If the steals went to the 4 way knockout who would win?

[Sachin Jain]

???

[FloorWax]

CammWess, Sid, Andrew.

 

Who voted for Joseph lol

[Cookie73]

S18- CammWess

S19- Sid Kingsley

S20- probably Andrew? (It was between Andrew and Avery but Andrew had the better performance)

Edited August 4, 2021 by Cookie73

[Misirlou]

S18 - CammWess

S19- Sid Kingsley

S20 - Andrew Marshall

 

Pretty easily honestly. But these are my winners, didn´t see the instruction lol.

Edited August 4, 2021 by Misirlou

[VintageVoice]

S18: Camm, easily - Kelly’s decently liked with the audience and I’m guessing that KO was a large factor in him making the finale despite being a re-steal.

 

S19: Sid, easily - again with the Kelly factor + it being the strongest vocal of the four.

 

S20: I voted for Avery because country is the safe bet with the audience, but I think Andrew would give him a run for his money and I wouldn’t be shocked to see Andrew win in this hypothetical scenario.

[AliXRose]

Lmao do you guys really think Avery would've lost the 4-way KO when it comes down to America's vote ? Who had the best app % again  ?

[colemanftw]

CammWess and Avery would take it easily. I love Sid's KO but I don't remember him ever catching on with the core audience. His appeal to minivan was heavily overrated here. I actually think Lauren would win if she wasn't Team Legend. This way, James could've taken it, tbh. 

Edited August 4, 2021 by colemanftw

[Misirlou]

4 minutes ago, AliXRose said:

Lmao do you guys really think Avery would've lost the 4-way KO when it comes down to America's vote ? Who had the best app % again  ?

The app really means nothing.

 

But I agree he would have won. People actually liked him better than Kenzie as a whole. I personally didn´t see the instruction and voted according to my preferences lol.

[Misirlou]

In terms of who would have won?

 

S18 - CammWess

S19 -  Sid

S20 - Avery

[ThrowawayCrayon]

Camm

Sid

Andrew (I was torn between him and Avery but it wasn't Avery's best performance) 

[FloorWax]

3 minutes ago, colemanftw said:

CammWess and Avery would take it easily. I love Sid's KO but I don't remember him ever catching on with the core audience. His appeal to minivan was heavily overrated here. I actually think Lauren would win if she wasn't Team Legend. This way, James could've taken it, tbh. 

 

James literally sang a Shawn Mendes song. Also, Lauren wasn't really an audience favorite either. I may be biased but I still think Sid would've taken it.

[colemanftw]

2 minutes ago, FloorWax said:

James literally sang a Shawn Mendes song. Also, Lauren wasn't really an audience favorite either. I may be biased but I still think Sid would've taken it.

James was a good looking guy with impressive range on Team Blake. Sure, he had some pitch issues but If Devan managed to win with Sign of the Times on Team Nick...

I know In My Blood is a pop song outside minivan's wheelhouse but it's basically become a regular song on show's catalogue so I assume they were at least familiar with it.

[QueenCami]

CammWess

Sid

All of them would have been instantly eliminated due to an app glitch that made Dana an option (and it goes without saying that Dana got 100% of the votes)

[VoiceFan!]

basically all team kelly contestants

[QueenMae16]

Who I would go with:

Joanna

Sid

Gean

 

Who would actually win:

Cammwess(deserved tbh)

Sid

Avery