Jump to content
idolforums.com
Sign in to follow this  
Elliott

Rank the Winners

Recommended Posts

Kelly Clarkson

Ruben Studdard

Fantasia Barrino

Carrie Underwood

Taylor Hicks

Jordin Sparks

David Cook

Kris Allen

Lee DeWyze

Scotty McCreery

Phillip Phillips

Candice Glover

Caleb Johnson

Nick Fradiani

Trent Harmon

Maddie Poppe

Laine Hardy

Just Sam

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Scotty McCreery

Carrie Underwood

Laine Hardy

Kelly Clarkson

Jordin Sparks

Maddie Poppe

Kris Allen

Phillip Phillips

Just Sam

Trent Harmon

David Cook

Candice Glover

Fantasia Barrino

Nick Fradiani

Lee Dewyze

Ruben Studdard

Caleb Johnson

Taylor Hicks

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Candice Glover

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. Fantasia Barrino

4. Maddi Poppe

5. Jordin Sparks

6. Trent Harmon

7. Just Sam

8. Phillip Phillips

9. Kris Allen

10. Carrie Underwood

11. Ruben Studdard

12. Laine Hardy

13. Caleb Johnson

14. Scotty McCreery

15. David Cook

16. Lee DeWyze

17. Nick Fradiani

18. Taylor Hicks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Carrie Underwood

3. Kris Allen

4. Maddie Poppe

5. David Cook

6. Scotty McCreery

7. Just Sam

8. Ruben Studdard

9. Phillip Phillips

10. Laine Hardy

11. Nick Fradiani

12. Taylor Hicks

13. Candice Glover

14. Jordin Sparks

15. Lee DeWyze

16. Caleb Johnson

17. Fantasia Barrino

18. Trent Harmon

 

15 and 16 are probably interchangeable since I didn't watch either of their seasons and neither of them has a post-Idol career to influence me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Carrie Underwood

Kelly Clarkson

David Cook

Jordin Sparks

Phillip Phillips

Fantasia Barrino

Trent Harmon

Maddie Poppe

Candice Glover

Samantha Diaz (Just Sam)

Scotty McCreery

Kris Allen

Laine Hardy

Caleb Johnson

Ruben Studdard

Lee DeWyze

Nick Fradiani

Taylor Hicks

 

 

I ranked who I think is the best, NOT my favorite...there's a big difference...

Edited by kenboy123

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  1. Lee DeWyze
  2. Trent Harmon
  3. David Cook
  4. Kelly Clarkson
  5. Phillip Phillips
  6. Kris Allen
  7. Laine Hardy
  8. Fantasia Barrino
  9. Candice Glover
  10. Scotty McCreery
  11. Jordin Sparks
  12. Carrie Underwood
  13. Maddie Poppe
  14. Just Sam
  15. Ruben Studdard
  16. Taylor Hicks
  17. Caleb Johnson
  18. Nick Fradiani

I actually like 14 of the 18 winners, so that's good. :haha:

  • Haha 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kris Allen

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. Carrie Underwood

4. Jordin Sparks

5. Candice Glover

6. Taylor Hicks

7. Ruben Studdard

8. David Cook

9. Fantasia Barrino

10. Maddie Poppe

11. Just Sam

12. Caleb Johnson

13. Nick Fradiani

14. Scotty McCreery

15. Phillip Phillips

16. Laine Hardy

17. Lee DeWyze

18. Trent Harmon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Lee DeWyze

2. Trent Harmon

3. David Cook

4. Phillip Phillips
5. Kelly Clarkson

6. Kris Allen

7. Laine Hardy

8. Fantasia

9. Candice Glover

10. Scotty McCreery

11. Carrie Underwood

12. Just Sam

13. Maddie Poppe

14. Jordin Sparks

15. Ruben Studdard

16. Taylor Hicks 

17. Caleb Johnson

18. Nick Fradiani

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1.  Kris Allen

2.  Carrie Underwood

3.  Kelly Clarkson

4.  David Cook

5.  Phillip Phillips

6.  Jordin Sparks

7.  Fantasia

8.  Scotty McCreery

9.  Nick Fradiani

10. Lee DeWyze

11. Trent Harmon

12.  Maddie Poppe

13.  Laine Hardy

14.  Candice Glover

15.  Ruben Studdard

16.  Taylor Hicks

17. Just Sam

18.  Caleb Johnson

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. David Cook

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. Candice Glover

4. Taylor Hicks

5. Phillip Phillips

6. Trent Harmon

7. Carrie Underwood

8. Ruben Studdard

9. Caleb Johnson

10. Jordin Sparks

11. Maddie Poppe

12. Kris Allen

13. Just Sam

14. Fantasia

15. Laine Hardy

16. Scotty McCreery

17. Nick Fradiani

18. Lee DeWyze

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Males:

1. Phillip 

2. Scotty 

3. Laine 

4. Trent 

5. Nick 

6. Lee 

7. David Cook 

8. Kris Allen

9. Caleb Lee Hutchinson

10. taylor hicks

Females:

1. Just Sam

2. Carrie Underwood

3. Kelly Clarkson

4. Jordin Sparks

5. Fantasia Barrino 

6. Maddie Poppe

7. Candice GLover

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Talent

1. Candice Glover

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. David Cook

4. Fantasia Barrino

5. Maddie Poppe

6. Kris Allen

 

Good

7. Trent Harmon

8. Carrie Underwood

9. Jordin Sparks

10. Just Sam

 

Meh

11. Phillip Phillips

 

Trash

12. Taylor Hicks

13. Ruben Studdard

14. Caleb Johnson

15. Laine Hardy

16. Scotty McCreery

17. Nick Fradiani

18. Lee DeWyze

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

01. Kelly Clarkson

02. Candice Glover

03. Caleb Johnson 

04. Fantasia Barrino

05. Jordin Sparks 

06. Nick Fradiani

07. Carrie Underwood

08. Ruben Studdard

09. Taylor Hicks

10. David Cook

11. Lee DeWyze

12. Scotty McCreery

13. Trent Harmon

14. Laine Hardy

15. Phillip Phillips

16. Just Sam

17. Kris Allen

18. Maddie Poppe

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

01.) Kelly Clarkson
02.) Carrie Underwood
03.) Phillip Phillips
04.) Candice Glover
05.) Kris Allen
06.) Maddie Poppe
07.) Lee DeWyze
08.) Fantasia
09.) David Cook
10.) Trent Harmon
11.) Jordin Sparks
12.) Just Sam
13.) Laine Hardy
14.) Scotty McCreery
15.) Taylor Hicks
16.) Ruben Studdard
17.) Caleb Johnson
18.) Nick Fradiani

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Carrie Underwood

3. Fantasia

4. David Cook

5. Candice Glover

6. Maddie Poppe

7. Kris Allen

8. Jordin Sparks

9. Trent Harmon

10. Just Sam

11. Phillip Phillips

12. Laine Hardy

13. Scotty McCreery

14. Caleb Johnson

15. Ruben Studdard

16. Lee DeWyze

17. Nick Fradiani

18. Taylor Hicks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1.  Candice Glover

2.  Kelly Clarkson

3.  Maddie Poppe

4.  Just Sam

5.  David Cook

6.  Carrie Underwood

7.  Fantazia

8.  Jordan Sparks

9.  Caleb Johnson

10. Ruben Studdard

11. Kris Allen

12. Laine Hardy

13. Scotty McCreery

14. Phillip Phillips

15. Trent Harmon

16. Taylor Hicks

17. Lee DeWyze

18. Nick Fradiani

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At the start of the reboot, The Wall St. Journal did a ranking by albums sales including ‘album equivalent units’ (10 track sales equal one album; 1,500 streams equal one album. Source: Nielsen.  Maddie Poppe has since released an album, but it did not make the Billboard Top 200.  Laine Hardy has not released an album.

 

1.  Carrie Underwood                                          

2.  Kelly Clarkson                                

3.  Fantasia Barrino                                             

4.  Scotty McCreery                                            

5.  Phillip Phillips/Ruben Studdard                   

7.  Jordin Sparks                                                  

8.  David Cook                                                     

9.  Taylor Hicks                                                   

10.  Kris Allen                                                      

11.  Lee Dewyze                                                   

12.  Candice Glover                                             

13.  Trent Harmon                                               

14.  Nick Fradiani                                 

15.  Caleb Johnson                                              

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Carrie Underwood

3. Just Sam

4. Maddie Poppe

5. Fantasia Barrino

6. Jordin Sparks

7. Candice Glover

8-17. The other men

18. Caleb Johnson

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kelly Clarksonrk

 

Kris Allen

David Cook

Maddie Poppe

Jordin Sparks

Carrie Underwood

Caleb Johnson

Fantasia Barrino

 

😐

Ruben Studdard

Taylor Hicks

Lee DeWyze

Scotty McCreery

Phillip Phillips

Candice Glover

Nick Fradiani

Trent Harmon

Laine Hardy

Just Sam

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Candice Glover

2. Carrie Underwood

3. Kelly Clarkson

4. Jordin Sparks

5. Kris Allen

6. David Cook

7. Trent Harmon

8. Fantasia

9. Just Sam

10. Phillip Phillips

11. Nick Fradiani

12. Ruben Studdard

13. Caleb Johnson

14. Maddie Poppe

15. Scotty McCreery

16. Laine Hardy

17. Lee DeWyze

18. Taylor Hicks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Phillip Phillips

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. Kris Allen

4. Nick Fradiani

5. Carrie Underwood 

6. Maddie Poppe 

7. David Cook

8. Jordin Sparks

9. Scotty McCreery

10. Just Sam

11. Lee DeWyze

12. Caleb Johnson

13. Laine Hardy

14. Trent Harmon 

15. Taylor Hicks

16. Candice Glover

17. Fantasia Barrino

18. Ruben Studdard

 

I honestly only dislike 17-18. I love 1-3, really like 4-6, like 7-11, somewhat like/don’t mind 12-16

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Kris Allen

3. Maddie Poppe

4. David Cook

5. Laine Hardy

6. Just Sam

7. Jordin Sparks

8. Carrie Underwood

9. Caleb Johnson

10. Phillip Phillips

11. Scotty MCcreery

12. Fantasia 

13. Ruben Studdard

14. Lee Dewyze

15. Taylor Hicks

16. Trent Harmon

17. Candice Glover

18. Nick Fradiani

 

 

BIASED. Yes. lol

 

My list is based on my faves from AI6-AI18.

 

 

Obviously I can't truly rank AI1-AI5...

 

 

I know all 5 of those winners though so yeah... I definitely love the first 3 winners on BOTH versions of Idol. ;) 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Kris Allen

2. Trent Harmon

3. Candice Glover

4. Jordin Sparks

5. Maddie Poppe

6. Lee DeWyze

7. Just Sam

8. David Cook

9. Laine Hardy

10. Nick Fradiani

11. Caleb Johnson

12. Scotty McCreery

13. Phillip Phillips

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1.  Kelly Clarkson — I have to put the original winner here.

2.  Carrie Underwood — she was also a successful singer, so I’m putting her here.

3.  Candice Glover — she was talented and creative.

4.  Just Sam — my favorite winner.  :wub:

5.  Fantasia Barrino — she was the first winner to rise from hardship to victory.

6.  Jordin Sparks — I wish Melinda Doolittle had won but Jordin earned her win.

7.  Maddie Poppe — my first favorite from the start to win.  I only ranked her this low because the ones above her were such powerful singers.

8.  Ruben Studdard — probably my favorite of the male winners.

9.  David Cook — not one of my favorites but he was talented and creative.

10.  Laine Hardy — I may have rooted for others but I still liked his singing.

11.  Taylor Hicks — he wasn’t as vocally gifted, but he was a smart performer.

12.  Kris Allen — I liked him but I only voted for him since I’d never vote for Adam.

13.  Trent Harmon — I just like those above him more.

14.  Caleb Johnson — I’m not a fan of rock music.
15.  Scotty McCreery — I might have liked him more had he not only sang country or countrified every song he sang.
16.  Phillip Phillips — he beat Jessica Sanchez, that’s why I ranked him so low.
17.  Nick Fradiani — he won mostly by avoiding disaster.
18.  Lee DeWyze — he was the least deserving winner, in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...