All-time favorite contestant of each gender and era

[TedZanarukando]

Who is your all-time favorite American Idol contestant of each gender and era?

 

Fox era male: Joshua Ledet

Fox era female: Jessica Sanchez

ABC era male: Tyson Venegas

ABC era female: Wé Ani

[Hsamid]

Lol this is way too hard but I'll try. The HM could easily be my number 1 pick on a different day lol 

 

Fox era male: Adam Lambert, HM to Joshua Ledet

 

Fox era female: Candice Glover, HM to Fantasia

 

ABC era female: Megan Danielle, HM to Casey Bishop, Leah Marlene, Kaeyra

 

ABC era male: Willie Spence, HM to Alejandra Aranda (mostly for his originals tbh)

 

 

[keychange]

Fox Era Male: Adam Lambert

Fox Era Female: Haley Reinhart

ABC Era Male: Jeremiah Lloyd Harmon

ABC Era Female: Casey Bishop

[Carrie_On]

Fox Era Male: Adam Lambert

Fox Era Female: Carrie Underwood

ABC Era Male: Iam Tongi

ABC Era Female: Julia Gargano

[KelseyW]

FOX era male: Kris Allen

FOX era female: Haley Reinhart

 

ABC era male: Iam Tongi/Alejandro Aranda (TIE)

ABC era female: Maddie Poppe/Casey Bishop/Leah Marlene (TIE)

 

I have many particulars here. Allison Iraheta was my main during Kris' season of Idol. Haley hasn't been topped out of FOX era. For me personally.

 

ABC Idol has been interesting and that I've had more female faves than male. Not equal amounts.

 

So my main is a guy this year.  

 

[Zoey]

Fox era male: David Archuleta

Fox era female: Vonzell Solomon

ABC era male: Michael J. Woodard

ABC era female: Gabby Barrett

[joe14]

FOX era male: Joshua Ledet

FOX era female: Vonzell Solomon (shout out to Hollie Cavanagh as well)

 

ABC era male: ...honestly I can't say I REALLY care for any of them, but gun to my head, probably Francisco Martin 

ABC era female: Casey Bishop

Edited May 16, 2023 by joe14

[Hamza Tufail]

Don't know much about Fox era, but I did watch all of Adam Lambert's performances. I loved his run, so he'd be my pick.

 

ABC era male:  Jeremiah Lloyd Harmon 

ABC era female: Leah Marlene. HM: Megan Danielle.

 

 

Overall #1 is Leah. 

[Elliott]

Fox era male: Lee DeWyze

Fox era female: Kelly Clarkson

ABC era male: Louis Knight

ABC era female: Casey Bishop

[taylorkat]

Fox era male: Kris Allen

Fox era female: Kelly Clarkson

ABC era male: Willie Spence

ABC era female: Nicolina Bozzo

[Solaris]

Fox era male: David Archuleta

Fox era female: Carrie Underwood

ABC era male: Laine Hardy Willie Spence

ABC era female: Gabby Barrett

[pepperman]

Fox Era Male: David Cook

Fox Era Female: Haley Reinhart

ABC Era Male: Chayce Beckham

ABC Era Female: Casey Bishop

[wgm]

too many to name