Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by redwood79

  1. 20. Nick Merico - Yeah, hard agree 19. Aliana Jester - Agree, also, her voice was just a bit weak compared to the other Top 20. 18. Louis Knight - Lol yeah, Louis was meh since his audition imo. 17. Faith Becnel - I liked Faith, but even I don't believe she merits much higher than #17. 16. Arthur Gunn - Anywhere out side of IDF, this would spark a worldwide protest. Lucky we're in IDF. 15. Sophia Wackerman/James - Yeah, I think she really fizzled out after quarantine rounds started 14. Cyniah Elise - Way too arrogant. And I don't think it's just the edit. Checkout her vlog, and she's just as bad as Nick. 13. Francisco Martin - Francisco is a bit too low for comfort 12. Dillon James - Yeah, Dillon was overrated. 11. DeWayne Crocker, Jr. - I think this is way to high for DeWayne lol. Maybe #18 or #17. 10. Kimmy Gabriela - No, you did Kimmy wrong Deserves to be Top 3. 09. Franklin Boone - Meh. He's fine here if a bit too high. 08. Lauren Spencer-Smith - A nice spot for Lauren. 07. Jonny West - A nice spot for Jonny. 06. Makayla Phillips - Makayla was a trainwreck lol, probably #15 would be better for her. After Hollywood she kinda sounded like she was struggling to breathe each time she sang. 05. Olivia Ximines - Yes!! Nice spot for Olivia. 04. Grace Leer - Bit too high. Grace had like one standout performance which carried her through to the Top 10. Her quarantine performances were pitchy and all over the place. 03. Julia Gargano - Nice spot for Julia. 02. Samantha "Just Sam" Diaz - She deserves #1, but close enough. 01. Jovin Webb - No thank you lol, maybe #8 or #9. (In my opinion) Too high - Jovin, Grace, Makayla, DeWayne Too low - Francisco, Kimmy Just right/Close enough - Everybody else
  2. if she doesnt hit #1 its luke's fault Last 24 iTunes Sales Top 4: 1 Luke Bryan One Margarita 5341 2 Just Sam Rise Up (Performance Version) 3416 3 Jonas Brothers X (feat. KAROL G) 2630 4 Katy Perry Daisies 2185
  3. Random note: Remember when everybody said they made it a Top 5 because Just Sam was 5th place and they needed a girl in the finale? I think the actuality was she was in a very close 2nd behind Arthur for the entire season and they wanted as many similar guys in the finale to split the votes (they got four carbon copies of the same guy, !!!), so they cut it right where the second to last girl would be eliminated (Julia was likely 6th in the vote) to ensure maximum vote splitting
  4. Idk, you can be happy, screaming happy even, for being Top 2. I get that. But they were just like on top of the world, popping confetti, drunk, singing, even as they announced he lost the actual title. Gosh, Gabby and Madison respectively broke into heavy tears after finishing 3rd place. So...
  5. Yeah, I feel bad for him. Language barrier worsened by COVID. (I feel bad for Arthur, not his fans. (Most of) Those people are monsters)
  6. This is what I thought. I was cringing so hard at the end seeing them dancing all around with champagne bottles, drunk. Like if they were really celebrating him getting 2nd, great, but if not, thats mega awkward. Compile that with a possibly enduring misunderstanding of Arthur thinking he got 36 million votes, I don't know how how he's going to let them down from that.
  7. 1. Kelly Clarkson 2. Carrie Underwood 3. Just Sam 4. Maddie Poppe 5. Fantasia Barrino 6. Jordin Sparks 7. Candice Glover 8-17. The other men 18. Caleb Johnson
  8. OMG YES SAM!!!!!!! YOURE AMAZING!!!!!!! IM SO HAPPY!!!!!! Side Note: Arthur fans on all other social media (Insta, Youtube, Reddit) make me want to VOMIT. ugh. So SALTY.
  9. Yay, Kimmy got 2nd! I missed the vote unfortunately, so I couldn't vote for the Final 2 but 2nd is still much better than not making it into the Top 10. ROBBED!
  10. Yes. Season 16 cast was mediocre at best, but I still enjoyed it the most out of all the three seasons. While Season 17/18 had pretty decent talent, it just isn't doing it for me. Probably COVID is to blame for Season 18, so we'll see with 19.
  11. Literally my 3 of my Top 4 all made the Final 4--it would've matched perfectly if Olivia replaced Makayla. why can't IDF determine the American Idol winner xD
  12. YES (removed name)! getting the recognition she deserved on the real show.
  13. I hope Kimmy made it to the finale.
  14. Correction because I'm PC: Just Sam is Black/Latina Francisco Martin is Southeast Asian Arthur Gunn is South Asian I do think Julia making it instead of Jonny/Dillon would've made for the perfect "diverse finalist" bunch
  15. Are you a troll? Or do you actually believe your wacky conspiracies that get proven wrong EVERY single week?
  16. All female Top 5--IDF did the opposite of what America couldn't
  • Create New...