Dai

That cover of Cellophane is amazing!! And it’s a crime that A Dustland Fairytale hasn’t been covered in any singing show yet. I’m sure Matt McAndrew would have killed it.

Sia - I’m In Here (Piano Version) Oasis - The Masterplan The Weeknd - Wicked Games Bon Iver - Holocene Hozier - Cherry Wine Killers - A Dustland Fairytale P!nk - Sober Lana del Rey - Video Games Birdy - Wings Bleachers - Don’t Take the Money Tom Odell - Another Love Fka Twigs - Cellophane

1. Todd 2. CWB 3. Adam 4. Sundance All of the others didn’t deserve finale IMO.

From Eden - Hozier Do I Wanna Know? - Arctic Monkeys A Dustland Fairytale - The Killers Champagne Supernova - Oasis If I am forced to pick a coach, I would probably pick Blake.

Voted. Michelle vs Josh was the toughest matchup for me.

She is one of my favorites from what I have seen so far, but in a few of her covers she botches some notes when she belts. However, she has a great tone and a stunning head voice, so that should be enough if she plays smart (Addison didn’t belt that often, she used her great head voice instead)

Jeffery Austin - Make It Rain Chris Jamison - Georgia On My Mind Kimberly Nichole - Seven Nation Army

I honestly like Celia Babini. I loved her blind and her battle (I think she was better than Karly). She flopped hard on the lives, but her performances were so hilariously bad that ended up being the most enjoyable to me and she was only person aside from Maelyn who I was actually looking forward to watch in S16 Same happened with Darby in S11 (You Don’t Own Me is comedy gold)

IMO the worst are those three + Reagan Strange.

Lain Roy screams Ryan Sill 2.0.

Add me! Great range and awesome tone! With the right song choices I think he can go far.

Add me! She has a beautiful tone and a great taste (love her BA song!) Even if I don’t like John as a coach, I have a feeling that she will be his favorite (similar to Maelyn and Zan) so she will go far.

Even if it’s too early to tell and everything can happen, I think Blake has this in the bag. Jim Granger (Todd 2.0) and Taryn (who gives me Carrie vibes) are going to be big threats.

1. Thunderstorm 2. Khalea 3. Mendeleyev 4. Katie 5. Ricky 6. Joanna the rest

Honestly, I don’t have a preference for any gender, but I usually root for females because they are better most of the time. Jordan, Will, Chris Jamison, Matthew and Thunderstorm were my favorites during their respective seasons, but more often than not the male talent is non existent and I personally can’t root for people who don’t have talent. Although I agree there is some bias for female talent over male talent on IDF.

It hurts to say this because she is on my Top 3 favorite contenstants ever, but Maelyn is very overrated on this forum. Fallingwater wasn’t a great performance (her competition was nonexistent so she still stood out as one of the best performances). And I say this mostly because the level of fanatism over her is too much here. I actually think Alisan had a better run, with more varied song choices, but she isn’t nearly as overrated as Maelyn. I still love Maelyn, but no one deserves the “Perfect Godess” status she recieves.

I voted for Amber, but objectively the most robbed is Kristen. That IS was rigged for Christina (even if I liked Christina way more than Kristen)

I still can’t believe they turned for that.

Very tough matchups. The only seemingly easy matchup for me was Katie vs Danielle (Katie >>> Danielle IMO) but Please Remember Me is my favorite performance of Danielle by far so it ended up being very close. PS: I have feeling that my favorite performance of this bracket is going to be eliminated in an upset.

The best performer to ever be on the show is Kimberly Nichole, no debate. Troy Ritchie was awesome as well (so robbed)

Erin Martin, the Queen of Queens, Maelyn could never

Agreed with Domenic. I thought he was a finale lock when I saw his blind.

Amy Vachal seemed like a Top 3 contender and she ended up in the bottom, so she is an obvious contender for most shocking elimination. Holly Tucker being voted through over Sarah and Judith was also a big upset.

So by that logic, Hoot was the deserving winner of S17 because he outperformed his opponents in the charts / sales / streams (IIRC). And I don’t think anyone in IDF was particularly happy about that result.