Who's winning season 19? (Post-comeback edition)

[CandiceFan12]

Discuss.

[m1key]

Want: Casey, Grace

Think: Chayce

[KelseyW]

Casey!! I am determined to get Idol's first rocker girl. To be fair... My AI at ABC track record so far...

 

1. Maddie Poppe (Cade was my early favorite...) - WINNER.

2. Alejandro Aranda- Runner Up

3. Arthur Gunn- Runner Up

 

So far so good...  

[Bk1234]

1 hour ago, KelseyW said:

 

1. Maddie Poppe (Cade was my early favorite...) - WINNER.

2. Alejandro Aranda- Runner Up

3. Arthur Gunn- Runner Up

1. Jurnee - 6th/7th Place

2. Ashley Hess - Semis

3. Makayla Phillips - Top 11 

 

(I’m clearly not as lucky... ) 

[MargoK]

54 minutes ago, Bk1234 said:

1. Jurnee - 6th/7th Place

2. Ashley Hess - Semis

3. Makayla Phillips - Top 11 

 

(I’m clearly not as lucky... ) 

 

[MargoK]

Want: Grace, Willie or Casey 

 

Think: Arthur or Chayce 

[KelseyW]

To be fair. Talent always seems to be a good leading controller with ABC Idols. Like. It's Casey's to lose but anyone's game if that makes sense?

[Usisnww]

Want: Hunter, Caleb, Willie

Think: Chayce 

[Usisnww]

Oh god I just realized Arther won the comeback 

[blackfield]

if Arthur is in then prepare for Arthur-Willie top 2. they have the biggest fan bases and their social media numbers are much higher than anyone else. 

Grace will make top 3. 

 

[Bill B]

Cassandra never should made it past the original auditions, she's 2 young.  Give her 2 or more seasons to try again.. She could never beat Alyssa (the next American Idol!!!!)

[Angeles]

1 minute ago, Bill B said:

Cassandra never should made it past the original auditions, she's 2 young.  Give her 2 or more seasons to try again.. She could never beat Alyssa (the next American Idol!!!!)

Regardless of age, Cassandra is talented! 

[Bill B]

Cassandra has a good voice granted but there's no power there.

[CarmenSandiego]

I prefer Alyssa but I think that it’s going to be Casey who wins.  But I like her voice as well.

[kamil24]

5 hours ago, Bill B said:

Cassandra never should made it past the original auditions, she's 2 young.  Give her 2 or more seasons to try again.. She could never beat Alyssa (the next American Idol!!!!)

She's the oldest one left (with Chayce)

[wgm]

Want to win females:

1. Grace

2. Casey

3. Cassandra 

 

Want to win Males:

 

1. Willie

2. Caleb 

3. Chayce