American Idol Season 20: IDF's Ratings

[m1key]

With the voting rounds beginning tomorrow, I thought I should make this! Credit to @David68 for the writeup, which I copied and then edited from The Voice Forum.

 

I know many of us used to look forward to WNTS to see performance ratings, but they did not do ratings last season and it is unclear if they are doing them this year. If they do decide to do them this year, we can still use this thread as well because I know they collect data from IDF for their ratings

 

AMERICAN IDOL SEASON 20: IDF's RATINGS!

 

Grade the each performance from 0 to 10 

(Artist - Song - Rating) 

 

I will calculate the average of everyone's ratings for each performance and compile it.

 

You can rate performances to the hundredths place (7.25, 9.75, 6.66, 0.01, 9.99) or just as whole numbers.

 

Anyone can put in their rankings (You need to rank every performance of a night, though). You will have until Friday @11:59 PM EST of every week to rate BOTH the Sunday and Monday night performances. Of course, not all weeks will have Monday episodes or performances, so we will not rate those on weeks where there aren't any.

 

The NUMBER ONE RULE is that NOBODY IS ALLOWED to create multiple accounts with the intention to throw the ratings off. Istersay will find out who you are and your main account and alts will be banned or suspended. We will be able to tell if there is suspicious activity.

 

You may edit your ratings as much as you want up until the deadline. 

 

You are free to rate however you want, and people have their ways of rating performances, but just don't be too absurd with low ratings (giving performances 0.01s for no good reason)

 

To any contestants: This is completely for fun. I wouldn't read too much into a rating! Maybe I would advise you to exit this page now.

 

As quoted from last season's topic of this, "Discussion is allowed and encouraged, as long as everyone is respectful. If you can't handle an opinion, go take a walk or something and then come back. The ignore button is also an option if you can't stand another user."

 

That being said, rate away, users of Idolforums!!

Edited April 12, 2022 by m1key

[m1key]

Top 24 Ratings

Group 1 Average: 6.61

Group 2 Average: 6.96

 

1. Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 8.38

2. Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri - 8.35

3. Jacob Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes -8.16

4. Katyrah Love - Blame It On The Boogie by The Jackson 5 - 8.08

5. Cadence Baker - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 8.06

6. Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie - 7.93

7. Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis - 7.90

8. HunterGirl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 7.66

9. Christian Guardino - Leave The Door Open by Silk Sonic - 7.59

10. Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 7.49

11. Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 7.38

12. Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac - 7.07

13. Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles - 6.79

14. Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers - 6.64

15. Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 6.32

16. Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 6.25

17. Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan - 6.17

18. Tristen Gressett - With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 6.13

19. Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood - 6.04

20. Sir Blayke - Breakeven by The Script - 5.76

21. Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 5.73

22. Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 4.94

23. Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival - 4.21

24. Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 3.76

 

Top 20 Performance Show Ratings

 

1. Leah Marlene - Heal by Tom Odell  - 9.39

2. Fritz Hager - When The Party’s Over by Billie Eillish - 8.39

3. Lady K - Love on the Brain by Rihanna -8.29

4. Allegra Miles - Free Fallin’ by Tom Petty - 8.15

5. Nicolina - Edge of Seventeen by Stevie Nicks - 7.92

6. Christian Guardino - Imagine by John Lennon - 7.89

7. HunterGirl - Heartbreak Down by Herself - 7.87

8. Jay Copeland - You Know I’m No Good by Amy Winehouse - 7.60

9. Emyrson Flora - Tell Me You Love Me by Demi Lovato - 7.39

10. Ava Maybee - Anyone by Demi Lovato - 7.18

11. Jacob Moran - Don’t You Worry Bout A Thing by Stevie Wonder - 7.18

12. Noah Thompson - Falling by Harry Styles - 7.11

13. Katyrah Love - Dream by Bishop Briggs - 6.76

14. Mike Parker - Chasing After You by Ryan Hurd & Maren Morris- 6.69

15. Elli Rowe - Somewhere Only We Know by Keane - 6.57

16. Sage - Rhiannon by Fleetwood Mac - 6.49

17. Cadence Baker - Train Wreck by James Arthur - 6.22

18. Tristen Gressett - Sacrifice by The Weekend - 5.91

19. Cameron Whitcomb - Changes by Black Sabbath - 5.86

20. Dan Marshall - Friends in Low Places by Garth Brooks - 5.12

 

Top 20 Result Show Ratings

 

1. Nicolina Bozzo - She Used To Be Mine by Sara Barellis - 8.97

2. Leah Marlene - Wisher to the Well by Herself - 7.78

3. Fritz Hager - Golden by Harry Styles -  7.71

4. Ava Maybee - Cuz I Love You by Lizzo - 7.70

5. Tristen Gressett - Are You Gonna Go My Way by Lenny Kravitz - 7.66

6. Emyrson Flora - Love in the Dark by Adele - 7.51

7. Allegra Miles - Tainted by Herself - 7.47

8. Lady K - Bust Your Windows by Jazmine Sullivan - 7.43

9. Jay Copeland - Believer by Imagine Dragons - 7.23

10. HunterGirl - Vice by Miranda Lambert - 7.18

11. Christian Guardino - Creep by Radiohead - 7.12

12. Sage - Brown Eyed Lover by Allen Stone - 6.80

13. Jacob Moran - Rise by Katy Perry - 6.78

14. Mike Parker - Bed on Fire by Teddy Swims - 6.78

15.Noah Thompson - Cover Me Up by Jason Isbell  - 6.70

16. Elli Rowe - All I Want by Kodaline - 6.62

17. Cadence Baker - I’m Your Baby Tonight by Whitney Houston - 6.55

18. Katyrah Love - Through the Fire by Chaka Khan - 6.35

19. Dan Marshall - Stuck on You by Lionel Richie -  4.90

20. Cameron Whitcomb - If It Hadn’t Been For Life by The SteelDrivers - 4.25

 

Top 14 Performance Ratings

 

1. Nicolina Bozzo - Hallelujah by Leonard Cohen - 8.50

2. Leah Marlene - Happy Together by The Turtles - 8.13

3. Fritz Hager - Let It Go by James Bay - 8.00

4. Allegra Miles - Ocean Eyes by Billie Eillish - 7.91

5. Mike Parker - Hurricane by Luke Combs - 7.47

6. Ava Maybee - Sign of the Times by Harry Styles - 7.43

7. Lady K - I Believe by Fantasia - 7.23

8. HunterGirl - Baby Girl by Sugarland - 7.14

9. Noah Thompson - Stand by Me by Ben E. King - 7.08

10. Jay Copeland - Just The Way You Are by Bruno Mars - 6.29

11. Christian Guardino - Take Me to Church by Hozier - 6.04

12. Emyrson Flora - Drivers License by Olivia Rodrigo - 6.01

13. Tristen Gressett - Whataya Want From Me by Adam Lambert - 5.82

14. Dan Marshall - She’s Got It All by Kenny Chesny - 3.97

 

Top 11 Performance Ratings

 

1. Jay Copeland - Lilac Wine by Jeff Buckley - 9.40

2. Leah Marlene - Make You Feel My Love by Bob Dylan - 9.02

3. Fritz Hager - Wonderwall by Oasis - 7.68

4. Emyrson Flora - Lovely by Billie Eillish - 7.32

5. Lady K - Traitor by Olivia Rodrigo - 6.78

6. Christian Guardino - I’m Not the Only One by Sam Smith - 6.70

7. Noah Thompson - Heartbreak Warfare by John Mayer - 6.64

8. HunterGirl - 9 to 5 by Dolly Parton - 6.47

9. Nicolina Bozzo - Since U Been Gone by Kelly Clarkson - 6.38

10. Mike Parker - Chasing You by Morgan Wallen - 6.31

11. Tristen Gressett - You Can’t Always Get What You Want by The Rolling Stones - 5.43

 

Top 10 Performance Ratings 

 

1. Nicolina Bozzo - Poor Unfortunate Souls from The Little Mermaid - 9.32

2. Leah Marlene - When She Loved Me from Toy Story 2 - 9.14 

3. HunterGirl - I’ll See The Light from Tangled - 8.14

4. Jay Copeland - Remember Me from Coco - 8.12

5. Fritz Hager - Go the Distance from Hercules - 7.85

6. Lady K - How Far I’ll Go from Moana - 7.36

7. Emyrson Flora - Carried Me With You from Onward - 7.21

8. Christian Guardino - Circle of Life from The Lion King - 7.04

9. Noah Thompson - You’ve Got a Friend In Me from Toy Story - 6.93

10. Mike Parker - You’ll Be In My Heart from Tarzan - 6.37

 

Top 7 Performance Ratings

 

1. Christian Guardino - Dear God by Smokie Norful - 9.21

2. Nicolina Bozzo - Light in the Hallway by Pentatonix - 9.17

3. Leah Marlene - Sanctuary by Nashville Cast- 8.86

4. Nicolina Bozzo - Alone by Heart - 7.98

5. Fritz Hager - The Ocean by Himself - 7.66

6. HunterGirl - You Broke Me First by Tate McRae - 7.50

7. HunterGirl - Like My Mother Does by Lauren Alaina - 7.48 

8. Fritz Hager - All My Friends by Himself - 7.42

9. Leah Marlene - Electric Love by Børns - 7.31

10. Christian Guardino - Lonely by Justin Bieber - 6.91

11. Noah Thompson - Landslide by Fleetwood Mac - 6.72

12. Noah Thompson - Painted Blue by Sunday Best  - 6.44

13. Jay Copeland - I Have Nothing by Whitney Houston - 5.91

14. Jay Copeland - A Song for Mama by Boyz II Men - 5.63

 

 

Top 5 Performance Ratings

 

1. Nicolina Bozzo - All I Ask by Adele - 9.29

2. Leah Marlene - Separate Ways by Journey - 9.07

3. HunterGirl - Girl Crush by Little Big Town - 8.48

4. Leah Marlene - I’ll Stand By You by The Pretenders - 7.65

5. Noah Thompson - Working Man by Larry Fleet - 7.55

6. HunterGirl - Undo It by Carrie Underwood - 7.53

7. Nicolina Bozzo - Blown Away by Carrie Underwood - 7.32

8. Fritz Hager - I Wanna Remember by NEEDTOBREATHE (ft. Carrie Underwood) - 6.95

9. Fritz Hager - Youngblood by 5 Seconds of Summer - 6.91

10. Noah Thompson - So Small by Carrie Underwood - 5.94

 

 

Top 3 Performance Ratings

 

1. Leah Marlene - Flowers by Herself - 8.29

2. Noah Thompson - Stay by Rihanna - 8.24

3. HunterGirl - Red Bird by Herself - 7.93

4. Leah Marlene - Cover Me by Bruce Springsteen - 7.82

5. HunterGirl - Riot by Rascal Flatts -  7.79

6. Noah Thompson - I’m On Fire by Bruce Springsteen - 7.18

7. HunterGirl - Dancing in the Dark by Bruce Springsteen - 5.96

8. Noah Thompson - One Day Tonight by Himself - 5.43

Edited May 28, 2022 by m1key

[m1key]

END OF SEASON STATS

 

Top 20 Contestant Averages

 

Overall

1. Leah Marlene - 8.37 (12 performances)

2. Nicolina Bozzo - 8.32 (10 performances)

3. Fritz Hager - 7.65 (10 performances)

4. Allegra Miles - 7.58 (4 performances)

5. HunterGirl - 7.47 (13 performances)

6. Jacob Moran - 7.37 (3 performances)

7. Christian Guardino - 7.31 (8 performances)

8. Lady K - 7.18 (6 performances)

9. Emyrson Flora - 7.16 (6 performances)

10. Ava Maybee - 7.12 (4 performances)

11. Katyrah Love - 7.06 (3 performances)

12. Jay Copeland - 7.05 (8 performances)

13. Cadence Baker - 6.94 (3 performances)

14. Sage - 6.89 (3 performances)

15. Noah Thompson - 6.82 (13 performances)

16. Elli Rowe - 6.75 (3 performances)

17. Mike Parker - 6.66 (6 performances) 

18. Tristen Gressett - 6.19 (5 performances)

19. Cameron Whitcomb - 4.77 (3 performances)

20 Dan Marshall - 4.44 (4 performances)

 

Finalists

1. Leah Marlene - 8.37 (12 performances)

2. Nicolina Bozzo - 8.32 (10 performances)

3. Fritz Hager - 7.65 (10 performances)

4. HunterGirl - 7.47 (13 performances)

5. Christian Guardino - 7.31 (8 performances)

6. Lady K - 7.18 (6 performances)

7. Emyrson Flora - 7.16 (6 performances)

8. Jay Copeland - 7.05 (8 performances)

9. Noah Thompson - 6.82 (13 performances)

10. Mike Parker - 6.66 (6 performances) 

 

Semifinalists

1. Allegra Miles - 7.58 (4 performances)

2. Jacob Moran - 7.37 (3 performances)

3. Ava Maybee - 7.12 (4 performances)

4. Katyrah Love - 7.06 (3 performances)

5. Cadence Baker - 6.94 (3 performances)

6. Sage - 6.89 (3 performances)

7. Elli Rowe - 6.75 (3 performances)

8.Tristen Gressett - 6.19 (5 performances)

9. Cameron Whitcomb - 4.77 (3 performances)

10. Dan Marshall - 4.44 (4 performances)

 

Episode Performance Rating Averages

1. Top 10 Performances: 7.75

2. Top 5 Performances: 7.67

3. Top 7 Performances: 7.44

4. Top 3 Performances: 7.33

5. Top 20 Performances: 7.20

6. Top 11 Performances: 7.10

7. Top 20 Results: 6.97

8. Top 14 Performances: 6.93

 

Combined Performance Ratings

1. Jay Copeland - Lilac Wine by Jeff Buckley - 9.40
2. Leah Marlene - Heal by Tom Odell  - 9.39
3. Nicolina Bozzo - Poor Unfortunate Souls from The Little Mermaid - 9.32
4. Nicolina Bozzo - All I Ask by Adele - 9.29
5. Christian Guardino - Dear God by Smokie Norful - 9.21
6. Nicolina Bozzo - Light in the Hallway by Pentatonix - 9.17
7. Leah Marlene - When She Loved Me from Toy Story 2 - 9.14 
8. Leah Marlene - Separate Ways by Journey - 9.07
9. Leah Marlene - Make You Feel My Love by Bob Dylan - 9.02
10. Nicolina Bozzo - She Used To Be Mine by Sara Barellis - 8.97
11. Leah Marlene - Sanctuary by Nashville Cast- 8.86
12. Nicolina Bozzo - Hallelujah by Leonard Cohen - 8.50
13.  HunterGirl - Girl Crush by Little Big Town - 8.48
14. Fritz Hager - When The Party’s Over by Billie Eillish - 8.39
15. Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 8.38
16. Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri - 8.35
17. Lady K - Love on the Brain by Rihanna -8.29
18. Leah Marlene - Flowers by Herself - 8.29
19. Noah Thompson - Stay by Rihanna - 8.24
20. Jacob Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes -8.16
21. Allegra Miles - Free Fallin’ by Tom Petty - 8.15
22. HunterGirl - I’ll See The Light from Tangled - 8.14
23. Leah Marlene - Happy Together by The Turtles - 8.13
24. Jay Copeland - Remember Me from Coco - 8.12
25. Katyrah Love - Blame It On The Boogie by The Jackson 5 - 8.08
26. Cadence Baker - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 8.06
27. Fritz Hager - Let It Go by James Bay - 8.00
28. Nicolina Bozzo - Alone by Heart - 7.98
29. HunterGirl - Red Bird by Herself - 7.93
30. Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie - 7.93
31. Nicolina - Edge of Seventeen by Stevie Nicks - 7.92
32. Allegra Miles - Ocean Eyes by Billie Eillish - 7.91
33. Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis - 7.90
34. Christian Guardino - Imagine by John Lennon - 7.89
35. HunterGirl - Heartbreak Down by Herself - 7.87
36. Fritz Hager - Go the Distance from Hercules - 7.85
37. Leah Marlene - Cover Me by Bruce Springsteen - 7.82
38. HunterGirl - Riot by Rascal Flatts -  7.79
39. Leah Marlene - Wisher to the Well by Herself - 7.78
40. Fritz Hager - Golden by Harry Styles -  7.71
41. Ava Maybee - Cuz I Love You by Lizzo - 7.70
42. Fritz Hager - Wonderwall by Oasis - 7.68
43. Fritz Hager - The Ocean by Himself - 7.66
44. HunterGirl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 7.66
45. Tristen Gressett - Are You Gonna Go My Way by Lenny Kravitz - 7.66
46. Leah Marlene - I’ll Stand By You by The Pretenders - 7.65
47. Jay Copeland - You Know I’m No Good by Amy Winehouse - 7.60
48. Christian Guardino - Leave The Door Open by Silk Sonic - 7.59
49. Noah Thompson - Working Man by Larry Fleet - 7.55
50. HunterGirl - Undo It by Carrie Underwood - 7.53
51. Emyrson Flora - Love in the Dark by Adele - 7.51
52. HunterGirl - You Broke Me First by Tate McRae - 7.50
53. Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 7.49
54. HunterGirl - Like My Mother Does by Lauren Alaina - 7.48 
55. Allegra Miles - Tainted by Herself - 7.47
56. Mike Parker - Hurricane by Luke Combs - 7.47
57. Ava Maybee - Sign of the Times by Harry Styles - 7.43
58. Lady K - Bust Your Windows by Jazmine Sullivan - 7.43
59. Fritz Hager - All My Friends by Himself - 7.42
60. Emyrson Flora - Tell Me You Love Me by Demi Lovato - 7.39
61. Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 7.38
62. Lady K - How Far I’ll Go from Moana - 7.36
63. Emyrson Flora - Lovely by Billie Eillish - 7.32
64. Nicolina Bozzo - Blown Away by Carrie Underwood - 7.32
65. Leah Marlene - Electric Love by Børns - 7.31
66. Jay Copeland - Believer by Imagine Dragons - 7.23
67. Lady K - I Believe by Fantasia - 7.23
68. Emyrson Flora - Carried Me With You from Onward - 7.21
69. Ava Maybee - Anyone by Demi Lovato - 7.18
70. HunterGirl - Vice by Miranda Lambert - 7.18
71. Jacob Moran - Don’t You Worry Bout A Thing by Stevie Wonder - 7.18
72. Noah Thompson - I’m On Fire by Bruce Springsteen - 7.18
73. HunterGirl - Baby Girl by Sugarland - 7.14
74. Christian Guardino - Creep by Radiohead - 7.12
75. Noah Thompson - Falling by Harry Styles - 7.11
76. Noah Thompson - Stand by Me by Ben E. King - 7.08
77. Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac - 7.07
78. Christian Guardino - Circle of Life from The Lion King - 7.04
79. Fritz Hager - I Wanna Remember by NEEDTOBREATHE (ft. Carrie Underwood) - 6.95
80. Noah Thompson - You’ve Got a Friend In Me from Toy Story - 6.93
81. Christian Guardino - Lonely by Justin Bieber - 6.91
82. Fritz Hager - Youngblood by 5 Seconds of Summer - 6.91
83. Sage - Brown Eyed Lover by Allen Stone - 6.80
84. Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles - 6.79
85. Jacob Moran - Rise by Katy Perry - 6.78
86. Lady K - Traitor by Olivia Rodrigo - 6.78
87. Mike Parker - Bed on Fire by Teddy Swims - 6.78
88. Katyrah Love - Dream by Bishop Briggs - 6.76
89. Noah Thompson - Landslide by Fleetwood Mac - 6.72
90. Christian Guardino - I’m Not the Only One by Sam Smith - 6.70
91. Noah Thompson - Cover Me Up by Jason Isbell  - 6.70
92. Mike Parker - Chasing After You by Ryan Hurd & Maren Morris- 6.69
93. Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers - 6.64
94. Noah Thompson - Heartbreak Warfare by John Mayer - 6.64
95. Elli Rowe - All I Want by Kodaline - 6.62
96. Elli Rowe - Somewhere Only We Know by Keane - 6.57
97. Cadence Baker - I’m Your Baby Tonight by Whitney Houston - 6.55
98. Sage - Rhiannon by Fleetwood Mac - 6.49
99. HunterGirl - 9 to 5 by Dolly Parton - 6.47
100. Noah Thompson - Painted Blue by Sunday Best  - 6.44
101. Nicolina Bozzo - Since U Been Gone by Kelly Clarkson - 6.38
102. Mike Parker - You’ll Be In My Heart from Tarzan - 6.37
103. Katyrah Love - Through the Fire by Chaka Khan - 6.35
104. Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 6.32
105. Mike Parker - Chasing You by Morgan Wallen - 6.31
106. Jay Copeland - Just The Way You Are by Bruno Mars - 6.29
107. Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 6.25
108. Cadence Baker - Train Wreck by James Arthur - 6.22
109. Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan - 6.17
110. Tristen Gressett - With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 6.13
111. Christian Guardino - Take Me to Church by Hozier - 6.04
112. Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood - 6.04
113. Emyrson Flora - Drivers License by Olivia Rodrigo - 6.01
114. HunterGirl - Dancing in the Dark by Bruce Springsteen - 5.96
115. Noah Thompson - So Small by Carrie Underwood - 5.94
116. Jay Copeland - I Have Nothing by Whitney Houston - 5.91
117. Tristen Gressett - Sacrifice by The Weekend - 5.91
118. Cameron Whitcomb - Changes by Black Sabbath - 5.86
119. Tristen Gressett - Whataya Want From Me by Adam Lambert - 5.82
120. Sir Blayke - Breakeven by The Script - 5.76
121. Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 5.73
122. Jay Copeland - A Song for Mama by Boyz II Men - 5.63
123. Tristen Gressett - You Can’t Always Get What You Want by The Rolling Stones - 5.43
124. Noah Thompson - One Day Tonight by Himself - 5.43
125. Dan Marshall - Friends in Low Places by Garth Brooks - 5.12
126. Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 4.94
127. Dan Marshall - Stuck on You by Lionel Richie -  4.90
128. Cameron Whitcomb - If It Hadn’t Been For Life by The SteelDrivers - 4.25
129. Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival - 4.21
130. Dan Marshall - She’s Got It All by Kenny Chesny - 3.97
131. Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 3.76

Edited May 28, 2022 by m1key

[erik g]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 8

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac  - 6

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 7

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 5

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 9

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 8.5

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 7

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 10

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 5.5

Jacon Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes - 9

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 7

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia -  10

 

 

Edited April 12, 2022 by erik g

[jarmon]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 7.0

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac  - 8.5

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 5.5

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 7.5

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 9.0

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 8.5

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 7.5

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 9.5

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 6.0

Jacon Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes - 9.0

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 6.5

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia -9.0

[taylorkat]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 8

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac - 6

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 5

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 4

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 7

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 6

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 8

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 7

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 3

Jacob Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes - 6

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 8

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 9

[m1key]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 6.5

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac  - 8.0

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 6.8

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 4.5

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 7.5

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 8.0

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 5.0

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 8.2

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 4.0

Jacon Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes - 8.0

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 7.7

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 8.0

Edited April 12, 2022 by m1key

[redwood79]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 5.5

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac  - 7

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 6.5

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 6.5

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 5.5

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 9

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 5

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 6

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 5

Jacon Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes - 9

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 7

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 9

Edited April 11, 2022 by redwood79

[QueenKalie]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 5

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac  - 8.5

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 5

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 4

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 8

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 4.5

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 8

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 8

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 3

Jacon Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes - 7

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 8

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 6

[Gustavo527]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 3

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac - 7

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 7.5

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 2.5

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 7

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 4

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 4.5

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 5.5

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 2

Jacob Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes - 7

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 8

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 8.5

[Persy]

I think for me it would be;

 

Jay - 10

Elli - 8

Tristen - 7.8

Scarlet - 6.2

Sage - 10

Danielle - 4

Mike - 8.2

Emyrson - 9

Dan - 2

Jacob - 9.8

Hunter Girl - 10

Nicolina - 10

[Dai]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 6

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac  - 7

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 6.25

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 4

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 6.5

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 4

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 5

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 6.75

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 4.5

Jacon Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes -  7.5

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 7.5

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 8

[CarmenSandiego]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 6.  It was entertaining but he kinda oversang it towards the end.

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac  - 7.  She was very good, but could improve.

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 6.  He's toned his antics down but they still annoy me somewhat.

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 6.  Sigh.  She was a real performer, but I would have recommended her to sing a different song.

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 7.  Definitely enjoyable, even though it began a little slow.

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 5.  She was a fine singer, but also boring.

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 6.  I would take points off because he sang a song by one of the mentors.

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 8.  That was the performance she needed to keep her safe.

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 4.  Boring and uncomfortable.

Jacon Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes - 8.  Best of the guys but his wailing was a bit too much at times for me.

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 7.  Not her best performance but she can afford to have a performance like this one.

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 9. Best of the night.

[m1key]

Top 24 Group #2 Template:

 

Cadence Baker - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 

Sir Blayke - Breakeven by The Script - 

Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles - 

Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri -

Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood - 

Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan - 

Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers - 

Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie - 

Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival - 

Christian Guardino - Leave The Door Open by Silk Sonic - 

Katyrah Love - Blame It On The Boogie by The Jackson 5 - 

Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis -

 

Some updates/clarifications (will edit into the OP): 

- You may edit your ratings up until the deadline. 

- Ratings will be due every Friday @11:59 PM EST instead of Saturday @11:59 PM EST. This is to ensure I have time to calculate the ratings before the next episode airs and that I don’t have to rush as much.

- If you did not have a chance to put in your Group 1 ratings before submissions for Group 2 ratings opened, you can still post them! Ratings for BOTH episodes close at the deadline, not just Group 2.

[erik g]

Cadence Baker - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 9.5/10

Sir Blayke - Breakeven by The Script - 4/10

Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles - 7.5/10

Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri -7.5/10

Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood - 8/10

Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan - 8.5/10

Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers - 7/10

Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie - 7.8/10

Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival - 5/10

Christian Guardino - Leave The Door Open by Silk Sonic - 7.5/10

Katyrah Love - Blame It On The Boogie by The Jackson 5 - 9/10

Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis -9/10

[redwood79]

Cadence Baker - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 9

Sir Blayke - Breakeven by The Script - 6

Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles - 4

Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri - 8

Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood - 6

Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan - 7 

Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers - 6

Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie - 8.5

Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival - 4

Christian Guardino - Leave The Door Open by Silk Sonic - 7.5

Katyrah Love - Blame It On The Boogie by The Jackson 5 - 6.5

Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis - 7

Edited April 12, 2022 by redwood79

[m1key]

Cadence Baker - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 8.5

Sir Blayke - Breakeven by The Script - 5.5

Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles - 9.0

Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri - 9.5

Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood - 5.5

Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan - 8.5

Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers - 7.0

Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie - 7.0

Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival - 3.5

Christian Guardino - Leave The Door Open by Silk Sonic - 6.5

Katyrah Love - Blame It On The Boogie by The Jackson 5 - 9.0

Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis - 7.5

[taylorkat]

Cadence Baker - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 8

Sir Blayke - Breakeven by The Script - 6

Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles - 6

Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri - 7

Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood - 5

Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan - 5

Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers - 5

Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie - 5

Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival - 3

Christian Guardino - Leave The Door Open by Silk Sonic - 8

Katyrah Love - Blame It On The Boogie by The Jackson 5 - 6

Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis - 6

[FloorWax]

Will give my ratings for both episodes on this post when I find the time today. (it's already noon where i'm from lol)

[peachfuz]

Jay Copeland - I Want You Back by The Jackson 5 - 6.5

Elli Rowe - Everywhere by Fleetwood Mac  - 7.5

Tristen Gressett- With A Little Help From My Friends by The Beatles - 7.0

Scarlet Ayliz - Levitating by Dua Lipa - 5.4

Sage - Jolene by Dolly Parton - 6.0

Danielle Finn - Your Song by Elton John - 5.0

Mike Parker - Best Shot by Jimmie Allen - 5.3

Emyrson Flora - Angels Like You by Miley Cyrus - 6.4

Dan Marshall - Heaven by Bryan Adams - 4.2

Jacon Moran - In My Blood by Shawn Mendes - 8.0

Hunter Girl - Banjo by Rascal Flatts - 7.0

Nicolina Bozzo - Elastic Heart by Sia - 7.6

[peachfuz]

Cadence Baker - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 7.2

Sir Blayke - Breakeven by The Script - 6.0

Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles - 6.3

Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri - 7.4

Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood - 5.1

Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan - 4.3

Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers - 5.4

Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie - 7.6

Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival - 4.5

Christian Guardino - Leave The Door Open by Silk Sonic - 7.8

Katyrah Love - Blame It On The Boogie by The Jackson 5 - 8.5

Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis - 7.1

[Persy]

For me it would be.....

Cadence - 10

Sir Blayke - 4.1

Allegra - 9.9

Kenedi - 10000000000

Lady K - 6.4

Ava - 5.5

Noah - 10

Leah - 10

Cameron - 0

Christian - 10

Katyrah - 10

Fritz - 10000000000

[jarmon]

Cadence Baker - Something's Got A Hold On Me by Etta James - 9.0

Sir Blayke - Breakeven by The Script - 6.0

Allegra Miles - Adore You by Harry Styles - 8.5

Kenedi Anderson - Human by Christina Perri - 9.5

Lady K - Before He Cheats by Carrie Underwood - 8.0

Ava Maybee - Tell Me Something Good by Chaka Khan - 8.5

Noah Thompson - Blue Side of the Mountain by The SteelDrivers - 5.0

Leah Marlene - Call Me by Blondie - 7.0

Cameron Whitcomb - Bad Moon Rising by Creedence Clearwater Revival - 6.0

Christian Guardino - Leave The Door Open by Silk Sonic - 7.0

Katyrah Love - Blame It On The Boogie by The Jackson 5 - 7.0

Fritz Hager - Waves by Dean Lewis - 8.5

[FloorWax]

Putting some thoughts too even though no one asked lol

 

Jay Copeland - I was irked by a lot of his vocal choices. He also kept going in and out of pitch, and the song choice was boring AF. 4.0
Elli Rowe - She has the loveliest tone in the competition but she went flat a few too many times. 7.0
Tristen Gressett - Solid performance but I think his vocal limitations prevented it from being great. 7.5
Scarlet Ayliz - She was very offkey in several spots but I honestly I was kinda entertained lmao. 5.0
Sage - There were some questionable moments here and there, but overall a decent showing. 7.25
Danielle Finn - Started ok, but everything after the key change was a mess, and she missed lots of obvious notes. 3.75
Mike Parker - Tragic song choice, he has lots of potential to give great performances but this wasn't it. 6.0
Emyrson Flora - I've rewatched it several times, and it's grown on me. Still could do with less umm... straining. 7.0
Dan Marshall - Sounds like a no-chair turn from The Voice lol. I hope this guy goes home. 3.5
Jacob Moran - This was a very well-paced performance. I'm not usually a fan of high male voices but he sold me on this one. 8.0
Hunter Girl - I liked this way more than I was expecting to. That was fun to watch. 7.5
Nicolina Bozzo - I expected her to do a little better ngl, but this was a standout on a weak night. 7.75

Edited April 12, 2022 by FloorWax

[FloorWax]

Cadence Baker - Her strongest performance since her audition. Nothing earth-shattering but very solid. 7.5
Sir Blayke - Didn't make a very big impression. He was very out of breath by the end and his vocals suffered. 6.0
Allegra Miles - What a fresh and interesting rendition of this song. It wasn't perfect but I adored many of the choices she made. 8.0
Kenedi Anderson - One of her better performances. Less attention to perfection and more "feeling". She could've been a winner but it is what it is. 7.75
Lady K - Wrong song choice. She's way better than this performance, very rough. 5.0
Ava Maybee - The first half was very meh, second half was... still meh. 5.25
Noah Thompson - Unlike most contestants this season, Noah doesn't bite off more than he can chew. It makes him a little boring but it also works in favor. 7.0
Leah Marlene - This is girl is endlessly talented. She plays an instrument and does weird things with her voice but her pitch doesn't suffer. Respect. 8.25
Cameron Whitcomb - Cameron did what Cameron does. Lmao. 4.0
Christian Guardino - This song is a very tall order and Christian did one of the better covers I've seen, but that's not saying much. 7.25
Katyrah Love - I was worried about this song choice being too "outdated", but she pulled it off well. That was a blast. 8.0
Fritz Hager - I didn't love it but I saw the potential there. Maybe I would like him more if he was a tad more polished. 7.0

Edited April 12, 2022 by FloorWax