Jump to content

The Voice S24: Idolforums' ratings


Gustavo527

Recommended Posts

THE VOICE: S24 IDOLFORUMS RATINGS!

 

Grade the each performance from 0 to 10 

(Artist - Song - Rating) 

 

I will calculate the average of everyone's ratings for each performance and compile it.

 

You can rate performances to the hundredths place (7.25, 9.75, 6.66, 0.01, 9.99) or just as whole numbers.

 

Anyone can put in their rankings (They need to rank every performance of a night, though). The deadline will be once the next round starts airing. So all the blinds are due to the time when the battle rounds premieres.

 

The NUMBER ONE RULE is that NOBODY IS ALLOWED to create multiple accounts with the intention to throw the ratings off. Istersay will find out who you are and your main account and alts will be banned or suspended. We will be able to tell if there is suspicious activity.

 

Be confident about your ratings when you post them. Re-listen over and over if needed, because I would prefer you not to change your ratings after you post them (it makes it harder).

 

You are free to rate however you want, and people have their ways of rating performances, but just don't be too absurd with low ratings (giving performances 0.01s for no good reason). Also, don't give a bunch of low ratings on a single round only to boost the placement of a certain performances . If you do that, i'm gonna be obligated to reject your ratings, sorry. 

 

I can't control how y'all rate the performances. However, please, try that your ratings go genuinely according to your honest opinion on a particular performance. I want the ratings to be as representative as possible of IDF's genuine opinion. 

 

To any contestants: This is completely for fun. I wouldn't read too much into a rating. You got chairs to turn for a reason! Maybe I would advise you to exit this page now.

 

Discussion is allowed and encouraged, as long as everyone is respectful. If you can't handle an opinion, go take a walk or something and then come back. The ignore button is also an option if you can't stand another user.

 

That being said, rate away, users of Idolforums!

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy -

Joslynn Rose - Arcade -

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work -

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me -

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away -

Alexa Wildish - Songbird -

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down -

Kristen Brown - Blown Away -

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart -

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You -

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me -

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag -

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful -

Edited by Gustavo527
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 8

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 8

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 7.75

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 7.75

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - 7.75

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 8.5

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 7.5

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 7.5

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 9

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 9

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 6.5

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 8

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 7.5

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 8.25

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 9.6

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 9.3

Deejay Young - This Woman's Work - 9

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 8.4

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn't So Far Away - 9.5

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 10

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 8

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 7.6

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 10

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 10

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 7.8

Julia Roome - Dream A Little Dream of Me - 9.8

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 8.6

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 9

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 8.75

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 7.75

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 8

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 7

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - 8.25

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 8.5

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 6

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 6.5

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 8

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 9.25

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 7

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 7.5

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 6

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 8

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 9.5 (way better than the previous versions that I have ever heard on TV)

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 9.3 (her voice is mesmerizing)

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 9.1 (good, but I would have rated this better if he hadn't oversung)

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 8 (she deserves chair turns though)

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - 9 (I didn't expect him to be a country singer... but at least he's different from most of them ig)

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 10 (perfection :wub: but still prefer Madi Davis btw)

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 8 (umm I mean she has potential)

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 8.2 (she aint Carrie Underwood... at least she tried, this song is way too fast for her)

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 9 (i don't think this song showed her true strength... i expected her to go more)

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 10 (her yodelling is so clean, and her belts are insanely strong)

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 8.2 (same as Kristen)

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 8.9 (love her)

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 8.6 (somehow i enjoyed it? liked her version)

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 8.4

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 7.5

Joslynn Rose - Arcade -8.75

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work -8

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me -7.5

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away -7

Alexa Wildish - Songbird -8.5

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down -6.5

Kristen Brown - Blown Away -6

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 9

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart -8

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You -6.75

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me -9

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag -6.25

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful -6.95

Edited by erik g
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mara- 9 my queen!!!! ( I don’t know what it is but she sounds so different from being on idol. It’s like her voice developed a husky thickness that I’m in loveee with)

 

Ruby- 10 not my thing but the girl can definitely sing it was more technically perfect than Maras but Mara is still my #1.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 8.75

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 8.5

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 7.75

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 7.5

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn't So Far Away - 6.5

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 9

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 6.25

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 5.75

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 8.25

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 8.75

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 7.25

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 9.25

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 7.25

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 6

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 7.75 (Love her tone, wish she sang something else.)

 

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - (High notes could use some work, otherwise gorgeous)

 

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 8.5 (OKAY this one grew on me. This was everything I wanted Kevin Hawkins’ version to be, vocally. His control is just insane, and he didn’t really sound unpleasant to me like some people said? I’m with @Hsamid on this one.)

 

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 7.5 (She has power for days, I’ll give her that.)

 

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - (Shrunk on me, it’s sweet but his tone isn’t interesting enough to carry such a simple vocal.)

 

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - (Heard some pitch issues, but the beautiful bits were outstanding.)

 

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 5.5 (This got three chairs to turn.)

 

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - (Not as bad as I remembered it being, but she just doesn’t have the power for the song.

 

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 8.5 (Personal favorite of the episode! She has lots of colors to her voice, which I’m glad she chose to focus on instead of just belting it out. I wish she got more than just 90 seconds.)

 

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - (I went back and listened to the last girl who has covered this song and it’s not even close. Ruby’s control is unreal. Would be higher if not for the gimmicky song choice.)

 

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 7.5 (I liked this the same way I liked Sorelle last season. Feels like a meme performance, almost 😅. I love the… fervor?)

 

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - (She was decent but this song is a snoozefest at this point.)

 

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 5.5 (Started out great but those choruses were just so flimsy that it got knocked down at least 2 points.)

 

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 7.75 (Great tone. I actually thought the song choice was a nice fit.)

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 7.5

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 8.5

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 8

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 8

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - 7

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 9

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 6

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 6.5

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 8.5

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 10

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 7

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 8.5

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 7.5

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 8

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 7.5

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 7.75

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 6

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 5

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - 6.75

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 10

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 5

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 5.75

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 9.25

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 9.25

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 5.5

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 6.25

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 5.5

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 6.75

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 8.5

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 8.25

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 9.75

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 8

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - 8

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 9.75

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 8.25

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 8.25

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 9.5

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 10

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 7.25

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 8.5

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 8.25

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 9

Edited by Mistake006
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 8.25

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 8.75

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 8

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 8.75

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - 7.75

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 8.75

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 7

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 7

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 9.5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 7

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 6.5

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 6

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 6

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - 7.5 

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 7.5

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 6.5

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 7

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 8.5

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 7

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 7

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 9

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 6

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 7

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was wondering  where this was.

 

 

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

 

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 7.

Lots of spunk to her voice. An all around fun, vocally competent audition.

 

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 7

Pretty and emotive voice. She can sing very softly billie Eilish style but can make her sound a bit more full when she wants to. The first belt sounded unintentionally raw but her second belt during the chorus was honestly really good. 

 

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 8

Gorgeous falsetto, incredible agility and belting range. Dude can sang. I don't think it's the right song to oversing with though, otherwise the score would be higher.

 

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 7 her belts are really good and she has some grit to her voice

 

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away -6.5

Pleasing tone, sung with sincerity, good audition.

 

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 7.5

Gorgeous pure sounding voice, and a surprisingly full lower register. but I thought I heard the slightest hint of a few pitch issues.

 

 

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 6.0

great lower register, but nerves were pretty noticeable throughout the performance. Her transitions switching registers didn't sound all that smooth either. 

 

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 6.5

hm, theres nothing really wrong with the audition, but everything felt just a notch below how it's sung.

 

 

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 8.

love the mid register with that slight hint of huskiness, and the belt at the end had a lot of power. I love the tone of her lower register too but it sounds a bit breathy at points, like it's a bit uncomfortable for her. Idk, I'd have to hear more. Personally, my favourite voice so far.

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

 

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 9

Objectively speaking, probably the most impressive audition so far. Belting power, breath control, agility are all top notch.

 

 

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 6.5

not my favourite arrangement or tone.. but she sung some high belts singing an upbeat song without much struggle.

 

 

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 7

Pretty voice, hints of some nice range and agility, she does sound her age though.

 

 

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 6.5

nice lower register, loves that raspy belt near the end, but the chorus sounded all over the place, not necessarily pitch wise, but idk, something about it.

 

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 7.5

Awesome voice. Strong belts, whether clean or raspy. The run at the end wasn't so smooth but that's minor. I still think his voice was a tad aggressive for this song, not a great fit totally imo.

 

Edit: changing Ruby from 8.5 to 9.

Edited by Hsamid
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 1

Jordan Rainer - Fancy - 8.5

Joslynn Rose - Arcade - 8.0

Deejay Young - This Woman´s Work - 9.0

Sophia Hoffman - Tell Me You Love Me - 7.5

Jackson Snelling - If Heaven Wasn´t So Far Away - 8.0

Alexa Wildish - Songbird - 9.0

Olivia Minogue - Lay Me Down - 8.5

Kristen Brown - Blown Away - 7.0

Mara Justine - Goodbye Yellow Brick Road - 9.5

 

Blind Auditions: Episode 2

Ruby Leigh - I Wanna Be A Cowboy's Sweetheart - 9.0

Juliette Ojeda - Hopelessly Devoted to You - 8.0

Julia Roome - Dream a Little Dream of Me - 8.0

Jenna Marquis - Teenage Dirtbag - 9.5

Ephraim Owens - Beneath your Beautiful - 9.5

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 3

 

Stee - Sugar -

Chechi Sarai - Lovin" You -

Reid Zingale - July -

Claudia B. - Human Nature -

Mac Royals - Gravity -

Noah Spencer - Something in the Orange -

Talakai - Stay with Me -

RUDI - You Don´t Own Me -

Edited by Gustavo527
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 3

 

Stee - Sugar - 4.5 (after rewatch I decided I just didn’t like this lol? chorus was weak and verses not particularly good either)

Chechi Sarai - Lovin" You - 10

Reid Zingale - July - 7.5

Claudia B. - Human Nature - 3.5

Mac Royals - Gravity - 8

Noah Spencer - Something in the Orange - 8.5

Talakai - Stay with Me - 6.5

RUDI - You Don´t Own Me - 6.75

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 3

 

Stee - Sugar - 9

Chechi Sarai - Lovin" You - 10

Reid Zingale - July - 8

Claudia B. - Human Nature - 7

Mac Royals - Gravity - 10

Noah Spencer - Something in the Orange - 9.7

Talakai - Stay with Me - 8.8

RUDI - You Don't Own Me - 9.9

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stee - Sugar -6

Falsetto was weak and that's brings it down a lot considering it's the main thing your supposed to show off on the song.

 

Chechi Sarai - Lovin" You - 9

She has the best whistle register I've seen on the show on a technical level as well as the tonal quality. The agility up there is insane. Her tone throughout all registers is sweet as well. Lastly, she changed quite a bit from the original yet remained faithful to it. Props.

 

 

Reid Zingale - July - 8.5

Might be the most unique voice so far. His voice is simultaneously pure yet raw sounding, soft yet powerful. You get a lot of singers that can do both, but not sound like both, Reid has the latter. Not to mention, very emotive as well.

 

Claudia B. - Human Nature - 5.0

A lot of this was shaky, and you need to distinguish yourself somehow if your gonna tackle MJ. This didn't do that 

 

Mac Royals - Gravity - 8

awesome vocalist. Lower, mid and falsetto register all great, and his agility throughout all 3 is impressive and effortless. Soulful, pleasing tone. Pretty understated performance as far as rnb/soul singers go.

 

Noah Spencer - Something in the Orange - 8.5

Another contender for most unique voice. Love the gravelly voice, and it's pretty distinguishable from other gravelly voices of the past.

 

Talakai - Stay with Me - 7

Vocally competent. Nice range and runs. This is a song that should be sung with feeling though and I didn't get that. I also don't think anything in particular stands out about the performance despite the very good vocals.

 

RUDI - You Don´t Own Me - 7

Incredible agility, pleasing, full sounding tone. I like the split second vocal decisions she did, like going into a growl or headvoice very quickly then back into her mid register. My main criticism is that she sort of stayed in almost the same octave throughout. Even the original took it up a notch every chorus. I can't help but wonder if it was a stylistic choice or if she's doing all those riffs to compensate.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Blind Auditions: Episode 3

 

 

 

Stee - Sugar - 6.5 (umm this was a 4-chair turn?)

 

Chechi Sarai - Lovin" You - 10 (no words)

 

Reid Zingale - July - 9.25 (I was really hoping to listen to this song on the show and this is exactly what I want)

 

Claudia B. - Human Nature - 4.5 (you don't have the ball to tackle MJ.)

 

Mac Royals - Gravity - 9 (great vocalist)

 

Noah Spencer - Something in the Orange - 9.25 (I like his tone along with Reid)

 

Talakai - Stay with Me - 8.5 (pretty solid audition but it's still pale in comparison to other versions. Watch Josh and Maiya)

 

RUDI - You Don´t Own Me - 9.75 (she ain't Kyla Jade but this is such a cool version of this song)

Edited by allistr
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...