Before the semis performances, what would your personal Top 5 consist of? (Select 5)

[Misirlou]

Go ahead.

[nytsch]

Karen

Madison

Asher

 

Not really sure after that, but probably Maddi and Nathan? I've really liked Bryan but he wasn't good this week.

[indii]

Karen

Asher

Maddi

Madison

Serenity

[StarWalker1]

Asher

Karen

Madison

Nathan

Maddi

[Hsamid]

Asher, Nathan, Madison, Tae and Josh.

 

I suspect Nathan and Asher will stay till the end. Probably Madison too. Bryan is most likely to replace one of the other 2 just based on everything prior to his top 12. But imma need to see another live performance first.

 

Edited May 8 by Hsamid

[MILO JAY]

Madison

Maddi

Karen

Asher

Josh

[Hamza Tufail]

Madison, Bryan, Karen, Asher, and Maddi.

[Someone648]

Madison

Bryan

Asher

Nathan

Karen (though I'd swap her for Josh if he was a bit more exciting/consistent)

[AD25]

Realistic Scenario

Madison, Nathan, Asher, Josh, Karen

 

Dream Scenario

Madison, Nathan, Maddi, Josh, Karen

[AliXRose]

1. Madison
2. Maddi
3. Nathan
4. Asher
5. Karen

[season1]

Karen

Tae

Nathan

Madison

Josh

[QueenKalie]

Josh, Karen, Madison and the other 2 are pretty irrelevant.

[BrokenHearted]

Nathan

Asher

Madison

Maddi

Tae

 

Literally any combination of 5 from the top 9 would be significantly better than the Idol top 5 though 

[Gustavo527]

Karen 

Madison 

Asher 

Nathan 

Maddi

[xfactor22]

This is actually one of the hardest seasons to select cause I enjoy all of them to some extent. But if I had to pick five Id go with Nathan obviously, Tae, Maddi, Madison, and Bryan. But the other four are very talented too