The Voice S24 - Playoffs 1 (Team Niall) poll

[Misirlou]

Y"all know it.

Edited November 22, 2023 by Misirlou

[MILO JAY]

how i would rank them based on my preference

 

1. Nini

2. Julia

3. Mara

4. Huntley

5. Alexa

6. Claudia
 

based on who did the best in general

 

1. Nini

2. Huntley

3. Mara

4. Alexa

5. Julia

6. Claudia

[istersay]

Alexa, Huntley, and Nini were my faves tonight

[nytsch]

1. Nini

2. Alexa

3. Huntley

4. Mara

5. Claudia

6. Julia

 

Claudia was good but just got outperformed. I think Julia was the weakest although she had nice parts.

[FloorWax]

After rewatching, both I think I actually prefer Huntley’s to Nini’s.

 

SHOWSTOPPING

1. Huntley

2. Nini

They did great as well

3. Alexa

4. Mara (these are interchangeable tbh)

Clearly below the rest, but not bad at all

5. Claudia

6. Julia

[Discovolcano]

1 Huntley 

2 Mara 

3 I didn’t like any of the others

 

He chose the right 3 IMO 

 

 

[erik g]

1. Mara

2. Alexa

3. Nini

4. Huntley

5. Claudia 

6. Julia
 

I understand picking Huntley though 

 

[QueenCami]

Stunning

1. Alexa (10/10)

 

Strong

2. Mara (8.5/10)

 

Mixed bag

3. Nini (7.5/10)

4. Julia (6.5/10)

 

Not for me

5. Huntley 

6. Claudia

[Weirdoo]

6. Julia

5. Claudia
4. Mara
3. Alexa
2. Nini
1. Huntley

 

I wish Alexa had moved on over Mara but I don't think it's outrageous 

[Someone648]

Playoff Night:

1. Huntley

2. Nini Iris

3. Alexa Wildish

4. Mara Justine

5. Claudia B

6. Julia Roome

 

Overall Run:

1. Huntley

2. Alexa Wildish

3. Nini Iris

4. Julia Roome

5. Mara Justine

6. Claudia B 

[MatthewPalermo]

1. Alexa

2. Nini

3. Mara

4. Huntley

5. Claudia

6. Julia

 

I get Niall's choices. I'd put Alexa in over Huntley, but hey that's just me. His team was so stacked; any combination of Huntley/Mara/Nini/Alexa was going to hurt for many since one had to get cut.

[Persy]

This is super hard as any of them are deserving of the top 12 and Niall couldn't go wrong with his choice. I think he chose wisely in terms of who he thought would get more votes from overall fans. I would have loved Alexa in the top 12 but I'm not sure if she would have made semis or the finale but with Nini, Huntley, and Mara I could see it.

 

1. Nini

2. Alexa

3. Huntley

4. Mara

5. Julia

6. Claudia

[xfactor22]

They all did good. Though I with nial brought back Chechi or Elizabeth instead of Julia, no offense 

[Dai]

1. Huntley

2. Nini

3. Mara

4. Alexa

5. Claudia

6. Julia

 

Alexa would have been the better choice strategically - and I like her more than Mara, but I can’t fault Niall for picking the 3 best performances.

[StarWalker1]

1. Nini

2. Alexa

3. Huntley

4. Mara

5. Claudia

6. Julia

[*Wallace]

1. Mara Justine - You've Got the Love
2. Nini Iris - River
3. Huntley - Daylight
4. Alexa Wildish - Fields of Gold
5. Julia Roome - True Colors
6. Claudia B. - Talking to the Moon
 

My Top 2 were interchangeable.

 

Then for the second poll: He chose correctly. No complaints.

 

I was so nervous Niall was gonna choose Alexa over Mara but I'm happy that wasn't the case.

[Feoz]

1. Mara

2. Nini

3. Alexa

4. Huntley

5. Claudia B

6. Julia

[Stacey.]

1. Alexa

2. Claudia

3. Julia

4. Nini

5. Mara

6. Huntley

 

Lmao I would have chosen his opposite 3 tbh.

[Hamza Tufail]

1. Huntley - Finally, a performance by him that I genuinely loved. By far his best performance.

2. Mara

3. Nini

4. Alexa

5. Claudia

6. Julia

 

I think all of them did a good job. 

[New but Old]

Huntley

Alexa

Mara

Nini

Claudia

Julia

 

I don´t really agree, but I get it

Edited November 27, 2023 by New but Old

[Tom_The_Man0000]

1.Huntley

2.Nini

3.Mara

4.Alexa

5.Claudia

6.Julia

[TyDSC]

1. Claudia

2. Mara

3. Nini

4. Huntley

5. Alexa

6. Julia

 

At the end of the day, and given the whole body of work, he picked the right 3 - though strategically I'd drop one of Mara / Nini in favor of Alexa. 
Claudia was the real surprise though, her performance blew me away. 

Edited November 27, 2023 by TyDSC

[AliXRose]

1. Huntley
2. Alexa
3. Nini
4. Claudia
5. Mara
6. Julia

[nytsch]

On 11/21/2023 at 9:18 PM, nytsch said:

1. Nini

2. Alexa

3. Huntley

4. Mara

5. Claudia

6. Julia

 

Claudia was good but just got outperformed. I think Julia was the weakest although she had nice parts.

 

After reflection I think I would actually also have Huntley at 1 lol

 

Nini shrank on me, she still did great but I don't think her version of that song stands out as much and I liked the other's song choices better.

 

Something more like:

1. Huntley

2. Alexa

3. Mara

4. Nini

5. Claudia

6. Julia

[Tomd24]

Based on specific playoffs performance

 

1 Huntley 

2 Nini

3 Mara

4 Alexa

5 Julia

6 Claudia

 

Based in general

1 Mara 

2 Nini

3 Alexa

4 Huntley 

5 Julia

6 Claudia