Rank the winners

[Jordan Smith Fan]

You can rank based on your personal preferences OR you can also rank them in order of best to worst or both.

 

Javier Colon

Jermaine Paul

Cassadee Pope

Danielle Bradbery

Tessanne Chin

Josh Kaufman

Craig Wayne boyd

Sawyer Fredericks

Jordan Smith

Alisan Porter

Sundance Head

Chris Blue

Chloe mk

Brynn Cartelli

Chevel Shepherd

Maelyn Jarmon

Jake Hoot

Todd Tilghman

Carter Rubin

Cam Anthony

Edited December 16, 2021 by Jordan Smith Fan

[David68]

• Maelyn
• Cam
• Tessanne
• Josh
• Alisan
• Chevel
• Jordan
• Chris
• Chloe
• Sundance
• Danielle
• Brynn
• Carter
• Todd
• CWB
• Jake

Excluding S1, 2, 3, and 8 as I never really watched any part of those.

They're all okay at least though

[Jyn Mycle]

S3 - S20 only

 

Alisan Porter

Jordan Smith

Maelyn Jarmon

Cam Anthony

Tessanne Chin

Chloe Kohanski

Chris Blue

Josh Kaufman

Chevel Shepherd

Sundance Head

Cassadee Pope

Danielle Bradbery

Brynn Cartelli

Sawyer Fredericks

Craig Wayne Boyd

Todd Tilghman

 

 

 

 

 

 

I forgot to say, I didn't like any performance by them

Carter Rubin

Jake Hoot

Edited May 26, 2021 by Jyn Mycle

[season1]

 

 

1. Danielle Bradbery
2. Cassadee Pope
3. Sawyer Fredericks
4. Tessanne Chin
5. Carter Rubin
6. Craig Wayne Boyd
7. Jake Hoot
8. Cam Anthony
9. Chris Blue
10. Jordan Smith
11. Sundance Head
12. Chevel Shepherd
13. Alisan Porter
14. Brynn Cartelli
15. Maelyn Jarmon
16. Chloe Kohanski
17. Todd Tilghman
18. Javier Colon
19. Jermaine Paul
20. Josh Kaufman

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[taylorkat]

1. Maelyn Jarmon 
2. Alisan Porter
3. Cassadee Pope
4. Tessanne Chin
5. Danielle Bradbery
6. Cam Anthony
7. Chloe Kohanski
8. Brynn Cartelli
9. Jordan Smith 
10. Chris Blue
11. Craig Wayne Boyd
12. Chevel Shepherd
13. Carter Rubin
14. Josh Kaufman
15. Sawyer Fredericks
16. Sundance Head
17. Javier Colon
18. Todd Tilghman
19. Jake Hoot
20. Jermaine Paul 

[Jordan Smith Fan]

The Kings:

1. Jordan Smith

2. Cam Anthony

 

The Queens:

3a. Chloe Kohanski

3b. Maelyn Jarmon

3c. Tessanne Chin

 

Incredible:

6. Alisan Porter

7. Josh Kaufman

8. Chris Blue

9. Craig Wayne boyd

10. Javier Colon

 

Not my favorite but really solid:

11. Todd Tilghman

 

Ok...

12. Cassadee Pope

13. Danielle Bradbery

 

They were hard for me to stomach...

14. Jake Hoot

15. Sundance Head

16. Jermaine Paul

 

Their win made me loose hope in humanity...

17. Chevel Shepherd

18. Sawyer Fredericks

19. Carter Rubin

20. Brynn Cartelli

 

Also, @B-B I'm interested to know your list. You're someone here whose taste I can respect.

Edited December 16, 2021 by Jordan Smith Fan

[IAN27TAY]

S4-s21 only

 

KINGS AND QUEENS DESERVE THE WINS

1.Chloe

2.Jordan

3/4. Cam

3/4.Alisan

5.Maelyn

6.Tessane

 

INCREDIBLE

7.Chris

8.Josh

9.Danielle

10.Sawyer

11

 

They are good...

12.Craig

13.Chevel

14.Sundance

15.Jake- an up because of hir duet with Kelly.

 

Local voices... I can hear them in every street here in the PH but still they are good

 

 

16.Brynn

17.Carter

 

 

Edited May 27, 2021 by IAN27TAY

[Teraginn]

I was disgusted when they won
20. Jermaine Paul

19. Craig Wayne Boyd

 

They did their thing

18. Sundance Head

Precocious teen singers aren't my bag, I guess?
17. Brynn Cartelli 

16. Chevel Shepherd

15. Sawyer Fredericks

14. Danielle Bradbery

13. Carter Rubin

They won deservedly but they didn't capture me

12. Javier Colon

11. Maelyn Jarmon

10. Jordan Smith

I liked them and glad they won
09. Cam Anthony

08. Chris Blue

07. Jake Hoot

Loved their runs, glad they won

06. Cassadee Pope

05. Alisan Porter

04. Chloe Kohanski

03. Tessanne Chin

 

Champion snowflakes

1B. Todd Tilghman

1A. Josh Kaufman

Edited May 26, 2021 by Teraginn

[BrokenHearted]

1 Tessanne

2 Maelyn

3 Cam

4 Brynn

5 Danielle

6 Cassadee

7 Jordan

8 Alisan

9 Chloe

10 Carter

11 Josh

12 Chevel

13 Chris

14 Javier

15 Jermaine

16 Sawyer

17 Craig

18 Todd

19 Sundance

20 Jake

[Dai]

Excluding S1-3 (Javier and Cass probably would be towards the middle, and Jermaine is B3 for sure).

 

Favorites
1. Alisan

2. Maelyn

3. Tessanne

4. Josh

5. Cam

Not my top picks but I am a fan

6. Jordan

7. Chloe

8. Sawyer

Solid but not my cup of tea

9. Danielle

10. CWB

11. Todd

12. Chris

13. Chevel

 

Ehhh

14. Sundance

15. Carter

16. Brynn

17. Jake

Excluding S1-3 (Javier and Cass probably would be towards the middle, and Jermaine is B3 for sure).

[TeamAudra]

Starting with S6 only. 

 

1. Chevel

2. Sawyer 

3. Maelyn

4. Alisan

5. Brynn

6. Cam

7. Sundance 

8. Jordan

9. Chloe 

10. Carter

 

This is where it gets really difficult. 

 

11. Craig

12. Jake

13. Josh

14. Todd

15. Chris 

[Hamza Tufail]

On 5/26/2021 at 6:05 PM, TeamAudra said:

Starting with S6 only. 

 

1. Chevel

2. Sawyer 

3. Maelyn

4. Alisan

5. Brynn

6. Cam

7. Sundance 

8. Jordan

9. Chloe 

10. Carter

 

This is where it gets really difficult. 

 

11. Craig

12. Jake

13. Josh

14. Todd

15. Chris 

Brynn goes below both Alisan and Maelyn. Wow, didn't expect that.

Edited December 17, 2021 by Hamza Tufail

[TeamAudra]

9 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Brynn goes below both Alisan and Maelyn. Wow, didn't expect that.

 

Anyways this is my list, and it's solely based off of their On-Show run.

 

The King + The Queen:

1. Jordan Smith

2. Tessanne Chin

 

The Legends

3a. Cam Anthony

3b. Sawyer Fredericks

3c. Todd Tilghman

 

The Icons

6. Craig Wayne boyd

7. Danielle Bradbery

8. Chris Blue

9. Josh Kaufman

 

Amazing

10. Sundance Head

11. Cassadee Pope

12. Alisan Porter

 

Great

13. Carter Rubin

14. Javier Colon

15. Chevel Shepherd

16. Maelyn Jarmon

17. Chloe mk

 

Liked some of their performances but never Wowed me

18. Brynn Cartelli

19. Jake Hoot

 

Not my favorite but I respect him

20. Jermaine Paul

They can move around, depending on my mood. I don’t take these rankings that seriously. The enjoyment I got from their wins, and in some cases, the ensuing meltdowns plays a role in my rankings. There were some really good meltdowns after Brynn’s win, but the shine has worn off after a while. I also enjoy underdog wins, which is why Chevel is at the top and Sundance is higher than the other country males...the non-pimped King and Queen.  

[Misirlou]

35 minutes ago, TeamAudra said:

Starting with S6 only. 

 

1. Chevel

2. Sawyer 

3. Maelyn

4. Alisan

5. Brynn

6. Cam

7. Sundance 

8. Jordan

9. Chloe 

10. Carter

 

This is where it gets really difficult. 

 

11. Craig

12. Jake

13. Josh

14. Todd

15. Chris 

Where would have Kenzie been for you had he won?

[TeamAudra]

Just now, Misirlou said:

Where would have Kenzie been for you had he won?

Right below Carter. 

[Hamza Tufail]

2 minutes ago, TeamAudra said:

Right below Carter. 

He would've been at #11 in my list too.

Edited May 26, 2021 by Hamza Tufail

[TeamAudra]

11 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

He would've been at #11 in my list too.

Actually, I’d have to contemplate that a little more. Maybe below Craig. Craig had a much more solid run. 

Edited May 26, 2021 by TeamAudra

[Hamza Tufail]

5 minutes ago, TeamAudra said:

Actually, I’d have to contemplate that a little more. Maybe below Craig. 

I never thought I would be seeing you saying that.

 

I actually like his run. "Beer Never Broke My Heart", "He Stopped Loving Her Today", and "The Keeper of The Stars" were really great. The reason I would've had him below those 10 people is because I love them even more.

Edited May 26, 2021 by Hamza Tufail

[TeamAudra]

Just now, Hamza Tufail said:

I never thought I would be seeing you saying that.

 

I actually like his run. "Beer Never Broke My Heart", "He Stopped Loving Her Today", and "The Keeper of The Hearts" were really great. The reason I would've had him below those 10 people is because I love them even more.

My thoughts are that he wasn’t confident on the big stage and it showed. Nobody else on the list of winners had that problem. 

[Misirlou]

Starting with S5

 

Enjoyed their runs inmensely:

1. Sawyer

2. Jordan

3. Josh

4. Maelyn

5. Cam

6. Tessanne

Solid all around

7.  Craig

8. Chloe

9. Todd

10. Chris

Their tones are not my cup of tea, but they won without pimping, so props

11. Chevel

12. Sundance

Not really a fan of their runs sans a couple of performances

13. Alisan

14. Jake

15. Cassadee

16. Brynn

 

Edited May 26, 2021 by Misirlou

[Dalton Eduardo]

Absolute Favorites/Snowflakes

1. Chloe Kohanski

2. Cam Anthony

3. Danielle Bradbery

4. Cassadee Pope

5. Todd Tilghman

 

Very good and consistent vocalists

6. Maelyn Jarmon

7. Tessanne Chin

8. Sundance Head

8. Josh Kaufman

9. Alisan Porter

 

I liked them

10. Chevel Shepherd

11. Carter Rubin

12. Craig Wayne Boyd

13. Sawyer Fredericks

 

I Respect their Voices But I Preferred the Other Finalists than them

14. Jordan Smith

15. Chris Blue

17. Brynn Cartelli

18. Jake Hoot

 

They're Good but I'm Just not a Fan of Them

19. Javier Colon

20. Jermaine Paul

[Cookie73]

Basing it off of their runs on the show

 

Really good and consistent, dominated their competition

1. Alisan Porter

2. Jordan Smith

3. Maelyn Jarmon

4. Cam Anthony

 

Also enjoyed them throughout their run brought it when it mattered the most

5. Tessanne Chin

6. Chris Blue

 

Enjoyed him throughout his run

7. Josh Kaufman

 

Really improved in the Lives to the point where they began dominating

8. Sundance Head

9. Cassadee Pope

 

Other winners I enjoyed 

10. Todd Tilghman

11. Carter Rubin

 

Good throughout their runs but don’t care as much about them 

12. Sawyer Fredericks

13. Craig Wayne Boyd

 

Inconsistent but had a few great performances

14. Chloe Kohanski

15. Jake Hoot

 

Didn't really blow me away like others their seasons, but still pretty good

16. Chevel Shepherd

17. Danielle Bradbery

 

Very underwhelmed by her run on the show, but is really good offshow

18. Brynn Cartelli

 

Omitted S1 and S2. Even the low tier winners on this show have something to like about them, and I can’t say I disliked any of them

[Hamza Tufail]

7 hours ago, Jordan Smith Fan said:

The Kings:

1a. Jordan Smith

1b. Cam Anthony

 

The Queens:

2a. Chloe Kohanski

2b. Maelyn Jarmon

2c. Tessanne Chin

 

Incredible:

6. Alisan Porter

7. Josh Kaufman

8. Chris Blue

9. Craig Wayne boyd

10. Javier Colon

 

Not my favorite but really solid:

11. Todd Tilghman

 

Ok...

12. Cassadee Pope

13. Danielle Bradbery

 

They were hard for me to stomach...

14. Jake Hoot

15. Sundance Head

16. Jermaine Paul

 

Their win made me loose hope in humanity...

17. Chevel Shepherd

18. Sawyer Fredericks

19. Carter Rubin

20. Brynn Cartelli

 

Also, @B-B I'm interested to know your list. You're someone here whose taste I can respect.

I hope after Cam's win your hope in humanity was once again revived.

[thevoiceswimmer]

Just to zig a little from everyone else

 

Top 10 Contestant of All For Me

1. Jordan Smith

2. Tessanne Chin

3. Maelyn Jarmon

 

Basically Top 10

4. Cam Anthony (he's literally number 11 lmao)

 

Love Them

5. Alisan Porter 

6. Chris Blue

7. Chloe Kohanski

 

Like Them a Lot

8. Cassadee

9. Sawyer

10. Sundance (Unpopular but Sundance is the country singer I want, he actually took risks by doing Etta, Alicia, Miley and he won without the slightest pimping, hats off to you sir)

 

Like Them, Don't Love Them

11. Todd Tilghman (Great vocalist if not my genre)

12. Brynn Cartelli (Her tone is actually weirdly one of my favorites of the whole group, but she had some pretty off weeks)

13. Jake Hoot (See Todd Tilghman, Desperado actually is stunning but overall fine with him)

 

Never Got Into Them

14. Danielle Bradbery (Love her post show though!!)

15. Chevel Shepherd

16. Craig Wayne Boyd

17. Carter Rubin

 

Really Talented (I Know He Is) But Can't Stand His Tone

18. Josh Kaufman

 

No Thank You

19. Javier Colon

20. Jermaine Paul

[Hamza Tufail]

5 minutes ago, thevoiceswimmer said:

 

Top 10 Contestant of All For Me

1. Jordan Smith

2. Tessanne Chin

Same.