American Idol S22 The Top 5 - Disney Night Discussion

[Solaris]

Carried me with you was much more in her wheelhouse and was leagues better then The Climb.

 

Her outfit was fun and it looked like she was having a good time moving around the stage. Her best stage presence to date.

[BlindMelon]

11 minutes ago, CountryIdols said:

Round 1:

Abi

Emmy

Jack

Triston

Will

Same for me. Exact order.

[ScarletDevilCCX]

3 minutes ago, jjeem said:

"Nobody really heard it, so let us highlight it."

Wait they really did? I thought they ignored it too; I only knew about it because allo' y'all were on top of it. (And yes, I really had to think hard about how to write that, because it's a contraction where the dropped letter is the last letter of the second word. "All of y'all". And no, "y'all" isn't a contraction to me, which is why that's not redundant.)

[wildestinvegas]

this was better than her first performance and a good fit for her voice and range but not finale material at all imo. 

[keychange]

i thought she sounded good and looked her most confident yet 

[sublymonal]

Would have had Emmy do the Climb second because this song choice is kinda meh

[CountryIdols]

LOVED that from Emmy!

[Hsamid]

Honestly, this was a pretty vocal for the most part besides a few bum notes. Significantly better than her first performance.

[Mathacoo200315]

Nice vocal, one of her best!

[ScarletDevilCCX]

Emmy's finally put it all together! She's got the confidence, the voice, she looks the end.

[CarmenSandiego]

Emmy was much better this song than with “The Climb”.  Not like that was hard.  

[Gustavo527]

I enjoyed that. My favorite from her since Coal Mine's Daughter.

[MILO JAY]

they want emmy and triston gone lol

[*Wallace]

That was a cute performance from Emmy. I liked that she had fun and moved around the stage and showcased stage presence there. Though she's still a little awkward on stage but she's showing improvement there, at least. Definitely better than her first performance. 

 

I do think this would be a nice performance for her to go out on but we'll see what happens.

[Emmyfan]

Emmy might be going home but tonight she gave all her haters #$#$#@

[StarWalker1]

Just now, MILO JAY said:

they want emmy and triston gone lol

they didnt really help will with them bringing up the lyric flub 

[Anythingcanhappen]

5 minutes ago, MILO JAY said:

they want emmy and triston gone lol

As they should. Triston especially really needs to go tonight. 

[Floaty]

4 minutes ago, StarWalker1 said:

they didnt really help will with them bringing up the lyric flub 

 

Yeah no idea why Katy did that... but I guess if she didn't another judge probably would have.

[StarWalker1]

this song choice ...

[MalwareDie]

5 minutes ago, Emmyfan said:

Emmy might be going home but tonight she gave all her haters #$#$#@

 

Abi is not a lock for the Top 3, contrary to what your posts have been suggesting. She could be going home.

[wildestinvegas]

i still think they want triston in the finale, otherwise they wouldn't give him that package. it was so much stronger than emmys. 

[StarWalker1]

Just now, MalwareDie said:

 

Abi is not a lock for the Top 3, contrary to what your posts have been suggesting. She could be going home.

lets hope that doesnt become a reality and VOTE!

[QueenMae16]

They want Triston through with that edit.

 

This song is a bop at least.

[sublymonal]

Triston’s age and lack of experience is showing. This is very kid at a high school talent show.

[Solaris]

Lol tristons mom dancing in the background. Mama harper is going to win American Idol by proxy of her son.

 

This is not the best life is a highway performance I've ever heard. I liked his first performance more.