While Idol has always said it is about creating a star, it usually doesn't happen. I don't know how much of the voters or Idol fans really think its creating a star. I think most are just trying to support who they like.
The way these last performances have been going it wouldn't surprise me if Jack is in the Top 3. Also, wouldn't be surprised if Triston isn't in the Top 3.
While I never thought you or anyone here hated Emmy this particular statement just isn't accurate. AI has never been about singing or performance ability. It's about creating a star.