Former Finalists Eligible to Audition

[thenghreport]

I was feeling bored and wanted a reminder of the unrelenting force that is time, so here is a list of former Idol finalists that are now eligible to re-audition for American Idol Season 20.

 

Aaron Kelly (Season 9, 5th Place)

Lauren Alaina (Season 10, 2nd Place)

Thia Megia (Season 10, 10th Place)

Jessica Sanchez (Season 11, 2nd Place)

Hollie Cavanagh (Season 11, 4th Place)

Skylar Laine (Season 11, 5th Place)

DeAndre Brackensick (Season 11, 8th Place)

Shannon Magrane (Season 11, 11th Place)

Angie Miller (Season 12, 3rd Place)

Amber Holcomb (Season 12, 4th Place)

Burnell Taylor (Season 12, 7th Place)

Devin Velez (Season 12, 8th Place)

Jena Irene (Season 13, 2nd Place)

Alex Preston (Season 13, 3rd Place)

Sam Woolf (Season 13, 5th Place)

Malaya Watson (Season 13, 8th Place)

MK Nobilette (Season 13, 10th Place)

Emily Piriz (Season 13, 12th Place)

Jax (Season 14, 3rd Place)

Tyanna Jones (Season 14, 5th Place)

Quentin Alexander (Season 14, 6th Place)

Qaasim Middleton (Season 14, 8th Place)

Daniel Seavey (Season 14, 9th Place)

Adanna Duru (Season 14, 10th Place)

Maddie Walker (Season 14, 10th Place)

Sarina-Joi Crowe (Season 14, 12th Place)

La'Porsha Renae (Season 15, 2nd Place)

Dalton Rapattoni (Season 15, 3rd Place)

Sonika Vaid (Season 15, 5th Place)

Tristan McIntosh (Season 15, 6th Place)

Lee Jean (Season 15, 7th Place)

Avalon Young (Season 15, 8th Place)

Gianna Isabella (Season 15, 9th Place)

Olivia Rox (Season 15, 10th Place)

Caleb Lee Hutchinson (Season 16, 2nd Place)

Cade Foehner (Season 16, 4th Place)

Michael Woodard (Season 16, 5th Place)

Catie Turner (Season 16, 6th Place)

Jurnee (Season 16, 7th Place)

Ada Vox (Season 16, 8th Place)

Michelle Sussett (Season 16, 9th Place)

Alejandro Aranda (Season 17, 2nd Place)

Madison VanDenburg (Season 17, 3rd Place)

Laci Kaye Booth (Season 17, 4th Place)

Walker Burroughs (Season 17, 7th Place)

Alyssa Raghu (Season 17, 8th Place)

Uche (Season 17, 9th Place)

Arthur Gunn (Season 18&19, 2nd & 6th Place)

Francisco Martin (Season 18, 3rd Place)

Dillon James (Season 18, 4th Place)

Jonny West (Season 18, 5th Place)

Louis Knight (Season 18, 6th Place)

Julia Gargano (Season 18, 7th Place)

Makayla Phillips (Season 18th, 8th Place)

Sophia James (Season 18, 9th Place)

 

*Does not include any Season 19 Contestants

**Some final rankings are inferred guesses due to elimination patterns

***Many of these contestants are signed with labels which may make it impossible for them to compete.

 

 

[blackfield]

marked in red those with record deals and are ineligible. also there might be some who wouldn't want to come back like dalton, jena, alex, laporsha, avalon, jonny west, sophia james. 

 

Aaron Kelly (Season 9, 5th Place)

Lauren Alaina (Season 10, 2nd Place)

Thia Megia (Season 10, 10th Place)

Jessica Sanchez (Season 11, 2nd Place)

Hollie Cavanagh (Season 11, 4th Place)

Skylar Laine (Season 11, 5th Place)

DeAndre Brackensick (Season 11, 8th Place)

Shannon Magrane (Season 11, 11th Place)

Angie Miller (Season 12, 3rd Place)

Amber Holcomb (Season 12, 4th Place)

Burnell Taylor (Season 12, 7th Place)

Devin Velez (Season 12, 8th Place)

Jena Irene (Season 13, 2nd Place)

Alex Preston (Season 13, 3rd Place)

Sam Woolf (Season 13, 5th Place)

Malaya Watson (Season 13, 8th Place)

MK Nobilette (Season 13, 10th Place)

Emily Piriz (Season 13, 12th Place)

Jax (Season 14, 3rd Place)

Tyanna Jones (Season 14, 5th Place)

Quentin Alexander (Season 14, 6th Place)

Qaasim Middleton (Season 14, 8th Place)

Daniel Seavey (Season 14, 9th Place)

Adanna Duru (Season 14, 10th Place)

Maddie Walker (Season 14, 10th Place)

Sarina-Joi Crowe (Season 14, 12th Place)

La'Porsha Renae (Season 15, 2nd Place)

Dalton Rapattoni (Season 15, 3rd Place)

Sonika Vaid (Season 15, 5th Place)

Tristan McIntosh (Season 15, 6th Place)

Lee Jean (Season 15, 7th Place)

Avalon Young (Season 15, 8th Place)

Gianna Isabella (Season 15, 9th Place)

Olivia Rox (Season 15, 10th Place)

Caleb Lee Hutchinson (Season 16, 2nd Place)

Cade Foehner (Season 16, 4th Place)

Michael Woodard (Season 16, 5th Place)

Catie Turner (Season 16, 6th Place)

Jurnee (Season 16, 7th Place)

Ada Vox (Season 16, 8th Place)

Michelle Sussett (Season 16, 9th Place)

Alejandro Aranda (Season 17, 2nd Place)

Madison VanDenburg (Season 17, 3rd Place)

Laci Kaye Booth (Season 17, 4th Place)

Walker Burroughs (Season 17, 7th Place)

Alyssa Raghu (Season 17, 8th Place)

Uche (Season 17, 9th Place)

Arthur Gunn (Season 18&19, 2nd & 6th Place)

Francisco Martin (Season 18, 3rd Place)

Dillon James (Season 18, 4th Place)

Jonny West (Season 18, 5th Place)

Louis Knight (Season 18, 6th Place)

Julia Gargano (Season 18, 7th Place)

Makayla Phillips (Season 18th, 8th Place)

Sophia James (Season 18, 9th Place)

 

 

Edited May 11, 2021 by blackfield

[thenghreport]

18 minutes ago, blackfield said:

marked in red those with record deals and are ineligible. also there might be some who wouldn't want to come back like dalton, jena, alex, laporsha, avalon, jonny west, sophia james. 

 

Aaron Kelly (Season 9, 5th Place)

Lauren Alaina (Season 10, 2nd Place)

Thia Megia (Season 10, 10th Place)

Jessica Sanchez (Season 11, 2nd Place)

Hollie Cavanagh (Season 11, 4th Place)

Skylar Laine (Season 11, 5th Place)

DeAndre Brackensick (Season 11, 8th Place)

Shannon Magrane (Season 11, 11th Place)

Angie Miller (Season 12, 3rd Place)

Amber Holcomb (Season 12, 4th Place)

Burnell Taylor (Season 12, 7th Place)

Devin Velez (Season 12, 8th Place)

Jena Irene (Season 13, 2nd Place)

Alex Preston (Season 13, 3rd Place)

Sam Woolf (Season 13, 5th Place)

Malaya Watson (Season 13, 8th Place)

MK Nobilette (Season 13, 10th Place)

Emily Piriz (Season 13, 12th Place)

Jax (Season 14, 3rd Place)

Tyanna Jones (Season 14, 5th Place)

Quentin Alexander (Season 14, 6th Place)

Qaasim Middleton (Season 14, 8th Place)

Daniel Seavey (Season 14, 9th Place)

Adanna Duru (Season 14, 10th Place)

Maddie Walker (Season 14, 10th Place)

Sarina-Joi Crowe (Season 14, 12th Place)

La'Porsha Renae (Season 15, 2nd Place)

Dalton Rapattoni (Season 15, 3rd Place)

Sonika Vaid (Season 15, 5th Place)

Tristan McIntosh (Season 15, 6th Place)

Lee Jean (Season 15, 7th Place)

Avalon Young (Season 15, 8th Place)

Gianna Isabella (Season 15, 9th Place)

Olivia Rox (Season 15, 10th Place)

Caleb Lee Hutchinson (Season 16, 2nd Place)

Cade Foehner (Season 16, 4th Place)

Michael Woodard (Season 16, 5th Place)

Catie Turner (Season 16, 6th Place)

Jurnee (Season 16, 7th Place)

Ada Vox (Season 16, 8th Place)

Michelle Sussett (Season 16, 9th Place)

Alejandro Aranda (Season 17, 2nd Place)

Madison VanDenburg (Season 17, 3rd Place)

Laci Kaye Booth (Season 17, 4th Place)

Walker Burroughs (Season 17, 7th Place)

Alyssa Raghu (Season 17, 8th Place)

Uche (Season 17, 9th Place)

Arthur Gunn (Season 18&19, 2nd & 6th Place)

Francisco Martin (Season 18, 3rd Place)

Dillon James (Season 18, 4th Place)

Jonny West (Season 18, 5th Place)

Louis Knight (Season 18, 6th Place)

Julia Gargano (Season 18, 7th Place)

Makayla Phillips (Season 18th, 8th Place)

Sophia James (Season 18, 9th Place)

 

 

Yep, good work.

 

Man, I would love to see the following people again:

 

Jessica Sanchez

Angie Miller

Jena Irene

Alex Preston

[ScarletDevilCCX]

12 minutes ago, thenghreport said:

Yep, good work.

 

Man, I would love to see the following people again:

 

Jessica Sanchez

Angie Miller

Jena Irene

Alex Preston

Same. I didn't even watch much of S13 for some reason so getting a second chance at Jena and Alex would be cool. I was also a huge fan of both Hollie and Skylar in S11 so I'd add them to that list.

 

Also, I'm guessing you just went by "year of birth=1993 or later"? Because I've also got Katie Stevens (Season 9, 8th place) and Mackenzie Bourg (Season 15, 4th place) on my list--both of them born in late 1992, so they should still be eligible. (Katie for sure, since her birthday's in December. Mackenzie, it's an interesting one, because he does turn 29 a few days before the deadline for contestants on the young end to turn 15, but for some reason there's actually a good 3.5 months where it's fine if you're already 29.)

[thenghreport]

3 minutes ago, ScarletDevilCCX said:

Same. I didn't even watch much of S13 for some reason so getting a second chance at Jena and Alex would be cool. I was also a huge fan of both Hollie and Skylar in S11 so I'd add them to that list.

 

Also, I'm guessing you just went by "year of birth=1993 or later"? Because I've also got Katie Stevens (Season 9, 8th place) and Mackenzie Bourg (Season 15, 4th place) on my list--both of them born in late 1992, so they should still be eligible. (Katie for sure, since her birthday's in December. Mackenzie, it's an interesting one, because he does turn 29 a few days before the deadline for contestants on the young end to turn 15, but for some reason there's actually a good 3.5 months where it's fine if you're already 29.)

 

Might have missed those two!

[m1key]

The fact that Jessica and La'Porsha could come back to compete is a joke to me 

[mrsvaledictorian2017]

 

1 hour ago, blackfield said:

marked in red those with record deals and are ineligible. also there might be some who wouldn't want to come back like dalton, jena, alex, laporsha, avalon, jonny west, sophia james. 

 

Aaron Kelly (Season 9, 5th Place)

Lauren Alaina (Season 10, 2nd Place)

Thia Megia (Season 10, 10th Place)

Jessica Sanchez (Season 11, 2nd Place)

Hollie Cavanagh (Season 11, 4th Place)

Skylar Laine (Season 11, 5th Place)

DeAndre Brackensick (Season 11, 8th Place)

Shannon Magrane (Season 11, 11th Place)

Angie Miller (Season 12, 3rd Place)

Amber Holcomb (Season 12, 4th Place)

Burnell Taylor (Season 12, 7th Place)

Devin Velez (Season 12, 8th Place)

Jena Irene (Season 13, 2nd Place)

Alex Preston (Season 13, 3rd Place)

Sam Woolf (Season 13, 5th Place)

Malaya Watson (Season 13, 8th Place)

MK Nobilette (Season 13, 10th Place)

Emily Piriz (Season 13, 12th Place)

Jax (Season 14, 3rd Place)

Tyanna Jones (Season 14, 5th Place)

Quentin Alexander (Season 14, 6th Place)

Qaasim Middleton (Season 14, 8th Place)

Daniel Seavey (Season 14, 9th Place)

Adanna Duru (Season 14, 10th Place)

Maddie Walker (Season 14, 10th Place)

Sarina-Joi Crowe (Season 14, 12th Place)

La'Porsha Renae (Season 15, 2nd Place)

Dalton Rapattoni (Season 15, 3rd Place)

Sonika Vaid (Season 15, 5th Place)

Tristan McIntosh (Season 15, 6th Place)

Lee Jean (Season 15, 7th Place)

Avalon Young (Season 15, 8th Place)

Gianna Isabella (Season 15, 9th Place)

Olivia Rox (Season 15, 10th Place)

Caleb Lee Hutchinson (Season 16, 2nd Place)

Cade Foehner (Season 16, 4th Place)

Michael Woodard (Season 16, 5th Place)

Catie Turner (Season 16, 6th Place)

Jurnee (Season 16, 7th Place)

Ada Vox (Season 16, 8th Place)

Michelle Sussett (Season 16, 9th Place)

Alejandro Aranda (Season 17, 2nd Place)

Madison VanDenburg (Season 17, 3rd Place)

Laci Kaye Booth (Season 17, 4th Place)

Walker Burroughs (Season 17, 7th Place)

Alyssa Raghu (Season 17, 8th Place)

Uche (Season 17, 9th Place)

Arthur Gunn (Season 18&19, 2nd & 6th Place)

Francisco Martin (Season 18, 3rd Place)

Dillon James (Season 18, 4th Place)

Jonny West (Season 18, 5th Place)

Louis Knight (Season 18, 6th Place)

Julia Gargano (Season 18, 7th Place)

Makayla Phillips (Season 18th, 8th Place)

Sophia James (Season 18, 9th Place)

 

 

I actually think Michael Woodard is ineligible too because he just got signed by Katy Perry.

 

https://www.google.com/amp/s/talentrecap.com/american-idol-star-michael-j-woodard-signed-to-katy-perrys-label/

Edited May 10, 2021 by mrsvaledictorian2017

[Elliott]

1 hour ago, m1key said:

The fact that Jessica and La'Porsha could come back to compete is a joke to me 

I’m pretty sure Jessica is signed to an an indie label of some kind.

[thenghreport]

22 minutes ago, Elliott said:

I’m pretty sure Jessica is signed to an an indie label of some kind.

 

I figured for smaller labels with less strict contracts, they could probably just part ways if they viewed getting back on Idol as a big enough opportunity.

[thenghreport]

The thing with so many of the past finalists is that VERY FEW of them were actually contenders to win.

 

Like, maybe two or three each season? The rest of the finalists always just felt like "also rans" that could serve as a spoiler or potentially a surprise runner-up. Many of them never screamed winner.

[jetsrule128]

Cassandra Coleman needs to try again 

[aaronjudge]

Lauren Alaina would be great if she did not already have a record deal and #1 songs lol I would love to see her comedy again she was one of a kind and brought a lot to Idol she just went up against a WGWG and a country singer all in 1 or she would have won lol.

[mytake1]

1 hour ago, thenghreport said:

 

I figured for smaller labels with less strict contracts, they could probably just part ways if they viewed getting back on Idol as a big enough opportunity.

 

It actually would be embarrassing for any alum who had already been voted off by the public to compete again, especially if they have been away from the show a few years. 

 

It's saying they couldn't make a go of their career and have to come back to Idol in hopes of getting a record deal (again).

Edited May 10, 2021 by mytake1

[thenghreport]

1 hour ago, mytake1 said:

 

It actually would be embarrassing for any alum who had already been voted off by the public to compete again, especially if they have been away from the show a few years. 

 

It's saying they couldn't make a go of their career and have to come back to Idol in hopes of getting a record deal (again).

 

I think this is true for SOME seasons over others.

 

For instance, there were certain seasons, where the frontrunner was SO well-established and obvious that no one else even had a chance. I'm thinking of Season 12 where Candice was just killing it week after week. I wouldn't blame some Season 12 alumni who wanted to come back and give it another go.

[mytake1]

3 minutes ago, thenghreport said:

 

I think this is true for SOME seasons over others.

 

For instance, there were certain seasons, where the frontrunner was SO well-established and obvious that no one else even had a chance. I'm thinking of Season 12 where Candice was just killing it week after week. I wouldn't blame some Season 12 alumni who wanted to come back and give it another go.

 

But it still means your career flopped and you need to come back after being off the show 8 years.  Everyone had a chance when they competed.  It's not like Candice did anything that great after the show.

[thenghreport]

Just now, mytake1 said:

 

But it still means your career flopped and you need to come back after being off the show 8 years.  Everyone had a chance when they competed.  It's not like Candice did anything that great after the show.

 

This is true!

[countrynineteen]

Maybe Hollie Cavanaugh would audition again. 

[aaronjudge]

Nobody who made the top 10 of any show really should not come back. If they were going to make it they would have since. Could you see the pressure of lets say finishing 5th and comeback and finish 10th? that means you're worse then before and would look really stupid.

[Bunny391848]

Long time lurker (and frequent MJs commenter ). Think you all forgot some. I got a more orderly list. Took out everybody with major deals I could think of or are with 19.I left Sophia James out since I thought I heard she didn't do the Comeback due to a publishing deal?

 

Eligible previous live show finalists born post June  1992

 

S9

Aaron Kelly(Born 1993)

Katie Stevens(Born Dec 1992-Too famous to do Idol again?)

Haely Vaughn(Born 1993)

 

S10

Thia Megia(Born 1995)

Brett Lowenstern(Born 1993)

Robbie Rosen(Born 1993)

 

S11

Jessica Sanchez(Born 1995)

Hollie Cavanaugh(Born 1993)

Skylar Laine(Born 1994)

DeAndre Brackensick(Born 1994)

Eben Frankowitz(Born 1996)

Shannon Magrane(Born 1995)

Brielle Von Hogel(Born 1994)

 

S12

Angie Miller(Born 1994)

Amber Holcomb(Born 1994)

Burrnell Taylor(Born 1993)

Devin Velez(Born 1994)

Aubrey Cleland(Born 1993)

Zoanette Johnson(Born Dec 1992)

Adrianna Lationo(Born 1996)

Charlie Askew(Born 1995)

 

S13

Jena Irene(Born 1996)

Alex Preston(Born 1993)

Sam Woolf(Born 1996)

MK Nobilette( Born 1993)

Malaya Watson(Born 1997)

Emily Piriz(Born 1996)

Adrianna Brogden(Born 1995)

Kenzie Hall(Born 1997)

Brady Nelly(Born 1995)

Austin Wolfe(Born 1998)

Jordan Brisbane (Born 1998)

Ethan Harris( Born 1994)

Briston Maroney(Born 1998)

Bri Ani(Born 1998)

Brianna Oakley(Born 1997)

Marielle Sellers(Born 1997)

Malcolm Allen(Born 1993)

Spencer Lloyd(Born 1993)

 

S14

Daniel Seavy( Born 1999, Too famous to do again?)

Quasim Middleton(Born 1995)

Quentin Alexander(Born 1994)

Tyanna Jones(Born 1998)

Adanna Duru(Born 1996)

Maddie Walker(Born 1997)

Sarina-Joi Crowe(Born 1995)

Riley Brea(Born 1997)

Trevor Douglas(Born 1998)

Michael Simeon(Born 1994)

Savion Wright(Born 1995)

Shannon Berthaiume(Born 1997)

Lovey James(Born 1997)

Shi Scott(Born 1995)

Katherine Watson(Born 1996)

Adam Ezegelian(Born 1995)

Alexis Gomez(Born 1993)

Loren Lott(Born 1993- She has been on Broadway)

 

S15

 

La’Porsha Renae(Born 1993)

Dalton Rapattoni(Born 1996)

Mackenzie Bourg(Born Sept 1992, Also was on The Voice)

Sonika Vaid(Born 1995)

Tristan McIntosh(Born 2000)

Lee Jean(Born 1999)

Avalon Young(Born 1994, currently battling cancer)

Gianna Isabella(Born 2000)

Olivia Rox(Born 1999)

James VII(Born 1993)

Emily Brooke(Born 1999)

Ameilia Eisenhaurer(Born 2000)

Stephany Negrate(Born 1995)

Jenea Renae(Born 1993)

Shelbie Z(Born 1993- Was also on The Voice)

Thomas Stringfellow(Born 1999)

Manny Torres(Born 1996)

Jenn Bilosi(Born 1993)

Jeneve Mitchell(Born 2000)

 

S16

Caleb Lee Hutchinson(Born 1999)

Cade Foehner(Born 1996)

Jurnee(Born 1998)

Ada Vox(Born 1994)

Michelle Susset(Born 1995)

Mara Justine(Born 1999- Also was on AGT)

Garrett Jacobs(Born 2000)

Johnny Brennis(Born 1999)

 

S17

Madison Vandenburg(Born 2001)

Jeremiah Lloyd Harmon(Born Oct 1992)

Walker Burroughs(Born 1998)

Alyssa Raghu (Born 2002)

Uche(Born 1995)

Evelyn Cormier(Born 1999)

Eddie Island(Born 1994)

Riley Thompson(Born 2003)

Ryan Hammond(Born 1993)

Logan Johnson(Born 1996)

Raquel Trinidad(Born 1999)

Kate Barrnette(Born 1996)

Shawn Robinson(Born 1998)

 

S18(* Also performed at Comeback round S19)

*Arthur Gunn(Born 1997)

Johnny West(Born 1996)

*Louis Knight(Born 2000)

*Maykayla Phillips(Born 2002)

* Faith Bencel(Born 1999)

* Franklin Boone(Born Aug 1992)

* Dewayne Crocker Jr(Born 1996)

* Cyniah Elise(Born 2003)

Kimmy Gabriela(Born 2003)

*Alaina Jester(Born 2001)

*Nick Merico(Born 1995)

Lauren Spencer Smith(Born 2003)

*Olivia Ximies(Born 2004)

 

Edited May 11, 2021 by Bunny391848

[Elliott]

1 hour ago, Bunny391848 said:

Long time lurker (and frequent MJs commenter ). Think you all forgot some. I got a more orderly list. Took out everybody with major deals I could think of or are with 19.

There's a few more you could take out for various reasons, too:

 

S9

Katie Stevens - From what I remember, having any sort of agent or manager makes you ineligible for Idol. I doubt she'd drop her acting career to do Idol again, anyway.

 

S11

Jessica - From what I remember, signed to an indie label

Skylar Laine - No longer does music.

Eben - Has sort of recording/publishing/idk contract. He actually opened for Daniel Seavey's band on their last tour.

Brielle - Not sure if she's officially ineligible, but she does a lot of stuff with PMJ and seems to be having success there.

 

S13

Briston - Signed to an independent label and I believe has a publishing deal

 

S14

Daniel Seavey - Part of Why Don't We, signed to major label

 

S15

La'Porsha - Isn't she signed to something?

Dalton - I don't think he does music anymore

 

S16

Caleb and Garrett both have publishing deals that could render them ineligible. Furthermore, I think Garrett is on an independent but he could be putting his stuff out indepedently

 

[Elliott]

On 5/10/2021 at 11:50 AM, thenghreport said:

Makayla Phillips (Season 18th, 8th Place)

Sophia James (Season 18, 9th Place)

I know it's just your best guess, but I really doubt Makayla was 8th in the vote when she didn't make the Top 10 in votes.

[thenghreport]

1 hour ago, Elliott said:

I know it's just your best guess, but I really doubt Makayla was 8th in the vote when she didn't make the Top 10 in votes.

Eh. I dunno.

 

My theory there was based on how that episode went for the two of them (Sophia and Makayla), but yea, no one knows.

[Bunny391848]

3 hours ago, Elliott said:

There's a few more you could take out for various reasons, too:

 

S9

Katie Stevens - From what I remember, having any sort of agent or manager makes you ineligible for Idol. I doubt she'd drop her acting career to do Idol again, anyway.

 

S11

Jessica - From what I remember, signed to an indie label

Skylar Laine - No longer does music.

Eben - Has sort of recording/publishing/idk contract. He actually opened for Daniel Seavey's band on their last tour.

Brielle - Not sure if she's officially ineligible, but she does a lot of stuff with PMJ and seems to be having success there.

 

S13

Briston - Signed to an independent label and I believe has a publishing deal

 

S14

Daniel Seavey - Part of Why Don't We, signed to major label

 

S15

La'Porsha - Isn't she signed to something?

Dalton - I don't think he does music anymore

 

S16

Caleb and Garrett both have publishing deals that could render them ineligible. Furthermore, I think Garrett is on an independent but he could be putting his stuff out indepedently

 

Thank you! I'm not the biggest expert on who's who. I wasn't sure if Why Don't We was with a major label or not so I just put him down. I know Skylar became a nurse or something but said in a interview she'd be open to singing again. Would make a good sob story. Think Dalton still teaches music in Texas and had a cryptic comment on how he "wasn't a service" a few years ago.

 

 

[Carrie_On]

Sarina needs to come back!

[CarmenSandiego]

4 minutes ago, Carrie_On said:

Sarina needs to come back!

I agree!