American Idol Season 21: IDF's Ratings

[m1key]

Welcome to American Idol Season 21: IDF's Ratings!

 

I am back again to calculate the ratings this season! Now that we are in the voting rounds, where all contestants will get their full performances shown, we can begin!

 

You will grade each performance on a scale of 0 to 10. You can also use decimal places, but please only go to the hundredths place (ex: 9.99) Each rating will be formatted as follows:

 

Artist - Song - Rating

 

I should be able to post a template after each episode where you can simply plug your ratings in, but in the case I am not able to, you know how to format it!

 

Everyone is welcome to submit ratings, though you must rate every performance of the episode in order for your submission to count. It is also totally okay if you submit rankings for some episodes, but not others. Of course, I encourage everyone to participate in rating every episode. 

 

You are free to rate however you want, and people have their ways of rating performances, but just don't be too absurd with low ratings (giving performances 0.01s for no good reason). Also, don't give a bunch of low ratings on a single round only to boost the placement of a certain performances . If you do that, I'm going to be obligated to reject your ratings. Additionally, you are not allowed to make multiple IDF accounts in an attempt to throw off the rankings. Istersay will eventually find out and you will be completely banned from IDF. 

 

Feel free to edit your ratings as much as you like after submitting them. However, the deadline each week will be every Saturday @11:59 PM EST. Once that deadline hits, I will begin calculating results, so additional submissions and further edits will not be considered. 

 

Discussion is allowed and encouraged, as long as everyone is respectful. If you can't handle an opinion, go take a walk or something and then come back. The ignore button is also an option if you can't stand another user. At the end of the day, this is just a fun activity that should not be taken seriously!

 

Let the ratings begin! 

 

(Shoutout to @Gustavo527; I stole some wording from his post in The Voice thread!)

 

Season 20 Ratings Thread: https://idolforums.com/topic/745379-american-idol-season-20-idfs-ratings/#comments

 

Edited April 23, 2023 by m1key

[m1key]

TOP 26 RATINGS

 

Group 1 (Average: 6.87)

1. Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 8.66

2. Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 8.40

3. Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 7.49

4. Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 7.40

5. Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 7.40

6. Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 7.33

7. Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 7.25

8. Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 7.07

9. Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 7.04

10. Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 6.55

11. Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 6.08

12. Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 4.51

13. Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 4.08

 

Group 2 (Average: 7.28)

1. Wé Ani - Edge of Midnight by Miley Cyrus and Stevie Nicks - 8.60

2. Nutsa - Paris (Ooh La La) by Grace Potter & The Nocturnals - 8.33

3. Olivia Soli - Emotions by Mariah Carey - 8.19

4. Michael Williams - Tuesdays by Jake Scott - 7.83

5. Tyson Venegas - It Will Rain by Bruno Mars - 7.75

6. Megan Danielle - The Chain by Fleetwood Mac - 7.71

7. Marybeth Byrd - Heart Like a Truck by Lainey Wilson - 7.52

8. Paige Anne - Wrecking Ball by Miley Cyrus - 7.32

9. Dawson Wayne - Copycat by Billie Eillish - 6.93

10. Hannah Nicolaisen - Glitter in the Air by P!nk - 6.91

11. Colin Stough - Midnight Train to Memphis by Chris Stapleton - 6.01

12. Malik Heard - Ain't It Fun by Paramore - 5.94 

13. Elijah McCormick - Good Vibes by Chris Janson - 5.64

 

Overall (Average: 7.07)

1. Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 8.66

2. Wé Ani - Edge of Midnight by Miley Cyrus and Stevie Nicks - 8.60

3. Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 8.40

4. Nutsa - Paris (Ooh La La) by Grace Potter & The Nocturnals - 8.33

5. Olivia Soli - Emotions by Mariah Carey - 8.19

6. Michael Williams - Tuesdays by Jake Scott - 7.83

7. Tyson Venegas - It Will Rain by Bruno Mars - 7.75

8. Megan Danielle - The Chain by Fleetwood Mac - 7.71

9. Marybeth Byrd - Heart Like a Truck by Lainey Wilson - 7.52

10. Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 7.49

11. Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 7.40

12. Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 7.40

13. Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 7.33

14. Paige Anne - Wrecking Ball by Miley Cyrus - 7.32

15. Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 7.25

16. Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 7.07

17. Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 7.04

18. Dawson Wayne - Copycat by Billie Eillish - 6.93

19. Hannah Nicolaisen - Glitter in the Air by P!nk - 6.91

20. Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 6.55

21. Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 6.08

22. Colin Stough - Midnight Train to Memphis by Chris Stapleton - 6.01

23. Malik Heard - Ain't It Fun by Paramore - 5.94 

24. Elijah McCormick - Good Vibes by Chris Janson - 5.64

25. Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 4.51

26. Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 4.08

 

TOP 20 REVEAL RATINGS

1. Kaeyra - Bruises by Lewis Capaldi - 8.93

2. Wé Ani - Skyfall by Adele - 8.87

3. Lucy Love - Boulders by Herself - 8.38

4. Olivia Soli - I Surrender by Celine Dion - 8.33

5. Nutsa - Un-Break My Heart by Toni Braxton - 8.18

6. Iam Tongi - The Winner Takes It All by ABBA - 7.52

7. Marybeth Byrd - People Pleaser by Herself - 7.50

8. Nailyah - Baby Love by Mother’s Finest - 7.50

9. Megan Danielle - Holy Water by We The Kingdom - 7.35

10. Hannah Nicolaisen - Somebody to Love by Queen - 7.32

11. Tyson Venegas - 180 by Himself - 7.05

12. Zachariah Smith - I Want To Know What Love Is by Foreigner - 7.01 

13. Warren Peay - Up There Down Here by Zach Williams - 6.76

14. Paige Anne - Say Something by A Great Big World - 6.73

15. Michael Williams - Lose You To Love Me by Selena Gomez - 6.60

16. Oliver Steele - Too Soon by Himself - 6.57

17. Haven Madison - Mean Girls by Leanna Crawford - 6.35

18. Matt Wilson - Say You Won’t Let Go by James Arthur - 5.97

19. Mariah Faith - Cry to Me by Solomon Burke - 5.95

20. Colin Stough - Pretty Heart by Parker McCollum - 4.55

 

TOP 12 REVEAL RATINGS

1. Kaeyra - If I Were Your Woman by Gladys Knight & The Pips - 9.11

2. Nutsa - And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going from Dreamgirls - 8.39

3. Lucy Love - Radioactive by Imagine Dragons - 8.29

4. Wé Ani - This Is Me from The Greatest Showman - 8.23

5. Tyson Venegas - Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me by Elton John - 8.16

6. Colin Stough - Dancing On My Own by Robyn - 8.13

7. Megan Danielle - Thank God I Do by Lauren Daigle - 8.07

8. Marybeth Byrd - Cover Me Up by Jason Isbell - 8.03

9. Olivia Soli - God is a Woman by Ariana Grande - 7.63

10. Matt Wilson - For Tonight by Giveon - 7.30

11. Iam Tongi - Stuck on You by Lionel Richie - 7.28

12. Nailyah - Alive by Sia - 7.23 

13. Zachariah Smith - Hold the Line by Toto - 7.09

14. Oliver Steele - You’re Still the One by Shania Twain - 7.04

15. Paige Anne - I Am Here by P!nk - 6.76

16. Hannah Nicolaisen - Royals by Lorde - 6.64

17. Mariah Faith - If It Hadn’t Been For Love by The SteelDrivers - 6.59

18. Warren Peay - It’s Not My Time by 3 Doors Down - 6.57

19. Michael Williams - Golden Hour by Jvke - 6.34

20. Haven Madison - 15 by Herself - 6.23

 

TOP 12 PERFORMANCES/TOP 10 REVEAL RATINGS

1. Nutsa - The Show Must Go On by Queen - 9.44

2. Wé Ani - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 9.23

3. Megan Danielle - Angel From Montgomery by Bonnie Raitt - 8.96

4. Iam Tongi - Bring It On Home To Me by Sam Cooke - 8.02

5. Zachariah Smith - Don’t Bring Me Down by Electric Light Orchestra - 7.64

6. Tyson Venegas - For Once in My Life by Stevie Wonder - 7.58

7. Lucy Love - All Night Long by Lionel Richie - 7.44

8. Oliver Steele - Georgia on My Mind by Ray Charles - 6.83

9. Warren Peay - House of the Rising Sun by The Animals - 6.78

10. Marybeth Byrd - Dancing Queen by ABBA - 6.52

11. Colin Stough - Midnight Rider by The Allman Brothers - 5.77

12. Haven Madison - Livin’ On a Prayer by Bon Jovi - 4.92

 

TOP 10 PERFORMANCES/TOP 8 REVEAL RATINGS

1. Wé Ani - I Have Nothing by Whitney Houston - 8.77

2. Megan Danielle - Go Rest High On That Mountain by Vince Gill - 8.58

3. Oliver Steele - High and Dry by Radiohead - 8.15

4. Tyson Venegas - Someone You Loved by Lewis Capaldi - 8.10

5. Iam Tongi - What A Wonderful World by Louis Armstrong - 7.71

6. Zachariah Smith - Wanted Dead or Alive by Bon Jovi - 7.37

7. Marybeth Byrd - Wasted On You by Morgan Wallen - 7.23

8. Haven Madison - The Only Exception by Paramore - 7.01

9. Warren Peay - Colder Weather by Zac Brown Band - 6.80

10. Colin Stough - It’s Been a While by Staind - 6.48

 

TOP 8 PERFORMANCES/TOP 5 REVEAL RATINGS

1. Wé Ani - Uninvited by Alanis Morissette - 8.33

2. Megan Danielle - Head Over Feet by Alanis Morissette - 8.12

3. Colin Stough and Megan Danielle - Dive by Ed Sheeran - 8.04

4. Warren Peay and Wé Ani - Perfect by Ed Sheeran - 8.04

5. Iam Tongi and Oliver Steele - Photograph by Ed Sheeran - 7.88

6. Iam Tongi - Guardian by Alanis Morissette - 7.52

7. Zachariah Smith - Ironic by Alanis Morissette - 7.23

8. Haven Madison and Zachariah Smith - Thinking Out Loud by Ed Sheeran - 7.17

9. Oliver Steele - You Oughta Know by Alanis Morissette - 6.94

10. Haven Madison - You Learn by Alanis Morissette - 6.77

11. Warren Peay - All I Really Want by Alanis Morissette - 6.58

12. Colin Stough - Hand In My Pocket by Alanis Morissette - 5.35

 

TOP 5 PERFORM/TOP 3 REVEAL RATINGS

1. Megan Danielle - You Can’t Stop The Girl from Maleficent: Mistress of Evil - 8.69

2. Wé Ani - Into the Unknown from Frozen II - 8.57

3. Megan Danielle - Carried Me With You from Onward - 8.40

4. Wé Ani - The Climb from Hannah Montana: The Movie - 8.36

5. Iam Tongi - Father and Son from Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 - 7.86

6. Iam Tongi - Lava from Lava - 7.61

7. Zachariah Smith - I Just Can’t Wait To Be King from The Lion King - 7.52

8. Colin Stough - Nobody Knows from Pete’s Dragon - 6.45

9. Zachariah Smith - Life Is A Highway from Cars - 6.25

10. Colin Stough - Real Gone from Cars - 5.80

 

TOP 3 PERFORMANCES/RESULTS RATINGS

1. Megan Danielle - Faithfully by Journey - 8.70

2. Megan Danielle - God Whispered Your Name by Keith Urban - 8.41

3. Megan Danielle - Dream Girl by Herself - 7.96

4. Iam Tongi - I'll Be Seeing You by Himself - 7.89

5. Iam Tongi - Cool Down by Kolohe Kai - 7.70

6. Iam Tongi - Making Memories of Us by Keith Urban - 7.39

7. Colin Stough - Either Way by Chris Stapleton - 6.12

8. Colin Stough - Stupid Boy by Keith Urban - 4.75

Edited May 29, 2023 by m1key

[m1key]

END OF SEASON STATS

 

TOP 26 AVERAGES

1. Nutsa - 8.59 (4 performances)

2. Wé Ani - 8.56 (9 performances)

3. Kaeyra - 8.51 (3 performances)

4. Emma Busse - 8.40 (1 performance)

5. Megan Danielle - 8.25 (12 performances)

6. Olivia Soli - 8.05 (3 performances)

7. Nailyah Serenity - 7.80 (3 performances)

8. Lucy Love - 7.79 (4 performances)

9. Tyson Venegas - 7.73 (5 performances)

10. Iam Tongi - 7.64 (12 performances)

11. Marybeth Byrd - 7.36 (5 performances)

12. Elise Kristine - 7.33 (1 performance)

13. Zachariah Smith - 7.15 (9 performances)

14. Oliver Steele - 7.14 (7 performances)

15. Warren Peay - 6.99 (7 performances)

16. Hannah Nicolaisen - 6.96 (3 performances)

17. Paige Anne - 6.94 (3 performances)

18. Dawson Wayne - 6.93 (1 performance)

19. Michael Williams - 6.92 (3 performances)

20. Matt Wilson - 6.89 (3 performances)

21. Mariah Faith - 6.21 (3 performances)

22. Colin Stough - 6.13 (11 performances)

23. Haven Madison - 6.08 (7 performances)

24. Malik Heard - 5.94 (1 performance)

25. Elijah McCormick - 5.64 (1 performance)

26. Pjae - 4.51 (1 performance)

 

FINALIST AVERAGES

1. Nutsa - 8.59 (4 performances)

2. Wé Ani - 8.56 (9 performances)

3. Megan Danielle - 8.25 (12 performances)

4. Lucy Love - 7.79 (4 performances)

5. Tyson Venegas - 7.73 (5 performances)

6. Iam Tongi - 7.64 (12 performances)

7. Marybeth Byrd - 7.36 (5 performances)

8. Zachariah Smith - 7.15 (9 performances)

9. Oliver Steele - 7.14 (7 performances)

10. Warren Peay - 6.99 (7 performances)

11. Colin Stough - 6.13 (11 performances)

12. Haven Madison - 6.08 (7 performances)

 

SEMIFINALIST AVERAGES

1. Kaeyra - 8.51 (3 performances)

2. Emma Busse - 8.40 (1 performance)

3. Olivia Soli - 8.05 (3 performances)

4. Nailyah Serenity - 7.80 (3 performances)

5. Elise Kristine - 7.33 (1 performance)

6. Hannah Nicolaisen - 6.96 (3 performances)

7. Paige Anne - 6.94 (3 performances)

8. Dawson Wayne - 6.93 (1 performance)

9. Michael Williams - 6.92 (3 performances)

10. Matt Wilson - 6.89 (3 performances)

11. Mariah Faith - 6.21 (3 performances)

12. Malik Heard - 5.94 (1 performance)

13. Elijah McCormick - 5.64 (1 performance)

14. Pjae - 4.51 (1 performance)

 

EPISODE AVERAGES

1. Judge's Song Contest (Top 10 Perform/Top 8 Reveal) - 7.62

2. Disney Night (Top 5 Perform/Top 3 Reveal) - 7.55

3. Top 12 Reveal - 7.46

4. Rock & Roll Hall of Fame Night (Top 12 Perform/Top 10 Reveal) - 7.43

5. Finale (Top 3 Perform/Results) - 7.36

6. Alanis Morissette/Ed Sheeran Night (Top 8 Perform/Top 5 Reveal) - 7.33

7. Top 26 Group 2 - 7.28

8. Top 20 Reveal - 7.17

9. Top 26 Group 1 - 6.87

 

OVERALL PERFORMANCE RATINGS

1. Nutsa - The Show Must Go On by Queen - 9.44

2. Wé Ani - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 9.23

3. Kaeyra - If I Were Your Woman by Gladys Knight & The Pips - 9.11

4. Megan Danielle - Angel From Montgomery by Bonnie Raitt - 8.96

5. Kaeyra - Bruises by Lewis Capaldi - 8.93

6. Wé Ani - Skyfall by Adele - 8.87

7. Wé Ani - I Have Nothing by Whitney Houston - 8.77

8. Megan Danielle - Faithfully by Journey - 8.70

9. Megan Danielle - You Can’t Stop The Girl from Maleficent: Mistress of Evil - 8.69

10. Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 8.66

11. Wé Ani - Edge of Midnight by Miley Cyrus and Stevie Nicks - 8.60

12. Megan Danielle - Go Rest High On That Mountain by Vince Gill - 8.58

13. Wé Ani - Into the Unknown from Frozen II - 8.57

14. Megan Danielle - God Whispered Your Name by Keith Urban - 8.41

15. Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 8.40

15. Megan Danielle - Carried Me With You from Onward - 8.40

17. Nutsa - And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going from Dreamgirls - 8.39

18. Lucy Love - Boulders by Herself - 8.38

19. Wé Ani - The Climb from Hannah Montana: The Movie - 8.36

20. Nutsa - Paris (Ooh La La) by Grace Potter & The Nocturnals - 8.33

20. Olivia Soli - I Surrender by Celine Dion - 8.33

20. Wé Ani - Uninvited by Alanis Morissette - 8.33

23. Lucy Love - Radioactive by Imagine Dragons - 8.29

24. Wé Ani - This Is Me from The Greatest Showman - 8.23

25. Olivia Soli - Emotions by Mariah Carey - 8.19

26. Nutsa - Un-Break My Heart by Toni Braxton - 8.18

27. Tyson Venegas - Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me by Elton John - 8.16

28. Oliver Steele - High and Dry by Radiohead - 8.15

29. Colin Stough - Dancing On My Own by Robyn - 8.13

30. Megan Danielle - Head Over Feet by Alanis Morissette - 8.12

31. Tyson Venegas - Someone You Loved by Lewis Capaldi - 8.10

32. Megan Danielle - Thank God I Do by Lauren Daigle - 8.07

33. Colin Stough and Megan Danielle - Dive by Ed Sheeran - 8.04

33. Warren Peay and Wé Ani - Perfect by Ed Sheeran - 8.04

35. Marybeth Byrd - Cover Me Up by Jason Isbell - 8.03

36. Iam Tongi - Bring It On Home To Me by Sam Cooke - 8.02

37. Megan Danielle - Dream Girl by Herself - 7.96

38. Iam Tongi - I'll Be Seeing You by Himself - 7.89

39. Iam Tongi and Oliver Steele - Photograph by Ed Sheeran - 7.88

40. Iam Tongi - Father and Son from Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 - 7.86

41. Michael Williams - Tuesdays by Jake Scott - 7.83

42. Tyson Venegas - It Will Rain by Bruno Mars - 7.75

43. Iam Tongi - What A Wonderful World by Louis Armstrong - 7.71

43. Megan Danielle - The Chain by Fleetwood Mac - 7.71

45. Iam Tongi - Cool Down by Kolohe Kai - 7.70

46. Zachariah Smith - Don’t Bring Me Down by Electric Light Orchestra - 7.64

47. Olivia Soli - God is a Woman by Ariana Grande - 7.63

48. Iam Tongi - Lava from Lava - 7.61

49. Tyson Venegas - For Once in My Life by Stevie Wonder - 7.58

50. Iam Tongi - Guardian by Alanis Morissette - 7.52

50. Iam Tongi - The Winner Takes It All by ABBA - 7.52

50. Marybeth Byrd - Heart Like a Truck by Lainey Wilson - 7.52

50. Zachariah Smith - I Just Can’t Wait To Be King from The Lion King - 7.52

54. Marybeth Byrd - People Pleaser by Herself - 7.50

54. Nailyah - Baby Love by Mother’s Finest - 7.50

56. Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 7.49

57. Lucy Love - All Night Long by Lionel Richie - 7.44

58. Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 7.40

58. Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 7.40

60. Iam Tongi - Making Memories of Us by Keith Urban - 7.39

61. Zachariah Smith - Wanted Dead or Alive by Bon Jovi - 7.37

62. Megan Danielle - Holy Water by We The Kingdom - 7.35

63. Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 7.33

64. Hannah Nicolaisen - Somebody to Love by Queen - 7.32

64. Paige Anne - Wrecking Ball by Miley Cyrus - 7.32

66. Matt Wilson - For Tonight by Giveon - 7.30

67. Iam Tongi - Stuck on You by Lionel Richie - 7.28

68. Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 7.25

69. Marybeth Byrd - Wasted On You by Morgan Wallen - 7.23

69. Nailyah - Alive by Sia - 7.23 

71. Zachariah Smith - Ironic by Alanis Morissette - 7.23

72. Haven Madison and Zachariah Smith - Thinking Out Loud by Ed Sheeran - 7.17

73. Zachariah Smith - Hold the Line by Toto - 7.09

74. Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 7.07

75. Tyson Venegas - 180 by Himself - 7.05

76. Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 7.04

77. Oliver Steele - You’re Still the One by Shania Twain - 7.04

78. Haven Madison - The Only Exception by Paramore - 7.01

78. Zachariah Smith - I Want To Know What Love Is by Foreigner - 7.01 

80. Oliver Steele - You Oughta Know by Alanis Morissette - 6.94

81. Dawson Wayne - Copycat by Billie Eillish - 6.93

82. Hannah Nicolaisen - Glitter in the Air by P!nk - 6.91

83. Oliver Steele - Georgia on My Mind by Ray Charles - 6.83

84. Warren Peay - Colder Weather by Zac Brown Band - 6.80

85. Warren Peay - House of the Rising Sun by The Animals - 6.78

86. Haven Madison - You Learn by Alanis Morissette - 6.77

87. Paige Anne - I Am Here by P!nk - 6.76

88. Warren Peay - Up There Down Here by Zach Williams - 6.76

89. Paige Anne - Say Something by A Great Big World - 6.73

90. Hannah Nicolaisen - Royals by Lorde - 6.64

91. Michael Williams - Lose You To Love Me by Selena Gomez - 6.60

92. Mariah Faith - If It Hadn’t Been For Love by The SteelDrivers - 6.59

93. Warren Peay - All I Really Want by Alanis Morissette - 6.58

94. Oliver Steele - Too Soon by Himself - 6.57

95. Warren Peay - It’s Not My Time by 3 Doors Down - 6.57

96. Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 6.55

97. Marybeth Byrd - Dancing Queen by ABBA - 6.52

98. Colin Stough - It’s Been a While by Staind - 6.48

99. Colin Stough - Nobody Knows from Pete’s Dragon - 6.45

100. Haven Madison - Mean Girls by Leanna Crawford - 6.35

101. Michael Williams - Golden Hour by Jvke - 6.34

102. Zachariah Smith - Life Is A Highway from Cars - 6.25

103. Haven Madison - 15 by Herself - 6.23

104. Colin Stough - Either Way by Chris Stapleton - 6.12

105. Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 6.08

106. Colin Stough - Midnight Train to Memphis by Chris Stapleton - 6.01

107. Matt Wilson - Say You Won’t Let Go by James Arthur - 5.97

108. Mariah Faith - Cry to Me by Solomon Burke - 5.95

109. Malik Heard - Ain't It Fun by Paramore - 5.94 

110. Colin Stough - Real Gone from Cars - 5.80

111. Colin Stough - Midnight Rider by The Allman Brothers - 5.77

112. Elijah McCormick - Good Vibes by Chris Janson - 5.64

113. Colin Stough - Hand In My Pocket by Alanis Morissette - 5.35

114. Haven Madison - Livin’ On a Prayer by Bon Jovi - 4.92

115. Colin Stough - Stupid Boy by Keith Urban - 4.75

116. Colin Stough - Pretty Heart by Parker McCollum - 4.55

117. Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 4.51

118. Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 4.08

Edited May 29, 2023 by m1key

[m1key]

Ratings will open immediately after Sunday's episode! Wanted to make the thread now cause I had a feeling I would forget before Sunday; I have a busy next few days  

[CarmenSandiego]

52 minutes ago, m1key said:

Ratings will open immediately after Sunday's episode! Wanted to make the thread now cause I had a feeling I would forget before Sunday; I have a busy next few days  

Oh.  Okay.

[m1key]

Group 1 Template

 

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue -

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele -

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner -  

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 

[erik g]

 

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 7

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 6.75

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 9

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue -8.5

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 4

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 7.75

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 6.5

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 8

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele -5.5

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 8.5

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 4.5

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner -  9

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 6.75

 

[QueenCami]

omg i love that you stole adapted this from the voice subforum !

[QueenCami]

10 = icon, legend, moment

8-9 = seriously impressive

7 = good performance w/ negligible issues

5-6 = boring OR interesting w/ non-negligible issues

3-4 = non-negligible issues

1-2 = major OR performance-long issues

 

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 7

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 5

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 6

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 5

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 2

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 7

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 4

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 8

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 7

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 10

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 1

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner -  6

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 5

[StarWalker1]

Group 1 Template

 

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 9

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 7.5

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 7

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 8.5

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 5.5

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 6

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 6.5

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 9

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 8

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 9.5

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 5

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 8

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 8

Edited April 17, 2023 by StarWalker1

[nytsch]

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 7 (love her but thought she overdid it with the growls here)

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 6 (a little boring, but didn’t hear issues)

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 8 (hate this song, but big notes were good)

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 5.5 (if you’re doing this song, you have to nail it, she wasn’t there for me)

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 3.5 (uhhh)

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 5 (this wasn’t for me, not terrible though)

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 2.5 (didn’t like this or the song at all)

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 9 (cool version, great vocals)

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 7.5 (somehow I liked this by the end lol)

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 10 (she did that)

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 1 (girl what)

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 7.5 (kept it together even when it went upbeat, but some pronunciations really bothered me)

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 6.5 (nice, that’s about all)

[StarWalker1]

5 minutes ago, nytsch said:

 

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 7 (love her but thought she overdid it with the growls here)

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 6 (a little boring, but didn’t hear issues)

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 8 (hate this song, but big notes were good)

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 5.5 (if you’re doing this song, you have to nail it, she wasn’t there for me)

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 3.5 (uhhh)

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 5 (this wasn’t for me, not terrible though)

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 2.5 (didn’t like this or the song at all)

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 9 (cool version, great vocals)

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 7.5 (somehow I liked this by the end lol)

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 10 (she did that)

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 1 (girl what)

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 7.5 (kept it together even when it went upbeat, but some pronunciations really bothered me)

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 6.5 (nice, that’s about all)

damn lol

[nytsch]

3 minutes ago, StarWalker1 said:

damn lol

I really don’t think a note of that Middle performance was in tune 

[StarWalker1]

Just now, nytsch said:

I really don’t think a note of that Middle performance was in tune 

Oh it was rough as hell don't get me wrong, but I just did not expect scores THAT low LOL

[nytsch]

5 minutes ago, StarWalker1 said:

Oh it was rough as hell don't get me wrong, but I just did not expect scores THAT low LOL

 

Depends on your scale I think, I mean even my 5s and 6s were mostly fine, just not my favorite, but I think for other people 5 or 6 means bad.

 

I’m used to TV so all I’ll say is so far AI is giving me higher highs and lower lows 

[StarWalker1]

Just now, nytsch said:

 

Depends on your scale I think, I mean even my 5s and 6s were mostly fine, just not my favorite, but I think for other people 5 or 6 means bad.

 

I’m used to TV so all I’ll say is so far AI is giving me higher highs and lower lows 

welp u sure got me there lol

 

 

[QueenCami]

28 minutes ago, nytsch said:

 

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 7 (love her but thought she overdid it with the growls here)

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 6 (a little boring, but didn’t hear issues)

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 8 (hate this song, but big notes were good)

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 5.5 (if you’re doing this song, you have to nail it, she wasn’t there for me)

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 3.5 (uhhh)

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 5 (this wasn’t for me, not terrible though)

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 2.5 (didn’t like this or the song at all)

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 9 (cool version, great vocals)

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 7.5 (somehow I liked this by the end lol)

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 10 (she did that)

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 1 (girl what)

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 7.5 (kept it together even when it went upbeat, but some pronunciations really bothered me)

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 6.5 (nice, that’s about all)

agree with 90% of this

[chrisaba]

Group 1 Template

 

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 9

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 7

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 8

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 8.5

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 6.5

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 8.5

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 9

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 9.5

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 8

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 10

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 5

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner -  8

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 9

[Persy]

Group 1 Template

 

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 10

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 8.4

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 9.8

Kaeyra - Don't Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 10

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 6

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 9

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 10

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 10

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 8.6

Nailyah - Lovin' You by Minnie Riperton - 10

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 6

Lucy Love - What's Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 10

Iam Tongi - Don't Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 10

[allistr]

Group 1 Template

 

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 10

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 9 (solid performance, but the song choice is sleepy)

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 10

Kaeyra - Don't Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 10 (queen)

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 4

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 8.5 (not my thing but wow)

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 9.8

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 9.8

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 9 (it reminds me of Laith from TV for some reason)

Nailyah - Lovin' You by Minnie Riperton - 10 (QUEEN)

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 1 (she should have been eliminated after "Bird Set Free" tbh. IDK why she has to make it this far when Paige and Megan had to be in a sing-off. Hoping for her redemption though.)

Lucy Love - What's Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 10

Iam Tongi - Don't Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 8 (way too overhyped)

Edited April 17, 2023 by allistr

[taylorkat]

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 5

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 5

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 5

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 6

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 4

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 5

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 5

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 7

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 8

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 10

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 7

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner - 8

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 6

[Hsamid]

yall are rating way harsher than what you do on TV lmao.

[FloorWax]

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 7.5 (Expected more after her Showstopper)

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 7 

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 8.5 (His most assured performance so far, and he nailed those big notes at the end. This song would be cheesy in most hands but he’s so genuine that it worked)

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 6.75 (Not much in the way of issues but she should stick to rock) 

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 4.5

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 7 (Good vocals but kinda grating for some reason)

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 4 (I like this song but this was bad. She should be sent home.)

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 7.5 (Idk y’all I didn’t love this)

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 7 (Liked the start, thought the rest lacked oomph)

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton -  9 (This was AMAZING. Much better than last round for sure.)

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 3 (If all was right in the world, she should be instantly eliminated bc wtf was that)

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner -  6

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 7.75

 

At first Matt was just an 8 but I had to bump him up after hearing everyone else lol.

Edited April 17, 2023 by FloorWax

[BrokenHearted]

Elise Kristine - Holding Out For A Hero by Bonnie Tyler - 8.5

Oliver Steele - Better Together by Jack Johnson - 7.5

Matt Wilson - Speechless by Dan + Shay - 8 

Kaeyra - Don’t Let Go (Love) by En Vogue - 8.5

Pjae - Golden by Jill Scott - 5.5

Zachariah Smith - Lucille by Little Richard - 7.5

Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave by Chris Stapleton - 6.5

Emma Busse - Lay Me Down by Sam Smith - 8.5

Warren Peay - Set Fire To The Rain by Adele - 7

Nailyah - Lovin’ You by Minnie Riperton - 7.5

Haven Madison - The Middle by Zedd, Maren Morris, & Grey - 5

Lucy Love - What’s Love Got To Do With It? by Tina Turner -  7.5

Iam Tongi - Don’t Let Go by SpawnBreezie - 8.5

[nytsch]

8 hours ago, Hsamid said:

yall are rating way harsher than what you do on TV lmao.

Bc it was worse that what I’m used to seeing on TV lol, maybe I need some recalibration… (although tbf if you look at my ratings for that ep with Walker and ALI, I think they were comparably low)