American Idol S20 Judge's Song Contest Discussion

[sublymonal]

meh. the only part I liked of that was the breakdown with the backup singers but otherwise it was very karaoke and uninspired 

[Brick]

This theme is amazing. Huntergirl's song choice though? Atrocious.

 

Soooo boring, no stage presence, and the song is not a good vocal or emotional showcase. Her worst performance to date. High school karaoke.

[*Wallace]

Hmm I think I would have liked "Here You Come Again" for Huntergirl? But "9 To 5" should be really fun.

[pepperman]

haha what will they pick for Leah???

Edited April 26, 2022 by pepperman

[erik g]

Just now, FloorWax said:

Huntergirl is always in the realm of decent/meh

Yeah i agree. I thought she was great in Showstoppers but everything else was meh

[Shireen]

Hunter could get shock booted for that calling it right now

[Brick]

Were they really standing up for that??? The plot has been lost.

[Carrie_On]

Just now, Shireen said:

Hunter could get shock booted for that calling it right now

Lol she’s not going anywhere until Top 5, at least. People LOVE Dolly Parton. 

[Bk1234]

Just now, Brick said:

Were they really standing up for that??? The plot has been lost.

She’s a judge favorite - what did you expect? 

[holinessss]

i don't think i've seen huntergirl not smile when she sings...like it's the polar opposite of having no facial expressions but just as emotionless??

[CarmenSandiego]

I actually enjoyed this performance of Huntergirl, but maybe that's because I remember practicing it for Voices Together back when I lived in Raleigh.  I would've gone for it in a heartbeat if I was her.

[ScarletDevilCCX]

I wonder what the twist Ryan keeps hyping up will be? Perhaps the judge who wins will get to "protect" a contestant for a week?

[DragonBahamut]

Huntergirl wtf..shock boot yo

[Elliott]

on the subject of The Chicks, someone needs to do this masterpiece!

[QueenCami]

46 minutes ago, m1key said:

Fritz continuously growing on me week after week tbhh

same, I wasn’t a big fan of him initially but he’s had some great performances recently

[holinessss]

Just now, ScarletDevilCCX said:

I wonder what the twist Ryan keeps hyping up will be? Perhaps the judge who wins will get to "protect" a contestant for a week?

that's what i'm thinking too

[ScarletDevilCCX]

1 minute ago, Brick said:

Were they really standing up for that??? The plot has been lost.

It was the best performance of the night! A low bar, I know, but it was.

[Elliott]

Just now, ScarletDevilCCX said:

I wonder what the twist Ryan keeps hyping up will be? Perhaps the judge who wins will get to "protect" a contestant for a week?

Triple elimination.

[Carrie_On]

Just now, ScarletDevilCCX said:

I wonder what the twist Ryan keeps hyping up will be? Perhaps the judge who wins will get to "protect" a contestant for a week?

I’m kinda thinking that too. Or any contestant who sang the winning judge’s song is declared safe. 

[miss denise]

Disney.  

[*Wallace]

5 minutes ago, Elliott said:

I think Huntergirl has a lot of potential to do well in country music, but I feel like her issue is that she keeps picking songs that are fun bar songs but not songs to create moments with.

[FloorWax]

2 minutes ago, holinessss said:

i don't think i've seen huntergirl not smile when she sings...like it's the polar opposite of having no facial expressions but just as emotionless??

 

It reminded me of Reagan Strange on Complicated

[Elliott]

Just now, Carrie_On said:

I’m kinda thinking that too. Or any contestant who sang the winning judge’s song is declared safe. 

At this rate, there’s only be like three contestants remaining.

[erik g]

i wanted Make You Feel My Love for Emyrson but ok

[*Wallace]

Cute, fun and enjoyable performance from Huntergirl. I did think it was your typical performance from her but I do like that she showcased some more rangier moments to pick up the performance up towards the end.