Best Top 12 Performance Of S25 (rate the round and pick which team performed best)

[Hsamid]

Pick. Will add the song names later

[AliXRose]

1. Nathan
2. Team D+S
3. B (Solid)

[QueenKalie]

1. Josh

2. Reba

3. C

[xfactor22]

Nathan 

 Reba , but it’s close 

either A- or B+

[indii]

My top 5 of the night:

1. Zoe

2. Karen

3. Madison

4. Nadege

5. Nathan

 

Team D&S

 

B-

[allistr]

Nathan was the best of the night, but I wanted to give Madison a vote. Cuz that was beautiful and flawless. Top 2 of the night for me.

HM: Karen and Asher

 

Team D+S ( liked every single performance of them all), Team Reba is close too!

 

B

Edited May 7 by allistr

[StarWalker1]

Madison, with Asher and Nathan right behind. HM goes to Karen

 

Best performing team: Reba

 

Grade of episode: B

[MusicBuff101]

Ate down

1. Nathan

2. Madison

3. Asher

 

Y’all were really good and stepped it up from last round

4. Karen

5. Nadége

 

Solid performances that deserve to go through

6. Josh

7. Tae

 

Varying degrees of rough (but i enjoyed all of them to an extent)

8. Maddi

9. L

10. Zoe
11. Bryan

12. Serenity

 

Dan and Shay’s team did the best

Edited May 7 by MusicBuff101

[Persy]

1. Nathan Chester

2. Asher HaVon

3. Karen Waldrup

4. Madison Curbelo

5. Josh Sanders

6. Nadege

7. Maddi Jane

8. L. Rodgers

9. Zoe Levert

10. Tae Lewis

11. Bryan Olesen

12. Serenity Arce

 

Team Reba for me

 

I gave it an A because I really enjoyed everyone so far. 

[New but Old]

Asher

Nathan

Madison

 

Dan+Shay

 

C - Average

 

But I think I voted below average, something seems of with the performances. 

[season1]

Madison 

D

 

Nathan and Karen round up the Top 3 for me.

[*Wallace]

1. Nathan Chester - Higher and Higher
2. Madison Curbelo - Yesterday
3. Asher Havon - I'll Make Love to You
4. L. Rodgers - Up to the Mountain
5. Tae Lewis - 19 You + Me
6. Nadège - He Loves Me
7. Karen Waldrup - I Hope You Dance 
8. Josh Sanders - Angels (Don't Always Have Wings) 
9. Maddi Jane - Happier Than Ever
10. Serenity Arce - traitor
11. Zoe Levert - Stick Season
12. Bryan Olesen - Don't Stop Me Now

 

My votes via the poll: Nathan / Team Dan + Shay / I'll go with a solid B 
 

[Hamza Tufail]

Madison

Team D+S

B