Jump to content

AIS20 - Top 24 Part 2 - Favorite Performance


Favorite Performance  

48 members have voted

  1. 1. Best Performance

    • Cadance Baker - Something's Got a Hold On Me by Etta James
    • Sir Blayke - Breakeven by the Script
    • Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles
    • Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri - :'(
    • Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood
    • Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan
    • Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers
    • Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie
    • Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by CCR
    • Christian Guardino - Leave the Door Open by Silk Sonic
    • Katyrah Love - Blame It on the Boogie by The Jackson 5
    • Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis

Recommended Posts

Cadence Baker

Katyrah Love

Ava Maybee

Fritz Hager

Lady K

Leah Marlene

Christian Guardino

Allegra Miles 

Kenedi Anderson

Noah Thompson

Cameron Whitcomb 

Sir Blayke 

Edited by erik g
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good job!
1. Kenedi 

2. Leah

3. Allegra


Mixed feelings

4. Katyrah

5. Fritz 
6. Noah

7. Lady K

8. Cadence

9. Christian

The “stage presence” ruins an otherwise fine performance

10. Cameron


11. Ava

12. Sir Blayke

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Leah - I like her, that's a creative arrangement and pull it off quite well.

2. Fritz - I like this boy as well, but his arrangement of the song didn't catch me at parts.

3. Katyrah - She could've chosen a better song to show her wonderful voice.

4.Christian - He definitely got a great voice but wrong song choice and wrong vocal choices at the end.

5. Cameron - wow, he needs tranqulizer. He sang solid anyway.

6. Noah - Oh, country boy, thank u, next. He was decent whatsoever.

7. Allegra - She has a great tone but the whole performance sounded dead flat.

8. Kenedi - I'm glad this overrated girl determined to withdraw by herself. A great decision.

9. Cadence - Nothing memorable.

10. Lady K - This is worse than karaoke standard. 

11. Sir - Pretty bad.

12. Ava - JESUS FKING CHRIST, what happened to this girl srsly. This disastrous rendition was out of tune 99%.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 Cadence - just amazing, wow

2 Leah- she is brilliant, such a cool arranger, but voice not as solid gold as Cadence

3 Noah- incredible voice would sound great on Stone Temple Pilots or Pearl Jam but he doesn't even know that I think

4 Lady K- not her best but she is still great

5 Katyrah- wonderful person, good singer, picks her songs so the audience will have fun which may cause her trouble at some point

6  Christian- awesome voice, missing just a bit of Elliott's funk and fun, curious to see where he takes it from here

7 Allegra- very sweet and solid, missing a bit of wow factor though

8 Fritz- so he has talent but his voice is missing something, he needs coaching I think.  The original singer of this song is way too good for Fritz to compare

9 Kenedi - this sounded *so* out of tune and I've watched it twice, make it make sense! Her audition was A+++

10 Cameron- actually a really cool voice, but also often out of breath, because of course.  I feel like in 5 or 10 years he will regret some of these choices...

11 Ava- that froggy first note was not the vibe at all.  Very likeable and fun presence, just doesn't have the voice to be the rocker she wants to be

12 Blayke- everything he does is sweet and samey...  doesn't hit bad notes, but his performances don't blow me away or stick with me.

Edited by haribobo
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

(Copy + pasted from the other thread)

1. Leah Marlene - THIS is how a flip is done. Well done. I've been wanting to like her from the beginning but she didn't quite get me until tonight. Hell yeah, I can root for this.

2. Noah Thompson - @ American Idol stop making me like country males stop making me like country males stop making me like country males stop making me like country males

3. Cameron Whitcomb - I finally get it. He's not everyone's cup of tea but I finally get him. The little breakdown in the middle - pure Bradley Nowell vibes. I'm intrigued now. The "He didn't listen to any of my advice" had me CACKLING.

4. Allegra Miles - Oh wow. I didn't care for Allegra on The Voice and obviously she's gotten a terrible edit thus far, but this is definitely the most natural I've felt her. She needs to work on enunciation for sure but a really solid job here.

5. Ava Maybee - I had low expectations going into it but I feel she did surprisingly well! I do think that this was verging on being too big of a choice for her (and she did have some iffy notes in there), but it did feel complete. I'm pleased with it.

6. Cadence Baker - This was the best I've seen from her since her audition for sure. It felt a lot more natural but still somewhat too big for her. Overall she did an adequate job, but I would've preferred this pick go to several other contestants tonight.



7. Katyrah Love - I do like her and don't think this was bad, but it could've been so much more.

8. Sir Blayke - A pretty standard vocal but sadly unexciting.



9. Lady K - The vocal itself wasn't terrible, but why? Besides just the song choice, her rendition sucked out all the energy of the song. I was waiting for it to be over. Didn't expect it to go down like this...

10. Fritz Hager - I simply didn't feel it. I found the vocals to be questionable and the song wasn't that good either.

11. Christian Guardino - Everything he does sounds so forced and I genuinely can't enjoy him when he sings. I'm sure he's a nice guy but I just don't like his voice.


12. Kenedi Anderson Trying and saving and trying to save." - Scandal Gif-Cap - Tick Tock - Head  Over Feels

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here are my rankings, grouped together according to the ratings I gave them in the American Idol IDF Ratings thread:


1.  Kenedi -- I still wish she'd stayed.  She could have won!  But at least she went out with a bang.

2.  Katyrah -- my favorite performance from those left in the competition.

3.  Fritz -- best of the white guys with guitars.  But that's not saying much in this crowd.

4.  Allegra -- she needs to enunciate more, but I enjoyed the performance.

5.  Leah -- probably one of the better renditions of "Call Me".

6.  Cadence -- she had the best performance since her audition.

7.  Lady K. -- why, oh why did you ever choose Carrie Underwood?

8.  Noah -- 😴  Still, one of his better vocal performances.

9.  Christian -- unfortunately, he over sang the song.

10.  Ava -- Chaka Khan was too big for her.

11.  Sir Blayke -- the only thing worse than being a train wreck on this show is being boring.  And he was boring.

12.  Cameron -- total train wreck.  At least it was entertaining, as far as train wrecks go.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Create New...