Rank the Winners

[Elliott]

Kelly Clarkson

Ruben Studdard

Fantasia Barrino

Carrie Underwood

Taylor Hicks

Blake Lewis

David Cook

Kris Allen

Lee DeWyze

Scotty McCreery

Phillip Phillips

Candice Glover

Caleb Johnson

Nick Fradiani

Trent Harmon

Maddie Poppe

Laine Hardy

Just Sam

Chayce Beckham

[kamil24]

 

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Carrie Underwood

3. Candice Glover

4. Jordin Sparks

5. David Cook

6. Kris Allen

7. Trent Harmon

8. Fantasia Barrino

9. Phillip Phillips

10. Just Sam

11. Nick Fradiani

12. Scotty McCreery

13. Ruben Studdard

14. Chayce Beckham

15. Caleb Johnson

16. Maddie Poppe

17. Lee DeWyze

18. Taylor Hicks

19. Laine Hardy

 

[Elliott]

1. Lee DeWyze
2. Trent Harmon
3. David Cook
4. Kelly Clarkson
5. Phillip Phillips
6. Kris Allen
7. Laine Hardy
8. Chayce Beckham
9. Fantasia Barrino
10. Scotty McCreery
11. Candice Glover
12. Carrie Underwood
13. Jordin Sparks
14. Maddie Poppe
15. Just Sam
16. Taylor Hicks
17. Ruben Studdard
18. Caleb Johnson
19. Nick Fradiani

[Carrie_On]

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Carrie Underwood

3. David Cook

4. Trent Harmon

5. Jordin Sparks

6. Fantasia 

7. Maddie Poppe

8. Candice Glover

9. Kris Allen

10. Chayce Beckham

11. Phillip Phillips

12. Just Sam

13. Scotty McCreery

14. Laine Hardy

15. Lee DeWyze

16. Ruben Studdard

17. Nick Fradiani

18. Caleb Johnson

19. Taylor Hicks

[wgm]

Females:

 

1. Carrie 

2 Kelly 

3. Jordin 

4. Maddie 

5. Just Sam

6. Fantasia 

7. Candice 

 

Males:

 

1. Phillip Phillips 

2. Scotty McCreery

3. Laine Hardy

4. Chayce Beckham

5. Trent Harmon

6. Nick Fradiani 

7. Ruben 

8. Lee 

9. Taylor 

10. Caleb 

11. Kris

 

[taylorkat]

1. Kris Allen

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. Carrie Underwood

4. Jordin Sparks

5. Taylor Hicks

6. Ruben Studdard

7. Candice Glover

8. Fantasia Barrino

9. David Cook

10. Maddie Poppe

11. Just Sam

12. Caleb Johnson

13. Nick Fradiani

14. Laine Hardy

15. Lee DeWyze

16. Phillip Phillips

17. Scotty McCreery

18. Chayce Beckham

19. Trent Harmon

[Hamza Tufail]

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Carrie Underwood

.

.

 

3. Chayce Beckham

4. Kris Allen

5. Jordin Sparks

.

.

.

 

6. Laine Hardy

7. Maddie Poppe

 

.

.

.

.

8. Just Sam

 

Again ranking only those who I know.

[BJ_Lock]

1. David Cook

2. Kelly Clarkson

3. Taylor Hicks

4. Candice Glover

5. Phillip Phillips

6. Carrie Underwood

7. Ruben Studdard

8. Trent Harmon

9. Caleb Johnson

10. Chayce Beckham

11. Maddie Poppe

12. Jordin Sparks

13. Laine Hardy

14. Fantasia Barrino

15. Kris Allen

16. Nick Fradiani

17. Just Sam

18. Scotty McCreery

19. Lee DeWyze

[thenghreport]

Kelly Clarkson

Taylor Hicks

David Cook

Ruben Studdard

Fantasia Barrino

Phillip Phillips

Carrie Underwood

Scotty McCreery

Maddie Poppe

Kris Allen

Chayce Beckham

Candice Glover

Lee Dewyze

Jordin Sparks

Laine Hardy

Caleb Johnson

Trent Harmon

Nick Fradiani

Sam Diaz

 

[KelseyW]

Kris Allen

 

Maddie Poppe

 

David Cook

 

Kelly Clarkson

 

Phillip Philips

 

Carrie Underwood

 

Jordin Sparks

 

Laine Hardy

 

Ruben Studdard

 

Trent Harmon

 

Caleb Johnson

 

Fantasia Barrino

 

Just Sam

 

Chayce Beckham

 

Scotty McCreery

 

Lee Dewyze

 

Taylor Hicks

 

Candice Glover

 

Nick Fradiani

 

 

 

 

[iloveadam]

1. Kelly Clarkson

2. Kris Allen

 

---HUGE HELL GAP----

3. David Cook

4. Carrie Underwood

5. Jordin Sparks

6. Caleb Johnson

7. Maddie Poppe

 

[MargoK]

On 5/23/2021 at 10:58 PM, Elliott said:

Kelly Clarkson

Ruben Studdard

Fantasia Barrino

Carrie Underwood

Taylor Hicks

Blake Lewis

David Cook

Kris Allen

Lee DeWyze

Scotty McCreery

Phillip Phillips

Candice Glover

Caleb Johnson

Nick Fradiani

Trent Harmon

Maddie Poppe

Laine Hardy

Just Sam

Chayce Beckham

Kelly Clarkson 

Carrie Underwood 

Maddie Poppe

Laine Hardy

Ruben Studdard

Jordin Sparks

Kris Allen

Fantasia Burrino

Scotty McCreey

Taylor Hicks

Candace Glover

Just Sam

Caleb Johnson

David Cook

Phillip Phillips 

Trent Harmon

chayce Beckham

Nick Fradiani

Lee Dewyze 

 

[Bunny391848]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Top tear 

1. David Cook(I've seen him 20+ times if you include virtual shows and met 4. He's soo talented and humble)

 

Amazing

2. Just Sam

3. Kelly Clarkson(I didn't start watching until S4 but I love her)

4.Candice Glover

5. Maddie Poppe

 

Not my top favorites but they are alright

6. Carrie Underwood

7. Phillip Phillips

8. Nick Fradiani

9. Jordin Sparks

10.  Kris Allen(I was all team Adam S8 and hated him for years but after seeing him at the reboot idol tour and his Stageit show with David Cook, he goes higher)

11. Chayce Beckham

12. Ruben Studdard

13. Trent Harmon

14. Taylor Hicks

15..  Caleb Johnson

 

Meh

16.  Lee Dewyze

17 Scotty McCreery 

18. Fantasia

19. . Laine Hardy

 

 

 

 

 

[BestIdol474]

01. Carrie Underwood 

02. Kelly Clarkson 

03. Kris Allen 

04. Trent Harmon 

05. Maddie Poppe 

06. Scotty McCreery 

07.  Jordin Sparks 

08. Candice Glover 

09. Phillip Phillips 

10.  David Cook 

11.  Fantasia Barrino 

12. Chayce Beckham 

13. Just Sam 

14. Ruben Studdard 

15. Lee DeWyze 

16. Laine Hardy 

17. Taylor Hicks 

18. Nick Fradiani 

19. Caleb Johnson 

 

 

[sneaky]

Based on American Idol Runs

 

1). David Cook

2). Candace

3) Fantasia

4) Caleb

5) Kelly- *The first few seasons were karaoke and she wasnt very experienced in performance and artistry. If it were today she'd be at the top

6) Jordin

7)Trent

Ruben

9) Carrie- as a pro she'd be top 5 but she was inexperinced

10) Taylor

11) Maddie

12) Kris

13) Scotty

14) Lee

15)Nick

16) Laine

17) Philli

18) Chayce

19) Sam