Jump to content

Rank the Performances - S20, Top 20


Elliott
 Share

Recommended Posts

Emyrson Flora - "Tell Me You Love Me" (Demi Lovato)
Mike Parker - "Chasing After You" (Ryan Hurd & Maren Morris)
Tristen Gressett - "Sacrifice" (The Weeknd)
Sage - "Rhiannon" (Fleetwood Mac)
Jay Copeland - "You Know I'm No Good" (Amy Winehouse)
Nicolina Bozzo - "Edge of Seventeen" (Stevie Nicks)
Jacob Moran - "Don't You Worry 'Bout a Thing" (Stevie Wonder)
Huntergirl - "Heartbreak Down" (Huntergirl)
Elli Rowe - "Somewhere Only We Know" (Keane)
Dan Marshall - "Friends in Low Places" (Garth Brooks)
Ava Maybee - "Anyone" (Demi Lovato)
Allegra Miles - "Free Fallin'" (Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers)
Noah Thompson - "Falling" (Harry Styles)
Leah Marlene - "Heal" (Tom O'Dell)
Christian Guardino - "Imagine" (John Lennon)
Fritz Hager - "when the party's over" (Billie Eilish)
Katyrah Love - "Dream" (Bishop Briggs)
Cameron Whitcomb - "Changes" (Black Sabbath)
Cadence Baker - "Train Wreck" (James Arthur)
Lady K - "Love on the Brain" (Rihanna)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In It To Win It Tier

 

1. Huntergirl

2. Allegra Miles

3. Leah Marlene

4. Jay

5. Katyrah Love

6. Dan Marshall

7. Cadence Baker

8. Nicolina

9. Sage

 

Good Enough to Get My Votes Tier:

 

10. Mike Parker

11. Tristen Gressett

12. Christian Guardino

13. Lady K

 

It Was Aight Dawg Tier:

 

14. Emyrson Flora

15. Noah Thompson

16. Ava Maybee

 

Not Feeling It Tier:

 

17. Jacob Moran

18. Fritz Hager

 

I'll Be Mad If You're In the Top 14 Tier:

 

19. Elli Rowe

 

I'll Be Even Madder If You're In the Top 14 Than I Already Am That You're In The Top 20 Tier:

 

20. Cameron Whitcomb

 

...and TBH, I might vote for Emyrson, too. I feel weird voting for literally enough people that even one person not getting my votes making it through means one that got my votes didn't, but honestly, I just want Cameron, Elli, and Fritz gone, and I'm not too keen on the idea of Noah sticking around since my verdict on him is "aggressively nondescript"; that is, he's too boring to even dislike.

Edited by ScarletDevilCCX
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Leah Marlene

2. Christian Guardino

 

3. Lady K

4. Jay Copeland
5. Katyrah Love

6. Fritz Hagar

7. Nicolina Bozzo

 

8. Dan Marshall

9. Ava Maybee

10. Huntergirl

 

11. Allegra Miles

12. Sage McNeely

13. Mike Parker

14. Jacob Moran

15. Elli Rowe

16. Cadence Baker

17. Tristen Gressett

18. Emyrson Flora

19. Cameron Whitcomb

20. Noah Thompson

 

3-7 could have been the "best performance of the night" in most other weeks :omg: 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Allegra Miles

2. Lady K

3. Ava Maybee

4. Fritz Hager

5. Leah Marlene

6. Jay

 

7. Nicolina

8. Christian

 

9. Katyrah

10. Jacob Moran

11. Emyrson Flora

12. Huntergirl

 

13. Cameron

14. Noah

15. Elli

 

16. Sage


 

17. Dan

18. Candace

19. Tristen

20. Mike 

Edited by erik g
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Leah

2. Fritz

3. Allegra 

4. Ava

5. Elli

6. Jacob

7. Nicolina

8. Katryah

9. Huntergirl

10. Cameron 

11. Lady K

12. Christian

13. Emersyn

14. Noah

15. Mike

16. Jay

17. Cadence

18. Dan

19. Tristen

20. Sage

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

King and Queen
1 Fritz

2 Leah


Amazing
3 Sage

4 Lady K

5 Elli

6 Tristen 

 

Solid
7 Katyrah

8 Jay

9 Ava

10 Emyrson

11 Dan

12 Christian


Good but not my favorite 

13 Jacob

14 Allegra 

15 Cadece

16 Mike

17 Huntergirl


Didn’t like it 
18 Nicolina

19 Noah

20 Cameron

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Queens 

1. HunterGirl 

2. Allegra 

3. Leah 

 

Solid performances

4. Lady K. 

5. Fritz 

6. Jacob 

7. Emyrson  

 

Good but they can do better

8. Nicolina 

9. Jay

10. Mike

11. Sage 

12 Christian 

 

Decent 

13. Elli 

14. Noah

15. Ava

 

Underwhelming

16. Katyrah 

17. Cadence

18. Dan 

 

Yikes 😬

19. Tristen 

20. Cameron 

 

Apparently a lot of people liked Jay so i re-listened to his performance and i realized that when i put him that low was probably because i have big standards when people cover Amy. I don't liked the arrangement but vocally, he was pretty good.

 

 

Edited by Gustavo527
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So much meh tonight.

1. Leah Marlene (9.5) - I think I'm officially rooting for this girl to win. Commenting as I watch in order on YT, but she's the only one that truly made me stop and watch.

2. Nicolina (8.5) - Wasn't sure how to feel at first, but it was a smooth vocal the whole way through, so I can't complain.

3. Noah Thompson (8.5) - A great flip on the song! Definitely can see him making the finale.

 

4. Lady K (8) - A solid end to the night and lightyears better than last week.

5. Cameron Whitcomb (8) - Now one of my favorite tones in the competition. I appreciate him dialing it back (at least for a bit). Also we stan Big Mouth.

6. HunterGirl (8) - The song's alright. She performed it well. Nothing I'd give multiple listens though.

7. Fritz Hager (8) - Haven't really been a fan of his up to this point, but this was undeniably solid. Pretty good job.

8. Allegra Miles (8) - Pleased to say she's shown improvement since her time on The Voice. This proves it. Better enunciation for sure.

9. Jay Copeland (8) - Much better than last week's disappointment, but still all over at times.

10. Jacob Moran (8) - Acceptable. I didn't have high hopes for it but he did a decent job overall.

11. Katyrah Love (8) - She's great, but this wasn't the best song choice for her.

12. Elli Rowe (8) - Much prefer this compared to last week. Shaky still, but progress. Would like to see her continue to grow.

 

13. Sage (7.5) - Started out well but then became a bit wobbly. Meh. Not a trainwreck.

14. Emyrson Flora (7.5) - A step down from last week. I do hope she goes through but the song as maybe a tad bit too big.

15. Christian Guardino (7.5) - Liked the arrangement but his voice didn't work for it, personally. Tears are gonna get him through despite being lower tier.

16. Ava Maybee (7.5) - It was fine but with this song, I need the singer to go all out and she didn't.

17. Dan Marshall (7.5) - It was fine. Just fine, really.

18. Mike Parker (7) - I like Mike but this was really bad compared to other weeks.

19. Cadence Baker (7) - That's the song title, not a description of how to perform it, Cadence.

20. Tristen Gressett (6.5) - I can respect the risk but this was really just not good. Tough to watch and listen to. 

 

A shame since these three singers on the bottom are ones I've previously enjoyed.

 

 

 

 

Edited by Someone648
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Holy s***
1. Leah

 

Good job!

2. Christian

3. Allegra

4. Nicolina

5. Lady K

6. Jay

7. Fritz

8. Ava

 

Ok

9. Noah

10. Hunter

11. Jacob

12. Katyrah

13. Emyrson

 

Meh

14. Cameron

15. Elli

16. Sage

17. Tristen

18. Mike

19. Cadence

20. Dan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The top 11 were really great for me.

My order-

Leah

Christian

Jay

Nicolina

Katyrah

Lady K

Allegra

Emyrson

Cadence

Cameron

Fritz

Hunter

Elli

Dan

Noah

Jacob

Mike

Tristen

Ava

Sage

Edited by haribobo
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So I went through the posts so far and assigned 10 points for every 1st place, down to 1 point for 10th place.  Here are our collective standings so far-

 

Leah 81

Allegra 51

Lady K 49

Fritz 45

Jay 40

Nicolina 39

Christian 30

Hunter 29

Katyrah 27

Ava 22

Jacob & Elli 12

Noah & Sage 10

Daniel & Cameron & Emyrson 8

Cadence 6

Tristen 5

Mike 3

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Group 1:

Elli Rowe - "Somewhere Only We Know" (Keane)

Huntergirl - "Heartbreak Down" (Huntergirl)

Mike Parker - "Chasing After You" (Ryan Hurd & Maren Morris)

Dan Marshall - "Friends in Low Places" (Garth Brooks)

Emyrson Flora - "Tell Me You Love Me" (Demi Lovato)

Jacob Moran - "Don't You Worry 'Bout a Thing" (Stevie Wonder)
Tristen Gressett - "Sacrifice" (The Weeknd)

Nicolina Bozzo - "Edge of Seventeen" (Stevie Nicks)
Sage - "Rhiannon" (Fleetwood Mac)
Jay Copeland - "You Know I'm No Good" (Amy Winehouse)
 

Group 2:

Fritz Hager - "when the party's over" (Billie Eilish)

Leah Marlene - "Heal" (Tom O'Dell)

Allegra Miles - "Free Fallin'" (Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers)

Ava Maybee - "Anyone" (Demi Lovato)

Lady K - "Love on the Brain" (Rihanna)

Cameron Whitcomb - "Changes" (Black Sabbath)

Katyrah Love - "Dream" (Bishop Briggs)
Noah Thompson - "Falling" (Harry Styles)

Christian Guardino - "Imagine" (John Lennon)
Cadence Baker - "Train Wreck" (James Arthur)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Fritz

2. Elli

3. Ava

4. Jay

5. Noah

6. Leah

7. Hunter

8. Lady K

9. Cameron

10. Emyrson

11. Cadence

12. Christian

13. Katyrah

14. Mike

15. Nicolina

16. Allegra

17. Jacob

18. Dan

19. Tristen

20. Sage

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1.  Allegra -- this was the performance that she needed!

2.  Leah -- that was my favorite performance from her!

3.  Emyrson -- she's really coming into her own now.

4.  Nicolina -- I always enjoyed powerhouse vocals, and she has them.

5.  Lady K. -- she did a fine job with her song.

6.  Fritz -- best of the males and the white guys with guitars.

7.  Elli -- I enjoyed her song even if she doesn't have the biggest voice.

8.  Huntergirl -- not really my cup of tea but she was still very good.

9.  Christian -- fine performance but that "YOU" was unnecessary.

10.  Jay -- I hope that he squeaks into the Top 10 with this.

11.  Katyrah -- I love her but this wasn't as good as last week.

12.  Mike -- best of the male country sngers.

13.  Cadence -- lovely but there were so many other fine performances that she's this low.

14.  Ava -- began slow but got into her stride halfway during her song.

15.  Noah -- he sang the song well, but it's overdone and he's boring.  :yawnwave:

16.  Jacob -- too much wailing for my taste.

17.  Sage -- I love the song, but I didn't love it on her the second time around.

18.  Tristen -- not his best vocal performance and the song wasn't my cup of tea.

19.  Dan -- better than last week but still the worst of the three country guys.

20.  Cameron -- much better than last week, but this song really isn't my cup of tea.  He's also still a little too much.Hun

Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 hours ago, Gustavo527 said:

Apparently a lot of people liked Jay so i re-listened to his performance and i realized that when i put him that low was probably because i have big standards when people cover Amy. I don't liked the arrangement but vocally, he was pretty good.

 

 

Understandable. There are certain artists or songs that I'm like that for (I didn't think Elli was that good regardless, but I absolutely love that song so I was probably extra-harsh), and I honestly think that Ava could've scored higher if she hadn't chosen such an ambitious song.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Nicolina - She's going for her rock side, well,  sort of karaoke for me. Anyway, it was decent. 

2. Jacob - That was totally a wrong song choice and the arrangement showed his high pitched screams too often.

3. Jay - He always have solid performance but he still doesn't so better than that so far.

4. Mike - I wasn't feeling this song, but his voice needs another chance.

5. Tristen - We all know he's quite confident in staging, that's it.

6. Elli - Forgettable again.

7. Emyrson - Okay,  the verse sounded pretty and then she went messy just like her performance last week. She should avoid chorus of any song.

8. Dan - Lords have some mercy on me, send him home plz.

9. Huntergirl - Chayce sang his original amazing, and she did her original like nobody was going to stream it after that.

10. Sage - Maybe I'm too familiar with the song, I just hated it very much tbh. Sigh, I really like her tone.

 

 

1. Leah - I got goosebumps. OMFG this girl is totally beyond my expectations. A truly winner potential here.

2. Fritz - I just hope he will go very far because I don't believe in American COUNTRY Idol voting mess.

3. Katyrah - Nice, but she still didn't choose a right song.

4. Allegra - Good, but she can do better with another song actually suiting her voice.

5. Lady K - This was just okay. There are many better performances of this overdone song on Youtube. 

6. Christina - Why destroyed the original melody so much and it didn't even sound good.

7. Cameron - I don't know what to say about this boy.  

8. Noah - At least he didn't sing those boring country songs.

9. Ava - She sounded like a ghost in the beginning and then stepped it up alright.

10. Candence - HORRIFIC. lol at what the judges said, are they members of World Peace Council? 

 

 

Overall

1. Leah

2. Fritz

3. Nicolina

4-20. The others

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

1.    Leah Marlene - Heal
2.    Jay - You Know I'm No Good
3.    Lady K - Love on the Brain
4.    Fritz Hager - when the party's over
5.    Ava Maybee - Anyone
6.    Christian Guardino - Imagine
7.    Katyrah Love - Dream
8.    Nicolina - Edge of Seventeen
9.    Jacob Moran - Don't You Worry 'Bout a Thing
10.    Emyrson Flora - Tell Me You Love Me
11.    Allegra Miles -  Free Fallin'
12.    Huntergirl - Heartbreak Down
13.    Mike Parker - Chasing After You
14.    Ellie Rowe - Somewhere Only We Know
15.    Noah Thompson - Falling
16.    Cadence Baker - Train Wreck
17.    Cameron Whitcomb - Changes
18.    Dan Marshall - Friends in Low Places
19.    Tristen Gressett - Sacrifice
20.    Sage - Rhiannon
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...