American Idol Performances Mini Rankdown

[*Wallace]

6 minutes ago, rdhaley96 said:

 

 

Unpopular opinion alert, but "Hungry Like The Wolf" was pretty dreadful and is easily my least favorite DC performance. He delivered it with no passion, forgot the words, and wasn't really even on point vocally. What's more is that the theme was right in his wheelhouse, and he still whiffed it. 

 

However, another unpopular opinion of mine is that Amanda's "You Can't Do That" was her best performance, even over "IHMFLY." So I was going to give you a like for cutting "HLTW," but alas. 

omgg  I agree with you on regarding HLAW. I was watching my lesser faves from David Cook last night but that was a performance that was worse than I remembered. I forgot about him forgetting some of the words.

 

Oooh oops sorry there. I thought IHMFLY was regarded as her best performance so thought it was better to leave that one alone.  

[Weedy_Speedy]

Syesha's Ghosts still strong to this day!

 

[Elliott]

43 minutes ago, Alex95 said:

A Syesha performance is a LOCK to win

Well now you've gone and jinxed it.

[Elliott]

10 minutes ago, Weedy_Speedy said:

Syesha's Ghosts still strong to this day!

When the vocal Syesha stans are all in separate groups thus preventing anyone from being able to cut her

[Elliott]

1 hour ago, .Rei said:

Cutting a Kristy Lee Cook song is the least homophobic thing in the world, so that outweighs the others

And Kristy Lee Cook covering Journey at that.

[~Tom~]

1 hour ago, rdhaley96 said:

 

However, another unpopular opinion of mine is that Amanda's "You Can't Do That" was her best performance, even over "IHMFLY." So I was going to give you a like for cutting "HLTW," but alas. 

Don’t think Hungry Like the Wolf was his worst, but I wish Baba O’Riley had the studio version instead!

 

I do agree with I Can’t Do That being Amanda’s best; I stopped my group from cutting it but I figured it wouldn’t last.  

[~Tom~]

1 hour ago, Elliott said:

And Kristy Lee Cook covering Journey at that.

But she made them sound decent! #lowstandards 

[Elliott]

Just now, ~Tom~ said:

But she made them sound decent! #lowstandards 

“Said no one” - Peppermint

[Deeee]

On 2/13/2021 at 5:26 PM, Alex95 said:

2. Fantasia Barrino "Summertime"

 

[Deeee]

On 2/13/2021 at 5:26 PM, Alex95 said:

2. Melinda Doolittle "My Funny Valentine"

 

[QueenKalie]

10 minutes ago, ~Tom~ said:

But she made them sound decent! #lowstandards 

I actually thought a countrified version of a Journey song was actually kind of a cool idea.

[Bk1234]

3 hours ago, 1234567890 said:

WILDCARD:

Brooke White - “Here Comes the Sun”

[Elliott]

Just now, Bk1234 said:

Almost like not every performance is making it through despite everyone solely putting amazing performances there.

[Bk1234]

Just now, Elliott said:

Almost like not every performance is making it through despite everyone solely putting amazing performances there.

[*Wallace]

1 hour ago, Elliott said:

Well now you've gone and jinxed it.

I lowkey was thinking that too.  

1 hour ago, Elliott said:

When the vocal Syesha stans are all in separate groups thus preventing anyone from being able to cut her

 

39 minutes ago, ~Tom~ said:

Don’t think Hungry Like the Wolf was his worst, but I wish Baba O’Riley had the studio version instead!

 

I do agree with I Can’t Do That being Amanda’s best; I stopped my group from cutting it but I figured it wouldn’t last.  

I felt like Cook chose (or maybe it was the producers doing) his weaker performance of the two on the multi-song night his recording and it drove me nuts.   

 

I wanted recording for "All I Ever Really Need Is You" and "Baba O'Riley" instead of "I'm Alive" and "Hungry Like a Wolf" those weeks.    

[*Wallace]

12 minutes ago, Elliott said:

Almost like not every performance is making it through despite everyone solely putting amazing performances there.

LMAO I noticed that strategy right away.  

[Deeee]

SYESHA STANS:

 

[*Diana]

2 hours ago, Elliott said:

When the vocal Syesha stans are all in separate groups thus preventing anyone from being able to cut her

PULLING A CARRIE STANS

[Elliott]

1 minute ago, *Diana said:

PULLING A CARRIE STANS

Syesha sweetie I’m so sorry that this comparison just happened to you

[Elliott]

9 minutes ago, *Wallace said:

I lowkey was thinking that too.  

 

I felt like Cook chose (or maybe it was the producers doing) his weaker performance of the two on the multi-song night his recording and it drove me nuts.   

 

I wanted recording for "All I Ever Really Need Is You" and "Baba O'Riley" instead of "I'm Alive" and "Hungry Like a Wolf" those weeks.    

The producers decided which song got the studio recordings.

[*Wallace]

18 minutes ago, Elliott said:

The producers decided which song got the studio recordings.

Ooh I figured it was the producers doing.  

[*Wallace]

I was curious in counting up the number of Round 4 Immunities per contestant as I feel it's all spread out.

 

David C - 5

 

Brooke - 4

David A - 4

 

Syesha - 3

 

Jason - 2

Michael - 2

 

Alaina - 1

Alexandria - 1

Carly - 1

Chikeze - 1

David H - 1

Kristy Lee - 1

 

So that’s 12 (out of 24)  people aka half of the contestants. I feel like this is the most spread out Round 4 immunities have ever been thus far.  Really proves how competitive this season is.  

[Elliott]

Carly only got one immunity?

 

[1234567890]

11 minutes ago, Elliott said:

Carly only got one immunity?

 

I’m shocked. I thought two at least.

[QueenKalie]

42 minutes ago, *Wallace said:

I was curious in counting up the number of Round 4 Immunities per contestant as I feel it's all spread out.

 

David C - 5

 

Brooke - 4

David A - 4

 

Syesha - 3

 

Jason - 2

Michael - 2

 

Alaina - 1

Alexandria - 1

Carly - 1

Chikeze - 1

David H - 1

Kristy Lee - 1

 

So that’s 12 (out of 24)  people aka half of the contestants. I feel like this is the most spread out Round 4 immunities have ever been thus far.  Really proves how competitive this season is.  

Cook beating out Archie once again.