BJ_Lock

1. Bo Bice 2. Jessica Sanchez 3. Clay Aiken 4. Adam Lambert 5. Crystal Bowersox 6. Diana DeGarmo 7. La'Porsha Renae 8. David Archuleta 9. Lauren Alaina 10. Clark Beckham 11. Blake Lewis 12. Katharine McPhee 13. Arthur Gunn 14. Kree Harrison 15. Caleb Lee Hutchinson 16. Justin Guarini 17. Jena Irene 18. Alejandro Aranda

1. David Cook 2. Kelly Clarkson 3. Candice Glover 4. Taylor Hicks 5. Phillip Phillips 6. Trent Harmon 7. Carrie Underwood 8. Ruben Studdard 9. Caleb Johnson 10. Jordin Sparks 11. Maddie Poppe 12. Kris Allen 13. Just Sam 14. Fantasia 15. Laine Hardy 16. Scotty McCreery 17. Nick Fradiani 18. Lee DeWyze

Is this supposed to represent hell?

Someone please tell Arthur the arrangement to this is terrible. Intervention is very badly needed.

1. Julia 2. Makayla 3. Jovin 4. Francisco 5. Sam 6. Grace 7. Jonny 8. Dillon 9. Arthur 10. Sophia 11. Louis

1. Julia 2. Makayla 3. Jovin 4. Grace 5. Sam 6. Francisco 7. Dillon 8. Louis 9. Jonny 10. Sophia 11. Arthur

Francisco.... gave a performance on American Idol.

Dillon as a person is more interesting than him as a singer.

That was fine but I couldn't connect to it at all.

It is horrific.

What is this hideous arrangement of a John Denver classic?

Sophia's too theatrical with her vocals/performances. Too much mugging at the camera.

Sam will be one of the other females through. Pimp spot last week + major exposure the whole season.

I can't be the only one that finds Sophia's voice really ugly?

This was permanently retired on AI after Caleb. Seems like a big mistake for Jonny to take this on.