AIS20 - Top 24 Part 2 - Favorite Performance

[thevoiceisthetop]

Rank them

[erik g]

Cadence Baker

Katyrah Love

Ava Maybee

Fritz Hager

Lady K

Leah Marlene

Christian Guardino

Allegra Miles 

Kenedi Anderson

Noah Thompson

Cameron Whitcomb 

Sir Blayke 

Edited April 14, 2022 by erik g

[Dai]

Good job!
1. Kenedi 

2. Leah

3. Allegra

 

Mixed feelings

4. Katyrah

5. Fritz 
6. Noah

7. Lady K

8. Cadence

9. Christian

The “stage presence” ruins an otherwise fine performance

10. Cameron

Zzzzz

11. Ava

12. Sir Blayke

[Hamza Tufail]

1. Cadence

2. Leah

3. Allegra

[FloorWax]

Two words: Leah. Marlene.

[rockerannah]

My faves from part 2 were:

 

1. Leah Marlene

2. Christian Guardino

3. Sir Blayke

[Adam_S]

Didn't expect to vote for Cadence but her performance ended up being my favorite. Second favorite being Kenedi but RIP.

 

Edit: Nvm Kenedi was better

Edited April 12, 2022 by Adam_S

[joe14]

Cadence's performance is the one I keep going back to which is a shock since she's been kind of a mess for some weeks now. Definitely a breakout moment for her. 

[MargoK]

Cadence, but also Kenedi.

[iloveadam]

1. Leah - I like her, that's a creative arrangement and pull it off quite well.

2. Fritz - I like this boy as well, but his arrangement of the song didn't catch me at parts.

3. Katyrah - She could've chosen a better song to show her wonderful voice.

4.Christian - He definitely got a great voice but wrong song choice and wrong vocal choices at the end.

5. Cameron - wow, he needs tranqulizer. He sang solid anyway.

6. Noah - Oh, country boy, thank u, next. He was decent whatsoever.

7. Allegra - She has a great tone but the whole performance sounded dead flat.

8. Kenedi - I'm glad this overrated girl determined to withdraw by herself. A great decision.

9. Cadence - Nothing memorable.

10. Lady K - This is worse than karaoke standard. 

11. Sir - Pretty bad.

12. Ava - JESUS FKING CHRIST, what happened to this girl srsly. This disastrous rendition was out of tune 99%.

[haribobo]

1 Cadence - just amazing, wow

2 Leah- she is brilliant, such a cool arranger, but voice not as solid gold as Cadence

3 Noah- incredible voice would sound great on Stone Temple Pilots or Pearl Jam but he doesn't even know that I think

4 Lady K- not her best but she is still great

5 Katyrah- wonderful person, good singer, picks her songs so the audience will have fun which may cause her trouble at some point

6  Christian- awesome voice, missing just a bit of Elliott's funk and fun, curious to see where he takes it from here

7 Allegra- very sweet and solid, missing a bit of wow factor though

8 Fritz- so he has talent but his voice is missing something, he needs coaching I think.  The original singer of this song is way too good for Fritz to compare

9 Kenedi - this sounded *so* out of tune and I've watched it twice, make it make sense! Her audition was A+++

10 Cameron- actually a really cool voice, but also often out of breath, because of course.  I feel like in 5 or 10 years he will regret some of these choices...

11 Ava- that froggy first note was not the vibe at all.  Very likeable and fun presence, just doesn't have the voice to be the rocker she wants to be

12 Blayke- everything he does is sweet and samey...  doesn't hit bad notes, but his performances don't blow me away or stick with me.

Edited April 12, 2022 by haribobo

[jjeem]

Not a lot to choose from. But basically:

 

Ok:

 

Lean

Cadance

Fritz

Katyrah

 

 

 

The rest:

I honestly can't remember them

 

 

 

 

[Someone648]

(Copy + pasted from the other thread)

1. Leah Marlene - THIS is how a flip is done. Well done. I've been wanting to like her from the beginning but she didn't quite get me until tonight. Hell yeah, I can root for this.

2. Noah Thompson - @ American Idol stop making me like country males stop making me like country males stop making me like country males stop making me like country males

3. Cameron Whitcomb - I finally get it. He's not everyone's cup of tea but I finally get him. The little breakdown in the middle - pure Bradley Nowell vibes. I'm intrigued now. The "He didn't listen to any of my advice" had me CACKLING.

4. Allegra Miles - Oh wow. I didn't care for Allegra on The Voice and obviously she's gotten a terrible edit thus far, but this is definitely the most natural I've felt her. She needs to work on enunciation for sure but a really solid job here.

5. Ava Maybee - I had low expectations going into it but I feel she did surprisingly well! I do think that this was verging on being too big of a choice for her (and she did have some iffy notes in there), but it did feel complete. I'm pleased with it.

6. Cadence Baker - This was the best I've seen from her since her audition for sure. It felt a lot more natural but still somewhat too big for her. Overall she did an adequate job, but I would've preferred this pick go to several other contestants tonight.

 

 

7. Katyrah Love - I do like her and don't think this was bad, but it could've been so much more.

8. Sir Blayke - A pretty standard vocal but sadly unexciting.

 

 

9. Lady K - The vocal itself wasn't terrible, but why? Besides just the song choice, her rendition sucked out all the energy of the song. I was waiting for it to be over. Didn't expect it to go down like this...

10. Fritz Hager - I simply didn't feel it. I found the vocals to be questionable and the song wasn't that good either.

11. Christian Guardino - Everything he does sounds so forced and I genuinely can't enjoy him when he sings. I'm sure he's a nice guy but I just don't like his voice.

 

12. Kenedi Anderson - 

[Discovolcano]

1 Fritz

2 Katyrah

3 Christian 

4 Leah 

5 Candece

6 Noah

7 Sir

8 Ava

9 Lady K

10 Cameron

11 Allegra

[kamil24]

Cadence

[Bk1234]

Either Leah or Katyrah. 

[QueenKalie]

I voted for Cadence she really impressed me.

[taylorkat]

1. Christian 

2. Cadence

3. Kenedi

4. Sir Blayke

5. Katyrah 

6. Allegra

7. Fritz 

8. Lady K

9. Ava 

10. Leah

11. Noah

12. Cameron

[CarmenSandiego]

Here are my rankings, grouped together according to the ratings I gave them in the American Idol IDF Ratings thread:

 

1.  Kenedi -- I still wish she'd stayed.  She could have won!  But at least she went out with a bang.

2.  Katyrah -- my favorite performance from those left in the competition.

3.  Fritz -- best of the white guys with guitars.  But that's not saying much in this crowd.

4.  Allegra -- she needs to enunciate more, but I enjoyed the performance.

5.  Leah -- probably one of the better renditions of "Call Me".

6.  Cadence -- she had the best performance since her audition.

7.  Lady K. -- why, oh why did you ever choose Carrie Underwood?

8.  Noah --   Still, one of his better vocal performances.

9.  Christian -- unfortunately, he over sang the song.

10.  Ava -- Chaka Khan was too big for her.

11.  Sir Blayke -- the only thing worse than being a train wreck on this show is being boring.  And he was boring.

12.  Cameron -- total train wreck.  At least it was entertaining, as far as train wrecks go.