AI 19 ● Top 16 Reveal and Performance ● Discussion

[Bk1234]

Anilee and Andrea ROBBED

[*Wallace]

Cassandra making it through over Anilee is disappointing for me.  But oh well, I can live with this result. I do kinda like Cassandra.

[*Wallace]

Oooh snap, Cassandra singing "Wicked Game."  Danggg this could be really good.

[joe14]

Anilee seems like a great person. She was done dirty this entire competition.

[Elliott]

7 repeat songs among the first 8... and Killing Me Softly is somehow the new-to-Idol song.

[1234567890]

Congrats Cassandra.

[1234567890]

Just now, joe14 said:

Anilee seems like a great person. She was done dirty this entire competition.

She was originally eliminated and was only brought back because Benson Boone dropped out.

[KelseyW]

She's a little shouty tonight... If Kris Allen can kill this song I don't see why she can't...  

[holinessss]

this is the perfect song, use that sadness of being called last girl!

[Elliott]

I just do not like Cassandra’s voice.

[Steven_]

I didn't really like Cassandra's performance. 

[Bk1234]

1 minute ago, 1234567890 said:

She was originally eliminated and was only brought back because Benson Boone dropped out.

Still robbed.

[keychange]

There were some moments of rawness and vulnerability where her nerves shown through but I loved this performance from Cassandra!

[*Wallace]

1 minute ago, Elliott said:

7 repeat songs among the first 8... and Killing Me Softly is somehow the new-to-Idol song.

omgg seriously?  How has no one sang that song in 19 seasons?  

[MargoK]

Deshawn is so underrated!Cassandra did not do this song justice!!!

[joe14]

Just now, 1234567890 said:

She was originally eliminated and was only brought back because Benson Boone dropped out.

So she was given close to no screen time and then treated as last minute back up so it supports my argument that she was done dirty. 

[1234567890]

2 minutes ago, Elliott said:

7 repeat songs among the first 8... and Killing Me Softly is somehow the new-to-Idol song.

Kimberly Caldwell did it first.

[1234567890]

Just now, Bk1234 said:

Still robbed.

[*Wallace]

Shockingly, i really liked the softer quieter parts of Cassandra's performance. Didn't care for the bigger belting parts and i don't seem to like that part of her voice. I did like the performance though.

[Elliott]

Just now, 1234567890 said:

Kimberly Caldwell did it first.

Not on Idol though  

[ScarletDevilCCX]

I thought about it, and there are two in this group that I'm disappointed to see go, and only one that I'm truly disappointed to see stay. And then I realized, yes, I absolutely would prefer to have 9 from Group A and 7 from Group B in the Top 16.

 

Actually, that might not even be true; I actually had Liahona 7th last week, and Colin 8th. Give me Chayce, Casey, Beane, Ava, Mary Jo, Hannah, and everyone from Group A except Wyatt and Cecil.

Edited April 12, 2021 by ScarletDevilCCX

[KelseyW]

I'm sad for Anilee. She's too good not to be there...

[holinessss]

not my fave from cassandra, time to pull out the nerves card for my faves lol!

[1234567890]

Just now, joe14 said:

So she was given close to no screen time and then treated as last minute back up so it supports my argument that she was done dirty. 

 

Her duet wasn’t even shown because her duet partner was Benson Boone.

[kamil24]

Loved Cassandra!