Huntley vs Chloe Kohanski

[Hsamid]

Although they sing different types of rock, they are also our only winners from that genre. Who do you prefer?

Edited December 30, 2023 by Hsamid

[Hamza Tufail]

Landslide and Daylight are my top 2 favs. Voted for the latter because Landslide is gonna win anyway.

 

Huntley. Dude never faltered.

[nytsch]

Higher (yes I liked this more than Landslide, sue me) ftr if I was voting for Chloe I would've picked TEOTH

 

Huntley

[Someone648]

This poll was made to kill me, huh?

[Hsamid]

16 hours ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Landslide and Daylight are my top 2 favs. Voted for the latter because Landslide is gonna win anyway.

 

Huntley. Dude never faltered.

Did Chloe falter though?

 

I'd say Huntley's performances on average, were on a higher level by virtue of being the more impressive vocalist. But that's not to say Chloe had a "bad" performance by any means. 

[nytsch]

1 hour ago, Hsamid said:

Did Chloe falter though?

 

I'd say Huntley's performances on average, were on a higher level by virtue of being the more impressive vocalist. But that's not to say Chloe had a "bad" performance by any means. 

She didn’t have like a train wreck performance but I didn’t think Thank You or either of her finale performances were very good.

[StarWalker1]

1 hour ago, Hsamid said:

Did Chloe falter though?

 

I'd say Huntley's performances on average, were on a higher level by virtue of being the more impressive vocalist. But that's not to say Chloe had a "bad" performance by any means. 

Chloe had more "less" stellar performances during the late parts of her run, so Huntley was more consistent. But when Chloe was at her BEST, she was just on a different level

[Misirlou]

Just give me these two singing Broken (Seether ft Amy Lee), or Gimme Shelter (Rolling Stones) together.

[QueenKalie]

Chloe lost her voice during the finale so her finale performances weren't that great. But the show used to be a lot of more demanding you used to have to sing a lot more songs and it lasted a lot longer. So I am surprised that didn't happen more often than it actually did. That's what makes it hard to compare past with present singers. Chloe definitely had a lot more high highs then Huntley did though. While I think Huntley was good I think he greatly benefited from The Voice not having a lot of rockers on the show and the ones that they had didn't do very good so that helped him look beter than he actually probably is. 

Edited December 30, 2023 by QueenKalie

[Hsamid]

18 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

Chloe lost her voice during the finale so her finale performances weren't that great. But the show used to be a lot of more demanding you used to have to sing a lot more songs and it lasted a lot longer. So I am surprised that didn't happen more often than it actually did. That's what makes it hard to compare past with present singers. Chloe definitely had a lot more high highs then Huntley did though. While I think Huntley was good I think he greatly benefited from The Voice not having a lot of rockers on the show and the ones that they had didn't do very good so that helped him look beter than he actually probably is. 

You called a male vocalist good so that's already a win for Huntley tbh.

[QueenKalie]

15 minutes ago, Hsamid said:

You called a male vocalist good so that's already a win for Huntley tbh.

I thought about adding ish after good but I decided to be nice and not do that.

[istersay]

17 hours ago, Someone648 said:

This poll was made to kill me, huh?

MTE hard choices

[eidi]

7 hours ago, QueenKalie said:

Chloe lost her voice during the finale so her finale performances weren't that great. But the show used to be a lot of more demanding you used to have to sing a lot more songs and it lasted a lot longer. So I am surprised that didn't happen more often than it actually did. That's what makes it hard to compare past with present singers. Chloe definitely had a lot more high highs then Huntley did though. While I think Huntley was good I think he greatly benefited from The Voice not having a lot of rockers on the show and the ones that they had didn't do very good so that helped him look beter than he actually probably is. 

Omar, Todd, Jake and many other rock singers say hi. Unfortunately they did not win but they are far from not being “very good”.

[QueenKalie]

Just now, eidi said:

Omar, Todd, Jake and many other rock singers say hi. Unfortunately they did not win but they are far from not being “very good”.

2 out of the 3 people you listed aren't even rock singers. Even if they were 3 in 25 seasons isn't a lot so not sure what your point is.

[eidi]

3 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

2 out of the 3 people you listed aren't even rock singers. Even if they were 3 in 25 seasons isn't a lot so not sure what your point is.

Are you sure? And I gave these 3 examples from recent seasons but there are many more…

 

https://toddmichaelhall.com/about-todd/

 

In 2019, Todd independently released more solo music in the light rock style via four 3-song EP’s – Air, Earth, Fire, and Water – which are available through all digital download and streaming services. 
 

http://brotherhoodoftheguitar.com/?team=jake-haldenwang

Haldenwang, is a naturally gifted guitarist, singer/song writer, who developed a deep passion for music through his father’s extensive CD & DVD collection of everything from original roots blues, soul, R&B, folk, modern & good ole’ vintage rock & roll. 
 

https://hollywoodlife.com/feature/who-is-omar-jose-cardona-the-voice-4908296/amp/

 

 

singer/song writer, who developed a deep passion for music through his father’s extensive CD & DVD collection of everything from original roots blues, soul, R&B, folk, modern & good ole’ vintage rock & roll. 
 

 

https://hollywoodlife.com/feature/who-is-omar-jose-cardona-the-voice-4908296/amp/
 

Omar told the coaches that he’s performed all over the world — over 20 countries! He also revealed that he hopes to be able to “create a little genre of pop and old-school rock” to suit his voice. 

[QueenKalie]

12 minutes ago, eidi said:

Are you sure? And I gave these 3 examples from recent seasons but there are many more…

 

https://toddmichaelhall.com/about-todd/

 

In 2019, Todd independently released more solo music in the light rock style via four 3-song EP’s – Air, Earth, Fire, and Water – which are available through all digital download and streaming services. 
 

http://brotherhoodoftheguitar.com/?team=jake-haldenwang

Haldenwang, is a naturally gifted guitarist, singer/song writer, who developed a deep passion for music through his father’s extensive CD & DVD collection of everything from original roots blues, soul, R&B, folk, modern & good ole’ vintage rock & roll. 
 

https://hollywoodlife.com/feature/who-is-omar-jose-cardona-the-voice-4908296/amp/

 

 

singer/song writer, who developed a deep passion for music through his father’s extensive CD & DVD collection of everything from original roots blues, soul, R&B, folk, modern & good ole’ vintage rock & roll. 
 

 

https://hollywoodlife.com/feature/who-is-omar-jose-cardona-the-voice-4908296/amp/
 

Omar told the coaches that he’s performed all over the world — over 20 countries! He also revealed that he hopes to be able to “create a little genre of pop and old-school rock” to suit his voice. 

oh that's a different todd and Jake then I was thinking of but those 2 aren't even good.

Edited December 31, 2023 by QueenKalie

[eidi]

2 hours ago, QueenKalie said:

oh that's a different todd and Jake then I was thinking of but those 2 aren't even good.

 

That's a matter of taste anyways.

[AliXRose]

1. Landslide - Chloe K
2. Huntley was a bit more consistent

[Hsamid]

On 12/31/2023 at 12:02 AM, eidi said:

 

That's a matter of taste anyways.

Yeah, TMH is fronting a metal band thats been active since 1977 and is fairly well known (within its genre). Metal is pretty demanding vocally, especially when it comes to belting.

 

There's no denying his talent.