Gustavo527 Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 (edited) Facebook Likes Asher - 4.1K Bryan - 2.6K Nathan - 2.3K Karen - 2.1K Josh - 1.8K Madison - 1.4K Tae - 1.3K L. - 1K Maddi - 868 Zoe - 718 Serenity - 589 Nadege - 545 (Credits to @indodol) Views Asher - 74K Bryan - 55K Karen - 38K L. - 33K Madison - 29K Josh - 29K Maddi - 24K Nathan - 24K Tae - 24K Zoe - 18K Serenity - 14K Nádege - 12K Views/likes ratios Nathan - 10.43 Josh - 16.11 Asher - 18.04 Karen - 18.09 Tae - 18.46 Madison - 20.71 Bryan - 21.15 Nádege - 22.01 Serenity - 23.76 Zoe - 25.06 Maddi - 27.64 L. - 33 Three hours after the show ended Edited May 7 by Gustavo527 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gustavo527 Posted May 7 Author Share Posted May 7 (edited) I took a quick glance at Facebook's comments - Bryan received plenty of criticism. Some people said that they really liked him but were dissapointed on the performance. - Tae was almost all positive. A negative comment but it received several angry reactions. - Maddi's criticism was mostly on the song choice. I expected worse, tbh - L. is getting some really harsh comments with several likes. It's not looking good. - Madison got a pretty positive comments' section. - Asher is getting lots of praise. Not really any signficative negative comment - Zoe is receiving several negative comments about the performance and song choice - Serenity received mostly positive comments, it's not looking too bad for her after all. - Nádege, on the other hand, got some negative comments, someone even said that she belongs on a cabaret lol - Karen got mostly positive comments but one negative comment saying that she did not the song justice, and that comment got several likes. Still, nothing too alarming...yet. - Nathan and Josh, plenty of praise, especially Nathan . Edited May 7 by Gustavo527 1 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
QueenKalie Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 Twitter thinks Reba is going to win Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
QueenMae16 Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 L.'s ratio doesn't look good for a PV, her likes aren't really saving her either. I think the song will be her best bet to not have to sing for the IS, but I wouldn't bet on it. Of the most vulnerable people, I think Tae will be the most safe, he succeeded well enough despite that bus(or promo for the duo) and the numbers support that. Glad to see Asher doing better than expected, I'll still peg him as a dark horse who has a chance. Karen is getting good numbers, but she needs a breakout if she wants to do better, the song was in the right direction but not quite there yet. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Someone648 Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 (edited) I know YouTube doesn't really matter all that much, but after 4+ hours on YouTube: View Count: Asher HaVon: 17k Nathan Chester: 14k Madison Curbelo: 12k Maddi Jane: 11k Bryan Olesen: 9.9k Nadège: 9.8k Serenity Arce: 8k Zoe Levert: 7.6k L. Rodgers: 7.4k Tae Lewis 7k Karen Waldrup: 6.7k Josh Sanders: 5.6k Obviously this doesn't match up super well with the FB stats, but could give some insight into the more general public vote. Maddi has more casual support/viewership that the country contestants don't, which I think will bolster her for at least one more week. I think the only country contestant affected as a result is Tae. Since his numbers are mid/low as well, he could fall below. L. is also underperforming everywhere so I think she'll end up there. That leaves Serenity, Nadège, and Zoe consistently at the bottom. Maybe Serenity or Zoe can muster up some more casual support as well, but neither delivered to earn much last night. IIRC, Serenity seemed to be getting better comments on FB than Zoe, so I can see a Zoe-Tae-Nadège-L. bottom 4, with all 4 coaches represented? Otherwise swap out Serenity for one of them, I'd say probably Tae. Edited May 7 by Someone648 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
FloorWax Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 9 hours after show end: Likes Asher - 5.6K Nathan - 3.6K Bryan - 3.1K Karen - 3K Josh - 2.5K Madison - 1.8K Tae - 1.6K L. - 1.2K Maddi - 1K Zoe - 950 Serenity - 825 Nadege - 775 5 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
FloorWax Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 19 minutes ago, FloorWax said: 9 hours after show end: Likes Asher - 5.6K Nathan - 3.6K Bryan - 3.1K Karen - 3K Josh - 2.5K Madison - 1.8K Tae - 1.6K L. - 1.2K Maddi - 1K Zoe - 950 Serenity - 825 Nadege - 775 Karen only has the 4th most reacts and she still has more than all of Team Chance combined 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rodney Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 (edited) 6 minutes ago, FloorWax said: Karen only has the 4th most reacts and she still has more than all of Team Chance combined Shows just how sad of a team that Chance has. Edited May 7 by Rodney Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AD25 Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 (edited) T12 Performance Rankings FB Likes Asher HaVon, 6.1K Nathan Chester, 4.1K Karen Waldrup, 3.3K Bryan Olesen, 3.2K Josh Sanders, 2.8K Madison Curbelo, 2K Tae Lewis, 1.7K L Rodgers, 1.3K Maddi Jane, 1.1K Zoe Levert, 1K Serenity Arce, 906 Nadege, 830 IG Likes Maddi Jane, 4559 Asher HaVon, 4480 Zoe Levert, 4162 Bryan Olesen, 3272 Nathan Chester, 2939 Madison Curbelo, 2836 Serenity Arce, 2255 Tae Lewis, 1932 Nadege, 1616 Karen Waldrup, 1902 L Rodgers, 1247 Josh Sanders, 1212 YT Likes Asher HaVon, 1.7K Nathan Chester, 1.3K Madison Curbelo, 817 Maddi Jane, 744 Nadege, 632 Bryan Olesen, 599 Serenity Arce, 512 L Rodgers, 509 Zoe Levert, 475 Tae Lewis, 471 Karen Waldrup, 435 Josh Sanders, 365 Twitter Retweets Karen Waldrup, 42 Asher HaVon, 42 Nathan Chester, 41 Madison Curbelo, 31 Bryan Olesen, 29 Maddi Jane, 27 Serenity Arce, 22 Zoe Levert, 20 L Rodgers, 20 Josh Sanders, 18 Tae Lewis, 17 Nadege, 14 Twitter Likes Nathan Chester, 219 Karen Waldrup, 213 Asher HaVon, 194 Madison Curbelo, 172 Bryan Olesen, 158 Maddi Jane, 157 Zoe Levert, 134 Tae Lewis, 116 Josh Sanders, 110 Serenity Arce, 106 L Rodgers, 99 Nadege, 78 Tik Tok Likes Asher HaVon, 6954 Serenity Arce, 5322 Karen Waldrup, 4402 Maddi Jane, 4099 Zoe Levert, 3450 Bryan Olesen, 3179 Nathan Chester, 2799 Madison Curbelo, 2204 Nadege, 1860 Tae Lewis, 1681 L Rodgers, 1377 Josh Sanders, 1168 Edited May 7 by AD25 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
FloorWax Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 4 hours ago, Rodney said: Shows just how sad of a team that Chance has. It gets better. If you combine all of Team Chance's numbers and multiply it by two, Asher still has more 6 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
istersay Posted May 7 Share Posted May 7 5 hours ago, AD25 said: T12 Performance Rankings FB Likes Asher HaVon, 6.1K Nathan Chester, 4.1K Karen Waldrup, 3.3K Bryan Olesen, 3.2K Josh Sanders, 2.8K Madison Curbelo, 2K Tae Lewis, 1.7K L Rodgers, 1.3K Maddi Jane, 1.1K Zoe Levert, 1K Serenity Arce, 906 Nadege, 830 IG Likes Maddi Jane, 4559 Asher HaVon, 4480 Zoe Levert, 4162 Bryan Olesen, 3272 Nathan Chester, 2939 Madison Curbelo, 2836 Serenity Arce, 2255 Tae Lewis, 1932 Nadege, 1616 Karen Waldrup, 1902 L Rodgers, 1247 Josh Sanders, 1212 YT Likes Asher HaVon, 1.7K Nathan Chester, 1.3K Madison Curbelo, 817 Maddi Jane, 744 Nadege, 632 Bryan Olesen, 599 Serenity Arce, 512 L Rodgers, 509 Zoe Levert, 475 Tae Lewis, 471 Karen Waldrup, 435 Josh Sanders, 365 Twitter Retweets Karen Waldrup, 42 Asher HaVon, 42 Nathan Chester, 41 Madison Curbelo, 31 Bryan Olesen, 29 Maddi Jane, 27 Serenity Arce, 22 Zoe Levert, 20 L Rodgers, 20 Josh Sanders, 18 Tae Lewis, 17 Nadege, 14 Twitter Likes Nathan Chester, 219 Karen Waldrup, 213 Asher HaVon, 194 Madison Curbelo, 172 Bryan Olesen, 158 Maddi Jane, 157 Zoe Levert, 134 Tae Lewis, 116 Josh Sanders, 110 Serenity Arce, 106 L Rodgers, 99 Nadege, 78 Tik Tok Likes Asher HaVon, 6954 Serenity Arce, 5322 Karen Waldrup, 4402 Maddi Jane, 4099 Zoe Levert, 3450 Bryan Olesen, 3179 Nathan Chester, 2799 Madison Curbelo, 2204 Nadege, 1860 Tae Lewis, 1681 L Rodgers, 1377 Josh Sanders, 1168 moved this to the SM thread Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
indodol Posted Tuesday at 03:07 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 03:07 AM Reviving this thread lol Top 9 FB reacts Josh 3.8k Karen 1.6k Nathan 1.4k Bryan 1.4k Asher 1.1k Madison 1.1k Serenity 988 Tae 712 Maddi 690 1 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
indodol Posted Tuesday at 03:27 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 03:27 AM TVLine poll: 1. Nathan 39% 2. Karen 19% 3. Asher 12% 4. Josh 8% 5. Madison 6% 6. Maddi 5% 7. Tae 4% 8. Bryan 3% 9. Serenity 0.77% 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
StarWalker1 Posted Tuesday at 03:28 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 03:28 AM 20 minutes ago, indodol said: Reviving this thread lol Top 9 FB reacts Josh 3.8k Karen 1.6k Nathan 1.4k Bryan 1.4k Asher 1.1k Madison 1.1k Serenity 988 Tae 712 Maddi 690 Asher is about to surpass Nathan/Bryan - his support could be stronger than we think Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
thecarterfilez Posted Tuesday at 04:07 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 04:07 AM Asher has been dominating facebook for the past 3 weeks... anyone who underestimated his support was being foolish.... Josh/Karen/Asher are guaranteed PV... Nathan/Bryan are next up... I don't think Madison is in the running for PV... also song choice will be very important for Asher next week... the fact that he's top 3 in numbers with a bad song choice just shows how massive his support is. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MatthewPalermo Posted Tuesday at 04:16 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 04:16 AM 6 minutes ago, thecarterfilez said: Asher has been dominating facebook for the past 3 weeks... anyone who underestimated his support was being foolish.... Josh/Karen/Asher are guaranteed PV... Nathan/Bryan are next up... I don't think Madison is in the running for PV... also song choice will be very important for Asher next week... the fact that he's top 3 in numbers with a bad song choice just shows how massive his support is. I wouldn't call Asher's PV guaranteed, but I think the odds are greatly in his favor. I bet he's 5th bare minimum. He'll easily beat Serenity, Maddi and Madison, and arguably Bryan too. And even with Tae's pimp spot, he performed right after Asher, has middling numbers and came into this week with an IS handicap. Anything can happen, of course, but Asher outperforming everyone on FB except Karen and Josh with a poor song choice is a very good sign. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
allistr Posted Tuesday at 04:35 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 04:35 AM How are the comments so far? I'm just gonna predict that Karen, Nathan, Madison and Josh will receive mostly positive comments, Asher got some complaints about the song choice, and the rest are between mixed and mostly negative. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gustavo527 Posted Tuesday at 04:36 AM Author Share Posted Tuesday at 04:36 AM Just now, allistr said: How are the comments so far? I'm just gonna predict that Karen, Nathan, Madison and Josh will receive mostly positive comments, Asher got some complaints about the song choice, and the rest are between mixed and mostly negative. For the sake of my mental health i'm not checking those this time. Sorry. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
QueenKalie Posted Tuesday at 04:46 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 04:46 AM 8 minutes ago, Gustavo527 said: For the sake of my mental health i'm not checking those this time. Sorry. If they are anything like the AI comments which I assume they probably are then that's probably for the best that you don't look at them. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
indodol Posted Tuesday at 05:11 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 05:11 AM Top 9 FB reacts update Josh 4.5k Karen 2.9k Asher 2.5k Bryan 2.2k Nathan 2k Tae 1.7k Madison 1.4k Serenity 1.2k Maddi 944 All female bottom 3 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Someone648 Posted Tuesday at 05:50 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 05:50 AM On 5/6/2024 at 10:26 PM, Gustavo527 said: Facebook Likes Asher - 4.1K Bryan - 2.6K Nathan - 2.3K Karen - 2.1K Josh - 1.8K Madison - 1.4K Tae - 1.3K [BOTTOM 4/SAVED] L. - 1K [BOTTOM 4] Maddi - 868 Zoe - 718 [BOTTOM 4] Serenity - 589 Nadege - 545 [BOTTOM 4] For reference last week^ Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
indii Posted Tuesday at 05:52 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 05:52 AM (edited) 1 hour ago, allistr said: How are the comments so far? I'm just gonna predict that Karen, Nathan, Madison and Josh will receive mostly positive comments, Asher got some complaints about the song choice, and the rest are between mixed and mostly negative. Nathan's comments are pretty much all positive Josh/Tae got their fair share of negative comments (Josh less so) but for the most part positive. Karen also got a significant amount of negative ones but I'd say mostly positive. Asher's comments are...well everybody seems in agreement that he picked the wrong song choice but they're all also saying he's the best singer in the competition so IDK what to make of that Bryan's comments are less negative than you'd think, still mostly negative but I saw a lot of praise. Madison's comments are SUPER negative, like all the way through. Everyone is saying they don't like what she did to the song You can guess what the rest look like Edited Tuesday at 05:55 AM by indii 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hsamid Posted Tuesday at 06:37 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 06:37 AM 42 minutes ago, indii said: Nathan's comments are pretty much all positive Josh/Tae got their fair share of negative comments (Josh less so) but for the most part positive. Karen also got a significant amount of negative ones but I'd say mostly positive. Asher's comments are...well everybody seems in agreement that he picked the wrong song choice but they're all also saying he's the best singer in the competition so IDK what to make of that Bryan's comments are less negative than you'd think, still mostly negative but I saw a lot of praise. Madison's comments are SUPER negative, like all the way through. Everyone is saying they don't like what she did to the song You can guess what the rest look like Surprised Madison's comments are negative. I thought she's been doing a really good job making subtle or just the right amount of changes to classic songs. So that sucks 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rodney Posted Tuesday at 07:32 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 07:32 AM (edited) Top 9 FB reacts update Josh 4.7k Karen 3.3k Asher 3.1k Bryan 2.5k Nathan 2.2k Tae 2k Madison 1.5k Serenity 1.3k Maddi 1k Asher has already passed Karen in views and is about to pass her in reacts, too. Edited Tuesday at 07:32 AM by Rodney 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Rodney Posted Tuesday at 11:14 AM Share Posted Tuesday at 11:14 AM (edited) Top 9 FB reacts at the close of the voting window: Josh 5.1k Asher 4.1k Karen 4.1k Bryan 2.9k Tae 2.6k Nathan 2.5k Madison 1.5k Serenity 1.5k Maddi 1.1k Asher fully caught up to Karen in reacts. And Tae passed up Nathan. Team Chance is the bottom two. If this reflects the actual voting, then Maddi and Serenity are done. Edited Tuesday at 01:10 PM by Rodney 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now