Top 3: AI vs TV

[Hamza Tufail]

Discuss.

Edited May 24, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[erik g]

1. Gina and it's not close

2. Megan i think

3. D Smooth and it's not close

[nytsch]

This is hard because I want to say Iam because he was more consistent, but if Gina had more performances because of this stupid format...

 

Honestly same with Grace vs Megan, I mean I guess I can for sure say D Smooth on the last one lmao

 

I think I'll go with

 

1. Gina

2. Megan

3. D Smooth

[Discovolcano]

1 Iam. I like the Hawaii feeling I get when he sings

2 Megan

3 D Smooth by a lightyear 

[keychange]

I prefer Gina > Iam in terms of artistry and vocals but Iam's run was more consistent imo. Both are great and satisfying winners!

 

Megan > Grace

 

D.Smooth >>>>>>>>>>> Colin

[jdanton2]

Iam was definitely my favorite of the winners though Gina is good as well. for second place Grace in my opinion is better than Megan.for third place D Smooth in my opinion is much better than Colin and overall of the 6 options my favorite.

[Bk1234]

Gina

Grace (but this is close)

D. Smooth

[Carrie_On]

1. Iam, but so glad both of my favorites won

 

2. Megan

 

3. D. Smooth of course

[season1]

Gina

Megan

Colin

 

[Voice]

Gina

Megan

D. Smooth

[QueenKalie]

clean sweep for the voice for me and it's not even close.

Gina, Grace, D Smooth. 

[Hamza Tufail]

Iam

Megan (Close)

D. Smooth

[Hsamid]

This was easy for me honestly.

 

3. D. Smooth. He never had a bad performance and while Colin had his moments, I can't say the same for him.

 

2. Megan because she proved over a far larger number of performances her ability to perform at a consistently high level. Grace is one of my favourite country singers on either show though, and had the format been longer, she may have been my choice.

 

1. Iam for the same reason as 2. While I don't think Iam has performances as good as Gina's battle or playoffs, the majority of his run is better than anything else Gina did imo.

[FloorWax]

1. Iam Tongi has IT. Gina Miles also has something special but Iam has IT.

 

2. I think Megan at her best was better than Grace at her best. Sad to say but Grace never wowed me but Megan did at least once or twice.

 

3. D. Smooth by a landslideeeeee lol

[xfactor22]

Iam

 

Megan

 

D. Smooth

[Stacey.]

5 hours ago, season1 said:

Gina

Megan

Colin

 

This!

[Adam Bruce]

Gina

Grace

D. Smooth

 

Clean Sweep. Not a fan of Idol this time. Everything was so bland.

[MILO JAY]

On 5/23/2023 at 11:18 PM, erik g said:

1. Gina and it's not close

2. Megan i think

3. D Smooth and it's not close

LOL LITERALLY ME.

1. i was like Gina 1000000000%.

2. hmm megan no wait... yeah megan

3. D. Smooth 10000000%

[MILO JAY]

On 5/23/2023 at 11:52 PM, season1 said:

Gina

Megan

Colin

 

How the heck is Colin over d Smooth????? agree with the other two tho

[season1]

5 minutes ago, MILO JAY said:

How the heck is Colin over d Smooth????? agree with the other two tho

 

I like Colin's music and voice more.

[QueenCami]

gina but not a massive fan of either

megan

colin but not a massive fan of either