Who Should Have Won Each Season?

[rp3598]

1. Javier Colon

2. Juliet Sims

3. Cassadee Pope

4. Danielle Bradberry

5. Jacquie Lee

6. Christina Grimmie

7. Matt McAndrew

8. Sawyer Fredericks

9. Jordan Smith

10. Alisan Porter

11. Billy Gilman

12. Chris Blue (Lauren deserved it too)

13. Addison Agen

14. Brynn Cartelli

15. Chevel Shepherd

16. Maelyn Jarmon

17. Rose Short

18. Thunderstorm Artis

19. DeSz

20. Cam Anthony

[QueenCami]

On 4/19/2020 at 12:01 PM, QueenCami said:

S12 - Chris Blue still I think

S13 - Addison Agen by far; next would have been Brooke though, I didn't like Chloe's tone/voice

S14 - Kyla Jade 

S15 - Kennedy Holmes? I don't like them too much, but she's obviously the most talented vocalist (also I think I listened to Turning Tables so much that I've started to hate it)

S16 - Maelyn Jarmon 

S17 - Rose Short, with Katie and Ricky up close. Jake performed Knockouts and Semifinals surprisingly well though

update a year later

S3: Cassadee???

S4: Danielle???

S5: Tessanne [Jacquie]

S6: Christina

S7: Damien???

S8: Koryn

S9: Jordan

S10: Alisan [Hannah]

S11: Billy [Sundance]

S12: Chris [Lauren/Aliyah]

S13: Addison [Brooke]

S14: Kyla [Brynn]

S15: Chevel

S16: Maelyn

S17: Rose

S18: Toneisha

S19: DeSz [Carter]

S20: Rachel [Cam]

 

[Cookie73]

Limiting this to the finalists

S20- Cam Anthony

S19- Carter Rubin/DeSz

S18- Todd Tilghman/Thunderstorm Artis

S17- Rose Short

S16- Maelyn Jarmon

S15- Kennedy Holmes

S14- Britton Buchanan/Kyla Jade

S13- Brooke Simpson

S12- Chris Blue

S11- Sundance Head/Billy Gilman

S10- Alisan Porter

S9- Jordan Smith

S8- Sawyer Fredericks

S7- Matt McAndrew/Chris Jamison

S6- Josh Kaufman/Christina Grimmie

S5- Tessanne Chin

S4- Michelle Chamuel

S3- Cassadee Pope

 

Didn't watch 2 and 1. I listed 2 contestants because there were some seasons where there were 2 contestants I would have been happy to see win

[Jordan Smith Fan]

S20- Cam Anthony

S19- DeSz

S18- Thunderstorm Artis

S17- Rose Short

S16- Maelyn Jarmon

S15- Makenzie Thomas

S14- Kyla Jade

S13- Chloe MK

S12- Chris Blue

S11- Ali Caldwell

S10- Alisan Porter

S9- Jordan Smith

S8- Kimberly Nichole

S7- Matt McAndrew

S6- Josh Kaufman/Christina Grimmi

S5- Tessanne Chin

S4- Michelle Chamuel

S3- Amanda Brown

S2- Juliet Simms

S1- Javier Colon

 

LOL I forgot Amanda. 

Edited August 11, 2021 by Jordan Smith Fan

[B-B]

4: Sasha

5: Tessanne

6: Sisaundra

7: Matt

8: Kimberly

9: Jordan

10: Alisan

11: Ali

12: Chris

13: Brooke

14: Kyla

15: Mackenzie

16: Maelyn

17. Rose

18. Toneisha

19: Desz

20: Cam

[sydneysam]

57 minutes ago, B-B said:

4: Sasha

5: Tessanne

6: Sisaundra

7: Matt

8: Kimberly

9: Jordan

10: Alisan

11: Ali

12: Chris

13: Brooke

14: Kyla

15: Mackenzie

16: Maelyn

17. Rose

18. Toneisha

19: Desz

20: Cam

 

 

All I can say is, you've got a great taste  

[VoiceFan!]

11: Ali

12: Vanessa F

13: Brooke/Addison

14: Kyla

15: Mackenzie/SandyRedd

16: Maelyn/Rod

17: Jake/Rose

18: Thunderstorm/Megan

19: DeSz

20: Cam/Victor

Edited August 11, 2021 by VoiceFan!

[QueenCami]

6 hours ago, B-B said:

4: Sasha

5: Tessanne

6: Sisaundra

7: Matt

8: Kimberly

9: Jordan

10: Alisan

11: Ali

12: Chris

13: Brooke

14: Kyla

15: Mackenzie

16: Maelyn

17. Rose

18. Toneisha

19: Desz

20: Cam

I absolutely love this list! I never became a fan of Matt, but the rest of them are absolutely excellent and would have been deserving winners. I would have picked Sasha for sure if not for the OP saying to pick only people who made the finale.