The Voice Season 23: Idolforums' ratings

[QueenMae16]

22 minutes ago, Gustavo527 said:

Don't ask me how but i lost all the data for the first two episodes . This is gonna take more time, hopefully i can put this out in the next hours 

All good, we know it's hard to keep up with it. Take your time tbh.

[Hamza Tufail]

3 hours ago, Arsh said:

Battle Rounds: Episode 1

 

Tasha vs EJ - The Tracks of My Tears - 8.5

Jamar vs Mariah - Gravity - 8

Gina vs Kala - Skinny Love - 9

Cait vs Allie - It Must Have Been Love - 9.3

Walker vs Kason - Here Without You - 5.5

Sorelle vs Manasseh - Someone like You - 7.5

 

Battle Rounds: Episode 2

 

Ross Clayton vs. Laura Littleton - Stop Draggin' My Heart Around - 7

Magnus vs. Alyssa Lazar - Your Song - 5.5

Kylee Dayne vs. Mary Kate Connor - Anti-Hero - 7.5

I'm not complaining, you can do whatever you want. But I find it really interesting how you (almost) always give Team Blake low grades, so that they don't surpass team Kelly members. Lol

[Hamza Tufail]

3 hours ago, Arsh said:

 

 

Edited March 30, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Arsh]

5 hours ago, Hamza Tufail said:

I'm not complaining, you can do whatever you want. But I find it really interesting how you (almost) always give Team Blake low grades, so that they don't surpass team Kelly members. Lol

 

Other than Cait vs. Allie and Gina vs. Kala, I actually didn't enjoy any of the battles up to this point.

 

8 hours ago, Arsh said:

Tasha vs EJ - The Tracks of My Tears - 8.5 ( This is Team Chance)

Team Chance

8 hours ago, Arsh said:

 

Magnus vs. Alyssa Lazar - Your Song - 5.5 

 

Team Blake

 

Edited March 30, 2023 by Arsh

[Hamza Tufail]

4 minutes ago, Arsh said:

 

Actually, other from Cait vs. Allie and Gina vs. Kala, I actually didn't enjoy any of the battles up to this point.

 

Team Chance

Team Blake

 

Must be a tough season for you then. 

[Arsh]

2 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Must be a tough season for you then. 

It is

[QueenCami]

8 hours ago, Hamza Tufail said:

I'm not complaining, you can do whatever you want. But I find it really interesting how you (almost) always give Team Blake low grades, so that they don't surpass team Kelly members. Lol

but you giving all your favorites 10s is not interesting ?

Edited March 30, 2023 by QueenCami

[jarmon]

13 minutes ago, QueenCami said:

but you giving all your favorites 10s is not interesting ?

[Gustavo527]

Y'all are desperate for the ratings to come out, i see  

 

Don't worry, they are ready, i just need time to post them. 

[Hamza Tufail]

1 hour ago, QueenCami said:

but you giving all your favorites 10s is not interesting ?

Yeah that too. Lol

[Cookie73]

Ross Clayton vs. Laura Littleton - Stop Draggin' My Heart Around - 7

Magnus vs. Alyssa Lazar - Your Song - 5

Kylee Dayne vs. Mary Kate Connor - Anti-Hero - 9

[Gustavo527]

On 3/7/2023 at 12:23 AM, Gustavo527 said:

Blind Auditions: Full Ranking 

 

1. Cait Martin - As it Was - 9.43 

2. Ryley Tate Wilson - Dancing on My Own - 8.94

3. NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 8.79

4. Grace West - Maybe It Was Memphis - 8.65  

5. Kala Banham - Both Sides Now - 8.58

6. Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8.47

7. NariYella - One Night Only - 8.43

8. Gina Miles - The One that Got Away - 8.4

9. Sheer Element - Leave the Door Open - 8.34

10. Neil Salsich - Honky Tonk Blues - 8.11 

10. Kate Cosentino - I Say A Little Prayer - 8.11

12. Tasha Jessen - River - 8.09

13. JB Somers - A Case of You - 8.06

14. Rachel Christine Gebel - Uninvited - 7.95 

15. Kylee Dayne - Fallingwater - 7.92

16. Mannasseh Simone - Rise Up - 7.85

17. Mariah Kalia - Idontwannabeyouanymore - 7.69 

18. Allie Keck - Paris (Ooh La La) - 7.67 

19. Talia Smith - Don't You Worry 'bout a Thing - 7.62  

20. EJ Michaels - Easy on Me - 7.56 

21. Alex Whalen - Help Me Make It Through the Night - 7.52  

22. Laura Littleton - Sign of the Times - 7.48

23. Mary Kate Connor - Stars - 7.44

24. Tiana Goss - Emotions - 7.4 

25. Katie Beth Forakis - Ghost - 7.3.

26. Jamar Langley - Try Me - 7.17

27. Magnus - Sara Smile - 7.16

28. Ross Clayton - Blue Ain't Your Color - 7.15 

29. Marcos Covos - Tu, Solo Tu - 7.12 

30. Carlos Rising - Change the World - 7.1 

31. D. Smooth - Perfect - 7.09 

32. Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 7.05 

33. Jerome Godwin III - pov - 7 

34. Ray Uriel - Glimpse of Us - 6.75 

34. Michael B. - Save Your Tears - 6.75 

36. ALI - Killing Me Softly - 6.67 

37. Kason Lester - It´s Not Over - 6.17  

37. Chloe Abbott - How Deep is Your Love - 6.17 

39. Walker Wilson - Hurricane - 6.1 

 

Average per episode 

Episode 1 - 7.67

Episode 2 - 7.8

Episode 3 - 7.39

Episode 4 - 7.25

Episode 5 - 7.79

Episode 6 - 8 

 

Average per team 

Team Blake - 7.46 

Team Niall - 7.74 

Team Chance - 7.45 

Team Kelly - 7.81 

 

Total average of the round  = 7.62

It took more time than expected, but here we are! Feel free to discuss

[QueenCami]

19 minutes ago, Gustavo527 said:

13. JB Somers - A Case of You - 8.06

14. Rachel Christine Gebel - Uninvited - 7.95 

15. Kylee Dayne - Fallingwater - 7.92

18. Allie Keck - Paris (Ooh La La) - 7.67 

26. Jamar Langley - Try Me - 7.17

27. Magnus - Sara Smile - 7.16

32. Sorelle - Good Old-Fashioned Lover Boy - 7.05 

33. Jerome Godwin III - pov - 7 

some of y'all must be broke bc why did y'all rob these contestants 

[Misirlou]

15 minutes ago, Gustavo527 said:

It took more time than expected, but here we are! Feel free to discuss

- As expected, Cait is #1. Congrats to her.

 

- I expected Grace to be higher and NOIVAS to be lower, but guess I didnt fully check. I saw some low grades for NOIVAS and he is a bit polarizing so that was my intuition.

 

- A teenage boy in the Top 2. New era for IDF.

 

- Sorelle proved to be quite polarizing. Their battle might be higher playing though.

 

- Interesting that with all the vocal criticism for his blind, D.Smooth still got more than a 7.

 

- I saw someone commenting that Kara wasnt liked by IDF. These results (and honestly, most comments I've read) prove otherwise. Indie girls are a favorite here lol.

 

- I knew Walker wasnt liked here, but wow, I didnt expect him to be the lowest graded one considering the very poor reception for other contestants (Kason, in particular, I'm quite surprised he beat him). Without disparaging anyone, I'll just say he definitely didnt deserve to be the bottom one.

[Hamza Tufail]

So, I was spot on with my predictions.

 

2 hours ago, Misirlou said:

- As expected, Cait is #1. Congrats to her.

 

- I expected Grace to be higher and NOIVAS to be lower, but guess I didnt fully check. I saw some low grades for NOIVAS and he is a bit polarizing so that was my intuition.

 

- A teenage boy in the Top 2. New era for IDF.

 

- Sorelle proved to be quite polarizing. Their battle might be higher playing though.

 

- Interesting that with all the vocal criticism for his blind, D.Smooth still got more than a 7.

 

- I saw someone commenting that Kara wasnt liked by IDF. These results (and honestly, most comments I've read) prove otherwise. Indie girls are a favorite here lol.

 

- I knew Walker wasnt liked here, but wow, I didnt expect him to be the lowest graded one considering the very poor reception for other contestants (Kason, in particular, I'm quite surprised he beat him). Without disparaging anyone, I'll just say he definitely didnt deserve to be the bottom one.

Grace also had many 7s. But if you look at the amount of 10s, NOIVAS has more.

 

[Hamza Tufail]

Also, Sorelle at 32??? Y'all are cancelled.

[nytsch]

Cait and Ryley top 2, we LOVE to see it

 

Nice to see Kala so high too, there’s only one I really object to in the top 10 but it’s probably already obvious which that is 

[Hamza Tufail]

Top 10 from s20 onwards:

 

S20:

1. Cam Anthony - Lay Me Down 8.95

2. Zae Romeo - Falling 8.85

3. Zania Alake - Sweet Love 8.66

4. Victor Solomon - Glory 8.59

5. Lindsay Joan - Nightmare 8.34

6. Corey Ward - Dancing On My Own 8.31

7. Savanna Woods - Zombie 8.24

8. Dana Monique - Freeway of Love 8.06

9. Anna Grace - my future 7.83

10a. Raine Stern - Electric Feel 7.68

10b. Avery Roberson - If You're Reading This 7.68.       

 

S21:

1. Wendy Moten - We Can Work It Out 9.42

2. Holly Forbes - Rocket Man 9.22

3. Gymani - pov 9.02

4. Girl Named Tom - Helplessly Hoping 8.89

5. Bella Denapoli - Damaged 8.88

6. Samuel Harness - Here Without You 8.8

7. LiBianca - Good Days 8.6

8. Brittany Bree - Call Out My Name 8.57

9. Samara Brown - Sweet Thing 8.53

10. Shadale - That’s What I Like 8.27

 

S22:

1. Parijita Bastola - Jealous - 9.16 

2. bodie - You Found Me - 8.74

3. Morgan Myles - Hallelujah -  8.71

4. Kim Cruse - Best Part - 8.58

5. Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 8.45

6. Kevin Hawkins - Isn't She Lovely - 8.38

6. Justin Aaron - Glory -  8.38 

8. Jaeden Luke - Make It With You - 8.36

9. Grace Bello - Ghost - 8.28 

10. Valarie Harding - Something He Can Feel - 8.12

 

S23:

1. Cait Martin - As it Was - 9.43 

2. Ryley Tate Wilson - Dancing on My Own - 8.94

3. NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 8.79

4. Grace West - Maybe It Was Memphis - 8.65  

5. Kala Banham - Both Sides Now - 8.58

6. Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8.47

7. NariYella - One Night Only - 8.43

8. Gina Miles - The One that Got Away - 8.4

9. Sheer Element - Leave the Door Open - 8.34

10. Neil Salsich - Honky Tonk Blues - 8.11 

 

S21 had the best ratings overall followed by S23. Then it's S22, and then at last S20. (Those 7s dragged it down a bit).

 

What's interesting is that Cait surpassed Wendy by 0.01.

Edited March 31, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Dai]

6 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Top 10 from s20 onwards:

 

S20:

1. Cam Anthony - Lay Me Down 8.95

2. Zae Romeo - Falling 8.85

3. Zania Alake - Sweet Love 8.66

4. Victor Solomon - Glory 8.59

5. Lindsay Joan - Nightmare 8.34

6. Corey Ward - Dancing On My Own 8.31

7. Savanna Woods - Zombie 8.24

8. Dana Monique - Freeway of Love 8.06

9. Anna Grace - my future 7.83

10a. Raine Stern - Electric Feel 7.68

10b. Avery Roberson - If You're Reading This 7.68.       

I saw this and thought “there was a S20 ratings thread???” and then I remembered it was the one I hosted  #RepressedTrauma

[FloorWax]

4 hours ago, Gustavo527 said:

It took more time than expected, but here we are! Feel free to discuss

 

- Cait and Ryley are both in my personal Top 3 so I’m happy with them being at the top.

 

- Surprised Sheer Element’s average ended up being so high lol, didn’t expect them to be Top 10.

 

- Neil and Kate being as high as they are is also kind of a surprise to me? A pleasant one, but still a surprise.

 

- JB, Rachel, and Kylee all deserved to be in the Top 10 hmph.

 

- Considering how much praise there often is for divas, Manasseh only being at 17 is pretty unusual for this forum, but I’m not complaining.

 

- Jamar and Sorelle deserved WAY higher positions imo

 

- Cmon guys, Walker wasn’t the worst 

[Hamza Tufail]

5 minutes ago, FloorWax said:

 

- Cait and Ryley are both in my personal Top 3 so I’m happy with them being at the top.

 

- Surprised Sheer Element’s average ended up being so high lol, didn’t expect them to be Top 10.

 

- Neil and Kate being as high as they are is also kind of a surprise to me? A pleasant one, but still a surprise.

 

- JB, Rachel, and Kylee all deserved to be in the Top 10 hmph.

 

- Considering how much praise there often is for divas, Manasseh only being at 17 is pretty unusual for this forum, but I’m not complaining.

 

- Jamar and Sorelle deserved WAY higher positions imo

 

- Cmon guys, Walker wasn’t the worst 

Yeah, I'm sad about Sorelle being this low, but NOIVAS being in the top 3 balanced it for me. There are a lot of people who gave him 7.5s, and many called his performance underwhelming, but King still managed to get into the top 3.

 

I love Cait, Ryley, and Grace as well, but they all have been getting positive response here. NOIVAS and Sorelle not so much.

[FloorWax]

30 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

NOIVAS and Sorelle not so much.

 

Okay Sorelle has definitely not been getting the most positive response, but aside from a few detractors (lol me), NOIVAS is one of the most popular contestants this season lmao.

[Hsamid]

Kinda surprised Holly Brand is that high. I barely see anyone talk about her. Not complaining though

1 hour ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Top 10 from s20 onwards:

 

S20:

1. Cam Anthony - Lay Me Down 8.95

2. Zae Romeo - Falling 8.85

3. Zania Alake - Sweet Love 8.66

4. Victor Solomon - Glory 8.59

5. Lindsay Joan - Nightmare 8.34

6. Corey Ward - Dancing On My Own 8.31

7. Savanna Woods - Zombie 8.24

8. Dana Monique - Freeway of Love 8.06

9. Anna Grace - my future 7.83

10a. Raine Stern - Electric Feel 7.68

10b. Avery Roberson - If You're Reading This 7.68.       

 

S21:

1. Wendy Moten - We Can Work It Out 9.42

2. Holly Forbes - Rocket Man 9.22

3. Gymani - pov 9.02

4. Girl Named Tom - Helplessly Hoping 8.89

5. Bella Denapoli - Damaged 8.88

6. Samuel Harness - Here Without You 8.8

7. LiBianca - Good Days 8.6

8. Brittany Bree - Call Out My Name 8.57

9. Samara Brown - Sweet Thing 8.53

10. Shadale - That’s What I Like 8.27

 

S22:

1. Parijita Bastola - Jealous - 9.16 

2. bodie - You Found Me - 8.74

3. Morgan Myles - Hallelujah -  8.71

4. Kim Cruse - Best Part - 8.58

5. Omar José Cardona - Separate Ways - 8.45

6. Kevin Hawkins - Isn't She Lovely - 8.38

6. Justin Aaron - Glory -  8.38 

8. Jaeden Luke - Make It With You - 8.36

9. Grace Bello - Ghost - 8.28 

10. Valarie Harding - Something He Can Feel - 8.12

 

S23:

1. Cait Martin - As it Was - 9.43 

2. Ryley Tate Wilson - Dancing on My Own - 8.94

3. NOIVAS - A Change Is Gonna Come - 8.79

4. Grace West - Maybe It Was Memphis - 8.65  

5. Kala Banham - Both Sides Now - 8.58

6. Holly Brand - Mississipi Girl - 8.47

7. NariYella - One Night Only - 8.43

8. Gina Miles - The One that Got Away - 8.4

9. Sheer Element - Leave the Door Open - 8.34

10. Neil Salsich - Honky Tonk Blues - 8.11 

 

S21 had the best ratings overall followed by S23. Then it's S22, and then at last S20. (Those 7s dragged it down a bit).

 

What's interesting is that Cait surpassed Wendy by 0.01.

Cait with the highest rated blind audition since S20.

 

She was excellent dont get me wrong, but that's really surprising. Is everyone becoming more lenient with their ratings or something?

 

Also, crazy to see the downfall of Holly and Zae. Both of them seemed to lose fanfare pretty fast.

[Hamza Tufail]

4 minutes ago, Hsamid said:

Kinda surprised Holly Brand is that high. I barely see anyone talk about her. Not complaining though

Cait with the highest rated blind audition since S20.

 

She was excellent dont get me wrong, but that's really surprising. Is everyone becoming more lenient with their ratings or something?

 

Also, crazy to see the downfall of Holly and Zae. Both of them seemed to lose fanfare pretty fast.

Both of them still had fans even at the time of Knockouts. They lost them during the lives where they both tanked.

Edited March 31, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Hsamid]

47 minutes ago, FloorWax said:

 

- Cait and Ryley are both in my personal Top 3 so I’m happy with them being at the top.

 

- Surprised Sheer Element’s average ended up being so high lol, didn’t expect them to be Top 10.

 

- Neil and Kate being as high as they are is also kind of a surprise to me? A pleasant one, but still a surprise.

 

- JB, Rachel, and Kylee all deserved to be in the Top 10 hmph.

 

- Considering how much praise there often is for divas, Manasseh only being at 17 is pretty unusual for this forum, but I’m not complaining.

 

- Jamar and Sorelle deserved WAY higher positions imo

 

- Cmon guys, Walker wasn’t the worst 

Agreed with everything you said. Seems like that's the case this season much more so than in the past lol.

 

Yeah Walker isn't the worst, I'd put Ray below him at least if we're talking about who had the most issues in their performance.