American Idol Season 21 Premiere - Fave Auditions Poll

[StarWalker1]

Vote as you may! Lemme know what are your thoughts?

Edited February 20, 2023 by StarWalker1

[jdanton2]

Tyson Venegas was the best one . William Guy Tongi  who is not listed as an option was second best . also liked Kya , Lucy ,Michael,. also Jack who did not make it.

[StarWalker1]

10 minutes ago, jdanton2 said:

Tyson Venegas was the best one . William Guy Tongi  who is not listed as an option was second best . also liked Kya , Lucy ,Michael,. also Jack who did not make it.

oh whoops! my mistake! Its fixed now

[keychange]

Iam, Kya, and Tyson were my Top 3!

[Bk1234]

Either Tyson or Michael for me  

[KelseyW]

Tongi and Tyson were the best of the night!!

[Hamza Tufail]

I liked Zachariah, Tyson, and Michael.

[erik g]

I only voted for one but my Top 3 were

 

 1. Tyson

2. Michael

3. Lucy 

[jazzontherocks]

I voted Tyson, Zachariah, Michael and Megan. 

[Daryl Adjei]

Tyson, Zachariah, and William were my favorites.

Lucy will definitely be the dark horse of the season 

[Discovolcano2]

Zachariah but Iam made cry before he even started singing

Edited February 20, 2023 by Discovolcano2

[QueenKalie]

There were some decent performances but I don't really have a favorite from this list.

[ptebwwong]

Iam & Tyson were my favorites from last night.

[FloorWax]

So far the poll chose the correct Top 3 but Michael needs more votes

[mytake1]

Same with Tyson and Tongi.

 

People are going to nick pick with Colin, but he actually was good.  He is also better in interviews than Laine and Noah.  And self- promotion is part of it.

 

At the bottom - Haven, Lyric, Megan - Forgettable.

Edited February 20, 2023 by mytake1

[thevoiceisthetop]

So IDF ranking based off the poll

 

1. Tyson Venegas

2. Iam Tongi

3. Zachariah Smith

4. Kya Monee

5. Michael Williams

6. Megan Danielle

6. Lucy Love

8. Haven Madison

8. Colin Stough

10. Lyric Mediroas

[thevoiceisthetop]

MJSBIGBLOG Ranking

 

1. Tyson Venegas

2. Iam Togni

3. Michael Williams

4. Colin Stough

5. Kya Monee

6. Zachariah Smith

7. Lucy Love

8. Haven Madison

9. Megan Danielle

10. Lyric Mediroas

[taylorkat]

Lucy.

[wgm]

1. Iam Tongi 

2. Colin Stough

3. Megan Danielle 

4. Zachariah Smith 

5. Haven Madison 

6. Michael Williams 

7. Kya Monee

8. Tyson Venegas

9. Lucy Love 

10 Lyric Mediroas

[CarmenSandiego]

Here's how I ranked the contestants who made it to Hollywood:

 

1.  Kya -- the best of the auditions imo.  Too bad she didn't make the Top 26.

2.  Tyson -- probably the only guy that I'll vote for.  I loved his song choice.

3.  Iam Tongi -- a really touching performance, but there are two who are higher than him.

4.  Zachariah -- he is a better performer than Colin.  Also loved his song choice.

5.  Megan -- she was very good.

6.  Lucy -- had she done her first song better, she'd be higher.

7.  Colin -- he's better than Noah but he's still not the best from this group.

8.  Haven -- raw and very young but talented nonetheless.

9.  Michael -- good enough to make the Top 26 but imo, the worst of those who got there from this round.

10.  Lyric -- she was too safe, even in her second song.  She'll be eliminated in Hollywood.