and she got next to nada.  

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Spurrious said:

It's interesting to contrast and compare and IDF poll to a general public poll like TVLine.  Pretty different outcomes.

 

IDF-B3.thumb.JPG.44636c4cefc5ad833f2f97fce705de46.JPGTVL-b3.JPG.f195bb7887d6fe6036e6a77400f34c74.JPG

it is very interesting to compare, especially since tvline isn't even a country hub, so if ben is doing so well, then it means he not only appealed to minivan, but also just the general audience, which is very impressive.

 

2 hours ago, FloorWax said:

Perhaps it also has something to do with the scores Charlie gives. He gave Desz a B- 

i think that the scores he gives do change peoples votes one way or another if they're already leaning one way. i think that people prefer power over richness in a diva, so that might be why they didn't vote her as much in this poll?

Link to post
Share on other sites
10 hours ago, FloorWax said:

Perhaps it also has something to do with the scores Charlie gives. He gave Desz a B- 

Lol Charlie mason on TV line and MJ Santilli on MJS Big Blog preferred T-storm and Toneisha. Charlie never gave T-storm a grade less than A-(and that A-was just on his KO performance otherwise he always gave T-storm an A grade) but still Todd Destroyed the polls. He always won the polls on MJS and on TV Line, except for Best Playoff Performance and Who Will Win(after Finale Performances) Todd won all the polls there as well.

Edited by Zainab Tufail
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...