Jump to content

Describe your ideal Playoffs scenario (S21)


Misirlou
 Share

Recommended Posts

Team Kelly

PV1: Girl Named Tom

PV2: Jeremy Rosado

CS: Gymani

WC: Hailey Mia

 

Team Legend

PV1: Samuel Harness

PV2: Jershika Maple
CS: David Vogel

WC: Shadale

 

Team Ariana

PV1: Holly Forbes

PV2: Bella DeNapoli

CS: Ryleigh Plank

WC: Jim and Sasha

 

Team Blake

PV1: Wendy Moten

PV2: Paris Winningham

CS: Peedy Chavis

WC: Lana Scott

 

WC Winner- Shadale

 

 

 

 

 

Edited by Cookie73
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, these are more fun than the predictions.

 

Team Kelly

PV1: Girl Named Tom

PV2: Jeremy Rosado

CC: Hailey Mia

WC: Gymani

 

Team Legend

PV1: Samuel Harness

PV2: Jershika Maple

CC: Shadale

WC: David Vogel

 

Team Ariana

PV1: Holly Forbes

PV2: Bella DeNapoli

CC: Ryleigh Plank

WC: Jim & Sasha Allen

 

Team Blake

PV1: Wendy Moten

PV2: LiBianca

CC: Paris Winningham

WC: Lana Scott

 

Wildcard Winner - David Vogel

Link to comment
Share on other sites

(Comeback winner - Samara Brown)

 

Team Kelly:

PV1: Girl Named Tom

PV2: Jeremy Rosado

CS: Gymani

WC: Katie Rae

 

Team Legend:

PV1: Samuel Harness

PV2: Jershika Maple

CS: David Vogel

WC: Samara Brown

 

Team Ariana

PV1: Bella DeNapoli

PV2: Jim & Sasha Allen

CS: Raquel Trinidad

WC: Ryleigh Plank

 

Team Blake:

PV1: Libianca

PV2: Lana Scott

CS: Wendy Moten

WC: Paris Winningham

 

Wildcard: Katie Rae vs. Samara Brown vs. Ryleigh Plank vs. Paris Winningham

Winner: Samara Brown

 

 

 

Top 13 consisting of:

Bella DeNapoli

David Vogel

Girl Named Tom

Gymani

Jeremy Rosado

Jershika Maple

Jim & Sasha Allen

Lana Scott

Libianca

Raquel Trinidad

Samara Brown

Samuel Harness

Wendy Moten

Link to comment
Share on other sites

PVs + CS:

Kelly - GNT and Gymani + Hailey Mia 

John - Samuel and Jershika + Joshua

Ariana - Bella and Holly + Jim & Sasha (ideally it'd be Raquel stepping up but i lowkey gave up on that)

Blake - Libianca and Wendy + Paris 

 

WC: 

Kelly - Jeremy

John - David WINS

Ariana - Raquel 

Blake - Peedy

(+Twitter crashes and no one comes back!)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly

PV: GNT, Hailey

CS: Gymani

WC: Katie

 

John

PV: Jershika, Shadale

CS: Samuel

WC: David

 

Ariana

PV: Holly, Bella

CS: Ryleigh

WC: Raquel

 

Blake

PV: Wendy, Lana

CS: Libianca

WC: Peedy

 

WC winner: Vaughn 😈

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Team Kelly

PV1: GNT

PV2: Jeremy

CS: Katie

WC: Gymani
 

Team John

PV1: Samuel

PV2: Jershika

CS: Shadale

WC: David

 

Team Ari

PV1: Bella

PV2: Jim & Sasha

CS: Holly

WC: Raquel

 

Team Blake

PV1: LiBianca

PV2: Wendy

CS: Paris

WC: Lana

 

Wildcard winner: David

Link to comment
Share on other sites

TEAM KELLY:

PV 1 : GNT

PV 2 : Jeremy

CS: Katie

WC: Hailey

 

TEAM LEGEND

PV 1 : Samuel

PV 2 : David

CS: I'm fine with anyone here.

WC: Same

 

TEAM ARIANA

PV 1 : Holly

PV 2 : Jim and Sasha

CS: Raquel

WC: Ryleigh

 

TEAM BLAKE

PV 1 : Paris

PV 2: Wendy

CS: LiBianca

WC: Peedy

 

WC Winner: Anyone on Team Legend that didnt get any of the first 3 spots.

 

Edited by Misirlou
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly:
PV: GNT, Hailey

CS: Katie

 

John:
PV: Samuel, Shadale

CS: Jershika

 

Ariana:
PV: Ryleigh

CS: Raquel (no way homegirl gets PV imo)

This team sucks.

 

Blake:
PV: Wendy

Hoping that PV 2, CS, and Wildcard all include Paris, Libianca, and Lana.

 

Wild Card: Insert Team Blake member here. Specifically counting on Vaughn to flop his performance for my own entertainment.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Comeback: Samara Brown

 

Kelly:
PV1 - GNT

PV2 - Gymani

CS - Katie

WC - Hailey

 

Ariana:
PV1 - Holly

PV2 - Bella

CS - Ryleigh

WC - Jim & Sasha

 

John:
PV1 - Jershika

PV2 - Samuel

CS - Shadale

WC - David

 

Blake:
PV1 - Wendy

PV2 - LiBianca

CS - Paris

WC - Lana

 

WC winner: David

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kelly

PV: GNT and Gymani

CS: Katie Rae

WC: Hailey (winner)

 

John

PV: Jershika and Shadale

CS: Samuel

WC: David

 

Ariana

PV: Bella and Holly

CS: Ryleigh or Raquel (based off PO)

WC: Ryleigh or Raquel

 

Blake

PV: Wendy and LiBianca

CS: Lana

WC: Paris
 

CB: Hailey or Samara

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Y’all said ideal, so here you go.

 

Comeback: Hailey Green (love Samara but Team Legend’s stupid stacked already)

 

Team Kelly

PV1: GNT

PV2: Jeremy

CS: Gymani

WC: Hailey Mia

 

Team Legend

PV1: Samuel

PV2: David

CS: Jershika

WC: Shadale

 

Team Ariana

PV1: Holly

PV2: Ryleigh

CS: Bella

WC: Raquel

 

Team Blake

PV1: Wendy

PV2: LiBianca

CS: Hailey Green

WC: Paris

 

Wildcard: Literally any of them could advance and I’d be happy tbh, but I’m picking Raquel bc she’s my longest-term investment here

 

Top 13

Bella

David

GNT

Gymani

Hailey G

Holly

Jeremy

Jershika
LiBianca

Raquel

Ryleigh

Samuel

Wendy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Team Kelly

PV1: Hailey Mia

PV2: Girl Named Tom

CS: Gymani

WC: Jeremy Rosado

 

Team Legend

PV1: Jershika Maple

PV2: Samuel Harness

CS: David Vogel

WC: Shadale

 

Team Ariana

PV1: Holly Forbes

PV2: Bella DeNapoli

CS: Ryleigh Plank

WC: Jim & Sasha Allen

 

Team Blake

PV1: Wendy Moten

PV2: Paris Winningham

CS: Lana Scott

WC: LiBianca

 

 Wildcard Winner - LiBianca 

 

Also, for the Comeback, i'll go with Hailey. (I'd be fine with either her or LiBianca winning the Wildcard)

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

*not counting Vaughn, Hailey G, Aaron, or Samara, although if i had to pick it would be Hailey

Team Blake

PV1: Wendy

PV2: Lana

CS: Libianca

WC: Paris

 

Team Ari

PV1: Holly

PV2: Bella

CS: Raquel

WC: Ryleigh

 

Team Legend 

PV1: Samuel

PV2: Jershika

CS: Shadale

WC: I dont care lol

 

Team Kelly 

PV1: Hailey

PV2: GNT

CS: Gymani

WC: Jeremy

 

WC: Ryleigh

 

Top 13

Wendy

Lana

Libianca

Holly

Bella

Raquel

Ryleigh

Samuel

Jershika

Shadale

Hailey 

GNT

Gymani 

 

 

 

Edited by erik g
Link to comment
Share on other sites

(Comeback winner Samara

 

Kelly

Pv 1 Gymani

Pv 2 Jeremy

CS Katie 

WC GNT

 

John

PV 1 Samuel

Pv 2 Joshua

CS Jershika

WC Samara

 

Blake

PV 1 Wendy

PV 2 Paris

CS Libainca 

WC Peedy

 

Ari

PV 1 Jim and Sasha

PV 2 Ryleigh

JC Raquel

WC Holly

 

WC winner Samara 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Team Blake:

 

PV1: Paris

PV2: Peedy

CS: Wendy

WC: Lana

 

Team Kelly:

 

PV1: GNT

PV2: Hailey Mia

CS: Gymani

WC: Jeremy

 

Team Ariana:

 

PV1: Holly

PV2: Jim and Sasha

CS: Bella

WC: Ryleigh

 

Team John:

 

PV1: Joshua

PV2: Samuel

CS: David

WC: Jershika

 

Jershika wins wildcard

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Team Kelly

PV1: Jeremy Rosado

PV2: Katie Rae

CS: Gymani

WC: GNT

 

Team Legend

PV1: Samuel Harness

PV2: Jershika
CS: David

WC: Samara (comeback and WC Winner) 

 

Team Ariana

PV1: Holly Forbes

PV2: Bella DeNapoli

CS: Raquel Trinidad

WC: Jim and Sasha

 

Team Blake

PV1: Wendy Moten

PV2: Paris

CS: Libianca 

WC: Peddy 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, Gustavo527 said:

Team Kelly

PV1: Hailey Mia

PV2: Girl Named Tom

CS: Gymani

WC: Jeremy Rosado

 

Team Legend

PV1: Jershika Maple

PV2: Samuel Harness

CS: David Vogel

WC: Shadale

 

Team Ariana

PV1: Holly Forbes

PV2: Bella DeNapoli

CS: Ryleigh Plank

WC: Jim & Sasha Allen

 

Team Blake

PV1: Wendy Moten

PV2: Paris Winningham

CS: Lana Scott

WC: LiBianca

 

 Wildcard Winner - LiBianca 

 

Also, for the Comeback, i'll go with Hailey. (I'd be fine with either her or LiBianca winning the Wildcard)

 

 

Literally the results I WANT!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't believe the public should be voting. Instead, the coaches should use a score sheet and the top three highest scores per team automatically advance and the fourth highest scoring artist competes in the Wild Card. In the rest of the lives, the bottom two or three scores should compete for the instant save and the highest score advances. The coaches are professionals. Most of the viewers are not and don't know what to look for in performances. Lots of us are voting based on popularity and that's not right in a show like this. 

Team Kelly:

PV: Girl Named Tom (amazing family harmony) and Jeremy (may be better than he was on Idol)

CC: Gymani (powerhouse, may make finale)

WC: Katie (rare alto voice, her voice is similar to mine)

Eliminated: Hailey (way too young, has lots of room to develop when she's older)

Team Legend:

PV: Samuel, Jershika

CC: David

WC: Samuel

Eliminated: Shadale

Team Ariana:

PV: Holly (she can make finale and maybe win), and Ryleigh 

CC: Bella

WC: Jim and Sasha (great harmony, amazing knockout)

Eliminated: Raquel (not a fan of her tone)

Team Blake:

PV: Wendy (can win it all) and Libicana

CC: Paris

WC: Lana

Eliminated: Peedy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, abigailcoasters said:

I don't believe the public should be voting. Instead, the coaches should use a score sheet and the top three highest scores per team automatically advance and the fourth highest scoring artist competes in the Wild Card. In the rest of the lives, the bottom two or three scores should compete for the instant save and the highest score advances. The coaches are professionals. Most of the viewers are not and don't know what to look for in performances. Lots of us are voting based on popularity and that's not right in a show like this. 


That’s a very hot take. I hate this show’s audience but nah, that would be the show’s demise.

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

53 minutes ago, Daillon said:


That’s a very hot take. I hate this show’s audience but nah, that would be the show’s demise.

I was in choir for two years in high school. It should be like in the battles and knockouts when the coaches pick who advances. Also, there should be a minimum age of 18 with a high school diploma/GED required, and college degree preferred (so school comes first and kids can have a normal childhood). The voice doesn't fully mature until around ages 17-18 (or even later in some). Also, it should be amateurs only, and anyone with a degree in or currently in school for vocal performance, music education, or other related fields should not be allowed to compete. This should occur for Idol as well.

 

  • Haha 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, abigailcoasters said:

I was in choir for two years in high school. It should be like in the battles and knockouts when the coaches pick who advances. Also, there should be a minimum age of 18 with a high school diploma/GED required, and college degree preferred (so school comes first and kids can have a normal childhood). The voice doesn't fully mature until around ages 17-18 (or even later in some). Also, it should be amateurs only, and anyone with a degree in or currently in school for vocal performance, music education, or other related fields should not be allowed to compete. This should occur for Idol as well.

 

 

A high school diploma required to audition for a singing competition? :rofl:

  • Haha 10
Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, abigailcoasters said:

I was in choir for two years in high school. It should be like in the battles and knockouts when the coaches pick who advances. Also, there should be a minimum age of 18 with a high school diploma/GED required, and college degree preferred (so school comes first and kids can have a normal childhood). The voice doesn't fully mature until around ages 17-18 (or even later in some). Also, it should be amateurs only, and anyone with a degree in or currently in school for vocal performance, music education, or other related fields should not be allowed to compete. This should occur for Idol as well.

 

By this logic, I would be more than qualified to compete - and believe me when I say your eardrums should be thankful that there’s no sane production staff member for this show that would allow me within a mile of the blind auditions as a performer.

  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, VintageVoice said:

By this logic, I would be more than qualified to compete - and believe me when I say your eardrums should be thankful that there’s no sane production staff member for this show that would allow me within a mile of the blind auditions as a performer.

 

I wouldn't, if playing the flute in elementary school counts as music education :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...