QueenCami

I don't think that Shalyah "annihilated" Emily, but they were both excellent, and Shalyah's powerhouse performance definitely came off as more impressive. also in general I love your commentary and the way you phrase it lmao, iconic. I always find it hilarous when y'all say one person ate another LOL

I prefer a lot of the singers they mentioned, but I don't think that all R&B/pop singers "bring some spark" and I don't think all country singers don't have that spark. I think Lauren Duski had that spark in terms of emoting a ton. However, there are R&B singers that I don't think have that spark (and I can think of one from this season, but I suspect I will get backlash from saying their name lmao). A lot of it comes down to opinion though! And we are all entitled to our own opinions for whether or not we like certain artists, and that's okay! (This post is not meant at all to be argumentative or meant to blame or anything, hopefully it doesn't come across that way! )

imo, kenzie has the potential to emote more, he just hasn't gotten a great song for that yet. he got a bro country song for the knockouts! you can't really expect people to emote a ton on that (and i thought he did a great job upping the energy to match that song, which is difficult in itself) give him an emotional ballad, and then we can talk

It's so funny they were trying to be quirky but they all did the same thing LMAO

Still a queen, five years ago

I came here expecting drama when I saw that the thread was locked, but it is a pleasant surprise to see that it was just off-topic conversation. I can see why you'd say that, we don't know how he would have been w song choices. But to be fair, I think that we here at IDF overestimate the importance of the coach in selecting song choices. It probably comes down to the contestant (10-25%) and the producers (75-90%), if I had to guess. However, as y'all know, I know nothing more than you guys so it's just an educated guess.

and Grace doing Adele!!!! i'm so excited, i love adele, especially that song can i get an amen, feels like the holy ghost running through you when i play the highway FM, i find my soul's revival, singing every single day, yeah i guess that's my church

haven't even clicked on the video (too busy listening to jacquie lee's ipasoy on spotify), but i can already tell this was probably.... very questionable to put it lightly LMAO

that actually made me laugh out loud lmao vocally, micah was stronger, but i preferred gigi's tone.

right, i think something like that can be rephrased to "i really dislike anna grace's tone" or something like that and for that example, it's not only that it's phrased like a fact, but also that it's just plain mean lmao (we all have our moments, but some more than others )

yeah i think the only way you'll get flack for not including imo or something is if you phrase it like a fact (or if you criticize maelyn or another idf darling, even an "imo" won't save you from that LMAO)

she emphasized the voting thing a lot in her post, hopefully that's a sign she won!

i personally loved her performance, but we all have our opinions!

Yeah, I thought Olivia gave cleaner vocals. However, after many repeats, I found that I did enjoy the texture of Tamara's voice and the imperfections in her singing, kind of. Yeah, I didn't think that Tamara gave any great performances other than "Crazy." Even her knockout didn't do much for me.

mte, i think that carolina has the win, but emma could put up a fight. savanna didn't have the views/likes to match up to carolina anywhere. there could be people who just watch once on the show and vote, though, i have no idea how numerous they are.

The audience doesn't always reward great performances. Keisha's semifinals performance is a reminder of that.

that's one knockout that contains two performances (thus, the views for corey and ryleigh's kos would be pooled together). as opposed to three separate knockouts that contain one performance. if you consider the sum of the views for the knockout pairings of s13, there'd surely be way more than 3 (which is still greater than 1 anyway).

Don't knockouts (even the ones with two performances) rarely reach 1M nowadays (well after the season is over)? This is while the season isn't even over and they already have three performances with over 1M views.

I am a fan of Jordan and this is an excellent performance, but I agree. Plus, it's so easy to find this performance online lmao, give us something harder to find!

Yeah all good if your opinions don't match up, I was going off of what you posted yesterday which seemed to be more similar to what IDF thinks than Charlie's rather interesting rankings. However, I think it's more interesting if your rankings do differ a little, it'll make things a little less predictable. I'm very excited!

i have one that works for three people so im waiting to see if i can get a fourth to work so i can post on here - i'm excited

Yup, I thought the same. Nick seemed to like him so I thought he'd blindly go with his mini-Nick, but I was pleasantly surprised when he picked Roderick, who won the knockout pretty clearly for me.

Charlie Mason except the reviews are well-thought out and fit with IDF's biases lmao, I'm excited!

I expect 10M+ for the audition in which Ariana inevitably sings with a contestant.

Perhaps he did so well on his first rehearsal he didn't need to go again