The Voice Season 23: Idolforums' ratings

[Gustavo527]

THE VOICE: S23 IDOLFORUMS RATINGS!

 

Grade the each performance from 0 to 10 

(Artist - Song - Rating) 

 

 I will calculate the average of everyone's ratings for each performance and compile it.

 

You can rate performances to the hundredths place (7.25, 9.75, 6.66, 0.01, 9.99) or just as whole numbers.

 

Anyone can put in their rankings (They need to rank every performance of a night, though). The deadline will be the Sunday immediately before the kickoff of the next round. So all the blinds are due on the day before the premiere of battles.

 

The NUMBER ONE RULE is that NOBODY IS ALLOWED to create multiple accounts with the intention to throw the ratings off. Istersay will find out who you are and your main account and alts will be banned or suspended. We will be able to tell if there is suspicious activity.

 

Be confident about your ratings when you post them. Relisten over and over if needed, because I would prefer you not to change your ratings after you post them (it makes it harder).

 

You are free to rate however you want, and people have their ways of rating performances, but just don't be too absurd with low ratings (giving performances 0.01s for no good reason). Also, don't give a bunch of low ratings on a single round only to boost the placement of a certain performances . If you do that, i'm gonna be obligated to reject your ratings, sorry. 

 

To any contestants: This is completely for fun. I wouldn't read too much into a rating. You got chairs to turn for a reason! Maybe I would advise you to exit this page now.

 

Discussion is allowed and encouraged, as long as everyone is respectful. If you can't handle an opinion, go take a walk or something and then come back. The ignore button is also an option if you can't stand another user.

 

That being said, rate away, users of Idolforums!! 

Edited March 7, 2023 by Gustavo527

[Gustavo527]

Blind Auditions: Full Ranking  

1. Cait Martin - As it Was - 9.43 

2. Ryley Tate Wilson - Dancing on My Own - 8.94

3. NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 8.79

4. Grace West - Maybe It Was Memphis - 8.65  

5. Kala Banham - Both Sides Now - 8.58

6. Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8.47

7. NariYella - One Night Only - 8.43

8. Gina Miles - The One that Got Away - 8.4

9. Sheer Element - Leave the Door Open - 8.34

10. Neil Salsich - Honky Tonk Blues - 8.11 

10. Kate Cosentino - I Say A Little Prayer - 8.11

12. Tasha Jessen - River - 8.09

13. JB Somers - A Case of You - 8.06

14. Rachel Christine Gebel - Uninvited - 7.95 

15. Kylee Dayne - Fallingwater - 7.92

16. Mannasseh Simone - Rise Up - 7.85

17. Mariah Kalia - Idontwannabeyouanymore - 7.69 

18. Allie Keck - Paris (Ooh La La) - 7.67 

19. Talia Smith - Don't You Worry 'bout a Thing - 7.62  

20. EJ Michaels - Easy on Me - 7.56 

21. Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 7.52  

22. Laura Littleton - Sign of the Times - 7.48

23. Mary Kate Connor - Stars - 7.44

24. Tiana Goss - Emotions - 7.4 

25. Katie Beth Forakis - Ghost - 7.3.

26. Jamar Langley - Try Me - 7.17

27. Magnus - Sara Smile - 7.16

28. Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7.15 

29. Marcos Covos - Tu, Solo Tu - 7.12 

30. Carlos Rising - Change the World - 7.1 

31. D. Smooth - Perfect - 7.09 

32. Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 7.05 

33. Jerome Godwin III - pov - 7 

34. Ray Uriel - Glimpse of Us - 6.75 

34. Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 6.75 

36. ALI - Killing Me Softly - 6.67 

37. Kason Lester - It´s Not Over - 6.17  

37. Chloe Abbott - How Deep is Your Love - 6.17 

39. Walker Wilson - Hurricane - 6.1 

 

Average per episode 

Episode 1 - 7.67

Episode 2 - 7.8

Episode 3 - 7.39

Episode 4 - 7.25

Episode 5 - 7.79

Episode 6 - 8 

 

Average per team 

Team Blake - 7.46 

Team Niall - 7.74 

Team Chance - 7.45 

Team Kelly - 7.81 

 

Total average of the round  = 7.62 

 

Battle Rounds: Full Ranking 

1. Gina vs Kala - Skinny Love - 9.04 

2. Kylee Dayne vs. Mary Kate Connor - Anti-Hero - 8.95 

3. Sorelle vs Manasseh - Someone like You - 8.88 

4. Cait vs Allie - It Must Have Been Love - 8.66 

5. Michael B vs Ryley Tate - Heartbreak Anniversary - 8.64 

6. Grace vs Carlos - I Told You So - 8.33 

7. ALI vs D Smooth - Unaware - 8.32 

8. NOIVAS vs. Ray Uriel - Jealous Guy - 8.22 

9. Tasha vs EJ - The Tracks of My Tears - 7.97 

10. Holly vs Katie Beth - Lady Like - 7.96 

11. NariYella vs Chloe - I Want You Around - 7.93 

12. Rachel Christine vs. JB Somers - Light On - 7.43 

13. Jamar vs Mariah - Gravity - 7.23 

14. Jerome Godwin III vs. Talia Smith - Like I Can - 6.85 

15. Ross Clayton vs. Laura Littleton - Stop Draggin' My Heart Around - 6.74 

16. Kate vs Tiana - Girls Just Wanna Have Fun - 6.52 

17. Magnus vs. Alyssa Lazar - Your Song - 5.59 

18. Walker vs Kason - Here Without You - 5.44 

 

Average per episode 

Episode 1. - 7.87

Episode 2. - 7.1

Episode 3. - 7.95

Episode 4.- 7.5 

 

Average per team 

Team Blake - 7.67 

Team Niall - 7.55  

Team Chance - 7.57 

Team Kelly - 8.09 

 

Total average of the round = 7.6 

 

Knockouts: Full Ranking 

1. Holly Brand - Blue Moon Of Kentucky - 9.24

2. Cait Martin - All The Man That I Need - 9.11

3. Kala Banham - Iris - 8.99

4. NOIVAS - I Put A Spell On You - 8.94 

5. Grace West - Here You Come Again - 8.76

6. Neil Salsich - Takin' it to the Streets - 8.42

7. Sorelle - Blame It On the Boogie - 8.35 

8. Kylee Dayne - All By Myself - 8.28 

9. Tasha Jessen - Take Me To Church - 8.03

10. Rachel Christine - Rhiannon - 7.96

11. Ross Clayton - Dirty Work - 7.85 

12. Gina Miles - Somebody That I Used To Know - 7.77 

13. ALI - Best Part - 7.66

14. Jamar Langley - Cruisin - 7.39

15. Michael B - When You're Gone - 7.34 

16. Ray Uriel - Lately - 7.16

 

Averages per episode 

Episode 1 - 8.24

Episode 2 - 8.17

 

Averages per team (Playoffs team)

Team Blake - 8.48

Team Niall - 7.74

Team Chance - 7.97

Team Kelly - 8.6 

 

Total average of the round = 8.2 

 

Playoffs: Full Ranking.  

1. Kala Banham - My Funny Valentine - 9.76 

2. Gina Miles - Wicked Game - 9.26

3. Holly Brand - Bring On the Rain - 8.91  

4. Grace West - Love Is Alive - 8.84

5. Ryley Tate Wilson - when the party's over - 8.66 

6. D.Smooth - Location - 8.58 

7. Sorelle - Something's Got a Hold on Me - 8.55 

8. NOIVAS - Come Together - 8.29 

9. Jamar Langley - The Thrill Is Gone - 7.82 

10. Neil Salsich - Have a Little Faith in Me - 7.79 

11. Rachel Christine - The Only Exception - 7.78 

12. ALI - Never Alone - 7.3

13. Michael B. - The Joke - 7.26 

14. Ray Uriel - Essence - 7.22 

15. Cait Martin - Alone - 7.1 

16. Mary Kate Connor - If I Die Young - 7.01 

17. Tasha Jessen - Here - 6.64 

18. Ross Clayton -With or Without You - 6.4 

19. Manasseh Samone - Speak the Name - 6.23 

20. Kylee Dayne - Flowers - 5.73

 

Average per episode 

Episode 1 - 7.72 

Episode 2. - 7.79 

 

Average per team 

Team Blake - 7.53 

Team Niall - 7.64 

Team Chance - 7.91 

Team Kelly - 7.93 

 

Total average of the round = 7.75 

 

Live Semifinal (Top 8): Full Ranking

1. Grace West - Til I Can Make It on My Own - 8.95  

2. Holly Brand - Rumor Has It - 8.32 

3. D.Smooth - Thinking Out Loud - 8.04 

4. Sorelle - Fallin - 8.04 

5. Gina Miles - All I Want - 8.02 

6. Ryley Tate Wilson - Vienna - 6.92 

7. NOIVAS - Skyfall - 6.52 

8. Ray Uriel - Can You Stand the Rain - 5.64 

 

Averages per team 

Team Blake - 7.73 

Team Niall - 7.47 

Team Chance - 6.84 

Team Kelly - 8.18  

 

Total average of the round = 7.55 

 

Live Finale (Top 5): Full Ranking
1. Grace West - She's Got You - 9.33 
2. Gina Miles - Nothing Compares 2 U - 9.23
3. D Smooth - What You Won't Do For Love - 8.19 
4. D. Smooth - My My My - 8.11
5. NOIVAS - Cold - 8.05 
6. Grace West - The Night The Lights Went Out In Georgia - 7.81
7. Sorelle - Million Reasons - 7.46
8. Sorelle - Ain't No Mountain High Enough - 7.06
9. Gina Miles - Style - 6.86
10. NOIVAS - Fly Away - 4.73 

 

1. D. Smooth and Kelly Clarkson - "Slow Dancing In The Dark"- 8.83
2. Gina Miles and Niall Horan - "New York State of Mind" - 8.57 
3. Sorelle and Chance The Rapper - "O-o-h Child" - 7.9 
4. Grace West and Blake Shelton - "Lonely Tonight" - 7.84
5. NOIVAS and Blake Shelton - "Home" - 7.04 
 
Average per contestant (Not counting coach duets)  
1. Grace - 8.57 
2. D. Smooth - 8.15 
3. Gina - 8.04 
4. Sorelle - 7.25 
5. NOIVAS - 6.39

Total average (Performances night) - 7.68
Total average (Results night) - 8.03 

Total average of the round - 7.85

Edited May 30, 2023 by Gustavo527

[Gustavo527]

Total averages per contestant (Top 20) 

1. Kala Banham – 9.09 (4 performances) 

2. Holly Brand – 8.58 (5 performances)

3. Cait Martin – 8.57 (4 performances) 

4. Grace West – 8.56 (8 performances) 

5. Gina Miles – 8.39 (8 performances) 

6. Ryley Tate Wilson – 8.29 (4 performances) 

7. D. Smooth – 8.16 (7 performances) 

8. Neil Salchich – 8.1 (3 performances) 

9. Sorelle – 7.91 (8 performances) 

10. Mary Kate Connor – 7.8 (3 performances) 

11. Rachel Christine – 7.78 (4 performances) 

12. Kylee Dayne – 7.72 (4 performances) 

13. Tasha Jessen – 7.68 (4 performances) 

14. Manasseh Simone – 7.65 (3 performances) 

15. NOIVAS – 7.57 (8 performances) 

16. Michael B. – 7.49 (4 performances)

17. ALI – 7.48 (4 performances) 

18. Jamar Langley - 7.4 (4 performances) 

19. Ross Clayton – 7.03 (4 performances) 

20. Ray Uriel – 6.99 (5 performances) 

 

 

THE VOICE SEASON 23’ IDF RATINGS: FULL RANKING 

1. Kala Banham - My Funny Valentine - 9.76

2. Cait Martin - As it Was - 9.43

3. Grace West – She’s Got You – 9.33

4. Gina Miles - Wicked Game - 9.26

5. Holly Brand - Blue Moon Of Kentucky - 9.24

6. Gina Miles – Nothing Compares 2 U – 9.23

7. Cait Martin - All The Man That I Need - 9.11

8. Gina vs Kala - Skinny Love - 9.04

9. Kala Banham - Iris - 8.99

10. Grace West - Til I Can Make It on My Own - 8.95

10. Kylee Dayne vs. Mary Kate Connor - Anti-Hero - 8.95

12. NOIVAS - I Put A Spell On You - 8.94

12. Ryley Tate Wilson - Dancing on My Own - 8.94

14. Holly Brand - Bring On the Rain - 8.91

15. Sorelle vs Manasseh - Someone like You - 8.88

16. Grace West - Love Is Alive - 8.84

17. D. Smooth and Kelly Clarkson – “Slow Dancing In The Dark”- 8.83

18. NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 8.79

19. Grace West - Here You Come Again - 8.76

20. Cait vs Allie - It Must Have Been Love - 8.66

20. Ryley Tate Wilson - when the party's over - 8.66

22. Grace West - Maybe It Was Memphis - 8.65

23. Michael B vs Ryley Tate - Heartbreak Anniversary - 8.64

24. D.Smooth - Location - 8.58

24. Kala Banham - Both Sides Now - 8.58

26. Gina Miles and Niall Horan – “New York State of Mind” – 8.57

27. Sorelle - Something's Got a Hold on Me - 8.55

28. Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8.47

29. NariYella - One Night Only - 8.43

30. Neil Salsich - Takin' it to the Streets - 8.42

31. Gina Miles - The One that Got Away - 8.4

32. Sorelle - Blame It On the Boogie - 8.35

33. Sheer Element - Leave the Door Open - 8.34

34. Grace vs Carlos - I Told You So - 8.33

35. ALI vs D Smooth - Unaware - 8.32

35. Holly Brand - Rumor Has It - 8.32

37. NOIVAS - Come Together - 8.29

38. Kylee Dayne - All By Myself - 8.28

39. NOIVAS vs. Ray Uriel - Jealous Guy - 8.22

40. D Smooth – What You Won’t Do For Love – 8.19

41. D. Smooth – My My My – 8.11

41. Neil Salsich - Honky Tonk Blues - 8.11

41. Kate Cosentino - I Say A Little Prayer - 8.11

44. Tasha Jessen - River - 8.09

45. JB Somers - A Case of You - 8.06

46. NOIVAS – Cold – 8.05

47. D.Smooth - Thinking Out Loud - 8.04

48. Sorelle - Fallin - 8.04

49. Tasha Jessen - Take Me To Church - 8.03

50. Gina Miles - All I Want - 8.02

51. Tasha vs EJ - The Tracks of My Tears - 7.97

52. Holly vs Katie Beth - Lady Like - 7.96

53. Rachel Christine - Rhiannon - 7.96

54. Rachel Christine Gebel - Uninvited - 7.95

55. NariYella vs Chloe - I Want You Around - 7.93

56. Kylee Dayne - Fallingwater - 7.92

57. Sorelle and Chance The Rapper – “O-o-h Child” – 7.9

58. Mannasseh Simone - Rise Up - 7.85

58. Ross Clayton - Dirty Work - 7.85

60. Grace West and Blake Shelton – “Lonely Tonight” – 7.84

61. Jamar Langley - The Thrill Is Gone - 7.82

62. Grace West – The Night The Lights Went Out In Georgia – 7.81

63. Neil Salsich - Have a Little Faith in Me - 7.79

64. Rachel Christine - The Only Exception - 7.78

65. Gina Miles - Somebody That I Used To Know - 7.77

66. Mariah Kalia - Idontwannabeyouanymore - 7.69

67. Allie Keck - Paris (Ooh La La) - 7.67

68. ALI - Best Part - 7.66

69. Talia Smith - Don't You Worry 'bout a Thing - 7.62

70. EJ Michaels - Easy on Me - 7.56

71. Sorelle – Million Reasons – 7.46

72. Rachel Christine vs. JB Somers - Light On - 7.43

73. Tiana Goss - Emotions - 7.4

74. Jamar Langley - Cruisin - 7.39

75. Michael B - When You're Gone - 7.34

76. ALI - Never Alone - 7.3

76. Katie Beth Forakis - Ghost - 7.3

78. Michael B. - The Joke - 7.26

79. Jamar vs Mariah - Gravity - 7.23

80. Ray Uriel - Essence - 7.22

81. Jamar Langley - Try Me - 7.17

82. Magnus - Sara Smile - 7.16

82. Ray Uriel - Lately - 7.16

84. Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7.15

85. Marcos Covos - Tu, Solo Tu - 7.12

86. Carlos Rising - Change the World - 7.1

86. Cait Martin - Alone - 7.1

88. D. Smooth - Perfect - 7.09

89. Sorelle – Ain’t No Mountain High Enough – 7.06

90. Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 7.05

91. NOIVAS and Blake Shelton – “Home” – 7.04

92. Mary Kate Connor - If I Die Young - 7.01

93. Jerome Godwin III - pov - 7

94. Ryley Tate Wilson - Vienna - 6.92

95. Gina Miles – Style – 6.86

96. Jerome Godwin III vs. Talia Smith - Like I Can - 6.85

97. Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 6.75

97. Ray Uriel - Glimpse of Us - 6.75

99. Ross Clayton vs. Laura Littleton - Stop Draggin' My Heart Around - 6.74

100. Tasha Jessen - Here - 6.64

101. NOIVAS - Skyfall - 6.52

101. Kate vs Tiana - Girls Just Wanna Have Fun - 6.52

103. Ross Clayton -With or Without You - 6.4

104. Manasseh Samone - Speak the Name - 6.23

105. Chloe Abbott - How Deep is Your Love - 6.17

105. Kason Lester - It´s Not Over - 6.17

107. Walker Wilson - Hurricane - 6.1

108. Kylee Dayne - Flowers - 5.73

109. Ray Uriel - Can You Stand the Rain - 5.64

110. Magnus vs. Alyssa Lazar - Your Song - 5.59

111. Walker vs Kason - Here Without You - 5.44

112. NOIVAS – Fly Away – 4.73

Edited June 7, 2023 by Gustavo527

[Gustavo527]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues -

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy -

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl -

Tasha Jessen - River -

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color -

Michael B. - Save Your Tears -

D. Smooth - Perfect -

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night -

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come -

Edited March 7, 2023 by Gustavo527

[Arsh]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

 

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 8

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy -  6.5

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 9

Tasha Jessen - River - 8.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 5.5

D. Smooth - Perfect - 6

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 5

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 8

Edited March 7, 2023 by Arsh

[StarWalker1]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 7.5

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 8

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 9.5

Tasha Jessen - River - 9

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 6.5

D. Smooth - Perfect - 7

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 7.5

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 9.5

Edited March 7, 2023 by StarWalker1

[nytsch]

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 8.5

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 6

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8.5

Tasha Jessen - River - 9

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 6

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 5

D. Smooth - Perfect - 7.5

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 6.5

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 9.5

[Misirlou]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 9.25

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 7

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8.25

Tasha Jessen - River - 8.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 6.5

D. Smooth - Perfect - 6

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 8.75

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 9

[Carebear1999]

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 8

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 5

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8.5

Tasha Jessen - River - 6.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 6.5

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 7

D. Smooth - Perfect - 7

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 9

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 10

[Persy]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 7.9

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 7.4

Holly Brand - Mississippi Girl - 10

Tasha Jessen - River - 10

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 6

Michael B - Save Your Tears - 7.6

D. Smooth - Perfect - 7.2

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 8.9

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 10

Edited March 7, 2023 by Persy

[allistr]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 9.5 (tones for days)

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 8.75 (weird but cute)

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 9.75 (powerful)

Tasha Jessen - River - 9 (great rendition)

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 8 (not bad, he can sustain a note but not my type of artist, appreciated the audition though)

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 8.25 (ok)

D. Smooth - Perfect - 8.5 (boring song choice, good rendition)

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 9.25 (wow)

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 10 (KING)

Edited March 7, 2023 by Ottoxxx

[QueenCami]

i think this season i'm going to try to take my ratings less seriously and just go off of ~vibes~, for example Sorelle's audition is sparking the most joy for me so it gets a 10 even though i think there were objectively stronger performances. also i won't be super stingy with 10s just for the sake of it (but maybe that'll change LOL)

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 8

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 10

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8 

Tasha Jessen - River - 9

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 6 

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 5

D. Smooth - Perfect - 3

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 7

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 8

[FloorWax]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 9

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 7.5

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 7

Tasha Jessen - River - 7

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7.25

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 7.25

D. Smooth - Perfect - 8

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 8.5

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 7.5

[Hamza Tufail]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 8.5

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 10

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 9

Tasha Jessen - River - 8.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7.25

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 8.5

D. Smooth - Perfect - 7.25

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 8.5

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 10

 

I know Noivas and sorelle aren't 10/10, but I still gave them 10s to balance things out. Because I know they're gonna receive some 6s or 7s.

Edited March 8, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Hsamid]

17 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 8.5

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 10

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 9

Tasha Jessen - River - 8.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7.25

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 7.5

D. Smooth - Perfect - 7.25

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 8.5

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 10

 

I know Noivas and sorelle aren't 10/10, but I still gave them 10s to balance things out. Because I know they're gonna receive some 6s or 7s.

Well then it's not the actual rating you'd otherwise give them, which sort of defeats the purpose of this thread, no?

[Hamza Tufail]

Just now, Hsamid said:

Well then it's not the actual rating you'd otherwise give them, which sort of defeats the purpose of this thread, no?

I'd still have given NOIVAS  a 9.5, and Sorelle a 9.5 too because I enjoyed that so much. Kinda close to 10. lol

[Hsamid]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 8.5

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 6

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 7.5

Tasha Jessen - River - 7.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 6.5

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 6

D. Smooth - Perfect - 6

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 7

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 7.5

Edited March 7, 2023 by Hsamid

[allistr]

I can already tell that @QueenMae16's ratings are going to matter a lot again 

[Hsamid]

15 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

I'd still have given NOIVAS  a 9.5, and Sorelle a 9.5 too because I enjoyed that so much. Kinda close to 10. lol

Fair enough, but you never know, could be the difference between NOIVAS getting 1st or 2nd place on the highest rated audition by the end of the blinds. lol.

[Arsh]

1 hour ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 8.5

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 10

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 9

Tasha Jessen - River - 8.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7.25

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 7.5

D. Smooth - Perfect - 7.25

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 8.5

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 10

 

I know Noivas and sorelle aren't 10/10, but I still gave them 10s to balance things out. Because I know they're gonna receive some 6s or 7s.

If this is the case, I can also change Holly and D Smooth to 10 and Sorelle and NOIVAS to 3 to balance things out. But I can't, and that's against the rules.

 

(I'm not fighting you, @Hamza Tufail, Just Chill.)

[Hamza Tufail]

6 minutes ago, Arsh said:

If this is the case, I can also change Holly and D Smooth to 10 and Sorelle and NOIVAS to 3 to balance things out. But I can't, and that's against the rules.

 

(I'm not fighting you, @Hamza Tufail, Just Chill.)

Yeah, but I did balancing to an extent. It's not that I changed NOIVAS' rating from 3 to 10. I just gave him 0.5 boost.

[erik g]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 7

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy -5

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl -8

Tasha Jessen - River -7.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color -8

Michael B. - Save Your Tears -8.5

D. Smooth - Perfect -8.75

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night -6

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come -9

[Mohammad]

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 8.75

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 9

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl -9

Tasha Jessen - River -9

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color -8.75

Michael B. - Save Your Tears -7

D. Smooth - Perfect -7

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night -8

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come -9

 

overall strong premiere IMO

[Dai]

Neil Salsich - Honk Tonk Blues - 7.5

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 8

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 7.75

Tasha Jessen - River - 8.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 6

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 6

D. Smooth - Perfect - 6

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 7.75

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 7.5

 

I actually liked Sorelle after a rewatch  

Edited March 7, 2023 by Daillon

[Teraginn]

Blind Auditions: Episode 1  

 

Neil Salsich - Honky Tonk Blues - 9

Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 7

Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8

Tasha Jessen - River - 7.5

Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 8.5

Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 8

D. Smooth - Perfect - 7

Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 7.5

NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 8