Favourite Top 26 contestant + rank them (post-Hawaii round)

[BrokenHearted]

Colin Stough

Dawson Wayne

Elijah McCormick

Elise Kristine

Emma Busse

Hannah Nicolaisen

Haven Madison

Iam Tongi

Kaeyra

Lucy Love

Malik Heard

Mariah Faith

Marybeth Byrd

Matt Wilson

Megan Danielle

Michael Williams

Nailyah Serenity

Nutsa

Oliver Steele

Olivia Soli

Paige Anne

PJAE

Tyson Venegas

Warren Peay

Wé Ani

Zachariah Smith

 

My ranking:

 

1. Kaeyra

2. Elise Kristine 

3. Paige Anne

4. Michael Williams

5. Olivia Soli

6. Iam Tongi

7. Megan Danielle

8. Emma Busse

9. Hannah Nicolaisen

10. Wé Ani

11. Nutsa

12. Tyson Venegas

13. Dawson Wayne

14. Lucy Love

15. Matt Wilson

16. Marybeth Byrd

17. Malik Heard

18. Oliver Steele

19. Colin Stough

20. Nailyah Serenity

21. Zachariah Smith

22. Elijah McCormick

23. PJAE

24. Haven Madison

25. Mariah Faith

26. Warren Peay

Edited April 18, 2023 by BrokenHearted

[CarmenSandiego]

Tyson, We, WE!

I’ll rank them later.

Edited April 18, 2023 by CarmenSandiego

[erik g]

 

 

1. We

2. Nutsa

3. Lucy

4. Nailyah

5. Matt

 

that's all i feel like doing lol

 

[QueenKalie]

Matt, Marybeth, Marybeth

[hazuki]

Favorite girl is probably between Kaeyra or Olivia. So hard to choose cause there both good. I think Emma and Elise are up there too.  

 

Matt is easily the best guy for me but I can recognize why Iam is considered the best by many but that is also a turnoff. 

Edited April 18, 2023 by hazuki

[FloorWax]

Matt Wilson for best guy, hasn’t been the strongest objectively but he has my favorite tone and he’s just very likable.

 

Wé Ani for the girls, with Kaeyra right behind her.

 

Overall is Wé.

[allistr]

I'm not sold on all of the guys here, but the closest to my liking is Matt Wilson. 

Of course my favorite of the girls here is We Ani, followed by Kaeyra, Paige Anne, Nutsa. Kinda interested in Marybeth and Megan too.

Overall, We takes my spot

[FloorWax]

Sorry I don’t care enough about most of these people to rank them 

 

1. Wé

2. Kaeyra

3. Matt

4. Oliver

5. Elise (just for Feeling Good, one of the highlights of this season so far)

6. Nailyah (just for Lovin’ You, one of the highlights of this season so far)

7. Warren

8. Marybeth

9. Iam

10. Olivia

 

the rest

Edited April 18, 2023 by FloorWax

[QueenKalie]

1. Marybeth

2. Olivia

3. Kaeyra

4. Elise

5. Paige

6. We

7. Emma

8. Matt

9. Hannah

10. Nutsa

11.  Tyson

12. Haven

13.  Megan

14. Lucy

15. Iam

16. Zachariah

17.  Mariah

18. Oliver

19. Elijah

20. Nailyah

21. Warren

22. Michael

23. Colin

24. Malik

25. Dawson

26. PJAE

[Persy]

1. We Ani

2. Iam Tongi

3. Marybeth Byrd

4. Tyson Venegas

5. Nailyah Serenity

6. Nutsa

7. Kaeyra

8. Lucy Love

9. Matt Wilson

10. Elise Kristine

11. Megan Danielle

12. Mariah Faith

13. Emma Busse

14. Oliver Steele

15. Warren Peay

16. Paige Anne

17. Hannah Nicolaisen

18. Olivia Soli

19. Dawson Wayne

20. Elijah McCormick

21. Zachariah Smith

22. Michael Williams

23. Haven Madison

24. PJAE

25. Malik Heard

26. Colin Stough

[CandiceFan12]

Frontrunners

We

Iam

Olivia

 

Good

Marybeth

Megan

Michael

Tyson

Oliver

Nutsa

 

Okay

Zachariah

Haven

Lucy

Matt

Hannah

Nailyah

Warren

Kaeyra

 

Bottom

Elijah

Malik

PJAE

Elise

Dawson

Emma

Mariah

Paige

 

Congrats on winning despite being the worst contestant

Colin

Edited April 18, 2023 by CandiceFan12

[Hamza Tufail]

Am I the only one here who likes Iam Tongi?

[Hsamid]

52 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Am I the only one here who likes Iam Tongi?

Nope, I think he's been the most consistent male vocalist thus far, and probably one of the few who so effortlessly connects to the songs he sings. He's my favourite overall male contestant.

 

It would have been Tyson Venegas but I'm still waiting for the quality he gave us during the blind, which is probably a top 3 performance for me this season.

Edited April 18, 2023 by Hsamid

[StarWalker1]

Tyson

We

 

Overall: We

[QueenKalie]

59 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Am I the only one here who likes Iam Tongi?

I always find the question of am I the only one to here that likes *insert popular contestant here* to be amusing.

[Hsamid]

I'll do my best to rank them.. the top 11 are really hard and change with every new performance.

 

 

Favourites 

1. Kaeyra

2. Emma 

3. Iam 

4. Wé 

5. Megan

 

Very good

6. Nailyah

7. Elise

8. Warren

9. Oliver

10. Lucy

11. Marybeth

12. Dawson

 

 good, but have had one or a few weak performances

 

11. Olivia

12. Tyson

13. Zachariah

14. Hannah

15. Nutsa

16. Elijah

17. Matt

18. Paige

 

Meh to the rest.

 

[*Wallace]

Now that I've seen them all perform, it's easier to rank them all now. Although I'm still not really 100% sure on this ranking but this is as good as I can get it at this point.  

 

 

1.    Wé Ani
2.    Nutsa
3.    Olivia Soli
4.    Matt Wilson
5.    Lucy Love
6.    Kaeyra
7.    Nailyah Serenity
8.    Elijah McCormick
9.    Tyson Venegas
10.    Emma Busse
11.    Paige Anne
12.    Zachariah Smith
13.    Malik Heard
14.    Iam Tongi
15.    Haven Madison
16.    Marybeth Byrd
17.    Elise Kristine
18.    Mariah Faith
19.    Megan Danielle
20.    Michael Williams
21.    Oliver Steele
22.    PJAE
23.    Dawson Wayne
24.    Warren Peay
25.    Colin Stough
26.    Hannah Nicolaisen
 

[CarmenSandiego]

Here's my ranking of the Top 26, based on how I rated their performances and how far I think they'll go:

 

1.  Wé Ani -- 

2.  Nutsa -- she's more likely to make the Top 12 than Nailyah.

3.  Nailyah -- she saved herself with her performance -- for now.

4.  Olivia -- she made a difficult song work!  Props to her.

5.  Iam -- best of the guys and he'll definitely make the finale.

6.  Marybeth -- she's the best of the country singers by a mile. 

7.  Emma -- I loved her performance but she's definitely in danger.

8. Kaeyra -- she is a very good performer.

9.  Michael -- his best performance but although Katy loves him, I think Top 20's as far as he can go.

10.  Elise -- love this song and she sang it really well!

11.  Matt -- singing his song for (and to) his wife was a very smart idea.

12.  Paige Anne -- I'm glad that she was invited back.  She did quite well.

13.  Megan -- fine voice, needs help with her performance skills and confidence.

14.  Zachariah -- he's definitely a performer but not the best vocally.

15.  Warren -- his version of "Set Fire To the Rain" was definitely different but almost unrecognizable.

16.  Tyson -- spent a little too much time interacting with the audience.

17.  Oliver -- in the middle of the pack for me but he'll get through easily.

18.  Hannah -- she would have been better had she not been recovering from COVID.

19.  Lucy -- this was an off performance for her.  She'll do much better.

20.  Elijah -- he'll probably rise up in the ranks, but for now he goes here.

21.  Colin -- meh, but he's going to get to the Top 5 most likely.

22.  Mariah -- after her performance, she should probably leave, sad to say.

23.  Dawson -- he really should have chosen "No Time To Die" instead.

24.  Haven -- I'm no longer certain that she'll reach the Top 12 or even the Top 20.

25.  PJAE -- he had one great performance during his whole run.

26.  Malik -- he really should have taken Noah's advice to cut down on the runs.

Edited April 20, 2023 by CarmenSandiego

[x3 because of u]

Voted for Iam and Marybeth, with Marybeth as my favorite overall (obvy).

[taylorkat]

1. Wé Ani

2. Nutsa

3. Lucy Love

4. Olivia Soli

5. Nailyah Serenity

6. Emma Busse

7. Warren Peay

8. Elijah McCormick

9. Marybeth Byrd

10. Malik Heard

11. Hannah Nicolaisen

12. Megan Danielle

13. Tyson Venegas

14. Iam Tongi

15. Mariah Faith

16. Paige Anne

17. Matt Wilson

18. Elise Kristine

19. Kaeyra

20. Haven Madison

21. Zachariah Smith

22. Oliver Steele

23. Michael Williams

24. Colin Stough

25. Dawson Wayne

26. PJAE