Rank the winners

[TeamAudra]

1 hour ago, Hamza Tufail said:

I never thought I would be seeing you saying that.

 

I actually like his run. "Beer Never Broke My Heart", "He Stopped Loving Her Today", and "The Keeper of The Stars" were really great. The reason I would've had him below those 10 people is because I love them even more.

Also...if Jordan would have won, I’d rank him higher than Kenzie. What a turn of events!

[Hamza Tufail]

6 minutes ago, TeamAudra said:

Also...if Jordan would have won, I’d rank him higher than Kenzie. What a turn of events!

Yeah, after his battle you said now you don't care about his chances but then "Gold dust Woman" happened...

[B-B]

Amazing:

1. Maelyn

2. Alisan 

3. Cam

4. Tessanne

5. Jordan

 

Great:

6. Chris

7. Chloe

 

Good:

8. Josh

9. Cassadee 

10. Javier

11. Sawyer

12. Chevel

13. Todd

14. Jake

 

Decent:

15. Sundance

16. Brynn

17. Danielle

Not a fan:

18. Carter

19. Craig

20. Jermaine

 

[Misirlou]

2 hours ago, TeamAudra said:

Actually, I’d have to contemplate that a little more. Maybe below Craig. Craig had a much more solid run. 

I think Kenzie is a superior vocalist than both, but apart from Craig, I also think that Hoot had a stronger run than him.

[Misirlou]

And the thread of the winners having "moments" in the KOs continues. Because Cam certainly had one.

 

[iloveadam]

1. Chloe mk

2. Alisan Porter

3. Cam Anthony

4. Maelyn Jarmon

5. Brynn Cartelli

 

 

Chloe is still my favorite of all time, she's got such an amazing tone and pretty stylish. 

Alisan, Cam and Maelyn are all gifted with naturally wonderful voice, wide vocal ranges, incredible control and put into their own vibes in every performance.

I wasn't feeling Brynn during her time on TV, but after that her improvement is very impressive, I like some of her originals.

Well, I don't even remember how the other winners sound at all.

[TeamAudra]

37 minutes ago, Misirlou said:

I think Kenzie is a superior vocalist than both, but apart from Craig, I also think that Hoot had a stronger run than him.

He probably is, but he didn’t bring it on that stage. On any given season, we can find finale worthy talent who couldn’t perform consistently on the big stage, and made early exits. He made runner-up despite his struggles. 

Edited May 26, 2021 by TeamAudra

[Jordan Smith Fan]

23 hours ago, Hamza Tufail said:

I hope after Cam's win your hope in humanity was once again revived.

Not really. I still don't have high hopes for the voters. Of course Cam never flopped but the major reason behind his win was that Kenzie never connected with minivan.

If he was up against some basic and generic white flop teenagers like boring Fredericks, pitchy Cartelli, and pre-pubescent Rubin, he would've lost.

Edited May 27, 2021 by Jordan Smith Fan

[Jordan Smith Fan]

On 5/26/2021 at 12:28 PM, Jordan Smith Fan said:

The Kings:

1. Jordan Smith

2. Cam Anthony

 

The Queens:

3a. Chloe Kohanski

3b. Maelyn Jarmon

3c. Tessanne Chin

 

Incredible:

6. Alisan Porter

7. Josh Kaufman

8. Chris Blue

9. Craig Wayne boyd

10. Javier Colon

 

Not my favorite but really solid:

11. GNT

12.Todd Tilghman

 

Ok...

12. Cassadee Pope

13. Danielle Bradbery

 

They were hard for me to stomach...

14. Jake Hoot

15. Sundance Head

16. Jermaine Paul

 

Their win made me loose hope in humanity...

17. Chevel Shepherd

18. Sawyer Fredericks

19. Carter Rubin

20. Brynn Cartelli

Added GNT.

[Misirlou]

Starting with S5

 

Enjoyed their runs inmensely:

1. Sawyer

2. Josh

3. Cam

4. Maelyn

5. GNT - Added them here.

6. Tessanne

7. Sundance

Solid all around

8. Craig

9. Chevel

10. Chloe

11. Todd

12. Chris

13. Alisan

Not really a fan of their runs sans a couple of performances

14. Jake

15. Cassadee

16. Brynn

[+octoberdana]

Alisan

Chloe 

Maelyn

 

 

[Gmm99]

1. Cam Anthony

2. Todd Tilghman

3. Craig Wayne Boyd

4. Jake Hoot

5. Jordan Smith

6. Sundance Head

7. Chevel Shepherd

8. Maelyn Jarmon

9. Girl Named Tom - Current rank

10. Cassadee Pope

11. Josh Kaufman

12. Danielle Bradbery

13. Brynn Cartelli

14. Chloe Kohanski

15. Carter Rubin

16. Chris Blue

17. Alisan Porter

[QueenKalie]

Untouchable Top 2

1. Cassadee Pope
2. Danielle Bradbery

Elite tier
3. Girl Named Tom
4. Chloe Kohanski

I like these winners
5. Maelyn Jarmon
6. Brynn Cartelli
7. Josh Kaufman
8. Tessane Chin
9. Jordan Smith
10. Javier Colon

Respectable 
11. Alisan Porter
12. Chris Blue
13. Jake Hoot
14. Cam Anthony

Meh 
15. Chevel Shepherd
16. Sawyer Fredericks
17. Jermaine Paul

GTFO
18. Craig Wayne Boyd
19. Todd Tilghman
20. Sundance Head
21. Carter Rubin

[Hamza Tufail]

.

Edited December 27, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Hamza Tufail]

.

Edited December 31, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Elena69]

Top Tier

1. Jordan

2. Girl Named Tom

3. Maelyn

4. Matt McAndrew

5. Lauren Duski

 

Winners I Love

6. Cassadee

7. Chloe

 

Winners I Like

8. Sawyer

9. Brynn

10. Chevel

11. Cam

 

Winners I Respect

12. Tessanne Chin

13. Alisan Porter

14. Josh Kaufman

15. Danielle Bradbery

16. Javier Colon

 

Nah...

17. Sundance Head

18. Jake Hoot

19. Todd Tilghman

20. Carter Rubin

21. Jermaine Paul

[Cookie73]

Time to remodel my old list (This is entirely based on their runs)

 

Probably the best/most consistent runs

Alisan Porter

Jordan Smith

Maelyn Jarmon

Cam Anthony

 

Other favorites

Tessanne Chin

Chris Blue

Girl Named Tom

Noticeably improved in Lives

Josh Kaufman

Sundance Head

Cassadee Pope

 

Enjoyed their runs as well

Todd Tilghman
Carter Rubin

Sawyer Fredericks 

 

Not my pick but had their moments

Chloe Kohanski

Jake Hoot

Craig Wayne Boyd

 

Preferred some others those seasons

Chevel Shepherd 

Danielle Bradbery

 

Underwhelmed with her run

Brynn Cartelli

 

Didn't include S1-2.

[emcee]

Top Tier

1. Alisan Porter- Most incredible run

2/3. Cassadee Pope- My first snowflake to win

2/3. Maelyn Jarmon- I just wish we got to see more performances from her

4. Chloe Kohanski

 

Amazing:

5. Tessanne Chin

6. Jordan Smith

7. Cam Anthony

8. Girl Named Tom

 

Liked:

9. Danielle Bradbury

10. Sawyer Fredricks

11. Josh Kaufman

12. Chris Blue

13. Brynn Cartelli

 

Not my favourite during their run, but turned out good

14. Sundance Head

15. Jake Hoot

16. Javier Colon

 

Meh

17. Todd Tilghman

18. Chevel Shephard

19. Carter Rubin

 

Not a fan at all

20. Craig Wayne Boyd

21. Jermaine Paul

 

 

 

[Hamza Tufail]

Let's see the updated version of everyone's list. I know we all have our lists changed every month.

[nytsch]

Top tier

1. Alisan

2. Sawyer

3. Chevel

 

Also really liked

4. Tessanne

5. Maelyn

6. Josh

7. Craig

 

Great too but just didn't like them as much as above (or not as consistent, shorter runs etc)

8. GNT

9. Jordan

10. Cam

11. Huntley

12. Sundance

13. Cassadee

 

(big gap)

 

Ehhh

14. Chris

15. Todd

16. Gina

 

More ehhh

17. Danielle

18. Carter

 

Did not like her overall run I'm sorry

19. Chloe

 

They were fine but just forgettable

20. Jake

21. Javier

 

Didn't care for

22. Brynn

23. Jermaine

24. Bryce

[peachfuz]

(tbh creature voice) YIPPEE

Chris Blue

Cam Anthony

Tessanne Chin

Maelyn Jarmon

Alisan Porter

 

i like them:)

Jordan Smith

Josh Kaufman

Girl Named Tom

Huntley

Sawyer Fredericks

 

dad

Todd Tilghman

 

not my absolute favorites, but had really great moments

Chloe Kohanski

Cassadee Pope

Gina Miles

Jake Hoot

Chevel Shepherd

Carter Rubin

Sundance Head

 

might need to revisit their runs but i remember them being good?

Craig Wayne Boyd

Javier Colon

 

much respect, but not a whole lot of love

Danielle Bradbery

Brynn Cartelli

 

hey, they won, good for them! too bad they were offkey for at least half of their live run

Bryce Leatherwood

Jermaine Paul

[Persy]

1. Maelyn Jarmon

2. Alisan Porter

3. Cam Anthony

4. Jordan Smith

5. Gina Miles

6. Girl Named Tom

7. Chris Blue

8. Carter Rubin

9. Tessanne Chin

10. Sawyer Fredericks

11. Huntley

12. Chloe Kohanski

13. Javier Colon

14. Jake Hoot

15. Sundance Head

16. Chevel Shepherd

17. Brynn Cartelli

18. Danielle Bradbery

19. Josh Kaufman

20. Cassadee Pope

21. Todd Tilghman

22. Craig Wayne Boyd

23. Jermaine Paul

24. Bryce Leatherwood

[Hamza Tufail]

15 hours ago, nytsch said:

Top tier

1. Alisan

2. Sawyer

3. Chevel

 

Also really liked

4. Tessanne

5. Maelyn

6. Josh

7. Craig

 

Great too but just didn't like them as much as above (or not as consistent, shorter runs etc)

8. GNT

9. Jordan

10. Cam

11. Huntley

12. Sundance

13. Cassadee

 

(big gap)

 

Ehhh

14. Chris

15. Todd

16. Gina

 

More ehhh

17. Danielle

18. Carter

 

Did not like her overall run I'm sorry

19. Chloe

 

They were fine but just forgettable

20. Jake

21. Javier

 

Didn't care for

22. Brynn

23. Jermaine

24. Bryce

I always knew you liked Sawyer and Chevel, but THAT much? Didn't expect.

[Stacey.]

Oh please dear god do NOT make me rank these people

[Stacey.]

Okay I have to do it now