American Idol S22 The Top 5 - Disney Night Discussion

[BlindMelon]

That was soo...painful for Triston. If he goes through...it's just at this point meh.

[ScarletDevilCCX]

Oh wow. I'm looking at the full soundtrack to Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2. That's quite the big loophole Abi's showing off.

[StarWalker1]

abi with a great edit omg

[*Wallace]

Yeah that was a predictable song choice from Triston. Wasn't too big on that performance but at least he looked like he was having fun with that.

[CountryIdols]

Not Abi's mom admitting to parentifying her daughter on national TV

[Gustavo527]

This is gonna be a big challenge for Abi, an unfortunately there is no big margin of error for her. 

 

She can handle it, but let's see what happens.

[Anythingcanhappen]

Angie Miller walked so Abi Carter could run

[ScarletDevilCCX]

Queen Abi!

[keychange]

i fear i can already see Minivan yelling about how short Abi's dress is

[AmericanIdolFan0310]

Loving this rendition of the chain for Abi. Shes slaying this

[Solaris]

I'll give Abi credit, she has the capacity of picking cool songs. That was the most interesting one of the night.

[keychange]

wow she literally keeps surprising me every week with her stage presence. a true mother who keeps her stans on their toes!!!  

[StarWalker1]

YALL BETTER VOTE FOR ABI!!!

[jdanton2]

not really a fan of Abi's song . it was ok though.

[FloorWax]

popping in for the last few minutes of the show for the first time since Rock and Roll week so I can be here for the results meltdowns 

[BlindMelon]

Abi looks beautiful. Bit disappointed...it fell kind of flat for me, didn't go where I was hoping with it. I wasn't a fan of the arrangement either. Big Fleetwood fan and it just was not the greatest rendition of this one for me. But she should be a lock.

 

ETA: Her stage presence is the best of them all for sure. She deserves to be in the finale.

 

Edited May 13, 2024 by BlindMelon

[CountryIdols]

Love Abi but not a fan of that at all. The Chain is one of those songs I don't think anyone can or should cover

[wildestinvegas]

ok she slayed that

[Gustavo527]

That's it, if Abi is not on the finale, i'm not even gonna bother to watch it. That was amazing.

[*Wallace]

LOL I do always enjoy Mama Harper dancing along Triston's performances!   

[Hsamid]

Been tired of the chain on these comps but Abi did make it a bit more fresh. Like the tempo changes she and the band did in the first half.

 

That was really good. As far as the 2 performance nights go I think this is her best set so far.

[sublymonal]

I didn’t LOVE the arrangement of that but she sounded good. It just felt like she didn’t know if she wanted to stay true to the original, turn it into a ballad or go full rock. But better than the garbage Triston and Will have given us tonight.

[joe14]

Her stance when she bends so far forward is so awkward to look at. I've noticed it will all of her uptempo songs. I guess she is still figuring out the stage presence thing. 

 

It was okay. Song has been done a million times and I won't remember this version by tomorrow. 

[Emmyfan]

Just now, jdanton2 said:

not really a fan of Abi's song . it was ok though.

 

 

I am a Abi fan but that was bad. But i guess hardcore fans have blinders on

[CarmenSandiego]

Abi was terrific as always.