Ep 3: Polls

[Misirlou]

Choose and rank if you so desire.

Edited March 14, 2023 by Misirlou

[StarWalker1]

Ryley, Manasseh and Laura were my top 3 of the night! Also enjoyed EJ, Walker and ALI

[erik g]

1. Ryley

2. Manasseh

3. ALI

4. Allie

5. Jerome

6. Laura

 7. Jamar

 8. EJ

9. Walker

 

looooved ryley and manasseh

Edited March 14, 2023 by erik g

[nytsch]

1. Ryley

2. Manasseh

3. Allie

 

That's all 

[Cookie73]

1. Ryley Tate Wilson

2. Manasseh
3. Allie Keck

4. EJ Michels

5. Laura Littleton

6. Jamar Langley

7. Jerome Godwin III

8. ALI

9. Walker Wilson

 

Ryley is the only audition from this episode in my overall Top 5 so far. 
 

I’ll give this episode a C. It was quite disappointing for an Episode 3, especially after a strong first week, but it had a few auditions I liked.

Edited March 14, 2023 by Cookie73

[Teraginn]

OK, all caught up now thanks to Twitter!

 

Coming on a little too strong

9. Allie Keck

 

Odd vocal placements

8. Walker Wilson

7. ALI

 

Odd arrangement

6. Laura Littleton

 

Solid AF

5. Jamar Langley

4. Manasseh Samone

3. Jerome Godwin

 

He FINNNNNNE

2. EJ Michels

 

Surprisingly great!

1. Ryley-Tate Wilson

[Misirlou]

Nuance and vocal maturity at that age is always great to see and hear.

1. Ryley

 

What can I say, I´m a sucker for a good rasp.

2. Walker

 

Great job

3. Allie

4. Manasseh 

 

Solid, but parts didn´t work.

5. Laura

6. EJ

 

Strong ending and good runs when confident, but it didn´t come together as well as I hoped it would.

7. ALI

 

Nice tone, that´s about it.

8. Jamar 

 

This did nothing for me.

9. Jerome

[QueenCami]

1 hour ago, Teraginn said:

Coming on a little too strong

9. Allie Keck

[QueenCami]

1 hour ago, nytsch said:

0. Jerome

1. Ryley

2. Manasseh

3. Allie

 

That's all 

love this list!

[nytsch]

3 minutes ago, QueenCami said:

love this list!

 

I may have to cancel you if you actually liked Jerome more than Manasseh  /lh

[Someone648]

1 hour ago, Teraginn said:

Coming on a little too strong

9. Allie Keck

[Someone648]

Liked all of them, don't think any were bad, but the only one that neared the WOW tier for me was Ryley.

1. Ryley Tate-Wilson

2.Allie Keck

3. Manasseh Samone

4. ALI

5. EJ Michels

6. Laura Littleton

7. Jamar Langley

8. Walker Wilson

9. Jerome Godwin

 

[StarWalker1]

My Rankings after relistening:

 

GREAT!!!

1. Ryley

 

Pretty good! A few imperfections here and there

2. Manasseh

3. Laura

4. Allie

 

Solid, albeit the imperfections kinda detracted me a bit

5. EJ

6. ALI

7. Walker

 

Eh

8. Jamar

 

Nope

9. Jerome

Edited March 14, 2023 by StarWalker1

[QueenCami]

1. Ryley

2. Jerome

3. Allie

4. Jamar (idk how he ended up here but apparently i liked it on a relisten ???)

5. Laura

6. Mannasseh

7. ALI

8. Walker

9. EJ

[Hamza Tufail]

1. Ryley

2. Ej

3. Laura

4/5. Jamar/Allie

6. Manasseh

7. Jerome

8. ALI

9. Walker

[FloorWax]

Dang EJ is pretty polarizing on here huh

 

Still love it

1. Ryley Tate Wilson

 

There were issues but I enjoyed this a lot

2. EJ Michels

 

Good but didn’t wow me

3. Manasseh Samone

 

Good but had issues that held them back

4. Walker Wilson (I actually really like his natural tone, but the growls were forced and unpleasant. The first 30 seconds were some of my favorite singing so far this season though )

5. Jamar Langley

6. Allie Keck

7. Laura Littleton

 

Some of the weakest auditions so far imo

8. Jerome Godwin

9. ALI

Edited March 14, 2023 by FloorWax

[Hamza Tufail]

2 hours ago, FloorWax said:

Dang EJ is pretty polarizing on here huh

 

Still love it

1. Ryley Tate Wilson

 

There were issues but I enjoyed this a lot

2. EJ Michels

 

Good but didn’t wow me

3. Manasseh Samone

 

Good but had issues that held them back

4. Walker Wilson (I actually really like his natural tone, but the growls were forced and unpleasant. The first 30 seconds were some of my favorite singing so far this season though )

5. Jamar Langley

6. Allie Keck

7. Laura Littleton

 

Some of the weakest auditions so far imo

8. Jerome Godwin

9. ALI

Yeah, Walker's beginning was amazing. Then, the excessive growls ruined it for me.

[Gustavo527]

I enjoyed their tones, but their performances were far from perfect 

9. Jamar 

8. ALI

7. Jerome 

 

50/50

6. Walker 

5. Laura 

 

Good performances, but i can't really get into their tones. They still deserve to be ranked this high 

4. Allie

3. EJ 

 

I loved it, but something was missing 

2. Manasseh 

 

Ok kid, you win this one.

1. Ryley

 

[FloorWax]

1 minute ago, Gustavo527 said:

I enjoyed their tones, but their performances were far from perfect 

9. Jamar 

8. ALI

7. Jerome 

 

50/50

6. Walker 

5. Laura 

 

Good performances, but i can't really get into their tones. They still deserve to be ranked this high 

4. Allie

3. EJ 

 

I loved it, but something was missing 

2. Manasseh 

 

Ok kid, you win this one.

1. Ryley

 

 

Didn’t expect you of all people to be one of the 3(?) people to not put Walker in their Bottom 2 lol

[Misirlou]

Never did I expect a white teenage boy crushing an AA powerhouse in a poll. I did expect the country singer on last place within many lists though. 50/50 for IDF predictability.

Edited March 14, 2023 by Misirlou

[Gustavo527]

4 minutes ago, FloorWax said:

 

Didn’t expect you of all people to be one of the 3(?) people to not put Walker in their Bottom 2 lol

I actually enjoyed the raspiness, even if there was a lot of it. 

[FloorWax]

3 minutes ago, Misirlou said:

Never did I expect a white teenage boy crushing an AA powerhouse in a poll. I did expect the country singer on last place within many lists though. 50/50 for IDF predictability.

 

DANGGGG she got 1 vote I didn’t even notice. IDF was so hyped for her too.

[allistr]

Winner
1. Ryley

A bit flat but still really wonderful
2. Manasseh

Underrated
3. EJ
4. Allie
5. Jerome


6. Laura

Like the tone better than the performance
7. ALI
8. Jamar
9. Walker


 

[Gustavo527]

4 minutes ago, Misirlou said:

Never did I expect a white teenage boy crushing an AA powerhouse in a poll. I did expect the country singer on last place within many lists though. 50/50 for IDF predictability.

Actually, i think it's because the expectations for white teenages boys are usually on the floor, and IMO Ryley excedeed them by a good margin. While, on the other hand, expectations for AA performances are high, and Manasseh honestly didn't quite meet them. And Ryley's audition ended being overall more solid, despite Manasseh being a better vocalist.

[Gustavo527]

2 minutes ago, allistr said:

6. Laura

I don't really know what this means but i somehow i kind of get it at the same time??  I was tempted to put her in her own category and just name the category "Laura" just like i did with Sorelle