Biggest disappointment: Season 22-24

[Hamza Tufail]

I know it's a mess. It's a little hard because some are eliminations, some are not. 

 

But discuss anyways.

 

Btw, I wasn't disappointed by some of these choices, but I think idf was.

Edited December 23, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Hsamid]

It's between Kim and Kala's elimination for me. I'll go with the latter cause her competition was much weaker and she was eliminated earlier.

 

Both were absolute robberies though.

[Hamza Tufail]

I loved Summertime, but I liked other contestants as well. She would have been a deserving finalist though.

 

Never cared for Parijita.

 

Liked one ortwo performances from Devix, but was never a fan.

 

Bryce wasn't my snowflake, but I still liked him. 

 

I would have also chosen Sorelle and Ray. Kala's tone wasn't for me.

 

Right now, I wish that man had gotten eliminated even before the playoffs. But I used to be a dumbass back then because I loved him.

 

I never really expected much from Chechi. I knew it from the get go that she has great whistles, but isn't great with other registers of her voice.

 

I loved Alexa's Frist 3 performances. But I didn't like her PO performance, and I thought Mara deserved it based off of that particular night. And in the long term, I've become a fan of Mara, and it's been proven that Niall made the right call.

 

Only liked first 2 Kaylee performances.

 

Sad about Nini. She deserved the finale, but I think the other 5 are good as well.

 

Noah was the biggest disappointment for me. 4 incredible performances back to back, still got eliminated. Would have loved to see him in the lives. He would have surely been in the finale.

 

 

So, Noah is my pick. Nini is a close second.

[Teraginn]

Neil Salsich getting shafted by Kelly 

 

TBH, other than S23 I've been having a good run with snowflakes since S17. Sid eliminated in S19 POs and Will, Joshua and Corey not making it to their respective Finales were sad, but they're not as painful as Neil's loss. 

Edited December 13, 2023 by Teraginn

[nytsch]

I hate to be petty but I honestly think it's Bryce winning lmao

All the talent that season and that was the result...

 

My second choice would be Nini not making finale though.

[Someone648]

Picked Kala, but oooh reading Devix's name brought up some rough feelings, too.

[FloorWax]

Gee I wonder what disappointed me most

[Misirlou]

I´m with @Teraginn. Neil not making it past playoffs. It was just bad luck, would have loved to see him on another season with a better format and longer live shows. We missed out.

Edited December 13, 2023 by Misirlou

[AliXRose]

 

[QueenKalie]

Out of what is on this list Kala not being picked was the easy answer. 

 

But if I had to pick something in general Reba picking Jordan Rainer over Caitlin Quisenberry would have to be really high on that list. Caitlin is great and honestly Jordan kinda sucks. 

[RTV]

My biggest disappointment is Grace West narrowly losing s23, primarily due to tactics of TPTB. But I voted for the fifth place finisher making the finale, because it was a major factor in that outcome. Even disregarding all the other issues about that contestant, his performances should've kept him from becoming a finalist.

[Persy]

This was really hard but I voted Nini because I felt the most upset about her going home before the finale. She was my number 1 favorite out of everyone throughout. That girl never disappoints. I also loved Kala and she deserved to go through. Same with Kim, Kaylee not making the top 12 as she would have made top 3 in the finale, Noah being eliminated before the lives, and I was disappointed with Bryce winning. Alexa was fantastic in the playoffs but so was Nini, Huntley, and Mara so in terms of voting wise Niall chose strategically. 

[seamaidencora]

I'm pretty relaxed, but I wish Taylor made it to lives. Think she would have lasted longer on show then AZAN, she was good too, just a preference thing 

 

Out of list, Nini...

She was a favorite which I think will remove viewers.

Can't lay down on these contestants, they work hard. If you start to prefer another that's one thing, but if you watched, vote! 

[erik g]

Tie between Kim and Kara, voted Kim because she had leas votes. 

[Anythingcanhappen]

Had to vote for Alexa bc the wound is still so fresh lol 

 

Runner up choice is Bryce’s win tho. Just horrible. ESP when the clear winner was Morgan Myles