Jump to content

Rank the T11's Fan Week Performances!


holinessss
 Share

Top 11  

51 members have voted

  1. 1. The Performance of the night!

    • Hello Sunday - The Middle
      1
    • Jake Hoot - Every Light in the House
      1
    • Joana Martinez - Dreaming of You
      1
    • Kat Hammock - I'll Fly Away
      1
    • Katie Kadan - Without You
      13
    • Marybeth Byrd - Stars
      3
    • Myracle Holloway - Everybody Hurts
      10
    • Ricky Duran - Downtown Train
      9
    • Rose Short - Maybe I'm Amazed
      9
    • Shane Q - Mercy
      1
    • Will Breman - Light My Fire
      1
  2. 2. Favorite Studio Recording?

    • Hello Sunday - The Middle
      1
    • Jake Hoot - Every Light in the House
      1
    • Joana Martinez - Dreaming of You
      3
    • Kat Hammock - I'll Fly Away
      5
    • Katie Kadan - Without You
      12
    • Marybeth Byrd - Stars
      4
    • Myracle Holloway - Everybody Hurts
      5
    • Ricky Duran - Downtown Train
      4
    • Rose Short - Maybe I'm Amazed
      10
    • Shane Q - Mercy
      3
    • Will Breman - Light My Fire
      2
  3. 3. Who has the best fans?

    • Hello Sunday
      1
    • Jake Hoot
      3
    • Joana Martinez
      3
    • Kat Hammock
      4
    • Katie Kadan
      8
    • Marybeth Byrd
      3
    • Myracle Holloway
      11
    • Ricky Duran
      4
    • Rose Short
      8
    • Shane Q
      5
    • Will Breman
      0


Recommended Posts

Studios (pre-lives):

first impressions of studios ranking:

 

Katie Kadan - not the best song, but she a legend so

Marybeth Byrd - not amanda b, but i prefer it from last week

 

Rose Short - i'm not thrilled about this song choice

Ricky Duran - this might be a mess

 

Kat Hammock - idk about the big/high notes translating, could get max'd

Hello Sunday - ew song, but duo slayage

 

Joana Martinez - this fodder doesn't deserve this iconic song

Myracle Holloway - i'm hurting for her tbh

 

Jake Hoot - not memorable

Will Breman - over him

 

Shane Q - have mercy on our ears, damn

Performances (live):

 

Katie Kadan - queen tingz!!!!!

Rose Short - she hella snapped!

 

Ricky Duran - sick? idk her

Marybeth Byrd - let down from her studio

 

 

 

Hello Sunday - i actually preferred chelsea, i --

Kat Hammock - i did not love this

 

Myracle Holloway - she's only this high because of song choice

Jake Hoot - i mean...

 

Joana Martinez - so so so so so tragic omg

 

 

Shane Q - i can't decide who's worse, but...

Will Breman - that was worse than i can imagine, truly

 

 

T13 Rankings: https://idolforums.com/index.php?showtopic=740957

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I got to watch Shane, Joana, and Will live so I’m just watching them/updating as they upload to YouTube:

 

Katie Kadan (9.5/10) Phenomenal as always, but did notice a few moments that were imperfect. For her standards, that knocks her down 0.5 for me. She’s winning the season.

 

Ricky Duran (9/10) Yeah, this is Blake’s finalist for the season. He stumbled just a tad bit throughout the middle rounds of the competition, but he’s found his footing again and he’s delivered strong, solid vocals for 2 weeks now with a style that’ll easily get support. People say Jake’s the lock for the finale, but I wouldn’t bet on that entirely quite yet.

 

Myracle Holloway (9/10) Beautifully done from beginning to end! I don’t think she really flubbed a single note, but I feel she would’ve benefitted from sprinkling a bit more technique or adding some flair to the first half like she did in the last minute of the song. The whole thing was fantastic, but that last minute was magical.

 

Rose Short (9/10) If I’m being honest, last week was a tad bit better, but Rose is easily the one to beat from Team Gwen. She knocks it out of the park weekly and this week certainly wasn’t an exception.

 

Marybeth Byrd (8/10) A step up from last week, but I must admit - I was dangerously bored throughout that. I do love the song but maybe it’s the overuse on singing shows and the fact that it’s been done better a handful of times, but this performance didn’t do anything for her to stand out in my eyes.

 

Joana Martinez (8/10) I had higher hopes for this but Selena songs are deceptively rough. Fortunately, there wasn’t a part that was horrid/dreadful, but her cover lacked a lot of the emotion from the original and she couldn’t hit the lower parts of the song very well either.

 

Kat Hammock (7/10) I think this was Kat’s best so far, really. It finally got her to step ever so slightly away from what she’s done thus far, but it was still riddled with plenty of mistakes that are hard to overlook. I don’t anticipate her landing in the bottom, but she’s losing momentum.

 

Jake Hoot (6.5/10) I can’t be paid enough to hear this in full. I got the first 20 seconds and fast forwarded to the last minute. He was mostly fine but otherwise unimpressive with a couple of iffy notes at the end. He’s a lock for the finals, it’s all whatever.

 

Will Breman (5.5/10) Sadly, my boy tanked hard tonight - and it was mostly the song. I appreciate his ability to flip (and I know he said his version was Jose Feliciano’s), but it was so bizarre and the vocals weren’t strong enough tonight to balance that out. I fear for his safety, but he needs to go back to basics ASAP.

 

Hello Sunday (5/10) I feel compelled to rank them individually. This felt like Chelsea at her best (4.5) with Myla at her absolute worst so far (5.5). This would’ve sent Myla home if she were solo, yet Chelsea keeps pulling her down even more. With all respect to the girls, one of them is doing the heavy lifting and the other’s an anchor... it’s time to go separate ways.

 

Shane Q (5/10) That was mostly dull, while the last chunk was just bad. On the plus side, this was his best in a while and he seems to be a sweetheart. The downside, he’s the worst top 12/13 contestant in a few seasons.

Edited by Someone648
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Katie Kadan - "Without You"

2. Rose Short - "Maybe I'm Amazed"

3. Myracle Holloway - "Everybody Hurts"

4. Marybeth Byrd - "Stars"

5. Kat Hammock - "I'll Fly Away"

6. Ricky Duran - "Downtown Train"

7. Joana Martinez - "Dreaming of You"

8. Hello Sunday - "The Middle"

9. Jake Hoot - "Every Light in the House"

10. Will Breman - "Light My Fire"

11. Shane Q - "Mercy"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I actually missed Ricky's performance, and it's still not up on youtube, so I'll add it later:

 

1. Myracle - Definitely my favorite performance from her so far, really liked it.

2. Rose - Don't like the song but she went off as usual

3. Katie - A ever so slight downgrade from last week, but still great.

4. Putting Ricky here as a placeholder because this is where I expect him to end up

 

5. Joana - Not her best :(

6. MB - I actually liked this performance over last week's, but I'm not surprised it isn't resonating as well bc of the lack of the sad story/tears

7. Hoot - Nothing impressive but not terrible

8. Kat - ditto, for me at least

9. HS - A step down from last week, unfortunately.

10. Will - :/

11. Shane - :/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  1. Ricky: My favorite performance of the night. Ricky's baaack, but how popular is he really?
  2. Rose - Still think Durbin retired that song, but she killed it.
  3. Myracle - Loved it.
  4. Katie - Flawless technically, still don't like her tone when she uses her upper range, i.e. screams
  5. Marybeth - Okay overall. Some bum notes, some lovely passages.
  6. Hoot - His usual decent but uninspired performance. But no worries, will get the bonus anyway.
  7. Joana - Another poor song choice for her--jmo. It was okay, but problems with her lower range.
  8. Kat: Cute and all, but it was like watching a middle school talent show audition. Still don't get it. Won't even fight it anymore: I'll never get it. Good luck to her.
Bottom (in no specific order) IPB Image But some of them have people and/or powervoters... :|
  • HS - that was bad. If they escape the bottom, they're in the finals lol
  • Will - started with the Jose Feliciano version. Kinda okay at first, then welp! Went south fast. Prediction: see HS above.
  • Shane - could've been worse I guess. Still not any worse than the other 2.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok, I am not very good at these ranking things, but, here goes my stab at it.

 

3 that received a big YES from me were Joanna, Hello Sunday & Marybeth

 

Jake Hoot will continue.

 

Ricky, Myracle, Will & Rose, somewhere in the middle, for me. Likely they will keep going.

 

And that leaves Katie, Kat & Shane looking at the door, for me. Although, I know it won't be Katie, no matter what my view is.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:thumbs:

1. Katie - Just give this girl the crown, I'm not a fan but she has been very consistent and the only voice who truly deserves the title in this horrific, disastrous, hearing-destoryed season.

 

 

:thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown:

2. Myracle - Okay.

3. Rose - SIGH.

4. Ricky - Nothing memorable.

5. Marybeth - Another belting song, are you kidding me? You are not a belter.

6. Jake - ANNOYING COUNTRY NOISE. GTFO MIDDLE AMERICA.

7. Kat - Turn off in the middle of this horrible hallelujah country song.

8. Will - Huge ambition but OFF PITCH in the second half, I mean REALLY OFF .

9. Shane - SHAME on your performance.

10. Joana - Just send her packing already srsly.

11. HS - WTF is this, speechlessly creepy.

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:thumbs:

1. Katie - Just give this girl the crown, I'm not a fan but she has been very consistent and the only voice who truly deserves the title in this horrific, disastrous, hearing-destoryed season.

:thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown::thumbsdown:

2. Myracle - Okay.

3. Rose - SIGH.

4. Ricky - Nothing memorable.

5. Marybeth - Another belting song, are you kidding me? You are not a belter.

6. Jake - ANNOYING COUNTRY NOISE. GTFO MIDDLE AMERICA.

7. Kat - Turn off in the middle of this horrible hallelujah country song.

8. Will - Huge ambition but OFF PITCH in the second half, I mean REALLY OFF .

9. Shane - SHAME on your performance.

10. Joana - Just send her packing already srsly.

11. HS - WTF is this, speechlessly creepy.

 

Wow, except for some of the meh middle stuff, do we ever have a different take on things. Although, I do agree about this Season in general.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Rose Short - "Maybe I'm Amazed"

2. Katie Kadan - "Without You"

3. Myracle Holloway - "Everybody Hurts"

4. Marybeth Byrd - "Stars"

5. Ricky Duran - "Downtown Train"

6. Kat Hammock - "I'll Fly Away"

7. Jake Hoot - "Every Light in the House"

8. Joana Martinez - "Dreaming of You"

9. Hello Sunday - "The Middle"

10. Will Breman - "Light My Fire"

11. Shane Q - "Mercy"

 

Still one week doesn't affect my overall preference that much. Here's where i am now:

1. Katie

2. Rose

 

3. Kat

4. MaryBeth

 

5. Myracle

6. Ricky D

7. Joana

 

8. Will

 

9. Jake

 

 

 

10. Hello Sunday

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

11. Shane

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Myracle - Perfect song and she delivered.

2. Ricky - Solid as usual..but this was his best imo.

3. Rose - Great singer, wrong song imo.

4. Marybeth - Liked the vocal, the arrangement not so much.

5. Kat - SoSo on Kat this week.

6. Katie - Not for me but I get why she'll win.

7. Joana - I really wanted to like this. Low notes were off.

8. Jake - Nothing about this worked. Slipping fast.

9. Shane - The ending was a disaster...up til then it was prolly his best yet?

10. HS - Just no.

11. Will - Nothing less than a train wreck.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 Katie - best performance of the season :wub:

2 Myracle - loved this <3 <3 hope it's enough to keep her safe

3 Rose - queen as usual

4 Joana - not perfect but I :wub: her voice

5 Kat - pretty

6 Ricky - solid as always, his song choices are boring though

7 Will - good first half, messy second half

8 Marybeth - stop. belting.

9 Jake - fine but boring

10 Shane - his best for a while, still not good

11 Hello Sunday - why do they alternate between slaying like last week and messes like this? >.<

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, dang, since no one's done it yet and I'm bored, guess I'll rank the fan bases. :haha:

 

1. Myracle Holloway... Her fans are just so wholesome and loyal to a queen who went under-appreciated for so long. And they picked the best song choice.

2. Katie Kadan... The intro package showed that they're just so wholesome and supportive.

3. Will Breman... Blue Crew <3 (His fans have THE BEST NAME. Plus, they were awesome enough to give him a song by The Doors.)

4. Rose Short... Third best song choice behind Myracle and Will, but best performance of the night IMO. Also has wholesome fans who appreciate a queen.

5. Joana Martinez... Just nice folks who like a nice voice that hasn't gained enough traction this season. And they're so nice in spite of the tragedy.

6. Shane Q... I'll give them credit, that's a verrrrry loyal bunch LOL. But they also tend to be awfully nice about it.

7. Marybeth Byrd... don't really have much to say here. They seem nice enough.

8. Jake Hoot... same.

9. Ricky Duran... same. (Honestly, 7-9 could be tied)

10. Kat Hammock... I'm sorry, her fans bother me because they keep making excuses for her pitch issues and weak performances. AND they keep voting for her. :haha:

11. Hello Sunday... Same as #10, but magnified, and even more annoying because of their ages. I like the fanbase name, though, The Weekends.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Rose Short - "Maybe I'm Amazed"

2. Katie Kadan - "Without You"

3. Myracle Holloway - "Everybody Hurts"

4. Marybeth Byrd - "Stars"

5. Ricky Duran - "Downtown Train" 

6. Joana Martinez - "Dreaming of You"

7. Shane Q - "Mercy"

8. Hello Sunday - "The Middle"

9. Jake Hoot - "Every Light in the House"

10. Kat Hammock - "I'll Fly Away"

11. Will Breman - "Light My Fire"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...