Jump to content

Recommended Posts

s14 

Drew Cole

Austin Giorgio

Christiana Danielle

Tish Haynes Key

 

s15 

Chris Krozke

RADHA

Sarah Grace

SandyRedd

 

s16

Domenic Haynes

Selkii

Jacob Maxwell

Abby Kasch

 

s17 

Zoe Upkins

Melinda Rodriguez

Marina Chello

Jessie Lawrence

 

s18

Samantha Howell

Todd Michael Hall

Nelson Cade III

Michael Williams

Link to post
Share on other sites

S14:

  1. Christiana/Drew
  2. Tish
  3. Austin

S15:

  1. SandyRedd
  2. Sarah Grace/RADHA
  3. Chris

S16

  1. Domenic
  2. Jacob/Abby/Selkii

S17

  1. Marina/Zoe
  2. Melinda
  3. Jessie

S18

  1. Nelson/TMH (before their performances at the KOs)
  2. Samantha
  3. Michael
Edited by VintageVoice
Link to post
Share on other sites

s14 

Christiana Danielle

Tish Haynes Key

 

s15 

RADHA

SandyRedd

Sarah Grace

Chris Kroeze

 

s16

Domenic Haynes

Jacob Maxwell

Abby Kasch

Selkii

 

s17 

Melinda Rodriguez

Marina Chello

Zoe Upkins

Jessie Lawrence

 

s18

Samantha Howell

Todd Michael Hall

Nelson Cade III

Michael Williams

Link to post
Share on other sites

SEASON 14

 

1. Tish Haynes Keys- her KO performance was spot on, thought she could atleast snatch one of Kelly's Final 3 spots.

2. Christiana Danielle- i love her.

3. Drew Cole- love his authenticity

4. Austin Giorgio- meh.

 

SEASON 15

 

1. SandyRedd- I actually prefer her KO performance more than Patrique's

2. Sarah Grace- super love her tone.

3. Chris Kroeze

4. RADHA- I am really disappointed on her KO performance, she had an uncontrollable massive amount of vibratos all over the place.

 

SEASON 16

 

1. Domenic Hayes- he's the only one I like among the saves on this bad season 😂

 

SEASON 17

 

1. Zoe Upkins- super love her battle with Khalea, super deserving of a save.

2. Marina Chello

3. Jessie Lawrence- Rose dominated him, but he did enough for me.

4. Melinda Rodriguez- meh, her battle with Shane was one of the worst covers of Too Good at Goodbyes I've heard so far.

 

SEASON 18

 

1. Samantha Howell- overall, she was the most consistent among the 4. Todd would've easily snatch the wildcard spot if his performance wasn't super disastrous.

2. Michael Williams- his KO performance was the best among the 4, but I've been on and off on him.

3. Nelson Cade III- meh.

4. Todd Michael Hall- super disappointed.

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

s14 

1. Christianna - Creative and a great artist

2. Tish Haynes Key - Powerhouse queen 

3. Drew Cole - Nice tone

4. Austin Giorgio - Boring karaoke

 

s15 

1. SandyRedd - That blind audition is an all time fave

2. Sarah Grace - Interesting style and very unique

3. Radha - Good blind but disappointing follow-ups

4. Chris Kroeze - A few good performances but lmao he is not second best of that season 

 

 

s16

1. Domenic Haynes - I loooove his tone. He deserved the finale imo

2. Abby Kasch - who?

3. Jacob Maxwell - I sleep

4. Selkii - I’m toOOOOoooOooOOoooOon. Yikes

 

s17 

1. Marina Chello - She SLAYED that knockout and deserved to win

2. Zoe Upkins - Nice tone, great battle

3. Jessie Lawrence - great tone and battle (Cuz of Rose obv) but bad song selection

4. Melinda Rodriguez - *snooze*

 

s18

1. Nelson Cade III - Loved his blind and battle, but bad song choice for the knockout

2. Todd Michael Hall - Great blind and battle but bad knockout. Great range tho

3. Samantha Howell - Good voice but nothing we haven’t seen before

4. Michael Williams: Boring white guy #4235

Edited by B-B
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

S14 

Tish Haynes Key - love her, I prefer her over DR

Christiana Danielle - thank God Alicia chose her in the POs

Drew Cole

Austin Giorgio - forgettable artist

 

 

S15 

SandyRedd - robbed Queen

RADHA - robbed Queen 2 

Chris Krozke/Sarah Grace - Meh

 

s16

Domenic Haynes - he deserved so much better (Even a finale spot) 

Jacob Maxwell - I like him but he was a POs fodder 

Selkii - i really like her BA but the rest was terrible 

Abby Kasch - cant believe she made the POs... 

 

I dont like the Save in the battles... I Love Marina Chello she deserved to go further but it was her fault for choosing Blake two times 🙄

 

 
  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

S14:

1. Drew Cole - extremely consistent performer with a pleasing tone and a clearly defined, unique vocal style.

2. Austin Giorgio - smooth jazz vocal with a nice raspy belt, he deserved better than his abysmal playoffs song choice.

3. Tish Haynes Keys - really, really good powerhouse belter but she got overshadowed by Kyla.

4. Christiana Danielle - started off super unique and interesting but seemed to completely lose her grasp on pitch in the lives.

 

S15:

1. SandyRedd - obvious choice here, there isn't another contestant on this list who can deliver a performance so technical and yet so raw.

2. Chris Kroeze - super unique tone, varied song choices, extremely consistent performer.

3. Sarah Grace - super cool style of singing, but she had some technical issues in her performances.

4. RADHA - started off great then became boring.

 

S16:

1. Domenic Haynes - probably the coolest tone I've ever heard, but his playoffs song choice was not ideal.

2. Jacob Maxwell - somewhat boring, but pleasant to listen to.

3. Selkii - started off great, then absolutely tanked.

4. Abby Kasch - IMO one of my least favorite singers to ever be on the show. No idea how she made it as far as she did.

 

S17:

1. Marina Chello - average in the blinds and battles, but it is a crime that she was eliminated after delivering one of the best knockouts of the season.

2. Zoe Upkins - again, I thought she was average. Nothing truly exceptional, whether good or bad.

3. Melinda Rodriguez - one of my favorite blinds that season, but her knockout was a mess.

4. Jessie Lawrence - snoozefest

 

S18:

1. Todd Michael Hall - yeah his knockout sucked, but I blame that on whoever approved his unfathomably awful song choice. Still my favorite voice by a long shot.

2. Nelson Cade III - super raspy, smoky tone. His knockout song choice was bad but again, probably not his fault.

3. Michael Williams - went from the worst blind of the season to one of the best battles, then gave a strong if unremarkable performance in the Knockouts. Not really interesting, but not bad.

4. Samantha Howell - personalIy I didn't think her pitchy, shouty blind deserved a single chair turn, much less three - and a block at that. Nonetheless, she did improve to the point where her tone only caused my ears to mildly sting rather than gush blood.      

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, B-B said:

s14 

1. Christiana - Creative and a great artist

2. Tish Haynes Key - Powerhouse queen 

 

s15 

1. SandyRedd - That blind audition is an all time fave

2. Sarah Grace - Interesting style and very unique

4. Chris Kroeze - A few good performances but lmao he is not second best of that season 

 

 

s16

1. Domenic Haynes - I loooove his tone. He deserved the finale imo

2. Abby Kasch - who?

4. Selkii - I’m toOOOOoooOooOOoooOon. Yikes

 

s17 

1. Marina Chello - She SLAYED that knockout and deserved to win

2. Zoe Upkins - Nice tone, great battle

3. Jessie Lawrence - great tone and battle (Cuz of Rose obv) but bad song selection

 

s18

2. Todd Michael Hall - Great blind and battle but bad knockout. Great range tho

4. Michael Williams: Boring white guy #4235

Your comments are priceless :rofl:

 

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

In terms of KO Performance/Battle depending where they were saved:

 

s14:

1. Christiana - She never had a moment like this once the lives rolled in.

2. Tish - I loved the playfulness of this performance.

3. Drew - Smooth tone. I liked him.

4. Austin - *snooze*

 

s15

1. SandyRedd - She had the better performance ngl.

2. Sarah Grace - I just loooove her tone.

3. Chris Kroeze - The only performance of his that I liked.

4. RADHA - Not a good song choice for her.

 

s16

1. Domenic Haynes - He was very interesting. Could've gone farther on Team Legend.

2. Jacob Maxwell - I seemed to be in the minority liking this one. 

3. Abby Kasch - Her only tolerable performance.

4. Selkii - Just no.

 

s17

1. Marina Chello - Ricky was better but she did great too.

2. Zoe Upkins - Her and Khalea were pretty even.

3. Jessie Lawrence - OK but forgettable. Rose owned that battle.

4. Melinda Rodriguez - What was that song choice???

 

s18

1. Samantha Howell - Liked her tone but nothing special.

2. Michael Williams - Boring and one of my least favorite contestants that season but technically better than those below him.

3. Nelson Cade III - Wrong song choice. He has some folky covers on IG and I wish we saw that side of him on the show.

4. Todd Michael Hall - Quite possibly the most baffling song choices ever. 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...