Jump to content

Who Should Have Won Each Season?


Recommended Posts

Hi guys, hope you are staying healthy! So this is who would you want to win from each season, FINALIST only. The Voice has had many robberies in it's past and I want to know who you wanted to win on finale night, not matter how unlikely. Here's mine

 

Season 1: Dia Frampton, Team Blake

Crowning Moment: "Heartless" Top 16

 

Season 2: Juliet Simms, Team CeeLo

Crowning Moment: "It's a Man's World" Top 8

 

Season 3: Cassadee Pope, Team Blake

Crowning Moment: "Over You" Top 10

 

Season 4: Michelle Chamuel, Team Usher (Though I do love Danielle post show more, but based on competition Michelle)

Crowning Moment: "Grenade" Top 8

 

Season 5: Jacquie  Lee, Team Christina (Still love Tessanne so much though)

Crowning Moment: "Who's Loving You" Top 8

 

Season 6: Christina Grimmie, Team Adam

Crowning Moment: "Hold On, We're Going Home" Top 10

 

Season 7: Matt McAndrew, Team Adam

Crowning Moment: "Wasted Love" Finale/"The Blower's Daughter" Top 8

 

Season 8: None of them? I guess Koryn Hawthrone, Team Pharrell

Crowning Moment: "Try" Knockouts

 

Season 9: Jordan Smith, Team Adam

Crowning Moment: "Somebody to Love" Top 8

 

Season 10: Hannah Huston, Team Pharrell (Alisan is godlike, but I just loved every Hannah performance)

Crowning Moment: "Something's Got a Hold On Me" Season 11

 

Season 11: Sundance Head, Team Blake  (Split with We, but she kinda collapsed during the lives versus Sundance got better and better and took risks with his songs)

Crowning Moment: "Love Can Build a Bridge" Top 8

 

Season 12: Chris Blue, Team Alicia (Love Lauren though)

Crowning Moment: "Love On the Brain" Playoffs

 

Season 13: Addison Aggen, Team Adam 

Crowning Moment: "She Used to Be Mine" Top 12

 

Season 14: Brynn Cartelli, Team Kelly (Sacrilege I know, but I loved Brynn and her post show is my favorite of all winners)

Crowning Moment: "Here Comes Goodbye" Knockouts

 

Season 15: Kennedy Holmes, Team Jennifer

Crowning Moment: "Greatest Love of All" Top 11

 

Season 16: Maelyn Jarmon, Team John

Crowning Moment: "Fields of Gold" Blind Audition/"Stay" Top 8

 

Season 17: Rose Short, Team Gwen (Love you Katie too!)

Crowning Moment: "God's Country" Top 10

 

Edited by thevoiceswimmer
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

S6: Christina Grimmie

S7: Matt McAndrew

S8: Kimberly Nichole

S9: Jordan Smith

S10: Alisan Porter

S11: Ali Caldwell/Sundance Head

S12: Lauren Duski

S13: Addison Agen

S14: Kyla Jade (adore Brynn post-show, but when it comes to the competition)

S15: Kennedy Holmes

S16: Maelyn Jarmon

S17: Rose Short

Link to post
Share on other sites

Finalist only is hard because I usually hate every finalist lol

 

S1: Vicci Martinez

S2: Juliet Simms

S3: Cassadee Pope

S4: Danielle Bradbery

S5: Tessanne Chin

S6: Christina Grimmie

S7: Matt McAndrew (kinda by default, this F4 sucked)

S8: Koryn Hawthorne

S9: Jeffery Austin

S10: Alisan Porter

S11: Nobody TBH, if I had to pick I’d choose Billy Gilman but he doesn’t really deserve to win

S12: Lauren Duski

S13: Addison Agen

S14: Brynn Cartelli

S15: Kennedy Holmes

S16: Maelyn Jarmon

S17: Rose Short

Edited by indii
  • Haha 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
57 minutes ago, antikid said:

S6: Christina Grimmie

S7: Matt McAndrew

S8: Kimberly Nichole

S9: Jordan Smith

S10: Alisan Porter

S11: Ali Caldwell/Sundance Head

S12: Lauren Duski

S13: Addison Agen

S14: Kyla Jade (adore Brynn post-show, but when it comes to the competition)

S15: Kennedy Holmes

S16: Maelyn Jarmon

S17: Rose Short

didn't read that it has to be finalists only, sorry, i guess it is what it is!

Link to post
Share on other sites

S6: Christina Grimmie: I just-

crowning moment: Wrecking Ball, no questions asked.

S11: Ignore, lmao. We McDonald was worthy tho

Crowning Moment: Take Me To Church

S12: Lauren Duski: lmao, trash finalists who were a bore, and Lauren slayed it. Queen

Crowning moment: Somewhere In My Broken Heart

S13: Addison Agen: Brooke and Chloe who? trash song selections in the finale and vocals were strained.

Crowning moment: Both Sides Now

S16: Maelyn Jarmon: This season I-

Crowning moment: Fields Of Gold, no questions asked or you don't know talent.

Edited by QueenMae16
Link to post
Share on other sites

S6 Grimmie - I thought she had it in the bag
S7 Matt - I thought he had it in the bag 

S8 Sawyer - Was my favorite from the blinds

S9 Jordan - Not a favorite, but I can’t look you in the eye and say he shouldn’t have won 

S10 Alisan - I threw her some votes in the finale. I like her recent country music more than anything she did on the show. 

S11 Sundance - Easy choice with that finale. Obviously, the audience agreed. 

S12 Lauren - Robbed. 

S13 Addison - Was fine with Chloe winning, though. 

S14 Brynn - The meltdowns on finale night were so much fun. Controversial win, but who cares. 

S15 Chevel - The meltdowns on finale night were so much fun. She was so underestimated by nearly everyone, and won with no pimping. My favorite win by far. 

S16 Maelyn - She was the only good live singer that season. No brainer. 

S17 Ricky - I did vote for him in the finale, but not enthusiastically. 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Making this finalist-only is rough for several seasons (not for good reasons...)

 

S17: Katie Kadan (all were somewhat deserving tbh)

S16: Maelyn Jarmon

S15: Kennedy Holmes

S14: Kyla Jade

S13: Chloe Kohanski

S12: Lauren Duski

S11: Wé McDonald?

S10: Alisan Porter

S9: Jordan Smith

S8: Meghan Linsey

S7: Matt McAndrew?

S6: Christina Grimmie?

S5: Tessanne Chin

S4: Michelle Chamuel

S3: Cassadee Pope

S2: Juliet Simms

S1: Dia Frampton?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Haven't been watching for that long so to make up for it I'll do order of how deserving they were lol

 

S17: Rose > Katie > Ricky > Jake

S16: Maelyn >>> Andrew = Dexter > Gyth

S15: Kennedy > Chevel > Kirk > Chris

S14: Kyla > Britton > Brynn 🤭 > Spensha 

S13: Chloe = Addison > Brooke >>> Red

Link to post
Share on other sites

S5: Tessanne Chin 

S6: Josh Kaufman

S7: Matt McAndrew

S8: Sawyer Fredericks

S9: Jordan Smith

S10: Alisan Porter 

S11: Sundance Head

S12: Chris Blue

S13: Chloe Kohanski

S14: Kyla Jade

S15: Kennedy Holmes

S16: Maelyn Jarmon

S17: Ricky Duran

 

I'm actually pretty content with many of the winners tbh.

-I didn't really like any of the S11 finalists but Sundance was the most consistent of the four.

- Unpopular opinion but I think Chris Blue deserved his win. I enjoyed him a lot throughout the season.

- Laith was actually my favorite in S10, but Alisan was without a doubt the best vocally of the four, so she deserved it.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

S3-Cassadee Pope-Team Blake

Crowning Moment-Over You-Top 10

 

S4-Michelle Chamuel-Team Usher

Crowning Moment-I Knew You Were Trouble-Top 6

 

S5-Tessanne Chin-Team Adam

Crowning Moment-Bridge Over Trouble Water-Semifinals

 

S6-Christina Grimmie-Team Adam

Crowning Moment-Wrecking Ball-BA and Finale Reprise Song

 

S7-Matt McAndrew-Team Adam

Crowning Moment-Wasted Love-Finale Oringinal Song

 

S8-Koryn Hawthorne-Team Pharrell

Crowning Moment-Make It Rain-Top 10

 

S9-Jordan Smith-Team Adam

Crowning Moment-Somebody To Love-Semifinals

 

S10-Alisan Porter-Team Christina

Crowning Moment-Stay With Me Baby-Top 11

 

S11-Billy Gilman-Team Adam

Crowning Moment-I Surrender-Semifinals

 

S12-Chris Blue-Team Alicia

Crowning Moment-Love On The Brain-Live Playoffs

 

S13-Brooke Simpson-Team Miley

Crowning Moment-Amazing Grace-Top 10

 

S14-Kyla Jade-Team Blake

Crowning Moment-How Great Thou Art-Live Playoffs Part 1 *

 

S15-Kennedy Holmes-Team Jennifer

Crowning Moment-Greatest Love Of All-Top 11

 

S16-Maelyn Jarmon-Team John

Crowning Moment-Stay-Semifinals

 

S17-Ricky Duran-Team Blake

Crowning Moment-A Woman Like Her-Finale Original Song *

 

*All songs I picked are performed Live

*On S14 I think it is a tie with Brynn Cartelli-Team Kelly

Crowning Moment-What The World Needs Now Is Love-Semifinals I put Kyla because I think she's a better artist.

*On S17 I just don't want Jake Hoot to win so bad. Either of the 3 Finalist is worth it but I think Ricky Duran should be.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hmm, finalists only you say? Interesting.

 

S4: Michelle Chamuel - One of my favorite contestants ever. I didn't watch her season live but I saw enough of her performances to say she rightly deserved the win.

 

S5: Jacquie Lee - I LOVED Tessanne but I always preferred Jacquie. I think this just comes down to personal preference.

 

S6: Christina Grimmie - The only finalist I remotely cared about.

 

S7: Matt McAndrew - The only finalist I remotely cared about. He probably would have won had Craig not been the only country singer in the top 12.

 

S8: Sawyer Fredericks - My favorite from day 1, though it would have been iconic if Koryn pulled off a miracle win.

 

S9: Jordan Smith - Anyone who thought he wasn't winning is delusional lmao.

 

S10: Alisan Porter - My favorite winner in the shows history. I'll admit, I thought Adam was going to end up winning over her, really happy I was proven wrong.

 

S11: Wé McDonald - I honestly really liked Wé. Yeah her live run was hella shaky but whatever. I found every other finalist impossible to tolerate. 

 

S12: Lauren Duski - As hyped as I was when Chris won, Lauren really deserved to win after giving it some thought. It was coach pimping and nothing else.

 

S13: Brooke Simpson - Chloe was overrated as hell and I couldn't stand Red. I loved Addison a lot but I always liked Brooke more. Favorite from day 1.

 

S14: Kyla Jade - Robbed. I still stand by the fact that she would have won had she been on Kelly's team, because she had all the momentum she needed going into the finale to pull off the win. However, her being on Blake's team ended up with her well-known finale buss, because they only pimped Brynn so hard to give Kelly a win on her first season.


S15: Kennedy Holmes - The poor girl had no chance in the finale no matter what. Confident was one of my favorite performances in the history of the show, but against 3 country singers combined with the instant save handicap left her with no shot to win, regardless of who her coach was. I'm just glad that Blake's horrible country singers both lost, I couldn't stand Kirk or Chris.

 

S16: Maelyn Jarmon - If you picked anyone else then I hope you have a REALLY good reason to back that up. Maelyn was the only finalist who could actually SING, and she never missed a note all season.

 

S17: Rose Short - I would have been happy with a Katie win, but Rose was just better and more consistent. It's too bad the winner was decided the second the top 13 was revealed. Most predictable outcome ever.

 

This was easier to decide than I expected, lol.

Edited by MatthewPalermo
Added reasons *shrug*
Link to post
Share on other sites

The following are the finalists who should have won/deserved their win during their respective seasons

 

Season 1 - Dia Frampton

Season 2 - Juliet Simms

Season 3 - Cassadee Pope

Season 4 - Danielle Bradbery

Season 5 - Tessane Chin

Season 6 - Josh Kaufman

Season 7 - Matt McAndrew

Season 8 - Meghan Linsey

Season 9 - Jordan Smith (not a fan because I was rooting for Emily Ann during this season but he deserved the win)

Season 10 - Alisan Porter

Season 11 - Sundance Head

Season 12 - Lauren Duski (2nd most robbed finalist)

Season 13 - Chloe Kohanski

Season 14 - Kyla Jade (most robbed finalist)

Season 15 - Kirk Jay

Season 16 - Maelyn Jarmon (not a huge fan but she deserved the win)

Season 17 - Ricky Duran

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, MatthewPalermo said:

Hmm, finalists only you say? Interesting.

 

S4: Michelle Chamuel - One of my favorite contestants ever. I didn't watch her season live but I saw enough of her performances to say she rightly deserved the win.

 

S5: Jacquie Lee - I LOVED Tessanne but I always preferred Jacquie. I think this just comes down to personal preference.

 

S6: Christina Grimmie - The only finalist I remotely cared about.

 

S7: Matt McAndrew - The only finalist I remotely cared about. He probably would have won had Craig not been the only country singer in the top 12.

 

S8: Sawyer Fredericks - My favorite from day 1, though it would have been iconic if Koryn pulled off a miracle win.

 

S9: Jordan Smith - Anyone who thought he wasn't winning is delusional lmao.

 

S10: Alisan Porter - My favorite winner in the shows history. I'll admit, I thought Adam was going to end up winning over her, really happy I was proven wrong.

 

S11: Wé McDonald - I honestly really liked Wé. Yeah her live run was hella shaky but whatever. I found every other finalist impossible to tolerate. 

 

S12: Lauren Duski - As hyped as I was when Chris won, Lauren really deserved to win after giving it some thought. It was coach pimping and nothing else.

 

S13: Brooke Simpson - Chloe was overrated as hell and I couldn't stand Red. I loved Addison a lot but I always liked Brooke more. Favorite from day 1.

 

S14: Kyla Jade - Robbed. I still stand by the fact that she would have won had she been on Kelly's team, because she had all the momentum she needed going into the finale to pull off the win. However, her being on Blake's team ended up with her well-known finale buss, because they only pimped Brynn so hard to give Kelly a win on her first season.


S15: Kennedy Holmes - The poor girl had no chance in the finale no matter what. Confident was one of my favorite performances in the history of the show, but against 3 country singers combined with the instant save handicap left her with no shot to win, regardless of who her coach was. I'm just glad that Blake's horrible country singers both lost, I couldn't stand Kirk or Chris.

 

S16: Maelyn Jarmon - If you picked anyone else then I hope you have a REALLY good reason to back that up. Maelyn was the only finalist who could actually SING, and she never missed a note all season.

 

S17: Rose Short - I would have been happy with a Katie win, but Rose was just better and more consistent. It's too bad the winner was decided the second the top 13 was revealed. Most predictable outcome ever.

 

This was easier to decide than I expected, lol.

*Yeah Brooke Simpson and her Amazing Grace is a Finale thing. I really think if she sang it in the Finale she could've won it.

Link to post
Share on other sites
27 minutes ago, JOMZ said:

*Yeah Brooke Simpson and her Amazing Grace is a Finale thing. I really think if she sang it in the Finale she could've won it.

Chloe was winning no matter what

Link to post
Share on other sites
Just now, antikid said:

Chloe was winning no matter what

Chloe is good and I really love her "Landslide" but I still think Brooke was robbed. During lives I sometimes think Chloe is boring.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Have only  consistently watched these

 

13: Addison-The only other teen with such maturity and emotion in their performances was Allison from AI

14.  I've been really impressed with Brynn post show but on the show she was too green. I'll go with Jackie from team Alicia as I prefer her stylistically to Kyla

15.  McKenzie- probably the best vocalist I've seen on the show though she does overdo it

16.  Maelyn- I dont really get the emotion when she sings but obv...

17. I dunno Katie is great at her thing but kinda gimmicky. I suppose Rose

 

I think this season is shaping up to be a lot better than last.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, sneaky said:

Have only  consistently watched these

 

13: Addison-The only other teen with such maturity and emotion in their performances was Allison from AI

14.  I've been really impressed with Brynn post show but on the show she was too green. I'll go with Jackie from team Alicia as I prefer her stylistically to Kyla

15.  McKenzie- probably the best vocalist I've seen on the show though she does overdo it

16.  Maelyn- I dont really get the emotion when she sings but obv...

17. I dunno Katie is great at her thing but kinda gimmicky. I suppose Rose

 

I think this season is shaping up to be a lot better than last.

Jackie and MaKenzie are not FINALIST. I get your point though. Jackie is really good but her semifinal song "Here We Go Again" was a mess. MaKenzie though was robbed.

Link to post
Share on other sites

S10 - Alison

S11 - Sundance

S12 - Lauren (biggest robbery in the ahows history)

S13 - Addison

S14 - Brynn

S15 - Chevel

S16 - Maelyn (duh

S17 - I would have been fine with either Rose or Ricky

Link to post
Share on other sites
45 minutes ago, JOMZ said:

Chloe is good and I really love her "Landslide" but I still think Brooke was robbed. During lives I sometimes think Chloe is boring.

I believe that Addison won that season easily. I'd rank Brooke and Chloe as a tie for the second place. Chloe kinda flopped on the finale night, delivering a rather boring performance in the pimp spot. I don't think she gained any new fans in the finale, she only could've lost some. She still managed to win though

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

S12 - Chris Blue still I think

S13 - Addison Agen by far; next would have been Brooke though, I didn't like Chloe's tone/voice

S14 - Kyla Jade 

S15 - Kennedy Holmes? I don't like them too much, but she's obviously the most talented vocalist (also I think I listened to Turning Tables so much that I've started to hate it)

S16 - Gyth Rigdon JK Maelyn Jarmon of course

S17 - Rose Short, with Katie and Ricky up close. Jake performed Knockouts and Semifinals surprisingly well though

Link to post
Share on other sites

S1: Dia Frampton

S2: Juliet Simms

S3: Cassadee Pope

S4: Michelle Chamuel

S5: Jacquie Lee

S6: Christina Grimmie

S7: Chris Jamison

S8: Koryn Hawthorne

S9: Jordan Smith

S10: Alisan Porter

S11: Wé McDonald

S12: Aliyah Moulden

S13: Addison Agen

S14: Kyla Jade

S15: Kennedy Holmes

S16: Maelyn Jarmon

S17: Katie Kadan

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...