IDF Rates DWTS29 Routines

[*Wallace]

Season 28 game: James & Emma

 

Welcome to the IDF Rates the Dancing with the Stars Routines game! This is of course one of my favorite DWTS games to host on here where we get to act as the judges and score routines on how we see them. We have been doing this for 5 years now. Although ugh IDF losing all of those past games we worked so hard on.  But we will make new memories here. You all know the rules so I will break them down below.

 

- We will score the routines on a scale of 1 to 10 (with no half points).

- Please score the routines objectively and based on how the dance was performed/dance. Don’t give high scores just for the celeb being your favorite or low scores because of you not liking the celeb. Base it purely on the dance.

- You are allowed to edit and change your scores throughout the week. I just ask that you re-quote your previous vote and let me know which changes you made as I usually update the scores as they are posted.

- I don’t have a specific post count but I’d say have at least 50 posts in order to vote. Although if you were a regular voter in the past then I could make changes.

- Debates and conversations are welcome. Just don’t bash anyone with their scoring.

- Lastly have fun!

 

 

Voting form will be posted later on!

 

Week 1: https://idolforums.com/topic/742256-idf-rates-dwts29-routines/page/2/?tab=comments#comment-28419448

 

[Elliott]

Can’t wait to be the only one who doesn’t give any routines a 10 until the last few weeks like last year  

[*Wallace]

23 minutes ago, Elliott said:

Can’t wait to be the only one who doesn’t give any routines a 10 until the last few weeks like last year  

  

[*Amanda]

Flashback to the epic Jordan vs. Lindsey fanwar in this thread on old IDF.  

[Deeee]

Just now, *Amanda said:

Flashback to the epic Jordan vs. Lindsey fanwar in this thread on old IDF.  

The last good season. 
 

[Elliott]

5 minutes ago, *Amanda said:

Flashback to the epic Jordan vs. Lindsey fanwar in this thread on old IDF.  

Me not participating in the ranking threads that season and thereby not participating in at least one Jordan/Lindsey fanwar.

[*Wallace]

7 minutes ago, *Amanda said:

Flashback to the epic Jordan vs. Lindsey fanwar in this thread on old IDF.  

And both got robbed of perfect 10 routines.   

 

1 minute ago, Elliott said:

Me not participating in the ranking threads that season and thereby not participating in at least one Jordan/Lindsey fanwar.

Lmaoo I'm shocked. So proud of you there!  

[*Wallace]

I'm not sure if I'll be around to watch the show live tonight..... may have some plans. But i'll post the voting form below. If I'm not around you all can vote on this after the show airs. And if someone could arrange it to the fix the performance order that would be lovely too.  Although if i'm here then I'll do it myself.

 

ETA: Nevermind the above post. Plans got changed and I'll be able to post the form later tonight.

[*Wallace]

Time to start scoring the routines! This voting round will be opened until next Tuesday (5 or so minutes before the next show). Please vote fairly!

 

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive):

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango):
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot):

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha):

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa):

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep):

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango):

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha):

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot):
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha):

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha):

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa):

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot):
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa):

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble):

[taylorkat]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 8

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 5
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 5

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 7

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 8

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 7

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 8

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 7

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 6
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 8

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 3

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 7
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 6

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 3

[ILuvCarrie4eva]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 6

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 5
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 6

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 6

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 7

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 6

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 7

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 7

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 6
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 6

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 4

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 6
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 5

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 3

[Ariel1989]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 6

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 4
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 6

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 5

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 5

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 5

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 7

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 7

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 6
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 6

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 1

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 6
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 5

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 1

[*Diana]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 6

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 5
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 4

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 5

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 7

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 6

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 7

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 7

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 6
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 6

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 2

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 6
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 5

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 1

[lhdang2000]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 6

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 4
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 4

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 6

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 7 

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 5

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 7

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 6 

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 7 
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 6

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7 

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 3

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 5
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 4

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 2

[.Rei]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 7

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 4
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 5

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 6

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 7

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 5

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 7

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 6

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 7
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 6

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 8

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 2

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 7
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 5

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 2

[*Lily]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 6

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 5
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 5

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 6

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 7

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 6

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 7

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 7

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 6
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 6

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 4

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 6
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 6

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 3

[Deeee]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 6

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 2
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 6

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 4

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 7

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 5

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 7

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 5

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 6
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 6

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 1

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 7
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 4

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 1

[rdhaley96]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 6

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 6
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 5

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 6

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 6

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 7

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 8

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 7

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 7
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 7

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 3

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 7
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 6

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 2

[*Wallace]

Up to 9 votes so far! Keep on voting if you haven't done so already.  

[*Wallace]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 7

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 5
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 6

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 6

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 7

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 6

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 7

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 7

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 7
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 6

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 3

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 6
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 5

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 3

[taylorkat]

I guess I was the generous one this time. 

[*Wallace]

On 9/19/2020 at 6:07 PM, taylorkat said:

I guess I was the generous one this time. 

As the generous scorer most of the time, nothing wrong with that.  

 

Two more days to get those votes in!

[*Amanda]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 6

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 5
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 5

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 5

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 7

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 6

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 7

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 7

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 6
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 6

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 7 

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 1

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 6 
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 4

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 1

[rpryor03]

AJ McLean & Cheryl Burke - “Blinding Lights” (Jive): 8

Chrishell Stause & Gleb Savchenko - “Raise Your Glass” (Tango): 4
Vernon Davis & Peta Murgatroyd - “All of Me” (Foxtrot): 6

Anne Heche & Keo Motsepe - “Don’t Start Now” (Cha-Cha): 6

Jeannie Mai & Brandon Armstrong - “Tell It to My Heart” (Salsa): 6

Jesse Metcalfe & Sharna Burgess - “Part Time Lover” (Quickstep): 6

Skai Jackson & Alan Bersten - “Super Bass” (Tango): 8

Kaitlyn Bristowe & Artem Chigvintsev - “Stupid Love” (Cha-Cha): 8

Nev Schulman & Jenna Johnson - “The Way You Look Tonight” (Foxtrot): 7
Johnny Weir & Britt Stewart - “Buttons” (Cha-Cha): 7

Justina Machado & Sasha Farber - “Respect” (Cha-Cha): 8

Charles Oakley & Emma Slater - “In Da Club” (Salsa): 2

Monica Aldama & Val Chmerkovskiy - “My Wish” (Foxtrot): 6
Nelly & Daniella Karagach - “Ride Wit Me” (Salsa): 5

Carole Baskin & Pasha Pashkov - “Eye of the Tiger” (Paso Doble): 1

[*Wallace]

Up to 12 votes. Just a couple more hours for any last minute votes!