Jump to content

Your Personal Top 10 (American Idol Season 18)


Recommended Posts

Females:

Aliana Jester
Amber Fiedler
Amelia Joyce

Camryn Leigh Smith
Cyniah Elise

DemiRae "Demi" Moreno
Faith Becnel
Geena Fontanella
Genavieve Linkowski 
Grace Leer
Grace Lundy*
Julia Gargano
Kimmy Gabriela
Lauren Mascitti
Lauren Spencer-Smith
Makayla Brownlee
Makayla Phillips
Natalie Jane*
Olivia Ximines
Perrin York
Samantha "Just Sam" Diaz
Shannon Gibbons
Sophia Wackerman 

 

Males:
Arthur Gunn

Bilaal Avaz
Cameron Havens
Devon Alexander
DeWayne Crocker, Jr. 
Dillon James
Elyjuh René 
Francisco Martin
Franklin Boone
Jeb VonderBruegge
Jonny West
Jordan Jones
Jovin Webb
Louis Knight
Nick Merico 
Rob Taylor 
Travis Finlay 

 

 

Thought I would make the other thread about WHO YOU WANT and NOT WHO WILL THINK!!!....

Edited by kenboy123
Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

WHO I WANT:

 

Francisco Martin

Genavieve Linkowski
Grace Leer
Julia Gargano
Kimmy Gabriella
Lauren Spencer Smith
Louis Knight
Makayla Phillips
Samanta Diaz
Sophia Wackerman

 

EDIT: Changed my mind...can't be honest and go with Jonny West...i only like Francisco and Louis in terms of guys...and Louis isn't even the type of male singer I like at all...which tells you how bad (or uninteresting) i think this group of guys are....

Edited by kenboy123
Link to post
Share on other sites

Very hard choices to make. We need a Top 12 now more than ever. 
 

1. Julia Gargano (still my favorite but she’s gonna have to step it up even more)

2. Lauren Spencer-Smith (she will give us some moments with that big voice of hers)

3. Just Sam (she has grown so much since her audition and nailed every round of HW)

4. Lauren Mascitti (an absolute songbird)

5. Francisco Martin (his nerves might get in the way but he definitely has star potential)

6. Cyniah Elise (we can count on her to bring the diva belting moments)

7. Arthur Gunn (when he’s not trying too hard, he has one of my favorite voices)

8. Louis Knight (so much potential)

9. Sophia Wackerman (when she gets it right, she GETS IT RIGHT)

10. Dillon James (one of the best storytellers this year)

 

If I could make it a Top 12... 

 

11. Grace Leer (a powerful voice but I think Lauren is the more relatable country girl)

12. Jonny West (I like his IG stuff more than what he’s shown us so far)

 

It pains me to have to leave out Franklin, Makayla, Kimmy, and Olivia. Such a talented cast. 

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, Carrie_On said:

Very hard choices to make. We need a Top 12 now more than ever. 
 

1. Julia Gargano (still my favorite but she’s gonna have to step it up even more)

2. Lauren Spencer-Smith (she will give us some moments with that big voice of hers)

3. Just Sam (she has grown so much since her audition and nailed every round of HW)

4. Lauren Mascitti (an absolute songbird)

5. Francisco Martin (his nerves might get in the way but he definitely has star potential)

6. Cyniah Elise (we can count on her to bring the diva belting moments)

7. Arthur Gunn (when he’s not trying too hard, he has one of my favorite voices)

8. Louis Knight (so much potential)

9. Sophia Wackerman (when she gets it right, she GETS IT RIGHT)

10. Dillon James (one of the best storytellers this year)

 

If I could make it a Top 12... 

 

11. Grace Leer (a powerful voice but I think Lauren is the more relatable country girl)

12. Jonny West (I like his IG stuff more than what he’s shown us so far)

 

It pains me to have to leave out Franklin, Makayla, Kimmy, and Olivia. Such a talented cast. 

 

 

 

I actually agree with a Top 12...I wished we had less audition episodes and sometimes the semi final rounds drag on....do we really need 5 WEEKS of auditions???...3 Weeks of auditions are more than enough IMO....i wished we had more live rounds...

Edited by kenboy123
Link to post
Share on other sites

Females:

 

1. Julia 

 

2. Laurn Masicity

3. Lauren Spencer Smith/Grace Leer

4. Just Sam

5. Sophia Wackerman

 

Males:

 

1. Arthur 

 

2. Johnny 

 

3. Nick 

 

4. Louis Knight 

 

5. Jovin/Dillon

Edited by wgm
added another name
Link to post
Share on other sites

Guys:

Francisco Martin

Robert Taylor

Louis Knight

Arthur Gunn

Travis Finlay

 

Girls:

Julia Gargano

Genavieve Linkowski

Just Sam

Sophia Wackerman

Grace Leer

Edited by ShortstopVM
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • istersay changed the title to Your Personal Top 10 (American Idol Season 18)

Nick Merico
Dewayne Crocker Jr.
Louis Knight
Francisco Martin
Jovin Webb
Faith Becnel
Samantha Diaz (Just Sam)
Jonny West

Dillon James
Franklin Boone
Julia Gargano
Aliana Jester
Sophia Wackerman
Kimmy Gabriella
Cyniah Elise
Makayla Phillips
Lauren Spencer-Smith
Olivia Ximines
Arthur Gunn

Lauren Mascitti

Grace Leer

 

 

Now that we know the Top 20/21.. TIME TO CHOOSE!!!

Link to post
Share on other sites

At the moment, my Top 12 would be:

 

Julia Gargano
Kimmy Gabriela
Lauren Spencer-Smith
Makayla Phillips 
Samantha "Sam" Diaz (A.K.A. Just Sam)
Sophia Wackerman

Francisco Martin
Franklin Boone
Jonny West
Jovin Webb
Louis "Louie" Knight
Nick Merico 


I'm having a really hard time picking just 10 because I like so many of them.

Link to post
Share on other sites

My Top 10 right now

(no particular order)

Nick Merico
Louis Knight
Francisco Martin
Julia Gargano
Aliana Jester
Sophia Wackerman
Makayla Phillips
Olivia Ximines
Arthur Gunn

Grace Leer

Link to post
Share on other sites

Personal Top 10 in this order

 

1. Francisco Martin

2. Julia Gargano

3. Jonny West

4. Lauren Spencer

5. Sophia Wackerman

6.  Grace Leer

7. Makayla Phillips

8. Olivia Ximines

9. Franklin Boone

10. Just Sam

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Francisco Martin

Louis Knight

 

(MY TWO SHIPS)...LOL...

 

Lauren Spencer Smith

Makayla Phillips

Grace Leer (GOSH!!!...I really hope she gets through this bull*** twist)...

Julia Gargano

Kimmy Gabriella

Sophia Wackerman 

Dillon James (i didn't rate him when I first heard him, but listening back....his voice is quite interesting)

Samantha Diaz (Just Sam)

 

 

As for some of the others, Olivia Ximenes could possibly take Kimmy's spot, but I haven't heard enough of her....Cyniah Elise has a great voice, but she's a little on the "boring" side, but I still like her, i guess I just prefer Makayla...as for Arthur, social media is REALLY REALLY making me dislike him....

 

Edited by kenboy123
Link to post
Share on other sites

My Top 10 (in no order):

Arthur Gunn

Louis Knight

Francisco Martin

Dillon James

Jonny West

Makayla Phillips 

Lauren Spencer Smith

Lauren Mascitti/Grace Leer

Just Sam

Sophia Wackerman/Julia Gargano (They're both pretty even for me, but prefer Sophia)

Link to post
Share on other sites

Here’s my personal Top 10.  Fair warning, it’s pretty top-heavy concerning gender:

 

1.  Just Sam 

2.  Cyniah

3.  Olivia 

4.  Kimmy 

5.  Sophia 

6.  Francisco 

7.  Aliana 

8.  Arthur 

9.  Grace 

10.  Lauren Spencer-Smith 

 

I told you that my list was top-heavy regarding gender.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...